Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / BabylonFiveS03E10SeveredDreams

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamEpisode: The station and other colonies break away from earth. Delenn faces down--and breaks--the Grey Council.

to:

* WhamEpisode: The station and other President Clark orders Mars bombed for refusing to enact martial law, resulting in multiple colonies break and outposts, Babylon 5 included, breaking away from earth.the Earth Alliance. Delenn faces down--and breaks--the Grey Council.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Hiroshi''': Too late to get out. Our primary systems are hit, we've got fire on all decks. There's nothing we can do now except... ''[comms cut out]''\\

to:

'''Hiroshi''': Too late to get out. Our primary systems are hit, we've got fire on all decks. decks now. There's nothing we can do now except... ''[comms cut out]''\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TakingYouWithMe: With the ''Churchill'' badly damaged, Hiroshi chooses to ram another destroyer to even the losses.
-->'''Ryan''': Hiroshi! Get out of there! Get to the life pods!\\
'''Hiroshi''': Too late to get out. Our primary systems are hit, we've got fire on all decks. There's nothing we can do now except... ''[comms cut out]''\\
'''Ryan''': Hiroshi?! ''Hiroshi!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LeeroyJenkins: The Narns on Garibaldi's defense force rush ahead him and straight into enemy fire, getting a lot of them killed in the process. This did have the (probably unintended) effect of forcing the boarders to engage in a pitched battle pretty much straight out of the breach pod, containing them away from civilian areas and the command deck.

to:

* LeeroyJenkins: The Narns on Garibaldi's defense force rush ahead of him and straight into enemy fire, getting a lot of them killed in the process. This did have the (probably unintended) effect of forcing the boarders to engage in a pitched battle pretty much straight out of the breach pod, containing them away from civilian areas and the command deck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigBadassBattleSequence: The fight between the Earthforce attackers and B5's forces takes up almost a third of the episode and includes what is, by general consensus, the greatest SugarWiki/MomentOfAwesome in the entire series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LeeroyJenkins: The Narns on Garibaldi's defense force rush ahead him and straight into enemy fire, getting a lot of them killed in the process.

to:

* LeeroyJenkins: The Narns on Garibaldi's defense force rush ahead him and straight into enemy fire, getting a lot of them killed in the process. This did have the (probably unintended) effect of forcing the boarders to engage in a pitched battle pretty much straight out of the breach pod, containing them away from civilian areas and the command deck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KilledOffScreen: The Agrippa/Roanoke wave of the attack had two Midwinter-class Heavy Cruisers with them, but we never saw them fight. They were apparently destroyed offscreen, possibly by the EAS Churchill. See WhatHappenedToTheMouse below.

to:

* KilledOffScreen: The Agrippa/Roanoke wave of the attack had two Midwinter-class Heavy Cruisers with them, but we never saw them fight. They were apparently destroyed offscreen, possibly by the EAS Churchill.''Churchill''. See WhatHappenedToTheMouse below.



* MeaningfulName: The EAS Roanoke is named after an early English colony in North Carolina that was later found to be totally deserted with no sign of the inhabitants (or of a struggle), just the word CROATAN carved into a tree.
** The Agrippa could've been named after the Roman General Marcus Vipsanius Agrippa, or, the Biblical (and historical) Herod Agrippa.
** The second wave of Earthforce ships that arrived are the Nimrod & the Olympic.
** The EAS Alexander is named after UsefulNotes/AlexanderTheGreat. The Churchill is, obviously, named after UsefulNotes/WinstonChurchill, whom Sheridan had [[{{Recap/BabylonFiveS02E16InTheShadowOfZHaDum}} referenced before]].

to:

* MeaningfulName: The EAS Roanoke ''Roanoke'' is named after an early English colony in North Carolina that was later found to be totally deserted with no sign of the inhabitants (or of a struggle), just the word CROATAN carved into a tree.
** The Agrippa ''Agrippa'' could've been named after the Roman General Marcus Vipsanius Agrippa, or, the Biblical (and historical) Herod Agrippa.
** The second wave of Earthforce ships that arrived arrive are the Nimrod & ''Nimrod'' and the Olympic.
''Olympic''.
** The EAS Alexander ''Alexander'' is named after UsefulNotes/AlexanderTheGreat. The Churchill ''Churchill'' is, obviously, named after UsefulNotes/WinstonChurchill, whom Sheridan had has [[{{Recap/BabylonFiveS02E16InTheShadowOfZHaDum}} referenced before]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Similarly, two of the four Earthforce ships that arrive with the first wave to attack B5 simply disappear after their first appearance. WordOfGod is that they were destroyed in the fighting; this was filmed, but cut from the final episode for time.

to:

** Similarly, two of the four Earthforce ships that arrive with the first wave to attack B5 simply disappear after their first appearance. WordOfGod is that they were destroyed in the fighting; this was filmed, but cut from the final episode for time.[[invoked]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A single {{Bridge Bunny}} leaves the deck when Sheridan gives permission for anyone to do so before the battle, in a deliberate subversion of the typical scene where everyone shows {{Undying Loyalty}} at such an order. [[WordOfGod JMS later said]] that was a deliberate choice on his part, to show that even on the station not everyone believed in what Sheridan was doing.

