Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / APassageToIndia

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Creator Chosen Casting is when the casting of an adaptation is influenced by the creator of the work being adapted; "director chooses the cast of the movie he's directing" is not a trope


* CreatorChosenCasting: Creator/DavidLean cast Creator/JudyDavis after a two-hour meeting with her. When she gave her interpretation of what happened in the caves — "She can't cope with her own sexuality, she just freaks out" — Lean said that the part was hers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CareerResurrection: For James Fox. Following a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved in drug culture, which (along with his father's death) precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema for 14 years to become a Christian missionary. This film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular character actor.

to:

* CareerResurrection: For James Fox. Following Despite a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved TheSixties, his deep involvement in drug culture, which (along along with his father's death) death, precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema acting for 14 years to become a Christian missionary. This missionary before this film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular a character actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Victor Banerjee made at least three films helmed by Ray; Ghare Baire was probably freshest in his mind when he made A Passage to India.


** The relationship between Creator/DavidLean and Creator/AlecGuinness deteriorated during the making of the movie. The final straw came for Guinness when he found out that a large chunk of his scenes had been left on the cutting floor by Lean. Neither man ever met or spoke to the other again. Lean also had frequent on-set clashes with Judy Davis, who said he didn't understand women and accused him of having lost his touch, not having directed for 15 years. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz' accent and dismissed him as a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay, who had directed him in ''Pikoo'' in 1981. And while Lean hurled a constant barrage of insults at James Fox over his performance, Fox mostly shrugged them off.

to:

** The relationship between Creator/DavidLean and Creator/AlecGuinness deteriorated during the making of the movie. The final straw came for Guinness when he found out that a large chunk of his scenes had been left on the cutting floor by Lean. Neither man ever met or spoke to the other again. Lean also had frequent on-set clashes with Judy Davis, who said he didn't understand women and accused him of having lost his touch, not having directed for 15 years. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz' accent and dismissed him as a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay, who Creator/SatyajitRay (who had just directed him in ''Pikoo'' in 1981.''Ghare Baire''). And while Lean hurled a constant barrage of insults at James Fox over his performance, Fox mostly shrugged them off.



** Creator/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay, with whom he'd previously worked on ''Pikoo''. Creator/PeggyAshcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. James Fox suffered near-constant, unmotivated insults from Lean over his performance, but, unlike his co-stars, he mostly shrugged them off. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.

to:

** Creator/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay, with whom he'd previously worked just finished work on ''Pikoo''.''Ghare Baire''. Creator/PeggyAshcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. James Fox suffered near-constant, unmotivated insults from Lean over his performance, but, unlike his co-stars, he mostly shrugged them off. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.

Added: 2225

Changed: 1086

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HostilityOnTheSet: The relationship between Creator/DavidLean and Creator/AlecGuinness deteriorated during the making of the movie. The final straw came for Guinness when he found out that a large chunk of his scenes had been left on the cutting floor by Lean. Neither man ever met or spoke to the other again. Lean also had frequent on-set clashes with Judy Davis who accused him of having lost his touch, not having directed for 15 years.

to:

* HostilityOnTheSet: HostilityOnTheSet:
**
The relationship between Creator/DavidLean and Creator/AlecGuinness deteriorated during the making of the movie. The final straw came for Guinness when he found out that a large chunk of his scenes had been left on the cutting floor by Lean. Neither man ever met or spoke to the other again. Lean also had frequent on-set clashes with Judy Davis Davis, who said he didn't understand women and accused him of having lost his touch, not having directed for 15 years.years. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz' accent and dismissed him as a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay, who had directed him in ''Pikoo'' in 1981. And while Lean hurled a constant barrage of insults at James Fox over his performance, Fox mostly shrugged them off.



* TroubledProduction: Compared to Creator/DavidLean's other shoots, his final film was a breeze, with even the Indian location shooting going smoothly. Except for one thing: Lean and his stars were constantly at each others' throats. Creator/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay. Peggy Ashcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.

to:

* TroubledProduction: Compared to Creator/DavidLean's other shoots, his final film was a breeze, with even the Indian location shooting going smoothly. Except for one thing: Lean and his stars were constantly at each others' throats. throats.
**
Creator/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay. Peggy Ashcroft Creator/SatyajitRay, with whom he'd previously worked on ''Pikoo''. Creator/PeggyAshcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. James Fox suffered near-constant, unmotivated insults from Lean over his performance, but, unlike his co-stars, he mostly shrugged them off. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.post-production.
** It wasn't just the cast who grew tired of Lean's [[ThePrimaDonna prima donna]] behavior. Santha Rama Rau, who had written the 1960 stage adaptation of ''India'', was originally contracted to write the screenplay. Though Lean rejected her script as unsatisfactory, Rau discovered that Lean incorporated much of her dialogue into the finished film anyway; ultimately, she received a screen credit after threatening a lawsuit. Lean also disliked his cinematographer Ernest Day, eventually "promoting" him to assistant director and sending Day to film superfluous landscape and crowd scenes that didn't make it into the final movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreatorChosenCasting: Creator/DavidLean cast Creator/JudyDavis after a two-hour meeting with her. When she gave her interpretation of what happened in the caves — "She can't cope with her own sexuality, she just freaks out" — Lean said that the part was hers.

Added: 600

Changed: 597

Removed: 225

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SavedFromDevelopmentHell: Various filmmakers tried adapting the novel over the years, but Forster refused to grant the rights as he feared that any film would take the side of either the English or Indians. Among the early candidates was Creator/DavidLean himself, who read the novel in the late '50s and wanted the novel as a follow-up to ''Film/TheBridgeOnTheRiverKwai''. Santha Rama Rau, who wrote the stage adaptation of ''Passage'', interested Creator/SatyajitRay in adapting it, but Forster again turned them down. Creator/MerchantIvory also attempted to buy the rights in the late '70s.



** Various filmmakers tried adapting the novel over the years, but Forster refused to grant the rights as he feared that any film would take the side of either the English or Indians. Among the early candidates was Creator/DavidLean himself, who read the novel in the late '50s and wanted the novel as a follow-up to ''Film/TheBridgeOnTheRiverKwai''. Santha Rama Rau, who wrote the stage adaptation of ''Passage'', interested Creator/SatyajitRay in adapting it, but Forster again turned them down. Creator/MerchantIvory also attempted to buy the rights in the late '70s.
** Creator/DavidLean hoped to reunite the stars of ''Film/BriefEncounter'' - Creator/CeliaJohnson and Creator/TrevorHoward as Mrs. Moore and Richard Fielding. They both passed. Also, Johnson died before the film was released.

to:

** Various filmmakers tried adapting the novel over the years, but Forster refused to grant the rights as he feared that any film would take the side of either the English or Indians. Among the early candidates was Creator/DavidLean himself, who read the novel in the late '50s and wanted the novel as a follow-up to ''Film/TheBridgeOnTheRiverKwai''. Santha Rama Rau, who wrote the stage adaptation of ''Passage'', interested Creator/SatyajitRay in adapting it, but Forster again turned them down. Creator/MerchantIvory also attempted to buy the rights in the late '70s.
** Creator/DavidLean hoped to reunite the stars of ''Film/BriefEncounter'' - Creator/CeliaJohnson as Mrs. Moore and Creator/TrevorHoward as Mrs. Moore and Richard Fielding. They both passed. Also, Johnson died before the film was released.



** Creator/PeterOToole was the first choice for Richard Fielding.

to:

** Creator/PeterOToole was the first choice for Richard Fielding.Fielding.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CareerResurrection: For JamesFox. Following a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved in drug culture, which (along with his father's death) precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema for 14 years to become a Christian missionary. This film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular character actor.

to:

* CareerResurrection: For JamesFox.James Fox. Following a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved in drug culture, which (along with his father's death) precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema for 14 years to become a Christian missionary. This film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular character actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CareerResurrection: For Creator/JamesFox. Following a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved in drug culture, which (along with his father's death) precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema for 14 years, became a born-again Christian and disavowed his earlier career. This film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular character actor.

to:

* CareerResurrection: For Creator/JamesFox.JamesFox. Following a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved in drug culture, which (along with his father's death) precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema for 14 years, became years to become a born-again Christian and disavowed his earlier career.missionary. This film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular character actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FakeBrit: Australian Creator/JudyDavis as the Englishwoman Adela Quested.


