Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / Dickinson

Go To

OR

Changed: 108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WalkAndTalk: In "[[ElectionDayEpisode We lose - because we win]]".

to:

* WalkAndTalk: In "[[ElectionDayEpisode We lose - because we win]]".win]]", complete with [[Creator/AaronSorkin Sorkensian]] dialogue in a deliberate homage to ''Series/TheWestWing''.

Added: 70

Changed: 37

Removed: 104

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MakingLoveInAllTheWrongPlaces:
** Sue is shown getting oral sex from Austin in the barn.
** Later, Sue and Emily have sex in the garden.

to:

* MakingLoveInAllTheWrongPlaces:
** Sue is shown getting oral sex from Austin in the barn.
** Later,
MakingLoveInAllTheWrongPlaces: Sue and Emily have sex in the garden.


Added DiffLines:

* RollInTheHay: Sue is shown getting oral sex from Austin in the barn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamLine: Sue tells Emily, [[spoiler: 'The only time I feel things is when I'm with you.']]

to:

* WhamLine: At the end of season 2, Sue tells Emily, [[spoiler: 'The only time I feel things is when I'm with you.']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhamLine: Sue tells Emily, [[spoiler: 'The only time I feel things is when I'm with you.']]

Added: 993

Removed: 1018

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetizing, commenting out zero context examples.


* AbusiveParents: Edward to all of his children in some ways. Only shown as physical with Emily.



* AfterlifeExpress: Death travels around in a black carriage pulled by ghost horses.



* BigEater: Sam Bowles seems to be shown eating a lot.



* HistoricalDomainCrossover: Emily meets Creator/HenryDavidThoreau, Creator/LouisaMayAlcott, Frederick Law Olmstead, Creator/EdgarAllanPoe, Creator/WaltWhitman, and Creator/SylviaPlath. She doesn't meet her as far as we know, but Sojourner Truth is also existing in Amherst in season 3.
%%* HistoricalPersonPunchline: Creator/SylviaPlath in season 3
* HistoricalRelationshipOverhaul: Dickinson experts still remain divided on the nature of real life Emily and Sue's relationship but the show goes at it full hilt.
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Sam Bowles was a dear friend of Emily and Sue's in real life. To a lesser extent, Jane. She and Emily only seem to dislike each other in season 1, but were good friends in real life.



%%* TeensAreMonsters: Anna and Clara.



* WildTeenParty: A very modern teen party takes place in episode 3. Of course, the soundtrack is classical piano and the rowdy kids are taking opium.
* HistoricalPersonPunchline: Creator/SylviaPlath in season 3
* HistoricalRelationshipOverhaul: Dickinson experts still remain divided on the nature of real life Emily and Sue's relationship but the show goes at it full hilt. See also AdaptationalSexuality
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Sam Bowles was a dear friend of Emily and Sue's in real life. To a lesser extent, Jane. She and Emily only seem to dislike each other in season 1, but were good friends in real life.
* HistoricalDomainCrossover: Emily meets Creator/HenryDavidThoreau, Creator/LouisaMayAlcott, Frederick Law Olmstead, Creator/EdgarAllanPoe, Creator/WaltWhitman, and Creator/SylviaPlath. She doesn't meet her as far as we know, but Sojourner Truth is also existing in Amherst in season 3.
* AbusiveParents: Edward to all of his children in some ways. Only shown as physical with Emily.
* AfterlifeExpress: Death travels around in a black carriage pulled by ghost horses.
* TeensAreMonsters: Anna and Clara
* BigEater: Sam Bowles seems to be shown eating a lot.

to:

* WildTeenParty: A very modern teen party takes place in episode 3. Of course, the soundtrack is classical piano and the rowdy kids are taking opium.
* HistoricalPersonPunchline: Creator/SylviaPlath in season 3
* HistoricalRelationshipOverhaul: Dickinson experts still remain divided on the nature of real life Emily and Sue's relationship but the show goes at it full hilt. See also AdaptationalSexuality
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Sam Bowles was a dear friend of Emily and Sue's in real life. To a lesser extent, Jane. She and Emily only seem to dislike each other in season 1, but were good friends in real life.
* HistoricalDomainCrossover: Emily meets Creator/HenryDavidThoreau, Creator/LouisaMayAlcott, Frederick Law Olmstead, Creator/EdgarAllanPoe, Creator/WaltWhitman, and Creator/SylviaPlath. She doesn't meet her as far as we know, but Sojourner Truth is also existing in Amherst in season 3.
* AbusiveParents: Edward to all of his children in some ways. Only shown as physical with Emily.
* AfterlifeExpress: Death travels around in a black carriage pulled by ghost horses.
* TeensAreMonsters: Anna and Clara
* BigEater: Sam Bowles seems to be shown eating a lot.
opium.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WildTeenParty: A very modern teen party takes place in episode 3. Of course, the soundtrack is classical piano and the rowdy kids are taking opium.

