Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / DoctorWhoS13E4TheAndroidInvasion

Go To

OR

Removed: 1023

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* RelationshipWritingFumble: The abusive relationship HoYay subtext between Styggron and Crayford deserves a mention. Styggron is intended as an obsessive ControlFreak who has no interest in anything besides his convoluted plan, and it was supposed to be him manipulating Crayford for these ends and then abandoning him. Unfortunately, the gibberish-level convolution of his plan means that his {{Gaslighting}} of Crayford comes across as abuse for its own sake. The {{Padding}} scenes added by Creator/RobertHolmes add a whole subplot where Styggron straps down Crayford to an Agony Beam scanner to psychologically torture him by creating and destroying a robot duplicate in front of him, which makes Crayford's later obsessive devotion to him come off as inexplicable, unless he's emotionally codependent. The Doctor eventually has to talk Crayford into realising that Styggron's been lying to him about who he really is, which Crayford plays in the manner of someone finally realising the truth about an abusive husband.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Uncanny Valley is IUEO now and the subjective version has been split; cleaning up misuse and ZCE in the process


* UncannyValley: Some of the androids qualify - the 'deactivated' androids with their flat expressions and staring eyes, the finger-gun androids with their slightly odd artificial hands, the android Doctor doing all the lovable Doctor tics but with dead, predatory eyes, and especially the android Sarah Jane when her face falls off and reveals a strange mechanical head with protruding eyeballs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Both Creator/IanMarter and John Levene were both unhappy making this serial because they felt that there was no reason for Harry and Benton to be there at all. Indeed, they play their android duplicates for most of the story and even then, they play a minimal role. And this was their last appearance to boot.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Both Creator/IanMarter and John Levene were both unhappy making this serial because they felt that there was no reason for Harry and Benton to be there at all. Indeed, they play their android duplicates for most of the story and even then, they play a minimal role. And this was their last appearance in the series proper to boot.boot; Levene would reprise Benton for a DVD movie and some audios, but Marter would sadly pass away before he could return as Harry.

Added: 363

Changed: 259

Removed: 103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: Sarah nearly falls down a fairly nonthreatening embankment. Not as bad as what she'd have to deal with [[Recap/DoctorWho20thASTheFiveDoctors later]], but it didn't come across as life threatening. Probably the best the location could offer and they made do.

to:

* {{Narm}}: {{Narm}}:
**
Sarah nearly falls down a fairly nonthreatening embankment. Not as bad as what she'd have to deal with [[Recap/DoctorWho20thASTheFiveDoctors later]], but it didn't come across as life threatening. Probably the best the location could offer and they made do.



* SignatureScene: The face falling off Sarah-Jane's android duplicate, to reveal the wiring underneath.


Added DiffLines:

* SignatureScene: The face falling off Sarah-Jane's android duplicate, to reveal the wiring underneath.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Both Ian Marter and John Levene were both unhappy making this serial because they felt that there was no reason for Harry and Benton to be there at all. Indeed, they play their android duplicates for most of the story and even then, they play a minimal role. And this was their last appearance to boot.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Both Ian Marter Creator/IanMarter and John Levene were both unhappy making this serial because they felt that there was no reason for Harry and Benton to be there at all. Indeed, they play their android duplicates for most of the story and even then, they play a minimal role. And this was their last appearance to boot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SignatureScene: The face falling off Sarah-Janes android duplicate, to reveal the wiring underneath.

to:

* SignatureScene: The face falling off Sarah-Janes Sarah-Jane's android duplicate, to reveal the wiring underneath.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SignatureScene: The fact falling off Sarah-Janes android duplicate, to reveal the wiring underneath.

to:

* SignatureScene: The fact face falling off Sarah-Janes android duplicate, to reveal the wiring underneath.

