Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Pompeii

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: in October of the same year as the film's release 68 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning just before noon when hundreds were on the mountain. Footage taken by people on the slopes show just how fast and silent the eruption came with one victim at the summit having only able to snap one photograph before the pyroclastic flow struck them. Just like in Pompeii all 68 victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven't been recovered from the mountain. Despite the hundred on the mountain that day, the number of fatalities were so low due to the pyroclastic flow at Ontake was a phreatic (steam explosion) generated 'cold surge' which didn't travel further than the summit area while the ones at Vesuvius that consumed Pompeii and the surrounding area were magmatic 'hot surges' caused by the eruption column continually collapsing.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: in October of the same year as the film's release 68 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning just before noon when hundreds were on the mountain. Footage taken by people on the slopes show just how fast and silent the eruption came with one victim at the summit having only able to snap one photograph before the pyroclastic flow struck them. Just like in Pompeii all 68 victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven't been recovered from the mountain. Despite the hundred hundreds of people on the mountain slopes that day, the number of fatalities were so low due to the pyroclastic flow at Ontake was being a phreatic (steam explosion) generated 'cold surge' which didn't travel that went no further than the summit area while the ones at Vesuvius that consumed Pompeii and the surrounding area were magmatic 'hot surges' caused by the eruption column continually collapsing.suffering fountain collapses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: in October of the same year as the film's release 68 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning just before noon when hundreds were on the mountain. Footage taken by people on the slopes show just how fast and silent the eruption came with one victim having only enough time to snap one photograph before the pyroclastic flow struck. Just like in Pompeii all 65 victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven't been recovered from the mountain. The reason that the number of casualties weren't higher is that the pyroclastic flow at Ontake was a steam explosion generated 'cold surge' while the one that consumed Pompeii and the surrounding area was a magmatic 'hot surge'.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: in October of the same year as the film's release 68 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning just before noon when hundreds were on the mountain. Footage taken by people on the slopes show just how fast and silent the eruption came with one victim at the summit having only enough time able to snap one photograph before the pyroclastic flow struck. struck them. Just like in Pompeii all 65 68 victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven't been recovered from the mountain. The reason Despite the hundred on the mountain that day, the number of casualties weren't higher is that fatalities were so low due to the pyroclastic flow at Ontake was a steam explosion phreatic (steam explosion) generated 'cold surge' which didn't travel further than the summit area while the one ones at Vesuvius that consumed Pompeii and the surrounding area was a were magmatic 'hot surge'. surges' caused by the eruption column continually collapsing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: in October of the same year as the film’s release 68 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning just before noon when hundreds were on the mountain with survivors being forced to make emergency descents. Just like in Pompeii all 65 victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven’t been recovered from the mountain.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: in October of the same year as the film’s release 68 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning just before noon when hundreds were on the mountain mountain. Footage taken by people on the slopes show just how fast and silent the eruption came with survivors being forced one victim having only enough time to make emergency descents.snap one photograph before the pyroclastic flow struck. Just like in Pompeii all 65 victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven’t been recovered from the mountain. The reason that the number of casualties weren’t higher is that the pyroclastic flow at Ontake was a steam explosion generated ‘cold surge’ while the one that consumed Pompeii and the surrounding area was a magmatic ‘hot surge’.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherinHindsight: in October 2014 63 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning while many others were forced to make emergency descents. The victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven’t been recovered

to:

* HarsherinHindsight: HarsherInHindsight: in October 2014 63 of the same year as the film’s release 68 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning while many others just before noon when hundreds were on the mountain with survivors being forced to make emergency descents. The Just like in Pompeii all 65 victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven’t been recoveredrecovered from the mountain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*HarsherinHindsight: in October 2014 63 people were killed when Mount Ontake in Japan erupted without warning while many others were forced to make emergency descents. The victims were either killed by heat, toxic fumes, or hit by flying rocks. Five of the dead still haven’t been recovered
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ClicheStorm: Just about the only original thing in the movie is the mashing of gladiator movie cliches with disaster movie cliches.
* CompleteMonster: [[CorruptPolitician Roman Senator Corvus]] is a [[SmugSnake sneering]], arrogant [[AristocratsAreEvil aristocrat]] who feels he can do whatever he wants. Starting the film with a brutal slaughter of a Celtic tribe, Corvus murders the mother of the young hero Milo, though the boy escapes and later becomes a slave at the city of Pompeii. When Milo becomes attached to the Roman noblewoman Cassia, whom Corvus lusts for, Corvus promises to spare him for Cassia's sake, but has him and another Gladiator named Atticus chained in the Arena to be slaughtered by Roman soldiers to recreate Corvus's victory over the Celts. When Cassia protests, Corvus tells her he simply wants her as a possession that he can break and that she will "stay broken," to beg and crawl as he demands. Corvus blackmails her family into agreeing to the marriage by threatening to accuse them of treason and murders Cassia's father when Mt. Vesuvius erupts. To get to safety, Corvus kills innocent civilians and even abandons his loyal [[TheDragon dragon]] Proculus while attempting to abduct Cassia and escape.

