Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekVoyagerS4E22Demon

Go To

OR

Added: 180

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathWorld[=/=]IDontLikeTheSoundOfThatPlace: The "Demon-class" planet.

to:

* DeathWorld[=/=]IDontLikeTheSoundOfThatPlace: The "Demon-class" planet.planet, which can be described as "Venus, but radioactive".


Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: Seven criticizes the use of the term "Demon-class", since "demon" implies a presence and the planet is uninhabited. We later find out there ''is'' a presence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TormentByAnnoyance: Neelix and the Doctor have a back-and-forth where the Doctor does his work in sickbay while singing opera to annoy Neelix and three other sleeping crew members out of sick bay. [[DreadfulMusician Neelix]] responds by getting his bunkmates to participate in a multi-cultural sing-a-long -- to which the Doctor responds by relenting.

to:

* TormentByAnnoyance: Neelix and the Doctor have a back-and-forth where the Doctor does his work in sickbay while singing opera to annoy Neelix and three other sleeping crew members out of sick bay. [[DreadfulMusician Neelix]] responds by getting his bunkmates to participate in a multi-cultural sing-a-long sing-along -- to which the Doctor responds by relenting.finally gives up on singing the sleepers away, allowing them to rest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
renamed to Clone Angst


* CloningBlues
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Voyager'' is desperately low on fuel and Captain Janeway orders all nonessential systems to be shut down. Seven of Nine uses the astrometric sensors to detect a planet with deposits of deuterium, but the planet is a "Class Y" or "demon" planet, extremely hostile to humanoid life. When the initial effort to transport some deuterium to the ship fails, Harry Kim and Tom Paris go down in a shuttlecraft to retrieve some. There they discover that the deuterium is in a liquid form and somehow is able to stay in a very cool temperature. Unfortunately, their environmental suits start to fail, and both Tom and Harry run out of oxygen before they could reach the shuttle.

to:

''Voyager'' is desperately low on fuel deuterium, which it uses for fuel, and Captain Janeway orders all nonessential systems to be shut down. Seven of Nine uses the astrometric sensors to detect a planet with deposits of deuterium, but the planet is a "Class Y" or "demon" planet, extremely hostile to humanoid life. When the initial effort to transport some deuterium to the ship fails, Harry Kim and Tom Paris go down in a shuttlecraft to retrieve some. There they discover that the deuterium is in a liquid form and somehow is able to stay in a very cool temperature. Unfortunately, their environmental suits start to fail, and both Tom and Harry run out of oxygen before they could reach the shuttle.

Changed: 61

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is given a Hand Wave by Seven saying that conventional scans (non-Astrometrics) would not have found it. It's likely that the Demon class planet is "cloaked" from long-range scans somehow.


* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: So ''Voyager'' is down to sublight speed, yet they find a deuterium-rich planet less than a week away at one-quarter lightspeed. If it's that close, shouldn't they have already detected it? And when their first attempt to mine the planet fails, why would Janeway consider resuming course when they wouldn't make it to anywhere else?

to:

* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: So ''Voyager'' is down to sublight speed, yet they find a deuterium-rich planet less than a week away at one-quarter lightspeed. If it's that close, shouldn't they have already detected it? And when their first attempt to mine the planet fails, why would Janeway consider resuming course when they wouldn't make it to anywhere else?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen, having one neutron in its nucleus where protium has none; a standard warp core combines it with {{antimatter}} to get energy. While deuterium accounts for only 0.02% of hydrogen in the naturally-occurring world, hydrogen itself is ''74%'' of the mass of the observable universe; the glowing red things on the front of a Starfleet vessel's engines are called "{{Ramscoop}}s," are used to pull protium out of, literally, the vacuum of space, and have been there since ''The Original Series''; and "heavy water," which contains man-made deuterium, was first created in ''1932''. ''Voyager'''s ability to make its own deuterium has been canonical since 1967. (The later episode ''[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS7E14TheVoid The Void]]'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void.) Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen, having one neutron in its nucleus where protium has none; a standard warp core combines it with {{antimatter}} to get energy. While deuterium accounts for only 0.02% of hydrogen in the naturally-occurring world, hydrogen itself is ''74%'' of the mass of the observable universe; the glowing red things on the front of a Starfleet vessel's engines are called "{{Ramscoop}}s," are used to pull protium out of, literally, the vacuum of space, and have been there since ''The Original Series''; and "heavy water," which contains man-made deuterium, was first created in ''1932''. ''Voyager'''s ability to ''Voyager'' can make its own deuterium deuterium, and has been canonical since 1967.this entire time, with its shortage in this episode nothing less than a RealLife IdiotBall on the part of the writers. (The later episode ''[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS7E14TheVoid The Void]]'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void.) Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen, having one neutron in its nucleus where protium has none. While deuterium accounts for only 0.02% of hydrogen in the naturally-occurring world, hydrogen itself is one of the most abundant things in the physical universe; the glowing red things on the front of ''Voyager'''s nacelles are called "{{Ramscoop}}s" and are used to pull protium out of, literally, the vacuum of space; and "heavy water," which contains man-made deuterium, was first created in ''1932''. (The later episode ''[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS7E14TheVoid The Void]]'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void.) Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen, having one neutron in its nucleus where protium has none.none; a standard warp core combines it with {{antimatter}} to get energy. While deuterium accounts for only 0.02% of hydrogen in the naturally-occurring world, hydrogen itself is one ''74%'' of the most abundant things in mass of the physical observable universe; the glowing red things on the front of ''Voyager'''s nacelles a Starfleet vessel's engines are called "{{Ramscoop}}s" and "{{Ramscoop}}s," are used to pull protium out of, literally, the vacuum of space; space, and have been there since ''The Original Series''; and "heavy water," which contains man-made deuterium, was first created in ''1932''.''1932''. ''Voyager'''s ability to make its own deuterium has been canonical since 1967. (The later episode ''[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS7E14TheVoid The Void]]'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void.) Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TormentByAnnoyance: Neelix and the Doctor have a back-and-forth where the Doctor does his work in sickbay while singing opera to annoy Neelix and three other sleeping crew members out of sick bay. [[DreadfulMusician Neelix]] responds by getting his bunkmates to participate in a multi-cultural sing-a-long -- to which the Doctor responds by relenting.

