Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / EvilDead2013

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: [[YourSoulIsMine The Taker of Souls]] is a [[OurDemonsAreDifferent demonic entity]] whose evil is so great that he is regarded as the Devil itself by many who face him. Often accidentally summoned by hapless innocents using the [[TomeOfEldritchLore Naturom Demonto]], the Taker seeks to [[DemonicPossession possess]], torment, and kill five people so as to use their feasted-upon souls to summon the nightmarish [[HumanoidAbomination Abomination]] to the mortal realm. In one instance of his summoning, the Taker turned a teenage girl into his host and killed her mother, laughing in her father's face about it. In the present, the Taker possesses Mia by raping her, then goes about torturing and maiming her and her friends in horrific ways while picking them all off. The Taker gleefully mocks her brother all the while that Mia and their mother are burning in Hell, and he'll soon join them for daring to defy the Taker.

to:

* CompleteMonster: [[YourSoulIsMine The Taker of Souls]] is a [[OurDemonsAreDifferent demonic entity]] whose evil is so great that he is regarded as the Devil itself by many who face him. Often accidentally summoned by hapless innocents using the [[TomeOfEldritchLore ''[[TomeOfEldritchLore Naturom Demonto]], Demonto]]'', the Taker seeks to [[DemonicPossession possess]], torment, and kill five people so as to use their feasted-upon souls to summon the nightmarish [[HumanoidAbomination Abomination]] to the mortal realm. In one instance of his summoning, the Taker turned a teenage girl into his host and killed her mother, laughing in her father's face about it. In the present, the Taker possesses Mia by raping her, then goes about torturing and maiming her and her friends in horrific ways while picking them all off. The Taker gleefully mocks her brother all the while that Mia and their mother are burning in Hell, and he'll soon join them for daring to defy the Taker.

Changed: 24

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: [[YourSoulIsMine The Taker of Souls]] is a [[OurDemonsAreDifferent demonic entity]] whose evil is so great that he is regarded as the Devil itself by many who face him. Often accidentally summoned by hapless innocents using the ''[[TomeOfEldritchLore Naturom Demonto]], the Taker seeks to possess, torment, and kill five people so as to use their feasted-upon souls to summon the nightmarish [[HumanoidAbomination Abomination]] to the mortal realm. In one instance of his summoning, the Taker turned a teenage girl into his host and killed her mother, laughing in her father's face about it. In the present, the Taker possesses Mia by raping her, then goes about torturing and maiming her and her friends in horrific ways while picking them all off. The Taker gleefully mocks her brother all the while that Mia and their mother are burning in Hell, and he'll soon join them for daring to defy the Taker.

to:

* CompleteMonster: [[YourSoulIsMine The Taker of Souls]] is a [[OurDemonsAreDifferent demonic entity]] whose evil is so great that he is regarded as the Devil itself by many who face him. Often accidentally summoned by hapless innocents using the ''[[TomeOfEldritchLore [[TomeOfEldritchLore Naturom Demonto]], the Taker seeks to possess, [[DemonicPossession possess]], torment, and kill five people so as to use their feasted-upon souls to summon the nightmarish [[HumanoidAbomination Abomination]] to the mortal realm. In one instance of his summoning, the Taker turned a teenage girl into his host and killed her mother, laughing in her father's face about it. In the present, the Taker possesses Mia by raping her, then goes about torturing and maiming her and her friends in horrific ways while picking them all off. The Taker gleefully mocks her brother all the while that Mia and their mother are burning in Hell, and he'll soon join them for daring to defy the Taker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.

