Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / Merlin

Go To

OR

Added: 703

Changed: 227

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigScrewedUpFamily: As of the end of series three, the Pendragons definitely qualify, what with Uther and Arthur's strained relationship and the fact that Morgana is not only [[spoiler: Uther's illegitimate daughter and Arthur's unacknowledged half-sister, but actively trying to kill them both]]. Both of Arthur’s [[EvilUncle uncles]] tried to avenge Ygraine’s death: Tristan by coming back from the grave to kill Uther and [[spoiler: Agravaine by plotting with Morgana]].

to:

* BigScrewedUpFamily: As of the end of series three, the Pendragons definitely qualify, what with Uther and Arthur's strained relationship and the fact that Morgana is not only [[spoiler: Uther's illegitimate daughter and Arthur's unacknowledged half-sister, but actively trying to kill them both]]. Both of Arthur’s Arthur’s [[EvilUncle uncles]] tried to avenge Ygraine’s death: Tristan by coming back from the grave to kill Uther and [[spoiler: Agravaine by plotting with Morgana]].



* DemotedToExtra: Gaius in series four, who only has one episode that centers on him, and for the most part is just used for exposition.

to:

* DemotedToExtra: Gaius Especially in Season One, the show had a habit of taking the names of reasonably significant Arthurian characters, like Pellinore, and giving them to random knights, [[RedshirtArmy who were then killed]].
** In series four and five, [[CanonForeigner Gaius]] is given virtually nothing to do except [[MrExposition provide exposition]] and exist as a [[TheConfidant sounding board]] to Merlin. True, that was always his role, but he was also given several character-centric episodes in the past. This was not necessarily a bad thing, as the introduction of the knights of the Round Table at the end of series three meant that the show was juggling LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters, and one of the themes of the season was passing on the torch to the younger generation.
** Gwaine became this
in series four, who only has one episode that centers on him, four and for the most part is just used for exposition.five - oddly enough, he got more screen-time and characterization as a guest star than as a series regular.

Added: 270

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DisproportionateRetribution:

to:

* DisproportionateRetribution:DisproportionateRetribution:



** No mention of "The Lady of the Lake" when [[spoiler: a sorceress cursed Freya to turn into a bloodthirsty, killing Bastet every night for accidentally killing said sorceress's son in self-defense]]?

to:

** No mention of "The Lady of the Lake" when [[spoiler: a sorceress cursed Freya to turn into a bloodthirsty, killing Bastet every night for accidentally killing said sorceress's son in self-defense]]?self-defense]]?
** Also the dragon's attack on Camelot. Uther slaughtered his entire kind, and in response he attempts to raze the city to the ground, leaving Uther untouched as his subjects die. Well, it's the exact same thing that Uther did to him, but he was still killing innocents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ColourCodedForYourConvenience: Merlin and Arthur usually wear blue and red respectively, as a near-literal example of RedOniBlueOni. SpiritedYoungLady and RebelliousPrincess Morgana wears bright, jewel-like colours such as reds, blues, purples, and greens, whilst the gentler ShrinkingViolet Guinevere wears almost every shade of pastel imaginable: lavender, peach, pink, and light blue. By series four, the bad guys (Morgana, Agravaine, Helios, and [[spoiler: Shade!Lancelot]]) wear black, whilst those with magical powers are usually delinated by the colour green, particularly Mordred and the other Druids, who wear green cloaks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ComicallyMissingThePoint: The show does this quite often, particularly with Merlin himself.
-->'''Arthur:''' You can't leave him here [on the floor]! We have to get him onto the bed.
-->'''Merlin:''' Why? He's asleep. He's not going to know.
-->'''Arthur:''' Merlin!
-->'''Merlin:''' Alright, I'll get him a pillow.
-->'''Arthur:''' He's ''the king!''
-->'''Merlin:''' You're right....''two pillows!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Morgana [[spoiler:Pendragon]] as well. Even before [[spoiler:her HeelFaceTurn]], the writers did not seem to like her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PersonOfMassDestruction: Merlin and Morgana. Any high-level mage, especially if they get creative, can cause hell.

to:

* PersonOfMassDestruction: Merlin and Morgana. Any high-level mage, especially if they get creative, can cause raise hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PersonOfMassDestruction: Merlin.

to:

* PersonOfMassDestruction: Merlin. Merlin and Morgana. Any high-level mage, especially if they get creative, can cause hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ConspicuousGloves: Uther, who never took them off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hot Mom is no longer a trope.