to:

* TormentByAnnoyance: Neelix and the Doctor have a back-and-forth where the Doctor does his work in sickbay while singing opera to annoy Neelix and three other sleeping crew members out of sick bay. [[DreadfulMusician Neelix]] responds by getting his bunkmates to participate in a multi-cultural sing-a-long -- to which the Doctor responds by relenting.relenting.
* TurnTheOtherCheek: When news comes through that (the supposed) Tom and Harry are in need of medical attention, the Doctor -- with no small amount of satisfaction -- orders Neelix and the other three couch-crashers out of sickbay. Neelix's response is... to graciously thank the Doctor for his hospitality and to let him know his door is always open should the Doctor need a place to stay. The Doctor is left looking somewhat abashed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen, having one neutron in its nucleus where protium has none. While deuterium accounts for only 0.02% of hydrogen in the naturally-occurring world, hydrogen itself is one of the most abundant things in the physical universe; and "heavy water," which contains man-made deuterium, was first created in ''1932''. (The later episode ''The Void'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void.) Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen, having one neutron in its nucleus where protium has none. While deuterium accounts for only 0.02% of hydrogen in the naturally-occurring world, hydrogen itself is one of the most abundant things in the physical universe; the glowing red things on the front of ''Voyager'''s nacelles are called "{{Ramscoop}}s" and are used to pull protium out of, literally, the vacuum of space; and "heavy water," which contains man-made deuterium, was first created in ''1932''. (The later episode ''The Void'' ''[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS7E14TheVoid The Void]]'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void.) Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is only rare in comparison to protium, the other isotype of hydrogen. It is literally one of the most abundant things in the physical universe. The later episode ''The Void'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void. Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen, having one neutron in its nucleus where protium has none. While deuterium accounts for only rare 0.02% of hydrogen in comparison to protium, the other isotype of hydrogen. It naturally-occurring world, hydrogen itself is literally one of the most abundant things in the physical universe. The universe; and "heavy water," which contains man-made deuterium, was first created in ''1932''. (The later episode ''The Void'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void. void.) Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics:
** Deuterium is only rare in comparison to protium, the other isotype of hydrogen. It is literally one of the most abundant things in the physical universe. The later episode ''The Void'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void. Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics:
**
ArtisticLicensePhysics: Deuterium is only rare in comparison to protium, the other isotype of hydrogen. It is literally one of the most abundant things in the physical universe. The later episode ''The Void'' actually made a crack about this before they find out it's ''actually rare'' in the titular void. Additionally, it can only exist as a liquid at extremely low temperatures or very high pressures.pressures.
* AsYouKnow: Tuvok reminds Janeway that landing the ship would require a large amount of energy.



* InsaneTrollLogic: While Tom and Harry are trapped on the planet and they can't wait for them too long, as the ship is slowly running out of energy and just staying in orbit of the planet is dangerous, Chakotay suggest taking a shuttle and go look for them. Janeway dismisses this as too dangerous-so she decides to land the whole ship on the planet, which will take big amount of energy and the ship might not even survive landing due to its weakened shields.

to:

* InsaneTrollLogic: While Tom and Harry are trapped on the planet and they can't wait for them too long, as the ship is slowly running out of energy and just staying in orbit of the planet is dangerous, Chakotay suggest taking a shuttle and go look for them. Janeway dismisses this as too dangerous-so dangerous -- so she decides to land the whole ship on the planet, which will take a big amount of energy and the ship might not even survive landing due to its weakened shields.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExtremophileLifeforms: he Silver Blood, a deuterium-based race encountered on a Class Y planet. The episode takes its name from the fact that Class Y planets are sometimes termed "demon" worlds because they're basically FireAndBrimstoneHell (start with temperatures averaging 500 Kelvin and go downhill from there).

to:

* ExtremophileLifeforms: he The Silver Blood, a deuterium-based race encountered on a Class Y planet. The episode takes its name from the fact that Class Y planets are sometimes termed "demon" worlds because they're basically FireAndBrimstoneHell (start with temperatures averaging 500 Kelvin and go downhill from there).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ExtremophileLifeforms: he Silver Blood, a deuterium-based race encountered on a Class Y planet. The episode takes its name from the fact that Class Y planets are sometimes termed "demon" worlds because they're basically FireAndBrimstoneHell (start with temperatures averaging 500 Kelvin and go downhill from there).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
But it's Space Polyester


** The "demon planet" is mentioned to have temperatures of 500 Kelvin, which is just shy of the melting point for tin. Yet, the soft polyester interior of the shuttle is exposed to such an environment through an open hatch and is completely fine.

Top