Added DiffLines:

* CompleteMonster: [[YourSoulIsMine The Taker of Souls]] is a [[OurDemonsAreDifferent demonic entity]] whose evil is so great that he is regarded as the Devil itself by many who face him. Often accidentally summoned by hapless innocents using the ''[[TomeOfEldritchLore Naturom Demonto]], the Taker seeks to possess, torment, and kill five people so as to use their feasted-upon souls to summon the nightmarish [[HumanoidAbomination Abomination]] to the mortal realm. In one instance of his summoning, the Taker turned a teenage girl into his host and killed her mother, laughing in her father's face about it. In the present, the Taker possesses Mia by raping her, then goes about torturing and maiming her and her friends in horrific ways while picking them all off. The Taker gleefully mocks her brother all the while that Mia and their mother are burning in Hell, and he'll soon join them for daring to defy the Taker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Which wouldn't be surprising if this brings her back to drugs. Death by heroin overdose probably sounds like an attractive option at this point.

to:

** Which wouldn't be surprising if all of this brings her back to drugs. Death by heroin overdose probably sounds like an attractive option at this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: Some cues of Roque Baños's score and its overall broodingly brassiness for the film can bring in mind Music/GraemeRevell's score to ''Film/ChildsPlay2'', while at the same time baring a resemblance to the horror film music works of [[Film/{{Scream}} Marco Beltrami]] and [[Frachise/{{Hellraiser}} Christopher]] [[Film/DragMeToHell Young]].

to:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: Some cues of Roque Baños's score and its overall broodingly brassiness for the film can bring in mind Music/GraemeRevell's score to ''Film/ChildsPlay2'', while at the same time baring a resemblance to the horror film music works of [[Film/{{Scream}} Marco Beltrami]] and [[Frachise/{{Hellraiser}} [[Franchise/{{Hellraiser}} Christopher]] [[Film/DragMeToHell Young]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: Some cues of Roque Baños's score and its overall broodingly brassiness for the film can bring in mind Music/GraemeRevell's score to ''Film/ChildsPlay2''.

to:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: Some cues of Roque Baños's score and its overall broodingly brassiness for the film can bring in mind Music/GraemeRevell's score to ''Film/ChildsPlay2''.''Film/ChildsPlay2'', while at the same time baring a resemblance to the horror film music works of [[Film/{{Scream}} Marco Beltrami]] and [[Frachise/{{Hellraiser}} Christopher]] [[Film/DragMeToHell Young]].

Added: 180

Changed: 79

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheScrappy: Olivia comes as this for some. Even though she tries to help Mia, most fans of the movie hate her for trying to pretend to be a real doctor and only making Mia's heroin problem worse.

to:

* TheScrappy: Olivia comes as this for some. Even though she tries to help Mia, most fans of the movie hate her for trying to pretend to be a real doctor and doctor, only making Mia's heroin problem worse.worse and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking for peeing herself as she gets possessed]].


Added DiffLines:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: Some cues of Roque Baños's score and its overall broodingly brassiness for the film can bring in mind Music/GraemeRevell's score to ''Film/ChildsPlay2''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NarmCharm: The forced exposition can be hilarious. Then again, it’s an Evil Dead movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not YMMV


* [[OurZombiesAreDifferent Our Deadites are Different]]: While Deadites throughout the franchise were never exactly [[{{Understatement}} pleasant creatures,]] the ones in this film are straight up malicious, the deadites seem to delight in keeping their hosts aware enough to see and feel what the host is doing, evidenced by one making a girl clearly watch in horror as it makes her mutilate her own face, and giving a false HopeSpot to another by letting her cut off her own arm, but, in an inversion to the original attempt in the franchise, it possesses her anyway, these ones actually seem much more fond of Self Mutilation and seriousness, than the Evil, prankster stylings of the Original Trilogies, they also look different, gone are the milky white eyes and inhuman growls, replaces with sickly yellow iris and a werid demonic insectile chirping sound.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Assuming she doesn't bleed to death from having to lose her hand, alone and in the woods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleting Natter.


