Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Clueless

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The fact that absolutely ''no one'' makes any kind of big deal about Christian turning out to be gay is shockingly ahead of its time, and his sexuality isn't played for laughs (other than Murray having to spell it out to Cher a few times before she realises). More than that, he isn't immediately dropped from the plot but is instead brought into Cher's circle of friends.

to:

** The fact that absolutely ''no one'' makes any kind of big deal about Christian turning out to be gay is shockingly ahead of its time, and his sexuality isn't played for laughs (other than Murray having to spell it out to Cher a few times before she realises).twigs, so the joke is more at her expense). More than that, he isn't immediately dropped from the plot but is instead brought into Cher's circle of friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The fact that absolutely ''no one'' makes any kind of big deal about Christian turning out to be gay is shockingly ahead of its time. More than that, he isn't immediately dropped from the plot but is instead brought into Cher's circle of friends.

to:

** The fact that absolutely ''no one'' makes any kind of big deal about Christian turning out to be gay is shockingly ahead of its time.time, and his sexuality isn't played for laughs (other than Murray having to spell it out to Cher a few times before she realises). More than that, he isn't immediately dropped from the plot but is instead brought into Cher's circle of friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The fact that absolutely no one makes any kind of big deal about Christian turning out to be gay is shockingly ahead of its time.

to:

** The fact that absolutely no one ''no one'' makes any kind of big deal about Christian turning out to be gay is shockingly ahead of its time.time. More than that, he isn't immediately dropped from the plot but is instead brought into Cher's circle of friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's implied that Cher's dad is perfectly fine with his stepson dating his daughter, and the pair's bickering is meant to come off as BelligerentSexualTension rather than SiblingRivalry. While Josh is a JerkWithAHeartOfGold who has a good influence on Cher, it feels a little weird in the 2020s that no one mentions they were brought up as family until five years before the movie starts. Not to mention the fact that he's old enough to be in college while she is still in high school. In fairness to the movie, Cher mentions that her dad was married to Josh's mom for "barely a year" before divorcing, and Josh mentions he's taking 101 level courses, which would make him a freshman, so unless he took some years off, he'd only be 2-3 years older than Cher at worst.

to:

** It's implied that Cher's dad is perfectly fine with his stepson dating his daughter, and the pair's bickering is meant to come off as BelligerentSexualTension rather than SiblingRivalry. While Josh is a JerkWithAHeartOfGold who has a good influence on Cher, it feels a little weird in the 2020s that no one mentions they were brought up as family until five years before the movie starts. Not to mention the fact that he's old enough to be in college while she is still in high school. In fairness to the movie, Cher mentions that her dad was married to Josh's mom for "barely a year" before divorcing, and Josh mentions he's taking 101 level courses, which would make him a freshman, so unless he took some years off, he'd only be 2-3 years older than Cher at worst.

Changed: 293

Removed: 817

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
If you have a problem with an example, rewrite it, don't debate it. Adding the context from the response.


** It's implied that Cher's dad is perfectly fine with his stepson dating his daughter, and the pair's bickering is meant to come off as BelligerentSexualTension rather than SiblingRivalry. While Josh is a JerkWithAHeartOfGold who has a good influence on Cher, it feels a little weird in the 2020s that no one mentions they were brought up as family until five years before the movie starts. Not to mention the fact that he's old enough to be in law school while she is still in high school.
*** Nobody mentions those things because neither of them are true. While some people are understandably squicked out by stepsiblings dating, Josh and Cher were absolutely not raised as family. In the opening sequence of the movie, Cher states "You were hardly married to his mother and that was five years ago!" suggesting that Cher's father and Josh's mother were married for no more than a year or two and that they divorced at least five years before the start of the movie. Additionally, Josh is in college/university[[note]]Implied to be a freshman, as Cher accuses him of psychoanalyzing her as a result of 'freshman psych' and Josh counters with the fact that he isn't taking psych[[/note]], not law school. Most likely their age difference is about 2-3 years (with Cher almost 16 and Josh in the 18-19 range).

to:

** It's implied that Cher's dad is perfectly fine with his stepson dating his daughter, and the pair's bickering is meant to come off as BelligerentSexualTension rather than SiblingRivalry. While Josh is a JerkWithAHeartOfGold who has a good influence on Cher, it feels a little weird in the 2020s that no one mentions they were brought up as family until five years before the movie starts. Not to mention the fact that he's old enough to be in law school college while she is still in high school.
*** Nobody mentions those things because neither of them are true. While some people are understandably squicked out by stepsiblings dating, Josh and Cher were absolutely not raised as family.
school. In the opening sequence of fairness to the movie, Cher states "You were hardly mentions that her dad was married to his mother and that was five years ago!" suggesting that Cher's father and Josh's mother were married mom for no more than "barely a year or two and that they divorced at least five years year" before the start of the movie. Additionally, divorcing, and Josh is in college/university[[note]]Implied to be mentions he's taking 101 level courses, which would make him a freshman, as Cher accuses him of psychoanalyzing her as a result of 'freshman psych' and Josh counters with the fact that so unless he isn't taking psych[[/note]], not law school. Most likely their age difference is about took some years off, he'd only be 2-3 years (with older than Cher almost 16 and Josh in the 18-19 range).at worst.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The 1996 follow-up series got this in spades. Aside from complaints that it ruined the legacy of the film (and ironically helped to popularize many of the themes that it was parodying in the 1995 film), specific changes got the most ire:
** Most infamously was the casting of Canadian actress Rachel Blanchard as Cher. In addition to concerns about her acting, her version of the main character lacked a lot of the charisma, confidence, and finesse that Alicia Silverstone's Cher embodied.
** Having the beloved Tai, who rounded out the PowerTrio in the film, DemotedToExtra. Even worse, through her scant appearances, she wasn't played by Brittany Murphy.
** Changing Mel from the intimidating and snarky StraightMan to a NiceGuy BumblingDad also garnered criticism.
** Retooling Josh and Cher's relationship. While this is more [[JustifiedTrope justified,]] what isn't as forgivable was writing him out of the series altogether once it went from [=ABC=] to [=UPN=].

Added: 1081

Changed: 550

Removed: 521

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: The image of fashion and wealth in the film suffer from this, especially the already mentioned mobile phones, as well as a very foolish-looking fashion by modern standards. To such a level that it can look like modern StealthParody on the rich of that time. Not to mention that ''Clueless'' basically pulled a {{Reconstruction}} of the teen movie after ''{{Film/Heathers}}'' killed it with a deconstruction - so any teen-oriented comedy made after 1995 owes its existence to ''Clueless'' in some way.



* UnintentionalPeriodPiece: The film is a mix of this and ''Intentional'' PeriodPiece. Yes, the {{Grunge}} and HipHop fashions and ubiquitous cellphones establish it as a '90s film, but much of the music is actually from TheEighties, and Cher Horowitz would likely feel right at home in a movie like ''Film/ValleyGirl''. One of the more subtle notes that pins this to TheNineties is the character of Christian, who is gay and whose tendency to dress stylishly is cited as clear proof of his sexuality, firmly placing the movie in a period before the metrosexual ideal took off.

to:

* UnintentionalPeriodPiece: UnintentionalPeriodPiece:
**
The film is a mix of this and ''Intentional'' PeriodPiece. Yes, the {{Grunge}} and HipHop fashions and ubiquitous cellphones establish it as a '90s film, but much of the music is actually from TheEighties, and Cher Horowitz would likely feel right at home in a movie like ''Film/ValleyGirl''. One of the more subtle notes that pins this to TheNineties is the character of Christian, who is gay and whose tendency to dress stylishly is cited as clear proof of his sexuality, firmly placing the movie in a period before the metrosexual ideal took off.off.
** The image of fashion and wealth in the film suffer from this, especially the already mentioned mobile phones, as well as a very foolish-looking fashion by modern standards. To such a level that it can look like modern StealthParody on the rich of that time. Not to mention that ''Clueless'' basically pulled a {{Reconstruction}} of the teen movie after ''{{Film/Heathers}}'' killed it with a deconstruction - so any teen-oriented comedy made after 1995 [[GenreTurningPoint owes its existence]] to ''Clueless'' in some way.



* {{Wangst}}: Tai acts like she's utterly heartbroken over Elton, even though they ''weren't even dating'', complete with banging her head on the table, tearing up over "their song" playing, and coming over to Cher's house to burn a box of things that reminded her of him. Bear in mind Tai didn't even know who Elton was until Cher and Dee pointed him out to her as a possible boyfriend. This is arguably part of the point, as blowing minor problems into life-ruining crises is one of the "privileged teenager" points being satirized.

to:

* {{Wangst}}: Tai acts like she's utterly heartbroken over Elton, even though they ''weren't even dating'', complete with banging her head on the table, tearing up over "their song" playing, and coming over to Cher's house to burn a box of things that reminded her of him. Bear in mind Tai didn't even know who Elton was until Cher and Dee pointed him out to her as a possible boyfriend. This is arguably part of the point, as blowing minor problems into life-ruining crises is one of the "privileged teenager" points being satirized.satirized.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Nobody talks about these things because neither of them are true. While some people are understandably squicked out by stepsiblings dating, Josh and Cher were absolutely not raised as family. In the opening sequence of the movie, Cher states "You were hardly married to his mother and that was five years ago!" suggesting that Cher's father and Josh's mother were married for no more than a year or two and that they divorced at least five years before the start of the movie. Additionally, Josh is in college/university[[note]]Implied to be a freshman, as Cher accuses him of psychoanalyzing her as a result of 'freshman psych' and Josh counters with the fact that he isn't taking psych[[/note]], not law school. Most likely their age difference is about 2-3 years (with Cher almost 16 and Josh in the 18-19 range).

