History YMMV / Mashed

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: WesternAnimation/PostmanPat gets this in "Man vs Train: Cartoon Nightmares". Jess getting run over by Thomas was really Pat's own fault for not being willing to wait a few more moments while the railway line still clearly had an oncoming train, so it's hard to side with him when he wants revenge on Thomas.

* UnintentionallyUnympathetic: WesternAnimation/PostmanPat gets this in "Man vs Train: Cartoon Nightmares". Jess getting run over by Thomas was really Pat's own fault for not being willing to wait a few more moments while the railway line still clearly had an oncoming train, so it's hard to side with him when he wants revenge on Thomas.

** Most of ''Cult of the Lamb: Doom & Shroom'', especially the way the Lamb and his wife are the ''only ones'' with basic common sense, even before the cult goes crazy, his outrage at his followers for leaving his ex to rot on the floor and even being [[TooDumbToLive Too Dumb To Eat]], with multiple commenters mentioning that Lamb reminds them more of a kindergarten teacher, a daycare center attendant or a frustrated patriarch than the leader of a cult.

** In general, their animation is seen as of pretty high quality, but in particular fans liked [[https://youtu.be/ryKsTMqxgRk Samurai Witcher]] for pretty much nailing the ''WesternAnimation/SamuraiJack'' style while simultaneously paying homage to ''VideoGame/TheWitcher''.
** The ''Waluigi vs Smash Bros'' series, a trilogy of music videos showcasing Waluigi's one-man crusade against ''all 70 characters'' in the ''Super Smash Bros Ultimate'' roster as revenge for not being invited, with heartpoundingly well-done animation to accompany the vocal performance of The Kevin Bennett.

** Eggman robiticizing Sonic? Dark. Sonic having oil ''in his butthole'' in the process? So evil you have a crack a little smirk.
** Sonic's friends betraying him for Metal Sonic as he acted like a douchebag with them for the whole episode? Understandable, but a bit disproportionned. Eggman taking pleasure at "repairing" Sonic for his "[[UnusualEuphemism Wednesday servicing]]" where the robot is transformed into a {{Hermaphrodite}} {{Sexbot}} for UsefulNotes/{{BDSM}} performances? Hysterical.

** The "Sonic vs. Rule 34" series is full of for how much it parodies and references Rule 34. From the very first episode, as Eggman states his latest plan to defeat Sonic, he claims that he searched the internet for "inspiration", with a flashback showing him clearly blushing with a gleeful expression, making it very clear that he's looking at porn. In the same episode, Sonic spontaneously learns [[SuperDrowningSkills how to swim]] out of pure desperation [[MakesJustAsMuchSenseInContext to escape a Rouge octopus]].

** Most of ''Cult of the Lamb: Doom & Shroom'', especially the way the Lamb and his wife are the ''only ones'' with basic common sense, even before the cult goes crazy, his outrage at his followers for leaving his ex to rot on the floor and even being [[TooDumbToLive Too Dumb To Eat]], with multiple commenters mentioning that Lamb reminds them more of a kindergarden teacher, a daycare center attendant or a frustrated patriarch than the leader of a cult.

** The [[DownerEnding ending]] to "Betty Help?". After going through all the trouble of trying to help a dying human, Betty finds herself too late with the human reduced to a skeleton. Betty herself stay by the skeleton until her battery dies.
** ''The secret history of Megaman'' puts a very tragic spin on the classic era, turning Dr. Willy into a WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds who's too deep in delusion from his grief to come back to the right path.

* SugarWiki/FunnyMoments: The "Sonic vs. Rule 34" series is full of for how much it parodies and references Rule 34. From the very first episode, as Eggman states his latest plan to defeat Sonic, he claims that he searched the internet for "inspiration", with a flashback showing him clearly blushing with a gleeful expression, making it very clear that he's looking at porn. In the same episode, Sonic spontaneously learns [[SuperDrowningSkills how to swim]] out of pure desperation [[MakesJustAsMuchSenseInContext to escape a Rouge octopus]].

* SugarWiki/SheReallyCanAct: Eileen "[=EileMonty=]" Montgomery's can be praised for her performance as the mentally broken pink hedgehog in the "There's something about Amy" series, especially in the second episode. She also managed to make the sentence "What are friends for?" chilling.

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
** [[spoiler: Tails recruiting Amy in "There's Something About Amy". Was it his plan all along and he orchestrated things to reach that point? Was he actually planning to kill Amy but she proved more dangerous than he anticipated so he had to think on his feet? Is he just so insane that he honestly didn't think Amy would react as badly as she did? The fact he seemed to plan for Amy to discover the original Tails' corpse just makes it even more unclear about what he's planning. The fourth part at least shows that he's afraid enough of Amy to not overextend his control of her, knowing that she can very easily overpower and kill him if she wants.]]
** [[spoiler: Another one for Tails is just why he arranged for Sonic's death, especially after he professes how he doesn't see the Sonic of this universe as the "Real Sonic". Is he just such a {{Yandere}} that he can't stand the thought of any Sonic being close to someone other than him? Did he want this Sonic dead for not being the real one? Was his death just part of a larger plan to bring Amy over to Tails side? Was it just ForTheEvulz?]]
** [[spoiler: Did Amy really fall for Tails talk of finding the "Real Sonic" or is she just playing along so she can get revenge on Tails in a more satisfying manner than just killing him? Or is a midpoint between the two where she knows that she shouldn't trust Tails by this point but she's too tempted by the thought of finding another Sonic to heed common sense, with it being possible that she will turn on Tails if he upsets her enough. Tails himself knows not to take her alliance for granted, as he notes that he doesn't want to be on the receiving end of her newfound insanity.]]