** [[spoiler: It's quite debatable. The condition for the Abomination's release is for 5 souls to be consumed. In the main story, 4 people die in the house: Olivia, Natalie, Eric and David. In the prologue, the little girl dies. Also, the dog dies. Anyway it's pretty certain that the "quota" has been fulfilled.]]
*** [[spoiler: Yeah, no. The girl is purified, so she doesn't count. The dog's soul would make sense, since it doesn't say they have to be ''human'' souls, but it's still pretty desperate. Among the main group, only Olivia dies in a way that wouldn't count as purification (getting her skull bashed in): Natalie was dismembered; Eric and David were burned; and Mia was buried alive and then brought back. So even if the dog could be counted, the Abomination would have only consumed 2 souls.]]
*** [[spoiler: On the other hand, the girl from the opening is stated to have killed her mother, so her soul could possibly be counted as the third, but it's still not enough to fill the "quota".]]
*** [[spoiler: The Abomination only needs to consume five souls, but may not need to retain them. So each soul acts like a key to a lock, but even if you take the key back the lock will remain open. Looking at who died, the little girl from the intro, Mia, Olivia, Natalie, and Eric were all possessed and David died in the fire before he became a Deadite. This could explain why it is so weak, all the souls it would have consumed to grow in power have been purified for the most part.]]
*** Mia's [[spoiler: death and subsequent resurrection could mean that she came back without a soul. That would fulfill the quota]] and count as FridgeHorror.
*** [[spoiler: Or, only the teens counted, and the reason the Abomination was so weak was because Mia was brought back as the Abomination was being summoned, ripping Mias soul out of the ritual, the reason it is so intent on getting Mia is because it cannot assume it's full range of power without her soul.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[OurZombiesAreDifferent Our Deadites are Different]]: While Deadites throughout the franchise were never exactly [[{{Understatement}} pleasant creatures,]] the ones in this film are straight up malicious, the deadites seem to delight in keeping their hosts aware enough to see and feel what the host is doing, evidenced by one making a girl clearly watch in horror as it makes her mutilate her own face, and giving FalseHope to another by letting her cut off her own arm, but, in an inversion to the original attempt in the franchise, it possesses her anyway, these ones actually seem much more fond of SelfMutilation and seriousness, than the Evil, prankster stylings of the Original Trilogies, they also look different, gone are the milky white eyes and inhuman growls, replaces with sickly yellow iris and a werid demonic insectile chirping sound.

to:

* [[OurZombiesAreDifferent Our Deadites are Different]]: While Deadites throughout the franchise were never exactly [[{{Understatement}} pleasant creatures,]] the ones in this film are straight up malicious, the deadites seem to delight in keeping their hosts aware enough to see and feel what the host is doing, evidenced by one making a girl clearly watch in horror as it makes her mutilate her own face, and giving FalseHope a false HopeSpot to another by letting her cut off her own arm, but, in an inversion to the original attempt in the franchise, it possesses her anyway, these ones actually seem much more fond of SelfMutilation Self Mutilation and seriousness, than the Evil, prankster stylings of the Original Trilogies, they also look different, gone are the milky white eyes and inhuman growls, replaces with sickly yellow iris and a werid demonic insectile chirping sound.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[OurZombiesAreDifferent Our Deadites are Different]]: While Deadites throughout the franchise were never exactly [[{{Understatement}} pleasant creatures,]] the ones in this film are straight up malicious, the deadites seem to delight in keeping their hosts aware enough to see and feel what the host is doing, evidenced by one making a girl clearly watch in horror as it makes her mutilate her own face, and giving FalseHope to another by letting her cut off her own arm, but, in an inversion to the original attempt in the franchise, it possesses her anyway, these ones actually seem much more fond of SelfMutilation and seriousness, than the Evil, prankster stylings of the Original Trilogies, they also look different, gone are the milky white eyes and inhuman growls, replaces with sickly yellow iris and a werid demonic insectile chirping sound.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Also considering we never actually find out anything more about the people from the opening scene, they might have been planning to take the book away, [[KilledOffscreen but never got the chance]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: Or, only the teens counted, and the reason the Abomination was so weak was because Mia was brought back as the Abomination was being summoned, ripping Mias soul out of the ritual, the reason it is so intent on getting Mia is because it cannot assume it's full range of power without her soul.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Details about the original movie don't apply to this one and it's never stated in this movie that the book can do that sort of thing.