to:

** *** Nobody talks about these mentions those things because neither of them are true. While some people are understandably squicked out by stepsiblings dating, Josh and Cher were absolutely not raised as family. In the opening sequence of the movie, Cher states "You were hardly married to his mother and that was five years ago!" suggesting that Cher's father and Josh's mother were married for no more than a year or two and that they divorced at least five years before the start of the movie. Additionally, Josh is in college/university[[note]]Implied to be a freshman, as Cher accuses him of psychoanalyzing her as a result of 'freshman psych' and Josh counters with the fact that he isn't taking psych[[/note]], not law school. Most likely their age difference is about 2-3 years (with Cher almost 16 and Josh in the 18-19 range).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Nobody talks about these things because neither of them are true. While some people are understandably squicked out by stepsiblings dating, Josh and Cher were absolutely not raised as family. In the opening sequence of the movie, Cher states "You were hardly married to his mother and that was five years ago!" suggesting that Cher's father and Josh's mother were married for no more than a year or two and that they divorced at least five years before the start of the movie. Additionally, Josh is in college/university[[note]]Implied to be a freshman, as Cher accuses him of psychoanalyzing her as a result of 'freshman psych' and Josh counters with the fact that he isn't taking psych[[/note]], not law school. Most likely their age difference is about 2-3 years (with Cher almost 16 and Josh in the 18-19 range).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jeremy Sisto likewise became more famous for ''Series/SixFeetUnder'' and ''Series/LawAndOrder''.

to:

** Jeremy Sisto Creator/JeremySisto likewise became more famous for ''Series/SixFeetUnder'' and ''Series/LawAndOrder''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some people have [[https://www.reddit.com/r/actuallesbians/comments/z8ob9k/clueless_a_lesbian_perspective_on_cher_horowitz/ theorized]] that Cher is actually a closeted lesbian, with her stated attraction to Josh actually being her buying into compulsory heterosexuality.

to:

** Some people have [[https://aninjusticemag.com/cher-from-clueless-was-definitely-a-lesbian-heres-why-efb75d24e256 have]] [[https://www.reddit.com/r/actuallesbians/comments/z8ob9k/clueless_a_lesbian_perspective_on_cher_horowitz/ theorized]] that Cher is actually a closeted lesbian, with her stated attraction to Josh actually being her buying into compulsory heterosexuality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Some people have [[https://www.reddit.com/r/actuallesbians/comments/z8ob9k/clueless_a_lesbian_perspective_on_cher_horowitz/ theorized]] that Cher is actually a closeted lesbian, with her stated attraction to Josh actually being her buying into compulsory heterosexuality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The movie basically has [[Film/BatmanAndRobin Batgirl]] falling in love with Film/AntMan.

to:

** The movie basically has [[Film/BatmanAndRobin Batgirl]] falling in love with Film/AntMan.Film/AntMan1.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* FunnyAneurysmMoment: Dionne and Murray's constant [[SlapSlapKiss bickering]] being PlayedForLaughs isn’t as funny since Stacey Dash's own [[https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/celebrities/2020/05/01/stacey-dash-splits-fourth-husband-after-her-domestic-violence-arrest/3069255001/ trouble]] with DomesticAbuse. Not helping is Cher comparing them to ''Ike and Tina Turner!''

to:

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: HarsherInHindsight: Dionne and Murray's constant [[SlapSlapKiss bickering]] being PlayedForLaughs isn’t as funny since Stacey Dash's own [[https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/celebrities/2020/05/01/stacey-dash-splits-fourth-husband-after-her-domestic-violence-arrest/3069255001/ trouble]] with DomesticAbuse. Not helping is Cher comparing them to ''Ike and Tina Turner!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FunnyAneurysmMoment: Dionne and Murray's constant [[SlapSlapKiss bickering]] being PlayedForLaughs isn’t as funny since Stacey Dash's own [[https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/celebrities/2020/05/01/stacey-dash-splits-fourth-husband-after-her-domestic-violence-arrest/3069255001/ trouble]] with DomesticAbuse. Not helping is Cher comparing them to''Ike and Tina Turner!''

to:

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: Dionne and Murray's constant [[SlapSlapKiss bickering]] being PlayedForLaughs isn’t as funny since Stacey Dash's own [[https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/celebrities/2020/05/01/stacey-dash-splits-fourth-husband-after-her-domestic-violence-arrest/3069255001/ trouble]] with DomesticAbuse. Not helping is Cher comparing them to''Ike to ''Ike and Tina Turner!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: Dionne and Murray's constant [[SlapSlapKiss bickering]] being PlayedForLaughs isn’t as funny since Stacey Dash's own [[https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/celebrities/2020/05/01/stacey-dash-splits-fourth-husband-after-her-domestic-violence-arrest/3069255001/ trouble]] with DomesticAbuse. Not helping is Cher comparing them to''Ike and Tina Turner!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Josh at several points acts more like a snotty older brother than a potential love interest. Case in point that he reacts with AdultFear and a BigBrotherInstinct when she calls him from a pay phone, explaining that she was mugged, and he comes over with no hesitation, just teasingly saying she owes him for the long drive. When did the transition happen, exactly?

to:

** Josh at several points acts more like a snotty older brother than a potential love interest. Case in point that he reacts with AdultFear worries and a BigBrotherInstinct when she calls him from a pay phone, explaining that she was mugged, and he comes over with no hesitation, just teasingly saying she owes him for the long drive. When did the transition happen, exactly?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Brittany Murphy basically plays a LadEtte who has to be taught how to act like a GirlyGirl. She'd later get typecast in Cher-like roles in the 2000s.
** Cher also says she's named after a [[Music/{{Cher}} famous singer]] who "now does infomercials". In the late 90s, Cher would have a CareerResurrection with her biggest hit "Believe", and would also achieve even more acting success (although at the point the movie was made, she'd already won an Oscar for ''{{Film/Moonstruck}}'', so this might have been meant to sell Cher as TheDitz).

to:

** Brittany Murphy basically plays a LadEtte {{Ladette}} who has to be taught how to act like a GirlyGirl. She'd later get typecast in Cher-like roles in the 2000s.
** Cher also says she's named after a [[Music/{{Cher}} famous singer]] who "now does infomercials". In the late 90s, Cher would have a CareerResurrection with her biggest hit "Believe", and would also achieve even more acting success (although at the point the movie was made, she'd already won an Oscar for ''{{Film/Moonstruck}}'', so this might have been meant to sell Cher as TheDitz).



* HollywoodPudgy: After Creator/BrittanyMurphy's death, all articles reporting on the subject referred to her as "...the chubby girl from ''Clueless''." The issue is that while Tai’s original look has her in baggy clothes (with badly dyed hair), after her makeover anyone with eyes can see she’s basically as thin as the other girls.

to:

* HollywoodPudgy: After Creator/BrittanyMurphy's death, all articles reporting on the subject referred to her as "...the chubby girl from ''Clueless''." The issue is that while Tai’s Tai's original look has her in baggy clothes (with badly dyed hair), after her makeover anyone with eyes can see she’s she's basically as thin as the other girls.



** Tai assuming that Elton rejected her for her hip size and that he was right to do so makes more sense during the “heroin chic” and forgiving-of-body-shaming 90’s.

to:

** Tai assuming that Elton rejected her for her hip size and that he was right to do so makes more sense during the “heroin chic” and forgiving-of-body-shaming 90’s.'90s.



** The fact that absolutely no one makes any kind of big deal about Christian turning out to be gay is quite shockingly ahead of its time.

to:

** The fact that absolutely no one makes any kind of big deal about Christian turning out to be gay is quite shockingly ahead of its time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's implied that Cher's dad is perfectly fine with his stepson dating his daughter, and the pair's bickering is meant to come off as BelligerentSexualTension rather than SiblingRivalry. While Josh is a JerkWithAHeartOfGold who has a good influence on Cher, it feels a little weird in the 2020s that no one mentions they were brought up as family until five years before the movie starts.

to:

** It's implied that Cher's dad is perfectly fine with his stepson dating his daughter, and the pair's bickering is meant to come off as BelligerentSexualTension rather than SiblingRivalry. While Josh is a JerkWithAHeartOfGold who has a good influence on Cher, it feels a little weird in the 2020s that no one mentions they were brought up as family until five years before the movie starts. Not to mention the fact that he's old enough to be in law school while she is still in high school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the TV series version, there's Sean, Murray's goofy but lovable HeterosexualLifePartner. He technically didn't appear at all in the film[[note]]arguably, he was in only one scene at the Christmas party as Murray's buddy [[AdaptationNameChange Lawrence]] who convinced him to shave his head and his ''two'' lines were "It's the bomb!" and "As will you!"[[/note]], but became a rare instance of a popular CanonForeigner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's easy to find on Website/{{Tumblr}} a post detailing Cher's speech about immigration, which may also be considered a case of SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped.

to:

** It's easy to find on Website/{{Tumblr}} a post detailing Cher's speech about immigration, which may also be considered a case of SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped.immigration.

Top