History YMMV / SantaAndTheIceCreamBunny

* NightmareFuel: The Bunny; see SpecialEffectFailure.

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Even in a movie filled with [=BLAMs=], the appearances of Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn make no sense.

* EnsembleDarkhorse: The giant. He's brings so much [[LargeHam hamminess]] to a dull production that it's hard to hate him.

* RetroactiveRecognition: Kim Nicholas (the blonde girl who was the elf that noticed Santa was missing in the opening scene, then later returned to play frisbee and bring a donkey to Santa) went on to a major role in ''Impulse'', a.k.a. "That cheesy low budget made-in-Florida thriller where Creator/WilliamShatner played a [[TheSociopath sociopathic]] [[TheBluebeard Bluebeard]]."

* BadBadActing: The acting in ''Jack'' makes the acting in ''Thumbelina'' look like the Mercury Theater.

* EarWorm: "If I could be Thuuuumbeliiiinaaa..."

* {{Squick}}: When Santa gets out of his sleigh to help with the sheep, you could see a dark stain on his pants. Please ''God'', let that just be sweat!

* TheyJustDidntCare: The reason Huck Finn is wearing a Hawaiian shirt.
** And, in some shots, Santa can clearly be seen wearing Sun Glasses?
** The fact that they just put the Thumbelina Film in, without changing the framing device or even removing the credits from that film, so it looks like that Santa is telling the children a story about a girl going to Pirates World to have the Story of Thumbelina narrated to her as she gazes at a diorama display, complete with their own credits! To quote Podcast/RiffTrax: "We interrupt your movie to bring you... a movie."
-->'''Kevin Murphy''': (As Santa) And then Children, Executive Producer Armand Cerami hired Barry Mahon to direct! Isn’t that wonderful?

** The fact that they just put the Thumbelina Film in, without changing the framing device or even removing the credits from that film, so it looks like that Santa is telling the children a story about a girl going to Pirates World to have the Story of Thumbelina narrated to her as she gazes at a diorama display. To quote Podcast/RiffTrax: "We interrupt your movie to bring you... a movie."

** The fact that they just put the Thumbelina Film in, without changing the framing device or even removing the credits from that film, so it looks like that Santa is telling the children a story about someone going to Pirates World to have the Story of Thumbelina narrated to her.
-->'''[[RiffTrax Kevin Murphy]]''': (As Santa) And then Children, Executive Producer Armand Cerami hired Barry Mahon to direct! Isn’t that wonderful?

** The fact that they just put the Thumbelina Film in, without changing the framing device, so it looks like that Santa is telling the children a story about someone going to Pirates World to have the Story of Thumbelina narrated to her (Complete with their own Credits!)
-->'''[[RiffTrax Kevin Murphy]]''': (As Santa) And then Children, Executive Producer: Armand Cerami hired Barry Mahon to direct! Isn’ that Wonderful!?

* CrowningMusicOfAwesome: Compared to the Thumbelina segment, the songs in this one are actually pretty decent at the very least.

* SpecialEffectsFailure: The "Golden hen" is pretty much just a store-bought ham wrapped in gold-painted newspaper.

----

** The set designs, which look more like blown up versions of grade school dioramas. Which, to fair, is what they're supposed to be.

** The biggest example might be Santa's "stuck" sleigh. You can clearly see the thing moving in several scenes after "failed" attempts to extract it. Also, it appears to be "buried" in a quarter-inch of sand. In certain spots along the rails. (It probably would've helped if Santa got out of the damned thing when they pushed.)

* CrowningMusicOfAwesome: Perhaps the only thing about this whole movie that comes close to being described as awesome (or even tolerable) is the HappilyEverAfter song, at least compared with everything else.

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Even in a movie filled with BLAMs, the appearances of Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn make no sense.

** Also, the magic harp, which was built with eleven cents in three minutes.