Added: 62

Removed: 62

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Styggron: "Commence the analysis of the ''braaaaaaaain!'' "



** Styggron: "Commence the analysis of the ''braaaaaaaain!'' "
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SignatureScene: The fact falling off Sarah-Janes android duplicate, to reveal the wiring underneath.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Both Ian Marter and John Levene were both unhappy making this serial because they felt that there was no reason for Harry and Benton to be there at all. Indeed, they play their android duplicates for most of the story and even then, they play a minimal role. And this was their last appearance to boot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RelationshipWritingFumble: The abusive relationship HoYay subtext between Styggron and Crayford deserves a mention. Styggron is intended as an obsessive ControlFreak who has no interest in anything besides his convoluted plan, and it was supposed to be him manipulating Crayford for these ends and then abandoning him. Unfortunately, the gibberish-level convolution of his plan means that his {{Gaslighting}} of Crayford comes across as abuse for its own sake. The {{Padding}} scenes added by Creator/RobertHolmes add a whole subplot where Styggron straps down Crayford to an Agony Beam scanner to psychologically torture him by creating and destroying a robot duplicate in front of him, which makes Crayford's later obsessive devotion to him come off as inexplicable, unless he's emotionally codependent. The Doctor eventually has to talk Crayford into realising that Styggron's been lying to him about who he really is, which Crayford plays in the manner of someone finally realising the truth about an abusive husband.



* SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The face falling off the android Sarah Jane. Not only is the effect one of the all-time behind the sofa moments, some very clever construction is used to make the servos look like they go right to the back of the head, and the eyeballs are mounted on stiff springs that twitch in a way frighteningly like natural eyeball flicker movement, making it seem like the android is still thinking and studying the Doctor as it turns its head towards him.

to:

* SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The face falling off the android Sarah Jane. Not only is the effect one of the all-time behind the sofa moments, some very clever construction is used to make the servos look like they go right to the back of the head, and the eyeballs are mounted on stiff springs that twitch in a way frighteningly like natural eyeball flicker movement, making it seem like the android is still thinking and studying the Doctor as it turns its head towards him.him.
----

Added: 62

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ater the Android Doctor is destroyed, fooling Sarah Jane into thinking the Doctor was dead for a moment, she tells him not to do [[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E13TheWeddingOfRiverSong anything like that ever again]].

to:

** Ater After the Android Doctor is destroyed, fooling Sarah Jane into thinking the Doctor was dead for a moment, she tells him not to do [[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E13TheWeddingOfRiverSong anything like that ever again]].



** Styggron: "Commence the analysis of the ''braaaaaaaain!'' "



* UncannyValley: Some of the androids qualify - the 'deactivated' androids with their flat expressions and staring eyes, the finger-gun androids with their slightly odd artificial hands, the android Doctor doing all the loveable Doctor tics but with dead, predatory eyes, and especially the android Sarah Jane when her face falls off and reveals a strange mechanical head with protruding eyeballs.

to:

* UncannyValley: Some of the androids qualify - the 'deactivated' androids with their flat expressions and staring eyes, the finger-gun androids with their slightly odd artificial hands, the android Doctor doing all the loveable lovable Doctor tics but with dead, predatory eyes, and especially the android Sarah Jane when her face falls off and reveals a strange mechanical head with protruding eyeballs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotPlot: The story has a plot twist based around the idea that Crayford, a character who wears an eyepatch, actually still has a perfectly functioning eye underneath it without his knowledge. This would require him to never take his eyepatch off for years - not to clean it, not to sleep, nothing. The Doctor comes up with several incorrect theories regarding the events in the village - first that they've landed in the aftermath of a radioactive incident, then that there's mass hypnosis going on - which is quite unusual for him; Sarah forgets to tell the Doctor that the TARDIS has gone missing; and Styggron's "plan" is without doubt the most incomprehensible and random Gambit Roulette any villain has ever attempted in Classic ''Who'', which is saying something. The Doctor even speculates to an android Sarah about just one aspect of Styggron's plan (why's he bothering to create a simulated Earth village and fill it with android doubles if he could just wipe everyone out with a virus?) and the story never answers it. The DVD production subtitles spent a lot of time pointing out all of these plot holes and eventually conclude that Styggron is 'one of the most eccentric opponents the Doctor has ever faced... or else he's a twit'.

to:

* IdiotPlot: The story has a plot twist based around the idea that Crayford, a character who wears an eyepatch, actually still has a perfectly functioning eye underneath it without his knowledge. This would require him to never take his eyepatch off for years - not to clean it, not to sleep, nothing. The Doctor comes up with several incorrect theories regarding the events in the village - first that they've landed in the aftermath of a radioactive incident, then that there's mass hypnosis going on - which is quite unusual for him; Sarah forgets to tell the Doctor that the TARDIS has gone missing; and Styggron's "plan" is without doubt the most incomprehensible and random Gambit Roulette GambitRoulette ploy any villain has ever attempted in Classic ''Who'', which is saying something. The Doctor even speculates to an android Sarah about just one aspect of Styggron's plan (why's he bothering to create a simulated Earth village and fill it with android doubles if he could just wipe everyone out with a virus?) and the story never answers it. The DVD production subtitles spent a lot of time pointing out all of these plot holes and eventually conclude that Styggron is 'one of the most eccentric opponents the Doctor has ever faced... or else he's a twit'.

Added: 162

Changed: 169

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: The rocket-launch StockFootage used for the takeoff of Styggron's ship is the same clip that MTV used for its hourly station-identification in its early years.

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: HilariousInHindsight:
**
The rocket-launch StockFootage used for the takeoff of Styggron's ship is the same clip that MTV used for its hourly station-identification in its early years.



* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The face falling off the android Sarah Jane. Not only is the effect one of the all-time behind the sofa moments, some very clever construction is used to make the servos look like they go right to the back of the head, and the eyeballs are mounted on stiff springs that twitch in a way frighteningly like natural eyeball flicker movement, making it seem like the android is still thinking and studying the Doctor as it turns its head towards him.

to:

* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The face falling off the android Sarah Jane. Not only is the effect one of the all-time behind the sofa moments, some very clever construction is used to make the servos look like they go right to the back of the head, and the eyeballs are mounted on stiff springs that twitch in a way frighteningly like natural eyeball flicker movement, making it seem like the android is still thinking and studying the Doctor as it turns its head towards him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Narm: Sarah nearly falls down a fairly nonthreatening embankment. Not as bad as what she'd have to deal with [[Recap/DoctorWho20thASTheFiveDoctors later]], but it didn't come across as life threatening. Probably the best the location could offer and they made do.

to:

* Narm: {{Narm}}: Sarah nearly falls down a fairly nonthreatening embankment. Not as bad as what she'd have to deal with [[Recap/DoctorWho20thASTheFiveDoctors later]], but it didn't come across as life threatening. Probably the best the location could offer and they made do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Narm: Sarah nearly falls down a fairly nonthreatening embankment. Not as bad as what she'd have to deal with [[Recap/DoctorWho20thASTheFiveDoctors later]], but it didn't come across as life threatening. Probably the best the location could offer and they made do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ater the Android Doctor is destroyed, fooling Sarah Jane into thinking the Doctorwas dead for a moment, she tells him not to do [[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E13TheWeddingOfRiverSong anything like that ever again]].

to:

** Ater the Android Doctor is destroyed, fooling Sarah Jane into thinking the Doctorwas Doctor was dead for a moment, she tells him not to do [[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E13TheWeddingOfRiverSong anything like that ever again]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Ater the Android Doctor is destroyed, fooling Sarah Jane into thinking the Doctorwas dead for a moment, she tells him not to do [[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E13TheWeddingOfRiverSong anything like that ever again]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HamAndCheese: Creator/ TomBaker and Creator/ElisabethSladen hated everything they had to say and so rewrote all of their dialogue together. Both of them are clearly having a lot of fun.

to:

* HamAndCheese: Creator/ TomBaker Creator/TomBaker and Creator/ElisabethSladen hated everything they had to say and so rewrote all of their dialogue together. Both of them are clearly having a lot of fun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HamAndCheese: Creator/ TomBaker and Creator/ElisabethSladen hated everything they had to say and so rewrote all of their dialogue together. Both of them are clearly having a lot of fun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Doctor Who Novelisations have their own YMMV page


* BetterThanCanon: The Target Novelisation is regarded as being superior to the story, largely because Creator/TerranceDicks filled in some of the PlotHoles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BetterOnDVD: A major plot point concerns a throwaway exchange about thirty seconds into the first episode (the Doctor casually offering Sarah a sip of his drink and Sarah turning it down). It's easy enough to remember that Sarah [[DoesNotLikeSpam doesn't like ginger pop]] if you watched the whole thing in one sitting, but most viewers who weren't anorak-level Sarah fans would have been lost after waiting a week between episodes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Padding}}: All of the scenes developing the relationship between Crayford and Styggron were added by Creator/RobertHolmes (and, since they're in a totally different writing style to Creator/TerryNation, it shows). It has the side effect of making Crayford and Styggron's relationship come off as a bit weirdly sadomasochistic.

