History YMMV / ALoudHouseChristmas

* UncannyValley: Luan's puppet, Mr. Coconut, was already a bit off-putting to most fans in the cartoon, but seeing it recreated and moving about for live-action turned this feeling UpToEleven.

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that it's a [[LiveActionAdaptation live-action]] ''Loud House'' movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy. Combine this with the fact that the plot depicts Lincoln as quite a jerk, and it's clear to see why many ''Loud House'' fans would rather pretend this special does not exist.

** The green screen is highly conspicuous, particularly when Rita is on the roof.

* SpecialEffectFailure: Lincoln's face on the original poster has a ghost copy lower down on his face. This has since been rectified after much mockery.

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that it's a Live Action Loud House movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy. Combine this with the fact that the plot depicts Lincoln as quite a jerk, and it's clear to see why many Loud House fans would rather pretend this special does not exist.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: While Leni and Luan got screwed over by situations beyond their control, and Lori just got sentimental, Luna still had a choice in the matter when she was duped into thinking that Mick Swagger was coming to town (I.e. she still could’ve chosen Sam over Mick). She comes off as completely oblivious, almost insensitively so, when she calls off the trip with Sam, who is clearly hurt by her decision. ''And'' she’s met Mick Swagger before. As such, it’s not hard to side with Sam when she’s angry with Luna and breaks up with her (though they get back together at the end).

* FanonDiscontinuity:
** The fact that it's a Live Action Loud House movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy. Combine this with the fact that the plot depicts Lincoln as quite a jerk, and it's clear to see why many Loud House fans would rather pretend this special does not exist.
** Also many fans questioned why make their first live action movie a Christmas special. ''Fairly Oddparents'' did a live action one too, but on their ''second'' movie. Their first was treated like a big event because it was live action and established the actors and settings. So having the first Loud House live action film around the holidays kinda diminishes the impact for it since it feels less like a movie and more just a common holiday sitcom episode with the promotion not really helping this notion. So most fans didn't really gel with the movie for this reason too.
* SpecialEffectFailure:
** Lincoln's face on the original poster has a ghost copy lower down on his face. This has since been rectified after much mockery.
** Moreso an audio error, but Lynn's first line, "Hey Stinkin," which she says off-screen before tackling Lincoln, is pretty obviously dubbed in.
* UncannyValley: As with any live-action media based on an animated property, some of the transition to real life came out a bit awkward. While most of the Louds look fine, the attempt to replicate Lucy's BlindingBangs looks more like she's cosplaying the character than a natural hairstyle. Also, as a ventriloquist dummy, Mr. Coconuts already looked somewhat creepy in animation, but in live-action, he looks absolutely ''terrifying''.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic
** Lincoln. While it is understandable that he wants his whole family to be together on Christmas Day, especially considering that he saved up all year for a sled big enough for all of them to ride in, the lengths he goes to sabotaging his family's plans[[note]]tricking Luna into thinking Mick Swagger is coming to visit Royal Woods, getting Luan fired from her comedy show at the retirement center, and getting Leni fired from Reininger's by stealing Tanya the mannequin during her shift[[/note]] make it very hard to root for him. Even when he tries to make things right by bringing the Sharkodile prop to the Royal Woods Mall to explain the hoax, he still causes thousands of dollars' worth of property damage in the process. While it’s said in the end to have to perform 300 hours of community service to pay it off, he’s still otherwise EasilyForgiven and gets his way despite all he's done.
** While not as bad as Lincoln, Luna falls into this as well. While Leni and Luan got screwed over by situations beyond their control, and Lori just got sentimental, Luna still had a choice in the matter when she was duped into thinking that Mick Swagger was coming to town (I.e. she still could’ve chosen Sam over Mick). She comes off as completely oblivious, almost insensitively so, when she calls off the trip with Sam, who is clearly hurt by her decision. ''And'' she’s met Mick Swagger before. As such, it’s not hard to side with Sam when she’s angry with Luna and breaks up with her (though they get back together at the end).

** The fact that it's a Live Action Loud House movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy. Combine this with the fact that the plot depicts Lincoln as quite a jerk (see UnintentionallyUnsympathetic below), and it's clear to see why many Loud House fans would rather pretend this special does not exist.

* SpecialEffectFailure: Lincoln’s face on the original poster has a ghost copy lower down on his face. This has since been rectified after much mockery.

** While not as bad as Lincoln, Luna falls into this as well. While Leni and Luan got screwed over by situations beyond their control, and Lori just got sentimental, Luna still had a choice in the matter when she was duped into thinking that Mick Swagger was coming to town (I.e. she still could’ve chosen Sam over Mick). She comes off as completely oblivious, almost insensitively so, when she calls off the trip with Sam, who is clearly hurt by her decision. ''And'' she’s met Mick Swagger before. As such, it’s not hard to side with Sam when she’s angry with Luna and breaks up with her (though they get back together at the end).