to:

* WildTeenParty: A very modern teen party takes place in episode 3. Of course, the soundtrack is classical piano and the rowdy kids are taking opium.opium.
* HistoricalPersonPunchline: Creator/SylviaPlath in season 3
* HistoricalRelationshipOverhaul: Dickinson experts still remain divided on the nature of real life Emily and Sue's relationship but the show goes at it full hilt. See also AdaptationalSexuality
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Sam Bowles was a dear friend of Emily and Sue's in real life. To a lesser extent, Jane. She and Emily only seem to dislike each other in season 1, but were good friends in real life.
* HistoricalDomainCrossover: Emily meets Creator/HenryDavidThoreau, Creator/LouisaMayAlcott, Frederick Law Olmstead, Creator/EdgarAllanPoe, Creator/WaltWhitman, and Creator/SylviaPlath. She doesn't meet her as far as we know, but Sojourner Truth is also existing in Amherst in season 3.
* AbusiveParents: Edward to all of his children in some ways. Only shown as physical with Emily.
* AfterlifeExpress: Death travels around in a black carriage pulled by ghost horses.
* TeensAreMonsters: Anna and Clara
* BigEater: Sam Bowles seems to be shown eating a lot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected timeline of the show, which stated that it took place in 1852-53. We are never told the date in season 1, but it is explicitly stated by Sam in season 2 that it is 1859 and stated by several characters in season 3 that it was then 1862.


* AnachronisticSoundtrack: Set in 1852-53, the soundtrack is made up of 21st century hip hop, pop, and indie rock.

to:

* AnachronisticSoundtrack: Set starting sometime in 1852-53, the 1850s and ending in 1862, the soundtrack is made up of 21st century hip hop, pop, and indie rock.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
edited for clarity that there should not be an audience question of the paternity of Sue's child.


* MamasBabyPapasMaybe: [[spoiler:Austin states he's unsure whether Sue's baby was sired by him or not, due to her affair.]]

to:

* MamasBabyPapasMaybe: [[spoiler:Austin states he's unsure whether Sue's baby was sired by him or not, due to her affair. It should be noted that this is ridiculous, since season 2 took place in 1859 and season 3 is 1862.]]

Changed: 187

Removed: 62

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changed to correct the "kiss of gratitude" in s1e3 It was Emily who was supposedly grateful to Sue, not Sue to Emily.


* SecretRelationship: Emily and Sue's relationship is romantic/sexual, with them clearly in love. Naturally it's kept from everyone else, since this was completely taboo at the time. When they're once caught kissing by Austin, the pair then quickly pass it off as Sue doing so in "thanks" to Emily.

to:

* SecretRelationship: Emily and Sue's relationship is romantic/sexual, with them clearly in love. Naturally it's kept from everyone else, since this was completely taboo at the time. When they're once caught kissing by Austin, the pair then quickly pass Emily passes it off as a "kiss of gratitude" for Sue doing so helping her with a personal problem (getting her period in "thanks" to Emily.the middle of the party).



* TwoPersonPoolParty:
** Emily and Sue share a bath in "You can not put a fire out".

to:

* TwoPersonPoolParty:
**
TwoPersonPoolParty: Emily and Sue share a bath in "You can not put a fire out".

Changed: 123

Removed: 133

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Three baths are listed, but they are all the same bath. This only happened once.