to:

* {{Padding}}: All of the scenes developing the relationship between Crayford and Styggron were added to fill the serial's running time by Creator/RobertHolmes (and, since they're in a totally different writing style to Creator/TerryNation, it shows). It has the side effect of making Crayford and Styggron's relationship come off as a bit weirdly sadomasochistic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Padding}}: All of the scenes developing the relationship between Crayford and Styggron were added by cREATOR/RobertHolmes (and, since they're in a totally different writing style to Creator/TerryNation, it shows). It has the side effect of making Crayford and Styggron's relationship come off as a bit weirdly sadomasochistic.

to:

* {{Padding}}: All of the scenes developing the relationship between Crayford and Styggron were added by cREATOR/RobertHolmes Creator/RobertHolmes (and, since they're in a totally different writing style to Creator/TerryNation, it shows). It has the side effect of making Crayford and Styggron's relationship come off as a bit weirdly sadomasochistic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Padding}}: All of the scenes developing the relationship between Crayford and Styggron were added by cREATOR/RobertHolmes (and, since they're in a totally different writing style to Creator/TerryNation, it shows). It has the side effect of making Crayford and Styggron's relationship come off as a bit weirdly sadomasochistic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BetterThanCannon: The Target Novelisation is regarded as being superior to the story, largely because Creator/TerranceDicks filled in some of the PlotHoles.

to:

* BetterThanCannon: BetterThanCanon: The Target Novelisation is regarded as being superior to the story, largely because Creator/TerranceDicks filled in some of the PlotHoles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IdiotPlot: The story has a plot twist based around the idea that Crayford, a character who wears an eyepatch, actually still has a perfectly functioning eye underneath it without his knowledge. This would require him to never take his eyepatch off for years - not to clean it, not to sleep, nothing. The Doctor comes up with several incorrect theories regarding the events in the village - first that they've landed in the aftermath of a radioactive incident, then that there's mass hypnosis going on - which is quite unusual for him; Sarah forgets to tell the Doctor that the TARDIS has gone missing; and Styggron's "plan" is without doubt the most incomprehensible and random Gambit Roulette any villain has ever attempted in Classic ''Who'', which is saying something. The Doctor even speculates to an android Sarah about just one aspect of Styggron's plan (why's he bothering to create a simulated Earth village and fill it with android doubles if he could just wipe everyone out with a virus?) and the story never answers it. The DVD production subtitles spent a lot of time pointing out all of these plot holes and eventually conclude that Styggron is 'one of the most eccentric opponents the Doctor has ever faced... or else he's a twit'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: The rocket-launch StockFootage used for the takeoff of Styggron's ship is the same clip that MTV used for its hourly station-identification in its early years.

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: The rocket-launch StockFootage used for the takeoff of Styggron's ship is the same clip that MTV used for its hourly station-identification in its early years.years.
* UncannyValley: Some of the androids qualify - the 'deactivated' androids with their flat expressions and staring eyes, the finger-gun androids with their slightly odd artificial hands, the android Doctor doing all the loveable Doctor tics but with dead, predatory eyes, and especially the android Sarah Jane when her face falls off and reveals a strange mechanical head with protruding eyeballs.
* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The face falling off the android Sarah Jane. Not only is the effect one of the all-time behind the sofa moments, some very clever construction is used to make the servos look like they go right to the back of the head, and the eyeballs are mounted on stiff springs that twitch in a way frighteningly like natural eyeball flicker movement, making it seem like the android is still thinking and studying the Doctor as it turns its head towards him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BetterThanCannon: The Target Novelisation is regarded as being superior to the story, largely because Creator/TerranceDicks filled in some of the PlotHoles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HilariousInHindsight: The rocket-launch StockFootage used for the takeoff of Styggron's ship is the same clip that MTV used for its hourly station-identification in its early years.

Top