*** Much like the original films. Everything could have been avoided had Ash not only not listened to the recording but picked up the book in the first place.
*** I believe the book has a supernatural power that frees itself and draws people to it. It's not stated outright, but it's not far fetched either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EndingFatigue: It should've ended after [[spoiler: David revives Mia]].

to:

* EndingFatigue: It Some felt it should've ended after [[spoiler: David revives Mia]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The reliance on practical effects pays off very well.

to:

* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The reliance on practical effects pays off very well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* LoveItOrHateIt: Although the fans outweigh the detractors, it's only by a ''very'' slim margin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LoveItOrHateIt: You will find as many fans as you will detractors.

to:

* LoveItOrHateIt: You will find as many Although the fans as you will detractors.outweigh the detractors, it's only by a ''very'' slim margin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenBase: It being yet another 2000s-2010s remake of a horror film this was bound to happen.
** The film's decision to remake the first horror film and stick with the horror tone rather than the franchise's more famous horror-comedy tone. For some it gave this film a clear identity especially as the remake of the similarly toned first movie and that's what made it stand out. Others, especially those not fond of the first movie, felt the horror comedy angle was much more in line with the Evil Dead Franchise and weren't happy with this direction.
** The film's quality:
*** The film is praised for not being a retread over the previous movies by having a different cast of characters and a number of different plot points. The originals creators were onboard so it does feel like the film came from a place of love rather than a cash-grab and the practical effects were a bonus.
*** Others felt the plot ran on too many dumb ideas and the characters were either uninteresting or unlikable. In spite of the attempts to be different it still feels like an attempt to recapture lost glories with the franchise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Mia's [[spoiler: death and subsequent resurrection]] could mean that she [[spoiler: came back without a soul.]] That would [[spoiler: fulfill the quota]] and count as FridgeHorror.

to:

*** Mia's [[spoiler: death and subsequent resurrection]] resurrection could mean that she [[spoiler: came back without a soul.]] soul. That would [[spoiler: fulfill the quota]] and count as FridgeHorror.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Mia's [[spoiler: death and subsequent resurrection]] could mean that she [[spoiler: came back without a soul.]] That would [[spoiler: fulfill the quota]] and count as FridgeHorror.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Which wouldn't be surprising if this brings her back to drugs.

to:

** Which wouldn't be surprising if this brings her back to drugs. Death by heroin overdose probably sounds like an attractive option at this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssPull: The whole ending after [[spoiler: David successfully (well, in the actual movie at least) depossesses Mia.
** It's quite debatable. The condition for the Abomination's release is for 5 souls to be consumed. In the main story, 4 people die in the house: Olivia, Natalie, Eric and David. In the prologue, the little girl dies. Also, the dog dies. Anyway it's pretty certain that the "quota" has been fulfilled.
*** Yeah, no. The girl is purified, so she doesn't count. The dog's soul would make sense, since it doesn't say they have to be ''human'' souls, but it's still pretty desperate. Among the main group, only Olivia dies in a way that wouldn't count as purification (getting her skull bashed in): Natalie was dismembered; Eric and David were burned; and Mia was buried alive and then brought back. So even if the dog could be counted, the Abomination would have only consumed 2 souls.
*** On the other hand, the girl from the opening is stated to have killed her mother, so her soul could possibly be counted as the third, but it's still not enough to fill the "quota".
*** The Abomination only needs to consume five souls, but may not need to retain them. So each soul acts like a key to a lock, but even if you take the key back the lock will remain open. Looking at who died, the little girl from the intro, Mia, Olivia, Natalie, and Eric were all possessed and David died in the fire before he became a Deadite. This could explain why it is so weak, all the souls it would have consumed to grow in power have been purified for the most part.]]

to:

* AssPull: The whole ending after [[spoiler: David successfully (well, in the actual movie at least) depossesses Mia.
Mia.]]
** [[spoiler: It's quite debatable. The condition for the Abomination's release is for 5 souls to be consumed. In the main story, 4 people die in the house: Olivia, Natalie, Eric and David. In the prologue, the little girl dies. Also, the dog dies. Anyway it's pretty certain that the "quota" has been fulfilled.
fulfilled.]]
*** [[spoiler: Yeah, no. The girl is purified, so she doesn't count. The dog's soul would make sense, since it doesn't say they have to be ''human'' souls, but it's still pretty desperate. Among the main group, only Olivia dies in a way that wouldn't count as purification (getting her skull bashed in): Natalie was dismembered; Eric and David were burned; and Mia was buried alive and then brought back. So even if the dog could be counted, the Abomination would have only consumed 2 souls.
souls.]]
*** [[spoiler: On the other hand, the girl from the opening is stated to have killed her mother, so her soul could possibly be counted as the third, but it's still not enough to fill the "quota".
"quota".]]
*** [[spoiler: The Abomination only needs to consume five souls, but may not need to retain them. So each soul acts like a key to a lock, but even if you take the key back the lock will remain open. Looking at who died, the little girl from the intro, Mia, Olivia, Natalie, and Eric were all possessed and David died in the fire before he became a Deadite. This could explain why it is so weak, all the souls it would have consumed to grow in power have been purified for the most part.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssPull: The whole ending after [[spoiler: David successfully (well, in the actual movie at least) depossesses Mia]].

to:

* AssPull: The whole ending after [[spoiler: David successfully (well, in the actual movie at least) depossesses Mia]].Mia.



*** The Abomination only needs to consume five souls, but may not need to retain them. So each soul acts like a key to a lock, but even if you take the key back the lock will remain open. Looking at who died, the little girl from the intro, Mia, Olivia, Natalie, and Eric were all possessed and David died in the fire before he became a Deadite. This could explain why it is so weak, all the souls it would have consumed to grow in power have been purified for the most part.
* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: As welcome as Ash's cameo in the stinger is, it makes zero contextual sense.

to:

*** The Abomination only needs to consume five souls, but may not need to retain them. So each soul acts like a key to a lock, but even if you take the key back the lock will remain open. Looking at who died, the little girl from the intro, Mia, Olivia, Natalie, and Eric were all possessed and David died in the fire before he became a Deadite. This could explain why it is so weak, all the souls it would have consumed to grow in power have been purified for the most part. \n]]
* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: As welcome as [[spoiler: Ash's cameo cameo]] in the stinger is, it makes zero contextual sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***The Abomination only needs to consume five souls, but may not need to retain them. So each soul acts like a key to a lock, but even if you take the key back the lock will remain open. Looking at who died, the little girl from the intro, Mia, Olivia, Natalie, and Eric were all possessed and David died in the fire before he became a Deadite. This could explain why it is so weak, all the souls it would have consumed to grow in power have been purified for the most part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TearJerker: [[spoiler: Natalie's death]]. [[spoiler: After she loses one arm in a botched amputation and becomes possessed anyway, David blows her other arm with a shotgun to save Eric. Suddenly [[DyingAsYourself the demon leaves her body]], and she doesn't understand why David is hurting her. She bleeds out in his arms, sobbing, scared and confused, while [[DissonantLaughter Eric laughs mirthlessly.]]]]

to:

* TearJerker: [[spoiler: Natalie's death]]. [[spoiler: After she loses one arm in a botched amputation and becomes possessed anyway, David blows her other arm off with a shotgun to save Eric. Suddenly [[DyingAsYourself the demon leaves her body]], and she doesn't understand why David is hurting her. She bleeds out in his arms, sobbing, scared and confused, while [[DissonantLaughter Eric laughs mirthlessly.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Considering the evil has the power to turn ''trees'' into rape-monsters, who's to say that hiding it in a forest wouldn't be the '''worst''' choice of disposal sites?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: When the possessed [[spoiler: show flickers of their human personality, is it the demon masquerading as its host, or is it the demon's control temporarily slipping? Or is it the demon intentionally permitting their human side temporary awareness and speech, ''just'' to sadistically mess with host and witnesses, alike?]]

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: When the possessed [[spoiler: show flickers of their human personality, is it the demon masquerading as its host, or is it the demon's control temporarily slipping? Or is it the demon intentionally permitting their human side its host temporary awareness and speech, ''just'' to sadistically mess fuck with host and witnesses, alike?]]

Top