Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Pluto

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorsSavingThrow: A number of readers found Pluto's characterization in the original Manga/AstroBoy manga to be [[UnintentionallyUnsympathetic very hard to sympathize with]], due to the fact he showed no remorse for the murders he was ordered out and did not have enough of a sympathetic backstory, other than just being programmed that way by his creator. In this series, however, [[AdaptationalSympathy he is rewritten into a more tragic figure]], where he is now a more TragicVillain, brainwashed into becoming a killing machine against his will, and he shows remorse for his actions multiple times, wishing to be put out of his misery so he can stop killing. It's easy to see why many prefer this version of Pluto's character over the original version.

to:

* AuthorsSavingThrow: A number of readers found Pluto's characterization in the original Manga/AstroBoy manga to be [[UnintentionallyUnsympathetic very hard to sympathize with]], due to the fact he showed no remorse for the murders he was ordered out and did not have enough of a sympathetic backstory, other than just being programmed that way by his creator. In this series, however, [[AdaptationalSympathy he is rewritten into a more more]] [[TragicVillain tragic figure]], where he is now a more TragicVillain, having been brainwashed into becoming a killing machine against his will, and he shows the remorse for his actions multiple times, wishing from which is so strong that he asks to be put out of his misery so he can stop killing.misery. It's easy to see why many prefer this version of Pluto's character over the original version.



* SuperlativeDubbing: The Netflix animated series is lauded for its excellent voicework, with heavyweights like KeithDavid lending gravitas to already-well-written characters.

to:

* SuperlativeDubbing: SugarWiki/SuperlativeDubbing: The Netflix animated series is lauded for its excellent voicework, with heavyweights like KeithDavid Creator/KeithDavid lending gravitas to already-well-written characters.



** The Anti-Robot Supremacist disappear from the plot after Gesicht saves Adolf.

to:

** The Anti-Robot Supremacist Supremacists disappear from the plot after Gesicht saves Adolf.



* ViewerGenderConfusion: Epsilon. What makes it even more difficult is that ''Pluto''[='=]s Epsilon is a composite character of the original & 2003 series Epsilon, the latter of whom was "[[RobotGirl female]]". The anime adaptation gave him a male voice courtesy of Creator/MamoruMiyano and Creator/KeithSilverstein, the latter whom previously voiced Johan Liebert in Naoki Urasawa's previous work, ''Manga/{{Monster}}''.

to:

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Epsilon. What makes it even more difficult is that ''Pluto''[='=]s Epsilon is a composite character of the original & 2003 series Epsilon, the latter of whom was "[[RobotGirl female]]".''[[RobotGirl female]]''. The anime adaptation gave him a male voice courtesy of Creator/MamoruMiyano and Creator/KeithSilverstein, the latter whom previously voiced Johan Liebert in Naoki Urasawa's previous work, ''Manga/{{Monster}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SuperlativeDubbing: The Netflix animated series is lauded for its excellent voicework, with heavyweights like KeithDavid lending gravitas to already-well-written characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorsSavingThrow: A number of readers found Pluto's characterization in the original Manga/AstroBoy manga to be [[UnintentionallyUnsympathetic very hard to sympathize with]], due to the fact he showed no remorse for the murders he was ordered out and did not have enough of a sympathetic backstory, other than just being programmed that way by his creator. In this series, however, [[AdaptationalSympathy he is rewritten into a more tragic figure]], where he was a former human turned cyborg, brainwashed into becoming a killing machine against his will, and he shows remorse for his actions multiple, wishing to be put out of his misery so he can stop killing. It's easy to see why many prefer this version of Pluto's character over the original version.

to:

* AuthorsSavingThrow: A number of readers found Pluto's characterization in the original Manga/AstroBoy manga to be [[UnintentionallyUnsympathetic very hard to sympathize with]], due to the fact he showed no remorse for the murders he was ordered out and did not have enough of a sympathetic backstory, other than just being programmed that way by his creator. In this series, however, [[AdaptationalSympathy he is rewritten into a more tragic figure]], where he was is now a former human turned cyborg, more TragicVillain, brainwashed into becoming a killing machine against his will, and he shows remorse for his actions multiple, multiple times, wishing to be put out of his misery so he can stop killing. It's easy to see why many prefer this version of Pluto's character over the original version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorsSavingThrow: A number of readers found Pluto's characterization in the original Manga/AstroBoy manga to be [[UnintentionallyUnsympathetic very hard to sympathize with]], due to the fact he showed no remorse for the murders he was ordered out and did not have enough of a sympathetic backstory, other than just being programmed that way by his creator. In this series, however, [[AdaptationalSympathy he is rewritten into a more tragic figure]], where he was a former human turned cyborg, brainwashed into becoming a killing machine against his will, and he shows remorse for his actions multiple, wishing to be put out of his misery so he can stop killing. It's easy to see why many prefer this version of Pluto's character over the original version.