to:

* ClicheStorm: Just about the only original thing in the movie is the mashing of gladiator movie cliches clichés with disaster movie cliches.
clichés.
* CompleteMonster: [[CorruptPolitician Roman Senator Corvus]] is a [[SmugSnake sneering]], arrogant [[AristocratsAreEvil aristocrat]] who feels he can do whatever he wants. Starting the film with a brutal slaughter of a Celtic tribe, Corvus murders the mother of the young hero Milo, though the boy escapes and later becomes a slave at the city of Pompeii. When Milo becomes attached to the Roman noblewoman Cassia, whom Corvus lusts for, Corvus promises to spare him for Cassia's sake, sake but has him and another Gladiator named Atticus chained in the Arena to be slaughtered by Roman soldiers to recreate Corvus's victory over the Celts. When Cassia protests, Corvus tells her he simply wants her as a possession that he can break and that she will "stay broken," to beg and crawl as he demands. Corvus blackmails her family into agreeing to the marriage by threatening to accuse them of treason and murders Cassia's father when Mt. Vesuvius erupts. To get to safety, Corvus kills innocent civilians and even abandons his loyal [[TheDragon dragon]] Proculus while attempting to abduct Cassia and escape.

Added: 172

Changed: 179

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: The admittedly rather epic-looking flood is kind of ruined by the comedy of a boat drifting perfectly into a street and then perfectly plugging up the hole it rams into.

to:

* {{Narm}}: {{Narm}}:
**
The admittedly rather epic-looking flood is kind of ruined by the comedy of a boat drifting perfectly into a street and then perfectly plugging up the hole it rams into.



* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The volcano eruption is indeed the best part of the film.

to:

* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The volcano eruption is indeed the best part of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** During the hail of rocks from the second stage of the eruption, a hapless extra next to the protagonists gets walloped right in the head by a huge, bouncy stone. The volcano has remarkable aim.

Removed: 295

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Admittedly, this option is probably best since if the movie was about any real person, people would be able to look the person up to see if they lived through the eruption or not, thus spoiling the film. The same formula would be used by Disney and Lucas Film for the StarWars Sequel trilogy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Admittedly, this option is probably best since if the movie was about any real person, people would be able to look the person up to see if they lived through the eruption or not, thus spoiling the film. The same formula would be used by Disney and Lucas Arts for the StarWars Sequel trilogy.

to:

** Admittedly, this option is probably best since if the movie was about any real person, people would be able to look the person up to see if they lived through the eruption or not, thus spoiling the film. The same formula would be used by Disney and Lucas Arts Film for the StarWars Sequel trilogy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Admittedly, this option is probably best since if the movie was about any real person, people would be able to look the person up to see if they lived through the eruption or not, thus spoiling the film. The same formula would be used by Disney and Lucas Arts for the StarWars Sequel trilogy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustHereForGodzilla: About everyone only came to this movie to see the volcano eruption.

to:

* JustHereForGodzilla: About everyone only came to this movie to either see the volcano eruption.eruption or [[Creator/KitHarington Jon Snow]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* EnsembleDarkhorse: Atticus
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is not a YMMV trope. Moved to the main page.


