History WMG / TheWolfAmongUs

[[WMG: Mr. Toad is going to be killed by [[spoiler:Bigby's Wolf form]]]]
Mr. Toad probably won't last until the end of the series, given his absence in the source material, and [[spoiler:it's his voice telling Wolf Bigby that "he don't look so good" in the teasers for both Episodes 2 and 3]].

The nursery rhyme he appears in goes:

[[WMG: The Tweedles are working for [[spoiler: The Crooked Man.]]
[[spoiler: The interrogation of Dee and Beauty's confession at the Open Arms all but clinches it. He's not the murderer though, you can't collect money from the dead.]]

* The Three of Hearts.
* The Moon.
* The Hermit.

* [[spoiler: Thinking about it, this is a killer that could potentially literally be anyone; an interaction with a character thought to be a friend could be an interaction with the killer in disguise, who could use that against you in a later episode.]]

[[WMG: Ichabod Crane is not the serial killer.]]
[[spoiler: He has a fetish for Snow White, but he didn't kill Lily or Faith. The killer knew about this, and planted the photos in room 207 to implicate him, as it's unlikely Crane would keep those photos there.]]

[[spoiler: He has a fetish for Snow White, but he didn't kill Lily or Faith. The killer knew about this, and planted the photos in room 207 to implicate him, as it's unlikely Crane would keep those photos there.]]

* The Three of Swords.

Which leads to a reunion between him and Faith [[spoiler: (assuming she wasn't really killed.)]]

[[WMG: Prince Lawrence is alive even if you were his second stop.]]

Explaining his absence in the comics.

[[WMG: The Red-Headed Guy is the guy [[spoiler: who brings the BigBad his Fable women in his cab.]]

It fell off. Her ribbon is what kept it on.

This is not something this troper would personally like to be true, since this troper likes them, but neither of those two characters have plot-critical roles in the Fables comic, so they could be the suspects in this game and not break canon (as long as they aren't killed in later chapters of the game).

[[WMG: The killer is either [[spoiler:Beauty or the Beast]].]]

[[WMG: The killer is either [[spoiler:Beauty]] or the [[spoiler:Beast]].]]

Georgie Porgie ran away"

** And more importantly, this ties into the idea that just the placement of the head is a message - in this case, it's the Horseman sending a message to Ichabod that, unless he comes out to face the music, more heads will roll. This also ties in with why Crane's nerves are always so frayed.

...though he's likely a pawn of the real villain rather than the BigBad proper. Think about it: in the third chapter, nearly every character depicted in the Book of Fables is somehow important to the story; even if they're not involved (like the Seven Dwarves and, arguably, Red Riding Hood) Bigby or Snow at least pass comment on them... all except the Horseman, which is even more jarring because they avoid mentioning him when talking about Ichabod Crane. Add this to the possible Geas mentioned on the main page and things start getting a bit suspicious... and [[OffWithHisHead what was the Horseman known for, again?]]

He's using his resources and hired thugs to manage the whole thing from wherever he is. Being in a FilmNoir, along with continuity issues, ''he'll get away with it.''

[[spoiler: His tie is covered with shepherd crooks, plus if he is the 'killer,' he's got plenty of reason to hate Bigby.]]

[[spoiler: He's a Red Hair-ing.]]

[[WMG: The Red-Headed Guy that we see in Woodlands right before seeing [[spoiler:Faith's head]], at the line to the office, and driving Snow's cab...[[spoiler:Is completely innocent.]] ]]

* The Ten of Swords is [[spoiler: Lawrence. The card is 'The Lowest Point' or 'Ultimate Defeat/Despair' which sums up the poor guy's life quite well.]]

* Strength is [[Spoiler: Bigby and Snow. Obvious, along with the picture.]]

[[WMG: Snow being decapitated isn't a problem. [[spoiler: It's an issue of finding her body.]] ]]