History YMMV / HeavensLostProperty

* ShipToShipCombat: Dear lord, not only is there no OfficialCouple, but also plenty of ShipTease between [[CluelessChickMagnet Tomoki]] and his 4/5 girls, in other words, it's a shipping mine! Particularly vicious is the battle between Tomoki/Ikaros and Tomoki/Nymph shippers: While Ikaros generally had a more important role in the storyline than Nymph, and many readers/viewers consider her a NiceGirl and fairly attractive, not to mention her UndyingLoyalty, she is also an ExtremeDoormat, who still [[WhatIsThisThingYouCallLove doesn't know, what love in particular means]]. Nymph on the other side is beneath her {{Jerkass}} and {{Tsundere}} tendencies also an extremly NiceGirl and unlike Ikaros, she really has TheWoobie bonus going for her (and, by the way, quite some people think of her as ''kawaii''). The Tomoki/Ikaros shippers have a tendency to swoon over Ikaros' hotness and absolute obedience and to call the Tomoki/Nymph shippers pedophiles (never mind the hypocrisy of calling someone disgusting when you like the idea of a girl who will do whatever her "master" commands, no matter what it is, without complaint), the latter ones on the other side usually point out Nymph's positive attributes. In comparison, the Tomoki/[[PatientChildhoodLoveInterest Sohara]] and Tomoki/[[DumbBlonde Astraea]] Shippers are much more subtle and tolerant and often cool enough to laughingly point out that they favor a Darkhorse. Considering [[IncorruptiblePurePureness Hiyori Kazane]]'s status as an EnsembleDarkhorse and the fact that she really is so much easier to pair off with the Protagonist, she was also a ''very'' popular runner, at least until [[spoiler: [[ShipSinking she died]].]]

* UncannyValley: The anime has one when [[spoiler:Chaos impersonates Tomoki. At this point, the only expression Chaos has is her GlasgowGrin, and her]] eyes are constantly adorned with three lines of light akin to Ikaros or Nymph when scanning. This expression on Tomoki's face is ''horrifying''.

* TheScrappy: Mikako is widely seen as the worst character in the series because she has no purpose other than to goad Tomoki into misery for her own enjoyment. Her whole shtick of "Organize an event, rope Tomoki in and then humiliate him" was funny the first time, chuckle-worthy a second time, facepalm inducing the third time and rage inducing every time after that.

* BaseBreakingCharacter:
** Sohara is a big one for some of the fans due to her [[DoubleStandardAbuseFemaleOnMale treatment of Tomoki.]] While some feel it's fair to keep his perverted (bordering on sexual assault) acts in check, others think she crosses the line and attacks him for things that aren't his fault, or are simply disproportional to the crime. It's worth noting that most of these opinions are from early on, before the insane level of Tomoki's perverted acts was revealed, and the hate is more of a NeverLiveItDown for blowing up his house.
** Mikako, with how she instigates many of the troubles the characters get into, and is especially sadistic in her treatment of Tomoki, yet never gets any sort of karmic retribution for it.

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Hiyori.

* CrazyAwesome:

** It's definitely genetics in Tomoki's case. Tomoyo also shows some good CrazyAwesome credentials. For instance, among her many pervesion attempts, [[http://raw.senmanga.com/Sora_no_Otoshimono/67/22/ this is her response]] when hearing from a crying Sohara about her son's HeroicBSOD.