* InvincibleHero / MadeOfIron: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as a minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems (even put on armor and slapped on the back without reacting). In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best explanation given is that he was descended from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InvincibleHero / MadeOfIron: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems (even put on armor and slapped on the back without reacting). In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was descended from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.

to:

* InvincibleHero / MadeOfIron: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as a minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems (even put on armor and slapped on the back without reacting). In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best explanation given is that he was descended from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Narm: The admittedly rather epic-looking flood is kind of ruined by the comedy of a boat drifting perfectly into a street and then perfectly plugging up the hole it rams into.

to:

* Narm: {{Narm}}: The admittedly rather epic-looking flood is kind of ruined by the comedy of a boat drifting perfectly into a street and then perfectly plugging up the hole it rams into.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Narm: The admittedly rather epic-looking flood is kind of ruined by the comedy of a boat drifting perfectly into a street and then perfectly plugging up the hole it rams into.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InvincibleHero/MadeOfIron: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems (even put on armor and slapped on the back without reacting). In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was descended from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.

to:

* InvincibleHero/MadeOfIron: InvincibleHero / MadeOfIron: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems (even put on armor and slapped on the back without reacting). In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was descended from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InvincibleHero: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems (even put on armor and slapped on the back without reacting). In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was descended from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.

to:

* InvincibleHero: InvincibleHero/MadeOfIron: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems (even put on armor and slapped on the back without reacting). In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was descended from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InvincibleHero: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems. In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was destined from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.

to:

* InvincibleHero: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems.problems (even put on armor and slapped on the back without reacting). In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was destined descended from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BoringInvincibleHero: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems. In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least. Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was destined from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.

to:

* BoringInvincibleHero: InvincibleHero: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems. In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least.least (if he survived at all). Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was destined from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BoringInvincibleHero: Milo. Through no readily explained reason, Milo is an absolute stunning fighter with unlimited amounts of stamina, fighting ability and pain tolerance. For example, the day before he has to engage in the fight of his life, he endures 50 lashes without even calling out, let alone losing consciousness. Afterwards the whip lashes are treated as minor inconvenience, and he's able to outfight everyone the next day without any problems. In real life, he would need a month to recover in the very least. Instead he goes on to fight many, many battles against perfectly healthy opponents and he easily defeats them all, one after another. The best given is that he was destined from the "horse clan," but that was 17 years ago, and we didn't even see him have any training.

Added: 1101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*CompleteMonster: [[CorruptPolitician Roman Senator Corvus]] is a [[SmugSnake sneering]], arrogant [[AristocratsAreEvil aristocrat]] who feels he can do whatever he wants. Starting the film with a brutal slaughter of a Celtic tribe, Corvus murders the mother of the young hero Milo, though the boy escapes and later becomes a slave at the city of Pompeii. When Milo becomes attached to the Roman noblewoman Cassia, whom Corvus lusts for, Corvus promises to spare him for Cassia's sake, but has him and another Gladiator named Atticus chained in the Arena to be slaughtered by Roman soldiers to recreate Corvus's victory over the Celts. When Cassia protests, Corvus tells her he simply wants her as a possession that he can break and that she will "stay broken," to beg and crawl as he demands. Corvus blackmails her family into agreeing to the marriage by threatening to accuse them of treason and murders Cassia's father when Mt. Vesuvius erupts. To get to safety, Corvus kills innocent civilians and even abandons his loyal [[TheDragon dragon]] Proculus while attempting to abduct Cassia and escape.

Added: 135

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NarmCharm: Positive reviews of the film emphasize that it's still a pretty fun, old-fashioned disaster movie despite all the cliches.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ClicheStorm: Just about the only original thing in the movie is the mashing of gladiator movie cliches with disaster movie cliches.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The destruction of Pompeii is rife with documented stories that could have made great movies, but instead we get a completely fictional, generic story that only involves the volcano in the last half hour.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Atticus
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustHereForGodzilla: About everyone only came to this movie to see the volcano eruption.



-->'''Senator Corvus''': ''KILL HIM! KILL HIM NOW!''

to:

-->'''Senator Corvus''': ''KILL HIM! KILL HIM NOW!''NOW!''
* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The volcano eruption is indeed the best part of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: If you, or the gods, still had any sympathy for Senator Corvus, that evaporated with five ill-chosen words in the arena that ensured that the wrath of the gods would fall upon Pompeii:

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: If you, or the gods, still had any sympathy for Senator Corvus, Corvus after everything he had done, that evaporated with five ill-chosen words in the arena that ensured that the wrath of the gods would fall upon Pompeii:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MoralEventHorizon: If you, or the gods, still had any sympathy for Senator Corvus, that evaporated with five ill-chosen words in the arena that ensured that the wrath of the gods would fall upon Pompeii:
-->'''Senator Corvus''': ''KILL HIM! KILL HIM NOW!''

Top