** Whether or not you liked Amy Rose’s fan girly crush obsession with Sonic, “There’s Something About Amy” takes this concept and [[spoiler: shows us a woman who’s a tragic victim of her own obsessions and Tails' manipulations, which culminates in part 2 with her violently murdering Sonic after he rejects what she is now. This then shatters her already fragile psyche even further once she realizes that she destroyed the object of her desire. This is a sad case in RealLife as most obsessive killers do kill their victims, who they often stalk, when their “perfect partner” rejects them and shatters their delusions of them.]]
*** [[spoiler: Her dialogues throughout part 2 don’t make it hurt any less. She seems to swing back between realizing something is wrong with this whole situation and clinging to the delusion that this is what both she and Sonic wanted. Another tragic case of RealLife with victims of delusional episodes as they can swing between being rational and being sucked back into their twisted fantasy world where they think that what they are doing is rational.]]
*** The further kicker is that [[spoiler: Sonic saw that she was mentally unstable and wanted to help her. But since she clung so hard to her delusion that she willingly altered her body to be what Sonic desired and that she was crushing Sonic's arm to the point that blood was being drawn and his bones were being crushed; Sonic saw no other way to reach out to her, but to snap at her and call her a monster and telling her that they will never be together. Poor choice of words on his part, but as he’s trying to leave, you can see how crushed he is with the whole situation and when she leaps to smash his head in, his expression is one of remorse and sadness. What makes the whole situation worse was that Sonic really did care about Amy and was hoping that they would have a romantic relationship. But because of Amy's insanity, that would sadly never happen.]]
---->'''Amy:'''[[spoiler: [[IJustWantToBeLoved I…I jus…I just wanted you to love me, my baby.]] [[IDidntMeanToKillHim I never mea-nt to…to…]]]]
*** [[spoiler: Come Part 3 and she’s now completely broken, a slave to her delusions and the manipulations of another Tails who claims he can take her to the “real Sonic”, the one who’ll love her no matter what.]]
*** Also from Part 3, with the reveal that Sonic did indeed reciprocate Amy's feelings for him, and as Tails put it, he was too scared to admit it, we're treated to a OnceMoreWithClarity moment of Amy's first attempt at romancing Sonic from Part 1, which shows Sonic's perspective after he shut the door on Amy, revealing that he berated himself for not mustering up the courage to display appreciation for Amy's efforts. We're also shown that the reason Amy's attempts at following Tails' advice in order to get Sonic to love her didn't work was because Tails gave the ''exact same advice'' to Sonic, and with TheReveal of Tails' true identity in the episode, it was all part of his true intention to keep them apart. People who have trouble admitting that they reciprocate the feelings of those who have crushes on them may sympathise with Sonic.

* CryForTheDevil: [[spoiler: Arguably, Tails deserves some pity from the audience despite his actions. Yes, he's a deranged psychopath, murdered innocent people, and drove a version of Amy to madness, but you can't help but feel slightly sad for him. His desire to find a version of Sonic that will accept him is the source of his insanity. He goes as far as to tear through the Sonic Multiverse in the hopes that there is a copy of the blue hedgehog that will be his friend. At the end of the day, "Secret History" Tails wants to be accepted and loved]].

* SympathyForTheDevil: [[spoiler: Arguably, Tails deserves some pity from the audience despite his actions. Yes, he's a deranged psychopath, murdered innocent people, and drove a version of Amy to madness, but you can't help but feel slightly sad for him. His desire to find a version of Sonic that will accept him is the source of his insanity. He goes as far as to tear through the Sonic Multiverse in the hopes that there is a copy of the blue hedgehog that will be his friend. At the end of the day, "Secret History" Tails wants to be accepted and loved]].

* CriticalResearchFailure: Bandana Waddle Dee is one of the waddle dees included in ''Grunt Battle 4'', which features a group of waddle dees and zombie dogs fighting each others. Several comments noted that Bandana Waddle Dee is not a [[{{Mook}} grunt]], but an unique character who is also playable, which makes him out of place here.

** [[spoiler: Tails recruiting Amy in "There's Something About Amy". Was it his plan all along and he orchestrated things to reach that point? Was he actually planning to kill Amy but she proved more dangerous than he anticipated so he had to think on his feet? Is he just so insane that he honestly didn't think Amy would react as badly as she did? The fact he seemed to plan for Amy to discover the original Tail's corpse just makes it even more unclear about what he's planning.]]