* HotShounenMom: In series two, Ygraine Pendragon.

Changed: 906

Removed: 258

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PoliticallyCorrectHistory: Gwen (Guinevere) is black. Anachronistic, perhaps, but we're not that fussed. Lancelot's race is never mentioned but he is noticeably darker-skinned than the rest of the cast (he is played by Santiago Cabrera, who is Chilean.)
** This is not necessarily true, as there have been black people in Britain since the Romans conquered it, and southern Europeans tend to be darker than those in the north (in reference to Lancelot, not Gwen).
** Actually, Gwen's physical appearance may just be one of the least anachronistic aspects of the show: her darker skin and curly hair suggest that she is [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silures Silurian]] (no, not [[Series/DoctorWho that]] kind of Silurian).

to:

* PoliticallyCorrectHistory: Comments have been made on the ethnicities of Gwen (Guinevere) is black. Anachronistic, perhaps, and Lancelot but we're not that fussed. Lancelot's race is never mentioned but he is noticeably darker-skinned than the rest of the cast (he is played by Santiago Cabrera, who is Chilean.)
** This is not necessarily true, as
there have been black people in Britain since the Romans conquered it, it and southern Europeans tend to be darker than those in the north (in reference to Lancelot, not Gwen).
** Actually,
Gwen). In fact, Gwen's physical appearance may just be one of the least anachronistic aspects of the show: her darker skin and curly hair suggest that she is [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silures Silurian]] (no, not [[Series/DoctorWho that]] kind of Silurian).Silurian).
** All the angsting over Arthur being in love with a servant girl. Love marriage is a rather modern phenomenon especially for royalty. A true prince of that (or most) ages would marry for politics and have Gwen on the side for romance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HatePlague: Lamia infects the knights with this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fix natter

Changed: 52

Removed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fix natter


* LegendaryWeapon: ''Excalibur'', which Arthur is going to rip out of that stone as revealed by the series trailer, and Lancelot's sword which I have momentarily forgotten the name of.
** Arondight.

to:

* LegendaryWeapon: ''Excalibur'', which Arthur is going to rip out of that stone as revealed by the series trailer, and Lancelot's sword which I have momentarily forgotten the name of.
**
sword, Arondight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Arondight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hottip cleanup


** Series 4 is more of a duel between the two of them than Arthur and Morgana. Arthur spends most of the series being puppeted and Morgana dwells more on her petty vendettas than anything that will actually help her, leaving Merlin and Agravaine to do anything actually beneficial. To further the parallels, they seem to be the only ones actually aware of how competent the other is.[[hottip:*: While Morgana dismisses (or pretends to dismiss) Merlin as a mere serving boy, Agravaine's actually smart enough to get him out of the way before abducting Gaius and watch him in case he does something. Later, Merlin states that Agravaine is far too dangerous to be left alone and his treachery should be exposed before he does real damage, and Gaius basically tells him that he's overreacting and refuses to confirm Agravaine kidnapped him to Arthur.]]

to:

** Series 4 is more of a duel between the two of them than Arthur and Morgana. Arthur spends most of the series being puppeted and Morgana dwells more on her petty vendettas than anything that will actually help her, leaving Merlin and Agravaine to do anything actually beneficial. To further the parallels, they seem to be the only ones actually aware of how competent the other is.[[hottip:*: [[note]] While Morgana dismisses (or pretends to dismiss) Merlin as a mere serving boy, Agravaine's actually smart enough to get him out of the way before abducting Gaius and watch him in case he does something. Later, Merlin states that Agravaine is far too dangerous to be left alone and his treachery should be exposed before he does real damage, and Gaius basically tells him that he's overreacting and refuses to confirm Agravaine kidnapped him to Arthur.]][[/note]]



** Merlin and Morgana have a huge NotSoDifferent thing going on. Anything she's done, he's done as well. Attempt to murder an innocent to prevent a prophecy, take away free will, betray a close friend, the works. [[hottip:*: Although it's not really a double standard, as Merlin spends a long time angsting over these decisions, and Morgana is positively gleeful to do them whenever she has the chance.]]

