Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / MenAtArms

Go To



* HarsherInHindsight: With the rise in stories about police brutality and shooting innocent people in the 2010s (or depending on how cynical you are, the rise in means to ''record'' these things), the Gonne's effect on Vimes is even more chilling. Ditto the part about how a good person will just kill you.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: HarsherInHindsight:
**
With the rise in stories about police brutality and shooting innocent people in the 2010s (or depending on how cynical you are, the rise in means to ''record'' these things), the Gonne's effect on Vimes is even more chilling. Ditto the part about how a good person will just kill you.you.
** Vimes's prejudice towards the undead along with Cuddy and Detritus quickly turning into BoomerangBigots behind the badge are largely played for laughs, but much less funny in light of current discussions about deeply ingrained racism in policing.


* {{Woolseyism}}: The Swedish translation translates Edward's last [[NamesToRunAwayFromReallyFast name to run away from really fast]] "d'Eath" as ''af Lifva'', using the noble prefix ''af'' while punning on ''avliva,'' meaning "to put down" (as in [[DeadlyEuphemism "kill"]]).

to:

* {{Woolseyism}}: The Swedish translation translates Edward's last [[NamesToRunAwayFromReallyFast name to run away from really fast]] name]] "d'Eath" as ''af Lifva'', using the noble prefix ''af'' while punning on ''avliva,'' meaning "to put down" (as in [[DeadlyEuphemism "kill"]])."kill"]]).
----


* {{Woolseyism}}: The Swedish translation translates Edward's last [[NamesToRunAwayFromReallyFast name to run away from really fast]] "d'Eath" as ''af Lifva'', using the noble prefix "af" while punning on "avliva," meaning "to put down" (as in [[DeadlyEuphemism "kill"]]).

to:

* {{Woolseyism}}: The Swedish translation translates Edward's last [[NamesToRunAwayFromReallyFast name to run away from really fast]] "d'Eath" as ''af Lifva'', using the noble prefix "af" ''af'' while punning on "avliva," ''avliva,'' meaning "to put down" (as in [[DeadlyEuphemism "kill"]]).


*** ... An interpretation which is in itself one other fans may disagree with! Pratchett always wrote fantasy that had a strong bearing on the real world. It is by no means self-evident exactly how applicable Pratchett saw the themes of this book to the real world.

to:

*** ... An interpretation which is in itself one other fans may disagree with! Pratchett always wrote fantasy that had a strong bearing on the real world. It is by no means self-evident exactly how applicable Pratchett saw the themes of this book to the real world.world.
* {{Woolseyism}}: The Swedish translation translates Edward's last [[NamesToRunAwayFromReallyFast name to run away from really fast]] "d'Eath" as ''af Lifva'', using the noble prefix "af" while punning on "avliva," meaning "to put down" (as in [[DeadlyEuphemism "kill"]]).


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Carrot's HiddenDepths in this book help create the impression that he is just as competent a manipulator as the Patrician. This includes stopping a riot between dwarfs and trolls by talking (a feat noted to have got any other member of the watch killed) and bluffing the head of the Fool's Guild.

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: AlternateCharacterInterpretation:
**
Carrot's HiddenDepths in this book help create the impression that he is just as competent a manipulator as the Patrician. This includes stopping a riot between dwarfs and trolls by talking (a feat noted to have got any other member of the watch killed) and bluffing the head of the Fool's Guild.Guild.
** Is the gonne itself somehow alive and actively corrupting its users, or is it all a product of the delusions of grandeur such a perfect killing tool puts into their heads? It seems to talk to them, and they have lucid moments that come and go... but most of them are degenerating mentally. It ''does'' fire itself at least once... but then again, that could just as easily be a product of the man in question fiddling around with something dangerous and volatile he didn't fully understand being interpreted differently by other characters later on.


** Also, the reason the gonne is portrayed as Very Bad within the story is the same reason that sourcery is Very Bad in ''Sourcery'': it's a complete game breaker ''for the Discworld''. (Whether or not, or to what extent, that reflects the real world is entirely up to the reader, and not really relevant in-story.) The point, which is explicitly brought up several times, is that all other forms of power on the Disc have built-in balancers: magic is capricious and unreliable, melee weapons like swords require training and expertise, crossbows are unwieldy and take time and strength to wind up. The gonne, however, is instant power unlike anything else on the Disc, at one's fingertips: if allowed to exist in that world it would utterly destroy the balance of power. That's why it instantly corrupts anyone who touches it: it's the effect that kind of power has, especially in a world that runs on Narrativium. Trying to project this moral onto ''our'' world is just that: a projection, and outside the scope of the story.

to:

** Also, the reason the gonne is portrayed as Very Bad within the story is the same reason that sourcery is Very Bad in ''Sourcery'': it's a complete game breaker ''for the Discworld''. (Whether or not, or to what extent, that reflects the real world is entirely up to the reader, and not really relevant in-story.) The point, which is explicitly brought up several times, is that all other forms of power on the Disc have built-in balancers: magic is capricious and unreliable, melee weapons like swords require training and expertise, crossbows are unwieldy and take time and strength to wind up. The gonne, however, is instant power unlike anything else on the Disc, at one's fingertips: if allowed to exist in that world it would utterly destroy the balance of power. That's why it instantly corrupts anyone who touches it: it's the effect that kind of power has, especially in a world that runs on Narrativium. Trying to project this moral onto ''our'' world is just that: a projection, and outside the scope of the story.story.
*** ... An interpretation which is in itself one other fans may disagree with! Pratchett always wrote fantasy that had a strong bearing on the real world. It is by no means self-evident exactly how applicable Pratchett saw the themes of this book to the real world.