Added DiffLines:

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: As mentioned above, although Pluto wasn't necessarily a scrappy in the original Astro Boy manga, many still found his character impossible to like or sympathize with, in spite of his few redeeming qualities, due to being completely remorseful about murdering other robots, even if he is just programmed to follow orders from his master. The depiction of Pluto portrayed in this series is viewed in a more favorable light by many, due to the fact he is given a more sympathetic backstory and expresses genuine guilt over his actions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* {{Applicability}}: The war in Persia is a direct parallel to the Iraq War, but the messages of a vague hard to pin down target granting justification to attack civilians has lead to fans applying it to numerous other conflicts as well. With the anime's release in late 2023 it was very common for fans to draw parallels to the genocide in Gaza.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Applicability}}: The war in Persia is a direct parallel to the Iraq War, but the messages of an imaginary target granting justification to attack civilians has lead to fans applying it to numerous other conflicts as well. With the anime's release in late 2023 it was very common for fans to draw parallels to the genocide in Gaza.

to:

* {{Applicability}}: The war in Persia is a direct parallel to the Iraq War, but the messages of an imaginary a vague hard to pin down target granting justification to attack civilians has lead to fans applying it to numerous other conflicts as well. With the anime's release in late 2023 it was very common for fans to draw parallels to the genocide in Gaza.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Applicability}}: The war in Persia is a direct parallel to the Iraq War, but the messages of an imaginary target granting justification to attack civilians has lead to fans applying it to numerous other conflicts as well. With the anime's release in late 2023 it was very common for fans to draw parallels to the genocide in Gaza.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not approved by complete monster proposal thread. If you have a case please come to this thread.


** [[spoiler: Adolf's Brother, like Adolf himself he's part of a Anti-Robot bigot movement but was hated by even his fellow racist for how far he took it, we get an Idea how depraved he is from the reveal he had killed Gesicht's robot child among several other robot children.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Adolf's Brother, like Adolf himself he's part of a Anti-Robot bigot movement but was hated by even his fellow racist for how far he took it, we get an Idea how depraved he is from the reveal he had killed Gesicht's robot child among several other robot children.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Adolf's Brother, like Adolf himself he's part of a Anti-Robot bigot movement but was hated by even his fellow racist for how far he took it, we get an Idea how depraved he is from the reveal he had killed Gesicht's robot child among several other robot children.

to:

** [[spoiler: Adolf's Brother, like Adolf himself he's part of a Anti-Robot bigot movement but was hated by even his fellow racist for how far he took it, we get an Idea how depraved he is from the reveal he had killed Gesicht's robot child among several other robot children. children.]]



** Bora itself for that matter, for all the destruction it was capable of and the fact it left the few who saw it in action with horrible PTSD, you'd probably have expected it to be a truly horrible monstrosity instead of a chunky rock golem with no discernible features.

to:

** [[spoiler: Bora itself for that matter, for all the destruction it was capable of and the fact it left the few who saw it in action with horrible PTSD, you'd probably have expected it to be a truly horrible monstrosity instead of a chunky rock golem with no discernible features.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Adolf's Brother, like Adolf himself he's part of a Anti-Robot bigot movement but was hated by even his fellow racist for how far he took it, we get an Idea how depraved he is from the reveal he had killed Gesicht's robot child among several other robot children.


Added DiffLines:

** Bora itself for that matter, for all the destruction it was capable of and the fact it left the few who saw it in action with horrible PTSD, you'd probably have expected it to be a truly horrible monstrosity instead of a chunky rock golem with no discernible features.


Added DiffLines:

** The Anti-Robot Supremacist disappear from the plot after Gesicht saves Adolf.

Top