to:

** Merlin and Morgana have a huge NotSoDifferent thing going on. Anything she's done, he's done as well. Attempt to murder an innocent to prevent a prophecy, take away free will, betray a close friend, the works. [[hottip:*: [[note]] Although it's not really a double standard, as Merlin spends a long time angsting over these decisions, and Morgana is positively gleeful to do them whenever she has the chance.]][[/note]]



** Alternatively, Merlin was still in there somewhere and didn't want to actually kill Arthur, or be arrested before he could.[[hottip:*:But that's highly doubtful.]]

to:

** Alternatively, Merlin was still in there somewhere and didn't want to actually kill Arthur, or be arrested before he could.[[hottip:*:But [[note]]But that's highly doubtful.]][[/note]]



* UnderestimatingBadassery: You have [[BadassDamsel two]] [[WarriorPrince royals]], [[BadassCrew a bunch of knights]], a HighPriestess, and a [[SquishyWizard small, untrained]],[[{{Dojikko}} clumsy]] manservant. Guess which one has the highest body count of the series? [[hottip:*: Making your soldiers do the job doesn't count, otherwise it would be Morgana.]]

to:

* UnderestimatingBadassery: You have [[BadassDamsel two]] [[WarriorPrince royals]], [[BadassCrew a bunch of knights]], a HighPriestess, and a [[SquishyWizard small, untrained]],[[{{Dojikko}} clumsy]] manservant. Guess which one has the highest body count of the series? [[hottip:*: [[note]] Making your soldiers do the job doesn't count, otherwise it would be Morgana.]][[/note]]

Changed: 449

Removed: 314

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixing up Thread Mode


* ChildrenAreInnocent: Initially played straight with Mordred, who despite being supposedly destined for evil, is at first just an ordinary (if telepathic) little boy; however, averted with each subsequent appearance, as Uther's persecution drives him to become more and more vengeful.
** YMMV on this. In the two occasions, he was attacked by adults and just defended himself.
*** It's still pretty scary for a kid who was raised by an extremely pacifistic people to kill without remorse.

to:

* ChildrenAreInnocent: Initially played straight with Mordred, who despite being supposedly destined for evil, is at first just an ordinary (if telepathic) little boy; however, averted boy. His morality becomes more and more ambiguous with each subsequent appearance, as Uther's persecution drives him to become more and more vengeful.
** YMMV on this. In the two occasions,
vengeful. Although he was attacked by adults and just defended himself.
*** It's
is defending himself against adults, it's still pretty scary for a kid who was raised by an extremely pacifistic people to kill without remorse.



* CommonEyeColors: Arthur and Mordred's matching baby blues seem... suggestive.
** YMMV here. In season 5, [[spoiler:Mordred's eyes match Morgana's, perfectly. Still suggestive, though, yes?]]

to:

* CommonEyeColors: Arthur and Mordred's matching baby blues seem... suggestive.
** YMMV here.
suggestive. ([[MythologyGag Mordred was Arthur's illegitimate son]] in [[Literature/LeMorteDarthur Sir Thomas Mallory's telling]] of the Arthurian legends.) In season Series 5, [[spoiler:Mordred's this takes a different direction as Mordred's eyes match Morgana's, perfectly. Still suggestive, though, yes?]][[spoiler:matches ''Morgana's'']].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: Perhaps not so much an "upgrade" as a "shift" in what the main characters angst about. Arthur has [[WellDoneSonGuy Daddy Issues]], Morgana grapples with fear of her growing magical powers, Guinevere is given a RagsToRiches story, and Merlin has to hide his true identity while making SadisticChoice after SadisticChoice. Their legendary counterparts had [[BecauseDestinySaysSo Depressing Destinies]], BrotherSisterIncest and [[LoveTriangle Love Triangles]] to contend with.

to:

* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: Perhaps not so much an "upgrade" as a "shift" in what the main characters angst about. Arthur has [[WellDoneSonGuy Daddy Issues]], Morgana grapples with fear of her growing magical powers, Guinevere is given a RagsToRiches story, and Merlin has to hide his true identity while making SadisticChoice after SadisticChoice. Their eTheir legendary counterparts had [[BecauseDestinySaysSo Depressing Destinies]], BrotherSisterIncest and [[LoveTriangle Love Triangles]] to contend with.

