Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / DoctorWhoS31E11TheLodger

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition: For American audiences, Creator/JamesCorden.

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition: For American audiences, Creator/JamesCorden. (British audiences [[Series/GavinAndStacey already knew who he was]].)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Not a "moment", exactly, but part of the set decorations is an inexplicably creepy]painting hanging on the wall that's prominently focused on in several shots, but has nothing to do with the plot of the episode. What the hell was that about?

to:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Not a "moment", exactly, but part of the set decorations is an inexplicably creepy]painting creepy painting hanging on the wall that's prominently focused on in several shots, but has nothing to do with the plot of the episode. What the hell was that about?

Removed: 1175

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what Association Football is [[ObfuscatingStupidity (probably)]], and when a team member says "We're going to destroy [next week's opponents]!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!), before realising partway through that it was meant in a perfectly harmless fashion. He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" Gareth Roberts has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once' - and, to be fair, the rest of 11's tenure bears this out (of all the Doctors, he is possibly the worst at blending in).

Changed: 18

Removed: 154

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Uncanny Valley is IUEO now and the subjective version has been split; cleaning up misuse and ZCE in the process


* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Not a "moment", exactly, but part of the set decorations is an [[UncannyValley inexplicably creepy]] painting hanging on the wall that's prominently focused on in several shots, but has nothing to do with the plot of the episode. What the hell was that about?

to:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Not a "moment", exactly, but part of the set decorations is an [[UncannyValley inexplicably creepy]] painting creepy]painting hanging on the wall that's prominently focused on in several shots, but has nothing to do with the plot of the episode. What the hell was that about?



* UncannyValley: Again, the [[http://www.hotink.com/wacky/LodgerPainting.jpg bizarre painting]] on the wall. It looks like Music/NickCave in clown makeup!

Added: 4

Changed: 23

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what Association Football is [[ObfuscatingStupidity (probably)]], and when a team member says "We're going to destroy [next week's opponents]!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!), before realising partway through that it was meant in a perfectly harmless fashion. He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once' - and, to be fair, the rest of 11's tenure bears this out (of all the Doctors, he is possibly the worst at blending in).
* RetroactiveRecognition: For American audiences, James Corden.
* UncannyValley: Again, the [[http://www.hotink.com/wacky/LodgerPainting.jpg bizarre painting]] on the wall. It looks like Music/NickCave in clown makeup!

to:

* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what Association Football is [[ObfuscatingStupidity (probably)]], and when a team member says "We're going to destroy [next week's opponents]!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!), before realising partway through that it was meant in a perfectly harmless fashion. He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer Gareth Roberts has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once' - and, to be fair, the rest of 11's tenure bears this out (of all the Doctors, he is possibly the worst at blending in).
* RetroactiveRecognition: For American audiences, James Corden.
Creator/JamesCorden.
* UncannyValley: Again, the [[http://www.hotink.com/wacky/LodgerPainting.jpg bizarre painting]] on the wall. It looks like Music/NickCave in clown makeup!makeup!
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what British Football is [[ObfuscatingStupidity (probably)]], and when a team member says "We're going to destroy [next week's opponents]!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!), before realising partway through that it was meant in a perfectly harmless fashion. He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once' - and, to be fair, the rest of 11's tenure bears this out (of all the Doctors, he is possibly the worst at blending in).

to:

* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what British Association Football is [[ObfuscatingStupidity (probably)]], and when a team member says "We're going to destroy [next week's opponents]!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!), before realising partway through that it was meant in a perfectly harmless fashion. He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once' - and, to be fair, the rest of 11's tenure bears this out (of all the Doctors, he is possibly the worst at blending in).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what British Football is, and when the opposing team says "We're going to murder you!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!). He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once'.

to:

* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what British Football is, is [[ObfuscatingStupidity (probably)]], and when the opposing a team member says "We're going to murder you!" destroy [next week's opponents]!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!).whatsoever!), before realising partway through that it was meant in a perfectly harmless fashion. He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once'.once' - and, to be fair, the rest of 11's tenure bears this out (of all the Doctors, he is possibly the worst at blending in).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RetroactiveRecognition: For American audiences, James Corden.

Added: 1064

Changed: 991

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what British Football is, and when the opposing team says "We're going to murder you!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!). He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once'.

to:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Not a "moment", exactly, but part of the set decorations is an [[UncannyValley inexplicably creepy]] painting hanging on the wall that's prominently focused on in several shots, but has nothing to do with the plot of the episode. What the hell was that about?
* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what British Football is, and when the opposing team says "We're going to murder you!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!). He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once'.once'.
* UncannyValley: Again, the [[http://www.hotink.com/wacky/LodgerPainting.jpg bizarre painting]] on the wall. It looks like Music/NickCave in clown makeup!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what BritishFootball is, and when the opposing team says "We're going to murder you!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!). He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once'.

to:

* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what BritishFootball British Football is, and when the opposing team says "We're going to murder you!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!). He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IdiotPlot: The Doctor pretends to be a human, and clichés every "Alien trying to fit in" trope one can think of. Not to mention The Doctor, one of the most brilliant minds in the universe, has no idea what BritishFootball is, and when the opposing team says "We're going to murder you!" The Doctor goes into rage mode (I am The Doctor! The Oncoming Storm! I refuse to allow any killing whatsoever!). He also very awkwardly interrupts Craig and his girlfriend completely oblivious to the fact that they want "Alone Time" despite Craig outright announcing it earlier. And after unintentionally making Craig jealous (all his friends and co-workers loving him more, which he really should have picked up on) he still seems surprised when Craig tells him "I hate you, get out!" The writer has stated in his defence 'this is the Doctor acting like the Doctor, he's just doing it in a "normal" situation for once'.

Top