Added DiffLines:

** Various filmmakers tried adapting the novel over the years, but Forster refused to grant the rights as he feared that any film would take the side of either the English or Indians. Among the early candidates was Creator/DavidLean himself, who read the novel in the late '50s and wanted the novel as a follow-up to ''Film/TheBridgeOnTheRiverKwai''. Santha Rama Rau, who wrote the stage adaptation of ''Passage'', interested Creator/SatyajitRay in adapting it, but Forster again turned them down. Creator/MerchantIvory also attempted to buy the rights in the late '70s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TroubledProduction: Compared to Creator/DavidLean's other shoots, his final film was a breeze, with even the Indian location shooting going smoothly. Except for one thing: Lean and his stars were constantly at each others' throats. Creatror/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay. Peggy Ashcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.

to:

* TroubledProduction: Compared to Creator/DavidLean's other shoots, his final film was a breeze, with even the Indian location shooting going smoothly. Except for one thing: Lean and his stars were constantly at each others' throats. Creatror/AlecGuinness Creator/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay. Peggy Ashcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


24 of 24 found this interesting | Share this
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeletedRole: The character of Mr. Hadley as filmed was a nice little cameo but in editing most of his scenes were deleted and all of his lines were cut as well.


Added DiffLines:

* HostilityOnTheSet: The relationship between Creator/DavidLean and Creator/AlecGuinness deteriorated during the making of the movie. The final straw came for Guinness when he found out that a large chunk of his scenes had been left on the cutting floor by Lean. Neither man ever met or spoke to the other again. Lean also had frequent on-set clashes with Judy Davis who accused him of having lost his touch, not having directed for 15 years.
** As well as some cast members, Lean steadily alienated most of the heads of department and their crew during production. The situation on set deteriorated to such an extent that the producer John Brabourne had to order the camera crew to at least say "good morning" to Lean each day.
24 of 24 found this interesting | Share this
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TroubledProduction: Compared to Creator/DavidLean's other shoots, his final film was a breeze, with even the Indian location shooting going smoothly. Except for one thing: Lean and his stars were constantly at each others' throats. Creatror/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Creator/VictorBanerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay. Creator/PeggyAshcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.

to:

* TroubledProduction: Compared to Creator/DavidLean's other shoots, his final film was a breeze, with even the Indian location shooting going smoothly. Except for one thing: Lean and his stars were constantly at each others' throats. Creatror/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Creator/VictorBanerjee Victor Banerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay. Creator/PeggyAshcroft Peggy Ashcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.



** Lean offered Creator/KatherineHepburn the role of Mrs. Moore.

to:

** Lean offered Creator/KatherineHepburn Creator/KatharineHepburn the role of Mrs. Moore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeDearBoy: Creator/PeggyAshcroft was a stage actress who had appeared in films only sporadically. She was initially not enthusiastic when Creator/DavidLean asked her to be Mrs Moore. "Mr Lean, I’m 75-years-old," she protested. "So am I," he replied. Although she had recently worked in India on Series/TheJewelInTheCrown, she said, "I thought, 'Oh dear, I really don’t want to do it', but it's very difficult to turn down a Lean film."

to:

* AwesomeDearBoy: Creator/PeggyAshcroft was a stage actress who had appeared in films only sporadically. She was initially not enthusiastic when Creator/DavidLean asked her to be Mrs Moore. "Mr Lean, I’m 75-years-old," she protested. "So am I," he replied. Although she had recently worked in India on Series/TheJewelInTheCrown, ''Series/TheJewelInTheCrown'', she said, "I thought, 'Oh dear, I really don’t want to do it', but it's very difficult to turn down a Lean film."

Added: 225

Changed: 343

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CareerResurrection: For James Fox. Following a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved in drug culture, which (along with his father's death) precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema for 14 years, became a born-again Christian and disavowed his earlier career. This film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular character actor.

to:

* CareerResurrection: For James Fox.Creator/JamesFox. Following a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved in drug culture, which (along with his father's death) precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema for 14 years, became a born-again Christian and disavowed his earlier career. This film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular character actor.



* WhatCouldHaveBeen: Forester originally wrote that Aziz did indeed rape Adela, but later decided against it.
** Creator/DavidLean hoped to reunite the stars of Film/BriefEncounter - Creator/CeliaJohnson and Creator/TrevorHoward as Mrs. Moore and Richard Fielding. They both passed. Also, Johnson died before the film was released.

to:

* WhatCouldHaveBeen: WhatCouldHaveBeen:
**
Forester originally wrote that Aziz did indeed rape Adela, but later decided against it.
** Creator/DavidLean hoped to reunite the stars of Film/BriefEncounter ''Film/BriefEncounter'' - Creator/CeliaJohnson and Creator/TrevorHoward as Mrs. Moore and Richard Fielding. They both passed. Also, Johnson died before the film was released.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CareerResurrection: For James Fox. Following a prominent start in the 1960s, he became heavily involved in drug culture, which (along with his father's death) precipitated a physical and mental breakdown. Fox left cinema for 14 years, became a born-again Christian and disavowed his earlier career. This film gave him a major comeback, both as a leading man and popular character actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Creator/DavidLean hoped to reunite the stars of ''Film/BriefEncounter - Creator/CeliaJohnson and Creator/TrevorHoward as Mrs. Moore and Richard Fielding. They both passed. Also, Johnson died before the film was released.