Added: 169

Removed: 166

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Merging Blood On These Hands into These Hands Have Killed. Zero Context Examples and misuse is being removed.


* BloodOnTheseHands: Uther carries a lot of subconscious guilt for the death of his wife and the innocent lives he's taken in the destruction of magic in the kingdom.


Added DiffLines:

* TheseHandsHaveKilled: Uther carries a lot of subconscious guilt for the death of his wife and the innocent lives he's taken in the destruction of magic in the kingdom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--'''The Great Dragon'''

to:

-->--'''The -->-- '''The Great Dragon'''



!!This series contains examples of:

to:

!!This series contains !!''Merlin'' provides examples of:
of the following tropes:



** A darker example in TheDarkTower. Morgana alternates between cruelty and kindness when she has Gwen hostage in an attempt to brainwash her. Morgana holding out her hand to Gwen and getting Gwen to take her hand in turn are vital steps on the road to inducing StockholmSyndrome.

to:

** A darker example in TheDarkTower."The Dark Tower". Morgana alternates between cruelty and kindness when she has Gwen hostage in an attempt to brainwash her. Morgana holding out her hand to Gwen and getting Gwen to take her hand in turn are vital steps on the road to inducing StockholmSyndrome.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


There is a [[Characters/{{Merlin}} Character Sheet]] and an [[Recap/{{Merlin}} Episode Guide]] for the series.

to:

There is a [[Characters/{{Merlin}} Character Sheet]] character sheet]] and an [[Recap/{{Merlin}} Episode Guide]] episode guide]] for the series.

Added: 692

Changed: 32

Removed: 692

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ARealManIsAKiller: Arthur describes himself as "the ultimate killing machine" and this is in no way an InformedAbility. In fact, it's almost disconcerting to see him kill another man (albeit one who was trying to kill ''him'') without a moment's hesitation in the very second episode of the show.



** Merlin mucking out the stables is a running gag, though. In ''Aithusa'' Merlin has to forgo his own dinner to feed the horses. And in ''Sword in the Stone Part 1'' Merlin has [[spoiler:simpleton!]] Arthur rub down the horses. So caring for the horses is definitely there, but LawOfConservationOfDetail often HandWaves it.

to:

** Merlin mucking out the stables is a running gag, though. In ''Aithusa'' Merlin has to forgo his own dinner to feed the horses. And in ''Sword in the Stone Part 1'' Merlin has [[spoiler:simpleton!]] Arthur rub down the horses. So caring for the horses is definitely there, but LawOfConservationOfDetail often HandWaves {{Hand Wave}}s it.



* TheChosenZero: Merlin's immediate reaction to being told that Arthur is the destined King who will save the land is "There must be another Arthur, because this one's an idiot!"



** The entire attitude toward killing on the show. What, you thought that the PG rating would put RoseColoredGlasses on? Nope. If someone's trying to kill you, you kill them. The only two exceptions are when Mordred kills soldiers because he's a child, and when it's in cold blood, like Arthur executing King Caerleon.

to:

** The entire attitude toward killing on the show. What, you thought that the PG rating would put RoseColoredGlasses rose colored glasses on? Nope. If someone's trying to kill you, you kill them. The only two exceptions are when Mordred kills soldiers because he's a child, and when it's in cold blood, like Arthur executing King Caerleon.



* GoryDiscretionShot: Combined with BloodlessCarnage in episode 9, during Owain and Tristan DuBois's otherwise violent (well, for bulky, armor-weighted knights) battle.

to:

* GoryDiscretionShot: Combined with BloodlessCarnage in episode 9, during Owain and Tristan DuBois's [=DuBois=]'s otherwise violent (well, for bulky, armor-weighted knights) battle.



* InelegantBlubbering: Nobody on this show cries nicely. Which makes TearJerkers that much worse.

to:

* InelegantBlubbering: Nobody on this show cries nicely. Which makes TearJerkers {{Tear Jerker}}s that much worse.



* ItSQuietTooQuiet: Arthur to Merlin in the forest in episode 3x12.

to:

* ItSQuietTooQuiet: ItsQuietTooQuiet: Arthur to Merlin in the forest in episode 3x12.



* TheMole: Agravaine. And previously, Morgana to a point.