** While not as bad as Lincoln, Luna falls into this as well. While Leni and Luan got screwed over by situations beyond their control, and Lori just got sentimental, Luna still had a choice in the matter when she was duped into thinking that Mick Swagger was coming to town (I.e. she still could’ve chosen Sam over Mick). She comes off as completely oblivious, almost insensitively so, when she calls off the trip with Sam, who is clearly hurt by her decision. As such, it’s not hard to side with Sam when she’s angry with Luna and breaks up with her.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Lincoln. While it is understandable that he wants his whole family to be together on Christmas Day, especially considering that he saved up all year for a sled big enough for all of them to ride in, the lengths he goes to sabotaging his family's plans[[note]]tricking Luna into thinking Mick Swagger is coming to visit Royal Woods, getting Luan fired from her comedy show at the retirement center, and getting Leni fired from Reininger's by stealing Tanya the mannequin during her shift[[/note]] make it very hard to root for him. Even when he tries to make things right by bringing the Sharkodile prop to the Royal Woods Mall to explain the hoax, he still causes thousands of dollars' worth of property damage in the process (and is said in the end to have to perform 300 hours of community service to pay it off). He's still otherwise EasilyForgiven and gets his way despite all he's done.

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: So you have Bobby in the movie...but not Ronnie Ann? Not even in a little cameo?

** Also many fans questioned why make their first one live action movie a Christmas special. ''Fairly Oddparents'' did a live action one too, but on their ''second'' movie. Their first was treated like a big event because it was live action and established the actors and settings. So having the first Loud House live action film around the holidays kinda diminishes the impact for it since it feels less like a movie and more just a common holiday sitcom episode with the promotion not really helping this notion. So most fans didn't really gel with the movie for this reason too.

* FanonDiscontinuity: The fact that it's a Live Action Loud House movie already turned off a large portion of the fandom from the start, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy. Combine this with the fact that the plot depicts Lincoln as quite a jerk (see UnintentionallyUnsympathetic below), and it's clear to see why many Loud House fans would rather pretend this special does not exist.

** Moreso an audio error, Lynn's first line, "Hey Stinkin," which she says off-screen before tackling Lincoln, is pretty obviously dubbed in.

* SpecialEffectFailure: Lincoln’s face on the poster has a ghost copy lower down on his face. This has since been rectified after much mockery.

* SpecialEffectFailure: Lincoln’s face on the poster has a ghost copy lower down on his face.

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: The concept of a Live Action Loud House movie has turned off most of the fandom, with some believing that Nickelodeon didn’t learn their lesson from the live-action ''WesternAnimation/FairlyOddParents'' movie trilogy.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Lincoln. While it is understandable that he wants his whole family to be together on Christmas Day, especially considering that he saved up all year for a sled big enough for all of them to ride in, the lengths he goes to sabotaging his family's plans[[note]]tricking Luna into thinking Mick Swagger is coming to visit Royal Woods, getting Luan fired from her comedy show at the retirement center, and getting Leni fired from Reninger's by stealing Tanya the mannequin which was Reininger's property[[/note]] make it very hard to root for him. Even when he tries to make things right by bringing the Sharkodile prop to the Royal Woods Mall to explain the hoax, he still causes thousands of dollars' worth of property damage in the process (and is said in the end to have to perform 300 hours of community service to pay it off). He's still otherwise EasilyForgiven and gets his way despite all he's done.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Lincoln. While it is understandable that he wants his whole family to be together on Christmas Day, especially considering that he saved up all year for a sled big enough for all of them to ride in, the lengths he goes to sabotaging his family's plans[[note]]tricking Luna into thinking Mick Swagger is coming to visit Royal Woods, getting Luan fired from her comedy show at the retirement center, and getting Leni fired from Reninger's since Tanya, the mannequin he used for his Sharkodile video was its property[[/note]] make it very hard to root for him. Even when he tries to make things right by bringing the Sharkodile prop to the Royal Woods Mall to explain the hoax, he still causes thousands of dollars' worth of property damage in the process (and is said in the end to have to perform 300 hours of community service to pay it off). He's still otherwise EasilyForgiven and gets his way despite all he's done.

* UncannyValley: As with any live-action media based on an animated property, some of the transition to real life came out a bit awkward. While most of the Louds look fine, the attempt to replicate Lucy's BlindingBangs look more like she's cosplaying the character than a natural hairstyle. Likewise Luan's Mr Coconuts was already a bit off-putting to some fans in the cartoon, but seeing it in real life looks ''terrifying''.

* UncannyValley: As with any live-action media based on an animated property, some of the transition to real life came out a bit awkward. While most of the Louds look fine, the attempt to replicate Lucy's BlindingBangs look more like she's cosplaying the character than a natural hairstyle. Likewise Luan's Mr Coconuts was already a bit off-putting to some fans in the cartoon, but seeing it in real life looks ''terrifying''.

* UncannyValley: As with any live-action media based on a animation, some of the transition to real life came out a bit awkward. While most of the Louds look fine, the attempt to replicate Lucy's BlindingBangs look more like she's cosplaying the character then a natural hairstyle. Likewise Luann's Mr Coconuts was already a bit off-putting to some fans in the cartoon, but seeing it in real life looks ''terrifying''.