to:

** Creator/DavidLean hoped to reunite the stars of ''Film/BriefEncounter Film/BriefEncounter - Creator/CeliaJohnson and Creator/TrevorHoward as Mrs. Moore and Richard Fielding. They both passed. Also, Johnson died before the film was released.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeDearBoy: Creator/PeggyAshcroft was a stage actress who had appeared in films only sporadically. She was not enthusiastic when Creator/DavidLean asked her to be Mrs Moore. "Mr Lean, I’m 75-years-old," she protested. "So am I," he replied. Although she had recently worked in India on ''Series/TheJewelInTheCrown, she said, "I thought, 'Oh dear, I really don’t want to do it', but it's very difficult to turn down a Lean film."

to:

* AwesomeDearBoy: Creator/PeggyAshcroft was a stage actress who had appeared in films only sporadically. She was initially not enthusiastic when Creator/DavidLean asked her to be Mrs Moore. "Mr Lean, I’m 75-years-old," she protested. "So am I," he replied. Although she had recently worked in India on ''Series/TheJewelInTheCrown, Series/TheJewelInTheCrown, she said, "I thought, 'Oh dear, I really don’t want to do it', but it's very difficult to turn down a Lean film."

Added: 1494

Changed: 570

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FakeNationality: British Alec Guinness as Hindu Brahmin Professor Godbole.
* WhatCouldHaveBeen: Forester originally wrote that Aziz did indeed rape Adela, but later decided against it.

to:

* AwesomeDearBoy: Creator/PeggyAshcroft was a stage actress who had appeared in films only sporadically. She was not enthusiastic when Creator/DavidLean asked her to be Mrs Moore. "Mr Lean, I’m 75-years-old," she protested. "So am I," he replied. Although she had recently worked in India on ''Series/TheJewelInTheCrown, she said, "I thought, 'Oh dear, I really don’t want to do it', but it's very difficult to turn down a Lean film."
* FakeNationality: British Alec Guinness Creator/AlecGuinness as Hindu Brahmin Professor Godbole.
* TheOtherMarty: Creator/NigelHawthorne was cast as Turton but fell ill and was replaced on-set by Creator/RichardWilson.
* TroubledProduction: Compared to Creator/DavidLean's other shoots, his final film was a breeze, with even the Indian location shooting going smoothly. Except for one thing: Lean and his stars were constantly at each others' throats. Creatror/AlecGuinness testified in his diaries to the toxic atmosphere on set, resulting in cast and crew insulting Lean behind his back, and occasionally to his face. Creator/JudyDavis told Lean "You can't fucking well direct" and claimed he didn't understand women. Creator/VictorBanerjee argued with Lean over Aziz's accent, calling him "obnoxious" and a hack compared to Creator/SatyajitRay. Creator/PeggyAshcroft disliked Lean's altering the novel and "lack of respect" for her co-stars. Finally, of course, was Guinness himself: playing the Indian mystic Godbole, he spent weeks learning an intricate Hindu dance, only to have Lean cut the entire scene in post-production.
* WhatCouldHaveBeen: Forester originally wrote that Aziz did indeed rape Adela, but later decided against it.it.
** Creator/DavidLean hoped to reunite the stars of ''Film/BriefEncounter - Creator/CeliaJohnson and Creator/TrevorHoward as Mrs. Moore and Richard Fielding. They both passed. Also, Johnson died before the film was released.
** Lean offered Creator/KatherineHepburn the role of Mrs. Moore.
** Creator/PeterOToole was the first choice for Richard Fielding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hey Its That Guy cut by TRS decision.


* HeyItsThatGuy: [[KeepingUpAppearances Richard Bucket]] plays a much more forceful character in Major Callendar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatCouldHaveBeen: Forester originally wrote that Aziz did indeed rape Adela, but later decided against it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FakeNationality: British Alec Guinness as Hindu Brahmin Professor Godbole.
* HeyItsThatGuy: [[KeepingUpAppearances Richard Bucket]] plays a much more forceful character in Major Callendar.

Top