* TwoPersonPoolParty: This seems to be Emily and Sue's thing.
** Emily and Sue start up their relationship again by sharing a bath, where they have sex.
** They do the same thing again in the wake of Sue's LoveConfession.
** Emily and Sue again share one in "You can not put a fire out".

to:

* TwoPersonPoolParty: This seems to be Emily and Sue's thing.
TwoPersonPoolParty:
** Emily and Sue start up their relationship again by sharing a bath, where they have sex.
** They do the same thing again in the wake of Sue's LoveConfession.
** Emily and Sue again
share one a bath in "You can not put a fire out".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* TheCaptivityNarrative: Invoked by Lavinia in "Alone, I cannot be."

to:

%%* * TheCaptivityNarrative: Invoked by Lavinia Lavinia, a young lady in 19th-century MA, in "Alone, I cannot be."" She starts fantasizing about getting abducted by Indians and becoming their princess to show up a man she liked who rejected her.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 161

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Has Two Mommies is now a disambig. Dewicking


* HasTwoMommies: {{Discussed}} when Sue is heavily pregnant and wistfully wishes she could raise the baby with Emily, asking why children can't have two mothers.

Added: 631

Changed: 361

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Expanding.


* BrokenPedestal: Emily with [[spoiler:Thoreau]]. He starts out as one of her heroes, but upon meeting him, Emily finds that he's really a lazy, entitled man who grossly exaggerated his whole "living in the woods" claims and is contemptuous of her over being an unpublished poet. [[spoiler:Thoreau]] [[LampshadeHanging lampshades]] it by saying "never meet your heroes" to Emily.

to:

* BrokenPedestal: BrokenPedestal:
**
Emily with [[spoiler:Thoreau]]. He starts out as one of her heroes, but upon meeting him, Emily finds that he's really a lazy, entitled man who grossly exaggerated his whole "living in the woods" claims and is contemptuous of her over being an unpublished poet. [[spoiler:Thoreau]] [[LampshadeHanging lampshades]] it by saying "never meet your heroes" to Emily.Emily.
** Although they clash at times, Emily is [[DaddysGirl closest with her father]]. When he won't even consider leaving Emily the house in his will and justifies this with the standard sexism of their time, she's appalled, tells him off about it then storms out crying.

Changed: 56

Removed: 109

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Expanding, dewicking.


* CaughtWithYourPantsDown: Austin is caught masturbating by his mother (unbeknownst to him, as his eyes are closed). She looks shocked and beats a hasty retreat.

to:

* CaughtWithYourPantsDown: Austin is caught masturbating by his mother on the couch (unbeknownst to him, as his eyes are closed). She looks shocked and beats a hasty retreat. He does it for "inspiration" when writing.



* ADateWithRosiePalms: Austin masturbates with his eyes closed on the couch to get "inspiration" for writing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnguishedDeclarationOfLove: While it's far from their first declaration, Sue's declaration of love in 2x10 is certainly pretty emotionally fraught.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Marked certain text as a spoiler (and slightly corrected grammar/punctuation), as it reveals how an important relationship in the show plays out in the last episodes of the final season


* BisexualLoveTriangle: Austin/Sue/Emily in season 1, and eventually Sam/Sue/Emily in season 2. Emily and Sue however end up as each other's true love though.

to:

* BisexualLoveTriangle: Austin/Sue/Emily in season 1, and eventually Sam/Sue/Emily in season 2. [[spoiler: Emily and Sue however Sue, however, end up as each other's true love though. in the end.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetizing.


* WildTeenParty: A very modern teen party takes place in episode 3. Of course, the soundtrack is classical piano and the rowdy kids are taking opium.
* WhiteGuilt: Emily wants her black servant, Henry, to play Shakespeare (Othello) even when he doesn't want to, so she can feel good about herself. When it ends up going wrong and she complains life shouldn't be this way, he tells her that she's a relatively safe white woman with a nice house, where she can have cake and is looked after. It's particularly heartbreaking is how Henry notes that she has her ''father'' to protect her. Consider the time they live in and how awful things were for slaves, how frequently families were broken up and destroyed. It's very likely that Henry never knew his father, and he certainly wouldn't have been able to protect Henry from the circumstances of their lives (he could have been a free black man, although this may indicate otherwise-even then it's possible he'd been {{born into slavery}}).

to:

* WildTeenParty: A very modern teen party takes place in episode 3. Of course, the soundtrack is classical piano and the rowdy kids are taking opium.
* WhiteGuilt: Emily wants her black servant, Henry, to play Shakespeare (Othello) even when he doesn't want to, so she can feel good about herself. When it ends up going wrong and she complains life shouldn't be this way, he tells her that she's a relatively safe white woman with a nice house, where she can have cake and is looked after. It's particularly heartbreaking is how Henry notes that she has her ''father'' to protect her. Consider the time they live in and how awful things were for slaves, how frequently families were broken up and destroyed. It's very likely that Henry never knew his father, and he certainly wouldn't have been able to protect Henry from the circumstances of their lives (he could have been a free black man, although this may indicate otherwise-even then it's possible he'd been {{born into slavery}}).slavery}}).
* WildTeenParty: A very modern teen party takes place in episode 3. Of course, the soundtrack is classical piano and the rowdy kids are taking opium.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PeriodPieceModernLanguage: The show establishes its irreverence in the first scene, where supposedly 19th century American gentlewoman Emily rages, "This is such bullshit." when asked to do a chore her brother is exempted from for being male. The rest of the show follows 21st century speech patterns. For example, their discussion on ''Literature/BleakHouse'''s ongoing plot developments[[note]]It was serialized from 1852-1853[[/note]] would not be out of place in a modern forum.
-->'''Lavinia''': I'm honestly gonna die if we don't find out who Esther's mother is soon.\\
'''Austin:''' It's obviously Lady Dedlock.\\
'''Lavinia:''' Austin! No spoilers!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LiteraryAllusionTitle: Appropriately, the real Emily Dickinson's poems are uses as the basis of episode titles, along with being quoted frequently. Emily is seen writing many of them during the series.

to:

* LiteraryAllusionTitle: Appropriately, the real Emily Dickinson's poems are uses used as the basis of episode titles, along with being quoted frequently. Emily is seen writing many of them during the series.

Added: 299

Changed: 342

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding trope, editing.


* LoveConfession: In "You cannot put a Fire out" Sue passionately confesses her love to Emily, saying it's the only true thing she'll ever feel. Emily reacts by kissing her fiercely. Their love had been obvious already, though neither ever said it before.

to:

* LoveConfession: LiteraryAllusionTitle: Appropriately, the real Emily Dickinson's poems are uses as the basis of episode titles, along with being quoted frequently. Emily is seen writing many of them during the series.
* LoveConfession:
** In the pilot, "Because I Could Not Stop", Emily and Sue admit they love each other then share a passionate kiss.
**
In "You cannot put a Fire out" Sue passionately confesses reaffirms her love to Emily, saying it's the only true thing she'll ever feel. Emily reacts by kissing her fiercely. Their love had been obvious already, though neither ever said it before.



* QueerEstablishingMoment: In the finale of the pilot, Emily and Sue's empassioned kiss shows they have an existing intimate relationship that is then a main theme during the series.

to:

* QueerEstablishingMoment: In the finale of Early in the pilot, Emily and Sue's mutual LoveConfession followed with their empassioned kiss shows they have an existing intimate relationship that is then a main theme during the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Editing.


* TransTribulations: A patient at the asylum (who was assigned female at birth) was committed because of their gender. They're dressed in a Union Army uniform, so it's indicated to stem from having joined up while presenting as male but seen as a woman once found out, at a time when this wasn't allowed. Like the other patients, they have no hope of release in the immediate future.

to:

* TransTribulations: A patient at the asylum (who was assigned female at birth) was had been committed because of their gender.gender (it's unsaid if they are a trans man or nonbinary in modern terms). They're dressed in a Union Army uniform, so it's indicated to stem from having joined up while presenting as male but seen as a woman once found out, at a time when this wasn't allowed. Like the other patients, they have no hope of release in the immediate future.anytime soon.



** Emily to Sue following their lovemaking: "I feel sorry for the dead today.".

to:

** Emily to Sue following their lovemaking: "I feel sorry for the dead today."."[[note]]Indicating the two were "[[TheImmodestOrgasm loud enough]] to wake the dead".[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Minor edit.


* RightThroughTheWall: Implied. In the episode "You can not put a fire out", as Emily and Sue lie in the garden after making love, Emily reflects that she already feels sorry for the dead that day. [[note]]''In other words, they were loud enough to wake the dead.''[[/note]]

to:

* RightThroughTheWall: Implied.{{Implied}}. In the episode "You can not put a fire out", as Emily and Sue lie in the garden after making love, Emily reflects that she already feels sorry for the dead that day. [[note]]''In other words, they were loud enough to wake the dead.''[[/note]]

Top