** [[spoiler: Did Amy really fall for Tails talk of finding the "Real Sonic" or is she just playing along so she can get revenge on Tails in a more satisfying manner than just killing him? Or is a midpoint between the two where she knows that she shouldn't trust Tails by this point but she's too tempted by the thought of finding another Sonic to heed common sense, with it being possible that she will turn on Tails if he upsets her enough.]]

* CatharisFactor: In ''Luigi's Revenge'', DisproportionateRetribution aside, one can't help but cheer seeing [[spoiler: Luigi fix the "great mistake" he made in ''Luigi's Lament'', breaking himself and his friends out of prison and taking down Bowser's regime after having been his prisoner for 2 years]].

* CatharisisFactor: In ''Luigi's Revenge'', DisproportionateRetribution aside, one can't help but cheer seeing [[spoiler: Luigi fix the "great mistake" he made in ''Luigi's Lament'', breaking himself and his friends out of prison and taking down Bowser's regime after having been his prisoner for 2 years]].

* MagnificentBastard: Tails [[spoiler: who turns out to be the version from the Secret Histories videos. After seamlessly pulling a KillAndReplace on the Tails of this world he effortlessly manipulates both Amy and Sonic to get exactly what he wants, only being exposed because he chooses to reveal himself. And when Amy has every reason to want him dead and is literally choking the life out of him he knows ''just'' the right words to say to not only defuse her rage but get her completely on his side as a willing accomplice.]]

*** [[spoiler: Come Part 3 and she’s now completely broken, a slave to her delusions and the manipulations of another Tail’s who claims he can take her to the “real Sonic”, the one who’ll love her no matter what.]]

* SugarWiki/FunnyMoments: The "Sonic vs. Rule 34" series is full of for how much it parodies and references Rule 34. From the very first episode, as Eggman states his latest plan to defeat Sonic, he claims that he searched the internet for "inspiration", with a flashback showing him clearly blushing with a gleeful expression, making it very clear that he's looking at porn.

* CrossesTheLineTwice: "Sonic's Metal Nightmare" crossed it so many times that the channel amusingly wondered if they didn't went too far with it:
** Eggman robiticizing Sonic? Dark. Sonic having oil ''in his butthole''? So evil you have a crack a little smirk.

** Sonic's friends betraying him for Metal Sonic as he acted like a douchebag with them for the whole episode? Understandable, but a bit disproportionned. Eggman taking pleasure at "repairing" Sonic for his "[[UnusualEuphemism Wednesday servicing]]" where the robot is transformed into a {{Hermaphrodite}} {{Sexbot}} for UsefulNotes/BDSM performances? Hysterical.

* SugarWiki/SheReallyCanAct: Eileen "[=EileMonty=]" Montgomery's can be applaused for her performance as the mentally broken pink hedgehog in "There's something about Amy". She also managed to make the sentence "What are friends for?" chilling.

** Sonic's friends betraying him for Metal Sonic as he acted like a douchebag with them for the whole episode? Understandable, but a bit disproportionned. Eggman taking pleasure at "repairing" Sonic for his "[[UnusualEuphemism Wednesday servicing]]"? Hysterical.

* SugarWiki/SheReallyCanAct: Eileen "[=EileMonty=]" Montgomery did a really moving performance as Amy in "There's something about Amy". Her performance as Tails is chilling too.

* TearJerker: The [[DownerEnding ending]] to "Betty Help?". After going through all the trouble of trying to help a dying human, Betty finds herself too late with the human reduced to a skeleton. Betty herself stay by the skeleton until her battery dies.

** [[spoiler: Her dialogues throughout part 2 don’t make it hurt any less. She seems to swing back between realizing something is wrong with this whole situation and clinging to the delusion that this is what both she and Sonic wanted. Another tragic case of RealLife with victims of delusional episodes as they can swing between being rational and being sucked back into their twisted fantasy world where they think that what they are doing is rational.]]
** The further kicker is that [[spoiler: Sonic saw that she was mentally unstable and wanted to help her. But since she clung so hard to her delusion that she willingly altered her body to be what Sonic desired and that she was crushing Sonic's arm to the point that blood was being drawn and his bones were being crushed; Sonic saw no other way to reach out to her, but to snap at her and call her a monster and telling her that they will never be together. Poor choice of words on his part, but as he’s trying to leave, you can see how crushed he is with the whole situation and when she leaps to smash his head in, his expression is one of remorse and sadness. What makes the whole situation worse was that Sonic really did care about Amy and was hoping that they would have a romantic relationship. But because of Amy's insanity, that would sadly never happen.]]
--->'''Amy:'''[[spoiler: [[IJustWantToBeLoved I…I jus…I just wanted you to love me, my baby.]] [[IDidntMeanToKillHim I never meant to…to…]]]]
** [[spoiler: Come Part 3 and she’s now completely broken, a slave to her delusions and the manipulations of another Tail’s who claims he can take her to the “real Sonic”, the one who’ll love her no matter what.]]