* ARealManIsAKiller: Arthur describes himself as "the ultimate killing machine" and this is in no way an InformedAbility. In fact, it's almost disconcerting to see him kill another man (albeit one who was trying to kill ''him'') without a moment's hesitation in the very second episode of the show.



** Could also count for SuspiciouslySpecificDenial, since RealMenDontLikeAffection.

to:

** Could also count for SuspiciouslySpecificDenial, since RealMenDontLikeAffection.RealMenHateAffection.



* TheUnreveal: So, so many times. The teaser for the next episodes sets up Arthur finding out that Merlin is a warlock every other episode, and yet... nothing.



* TheChosenZero: Merlin's immediate reaction to being told that Arthur is the destined King who will save the land is "There must be another Arthur, because this one's an idiot!"
* TheMole: Agravaine. And previously, Morgana to a point.


Added DiffLines:

* TheUnreveal: So, so many times. The teaser for the next episodes sets up Arthur finding out that Merlin is a warlock every other episode, and yet... nothing.

Changed: 177

Removed: 176

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NakedPeopleAreFunny:
[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TLQCi8Pfp7g This scene]]. Arthur usually has no problem strutting around his chambers naked, but with Gwen is there to see him, HilarityEnsues.

to:

* NakedPeopleAreFunny:
NakedPeopleAreFunny: [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TLQCi8Pfp7g This scene]]. Arthur usually has no problem strutting around his chambers naked, but with when Gwen is there to see him, HilarityEnsues.



* Single Tear: Merlin when he kisses Freya for the first time.

to:

* Single Tear: SingleTear: Merlin when he kisses Freya for the first time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswiking and adding one

Added DiffLines:

* GetOut: Arthur when sacking Merlin in ''Valiant'' after the servant's suspicions made him look bad in front of the court.


Added DiffLines:

* NakedPeopleAreFunny:
[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TLQCi8Pfp7g This scene]]. Arthur usually has no problem strutting around his chambers naked, but with Gwen is there to see him, HilarityEnsues.


Added DiffLines:

* Single Tear: Merlin when he kisses Freya for the first time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadStarWalking: This show ''loved'' bringing in reasonably big-name guest stars only to kill them off almost immediately, including: [[spoilers: Phil Davies, James Callis, Gary Lewis, Holliday Grainger, Sarah Parish, Charles Dance, Eve Myles, John Shrapnel, Julian Rhind-Tutt and John Lynch, among others).

to:

* DeadStarWalking: This show ''loved'' bringing in reasonably big-name guest stars only to kill them off almost immediately, including: [[spoilers: Phil Davies, James Callis, Gary Lewis, Holliday Grainger, Sarah Parish, Charles Dance, Eve Myles, John Shrapnel, Julian Rhind-Tutt and John Lynch, among others).others]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeadStarWalking: This show ''loved'' bringing in reasonably big-name guest stars only to kill them off almost immediately, including: [[spoilers: Phil Davies, James Callis, Gary Lewis, Holliday Grainger, Sarah Parish, Charles Dance, Eve Myles, John Shrapnel, Julian Rhind-Tutt and John Lynch, among others).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Played straight in season 4 when Arthur breaks up with Guinevere at Agravaine's insistence. Though Arthur claims it's his own choice, Gwen immediately realizes that someone else put him up to it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Something of a {{subversion}} considering a) leaving doesn't make Gwen particularly happy, and b) Lancelot leaves for Arthur's sake rather than for Gwen's, making it more a case of [[IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy I Want My Future King To Be Happy]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A darker example in TheDarkTower. Morgana alternates between cruelty and kindness when she has Gwen hostage in an attempt to brainwash her. Morgana holding out her hand to Gwen and getting Gwen to take her hand in turn are vital steps on the road to inducing StockholmSyndrome.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Dark Tower, very much so. In addition to the stories young knights are apparently told to scare them away from it, it is surrounded by an impenetrable forest that, in addition to being nigh impenetrable, reverses directions so you can only get out if you have help. It also looks terrifying and Queen Mab gives Merlin some rather disturbing advice:
--->'''Queen Mab''': You must beware, Emrys. The Tower is not a real place. It is the heart's rest, the mind's deepest fear, the stillness in the hummingbird's eye.

Top