** Which is ironic, given that the author's attitude towards firearms at least at one point (notably with part of Vimes' internal monologue in ''Night Watch'') much more in line with an American one. Of course, Vimes is not Pratchett, and Pratchett was not Vimes, and in any case, Vimes was thinking from a very different standpoint when the City Watch was little more than the Patrician's gang of armed thugs.

to:

** Which is ironic, given that the author's attitude towards firearms at least at one point (notably with part of weapons expressed by Vimes' internal monologue in ''Night Watch'') much Watch'' is more in line with an American one. Of course, Vimes is not Pratchett, and Pratchett was not Vimes, and in any case, Vimes was thinking from a very different standpoint when the City Watch was little more than the Patrician's gang of armed thugs.thugs.
** Also, the reason the gonne is portrayed as Very Bad within the story is the same reason that sourcery is Very Bad in ''Sourcery'': it's a complete game breaker ''for the Discworld''. (Whether or not, or to what extent, that reflects the real world is entirely up to the reader, and not really relevant in-story.) The point, which is explicitly brought up several times, is that all other forms of power on the Disc have built-in balancers: magic is capricious and unreliable, melee weapons like swords require training and expertise, crossbows are unwieldy and take time and strength to wind up. The gonne, however, is instant power unlike anything else on the Disc, at one's fingertips: if allowed to exist in that world it would utterly destroy the balance of power. That's why it instantly corrupts anyone who touches it: it's the effect that kind of power has, especially in a world that runs on Narrativium. Trying to project this moral onto ''our'' world is just that: a projection, and outside the scope of the story.


** Which is ironic, given that the author's attitude towards firearms is much more in line with an American one.

to:

** Which is ironic, given that the author's attitude towards firearms is at least at one point (notably with part of Vimes' internal monologue in ''Night Watch'') much more in line with an American one.one. Of course, Vimes is not Pratchett, and Pratchett was not Vimes, and in any case, Vimes was thinking from a very different standpoint when the City Watch was little more than the Patrician's gang of armed thugs.


* GeniusBonus: There is a throwaway line partway in the book, when Cuddy and Detrius are chasing the antagonist, that he runs down Grope Alley, which the book explains the origin of the name is fortunately lost in the mists of time. This is very amusing if you happen to know that [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gropecunt_Lane many streets were renamed to "Grope" from "Gropecunt"]].

to:

* GeniusBonus: There is a throwaway line partway in the book, when Cuddy and Detrius are chasing the antagonist, that he runs down Grope Alley, which the book explains the origin of the name is fortunately "fortunately" lost in the mists of time. This is very amusing if you happen to know that [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gropecunt_Lane many streets were renamed to "Grope" from "Gropecunt"]].

Added DiffLines:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Carrot's HiddenDepths in this book help create the impression that he is just as competent a manipulator as the Patrician. This includes stopping a riot between dwarfs and trolls by talking (a feat noted to have got any other member of the watch killed) and bluffing the head of the Fool's Guild.


* ItWasHisSled: That Angua [[spoiler:is a werewolf]]. None of the subsequent Watch books make a secret of it, naturally, and there's a running gag in the other Ankh-Morpork books that the general populace - told only that there ''is'' a werewolf in the Watch - leap to the assumption that it's Nobby.

to:

* ItWasHisSled: That Angua [[spoiler:is is a werewolf]].werewolf. None of the subsequent Watch books make a secret of it, naturally, and there's a running gag in the other Ankh-Morpork books that the general populace - told only that there ''is'' a werewolf in the Watch - leap to the assumption that it's Nobby.

Added DiffLines:

* HarsherInHindsight: With the rise in stories about police brutality and shooting innocent people in the 2010s (or depending on how cynical you are, the rise in means to ''record'' these things), the Gonne's effect on Vimes is even more chilling. Ditto the part about how a good person will just kill you.


* ItWasHisSled: That Angua [[spoiler:is a werewolf]]. None of the subsequent Watch books make a secret of it, naturally, and there's a running gag in the other Ankh-Morpork books that people think it's Nobby Nobbs.

to:

* ItWasHisSled: That Angua [[spoiler:is a werewolf]]. None of the subsequent Watch books make a secret of it, naturally, and there's a running gag in the other Ankh-Morpork books that people think the general populace - told only that there ''is'' a werewolf in the Watch - leap to the assumption that it's Nobby Nobbs.Nobby.


* GeniusBonus: There is a throwaway line partway in the book, when Cuddy and Detrius are chasing the antagonist, that he runs down Grope Alley, which the book explains the origin of the name is fortunately lost in the mists of time. This is very amusing if you happen to know that many streets were renamed to "Grope" from "Gropecunt". [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gropecunt_Lane]]

to:

* GeniusBonus: There is a throwaway line partway in the book, when Cuddy and Detrius are chasing the antagonist, that he runs down Grope Alley, which the book explains the origin of the name is fortunately lost in the mists of time. This is very amusing if you happen to know that many streets were renamed to "Grope" from "Gropecunt". [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gropecunt_Lane]]org/wiki/Gropecunt_Lane many streets were renamed to "Grope" from "Gropecunt"]].

Added DiffLines:

* ItWasHisSled: That Angua [[spoiler:is a werewolf]]. None of the subsequent Watch books make a secret of it, naturally, and there's a running gag in the other Ankh-Morpork books that people think it's Nobby Nobbs.

Showing 15 edit(s) of 21

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report