to:

** A single {{Bridge Bunny}} leaves the deck when Sheridan gives permission for anyone to do so before the battle, in a deliberate subversion of the typical scene where everyone shows {{Undying Loyalty}} at such an order. [[WordOfGod JMS later said]] that was a deliberate choice on his part, to show that even on the station not everyone believed in what Sheridan was doing.[[invoked]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeadInTheSandManagement: Delenn accuses the Council of this, standing by as the Shadows' influence grew. It's true that Delenn had been doing the same, but she had been quietly making preparations. The Council had outright stated that they were doing nothing, as they believed it wasn't really happening.

to:

* HeadInTheSandManagement: Delenn accuses the Council of this, standing by as the Shadows' influence grew. It's true that Delenn had been doing the same, but she had been quietly making preparations. The Council had outright stated that they were doing nothing, as they believed it wasn't were in denial that the return of the Shadows was really happening.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForgottenSuperweapon: Ivanova and Sheridan debate asking for Draal's help. Sheridan wants to keep Draal a secret and wants the fight to be "clean" - Earthforce vs Earthforce. When the second wave of Earth ships arrives, it seems to be implied that Sheridan would give up. WordOfGod from JMS is that Sheridan didn't want to give Clarke the excuse to try again and de-legitimize B5 in the eyes of the Earthforce rank and file. President Clark has the Shadows as allies and they would ambush the station later in the series.

to:

* ForgottenSuperweapon: Ivanova and Sheridan debate asking for Draal's help. Sheridan wants to keep Draal a secret and wants the fight to be "clean" - Earthforce vs Earthforce. When the second wave of Earth ships arrives, it seems to be implied that Sheridan would give up. WordOfGod from JMS is that Sheridan didn't want to give Clarke the excuse to try again and de-legitimize B5 in the eyes of the Earthforce rank and file. President Clark has the Shadows as allies and they would ambush the station later in the series. [[invoked]]



* HeadInTheSandManagement: Delenn accuses the Council this, standing by as the Shadows' influence grew. It's true that Delenn had been doing the same, but she had been quietly making preparations. The Council had outright stated that they were doing nothing, as they believed it wasn't really happening.

to:

* HeadInTheSandManagement: Delenn accuses the Council of this, standing by as the Shadows' influence grew. It's true that Delenn had been doing the same, but she had been quietly making preparations. The Council had outright stated that they were doing nothing, as they believed it wasn't really happening.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SymbolicallyBrokenObject: When Delenn dissolves the Grey Counsel, she also breaks the staff traditionally held by the leader of the Grey Counsel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: The second of Delenn's trip of blisteringly awesome speeches this episode, comprehensively dressing down the Gray Council for its indolence.

to:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: The second of Delenn's trip trio of blisteringly awesome speeches this episode, comprehensively dressing down the Gray Council for its indolence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: The second of Delenn's trip of blisteringly awesome speeches this episode, comprehensively dressing down the Gray Council for its indolence.
-->'''Delenn''': Three years. For three years I warned you this day was coming, but you would not listen. "Pride," you said, "presumption." And now the Shadows are on the move! The Centauri and the younger worlds are at war, the Narns have fallen, even the Humans are fighting one another. The pride was yours, the presumption was yours. For a thousand years, we have been awaiting the fulfillment of prophecy. And when it finally happens, you scorn it, you reject it because you no longer believe it yourselves. "We stand between the candle and the star, between the darkness and the light." You say the words but your hearts are empty, your ears closed to the truth. You stand for nothing but your own petty interests. "The problems of others are not our concern." I do not blame you for standing silent in your shame. You, who knew what was coming, but refused to take up the burden of this war. If the warrior caste will not fight, then the rest of us will. The council has lost its way. If it will not lead, if we have abandoned our covenant with Valen— ''[grabs the council staff]''— then the council ''should be '''broken'''''—''[breaks staff]''—as was prophesied! We must stand with the others now before it's too late. Between the worker caste and the religious caste, we control two thirds of our forces. To you, I say, listen to the voice of your conscience. Break the council and come with me. Our time of isolation is over. We move now, together, or not at all!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Afterwards, Ryan and Sheridan are discussing their situation, specifically, their pilots. Many of the ''Churchill's'' fighters are homeless, and Ryan asks Sheridan to take them on. He is going to leave, to split Earthforce's attention, and to look for any other rebel ships. Sheridan goes to meet with Delenn, finding Garibaldi seeing the Nightwatch members off station, the ones they know about, at least. They'll have to be on guard for sabotage for a while.

to:

Afterwards, Ryan and Sheridan are discussing their situation, specifically, their pilots. Many Sheridan says that about thirty percent of the ''Churchill's'' station's fighters were damaged or destroyed in the battle and it's not likely they'll be getting replacements anytime soon. Ryan states that the surviving ''Churchill'' fighters are homeless, and Ryan asks suggests Sheridan to take them on. He on and bring the station's fighter complement up to full strength. Sheridan said that while he didn't know Captain Hiroshi very well, he would be honored to give her pilots a new home. Ryan, meanwhile, is going to leave, to split Earthforce's attention, and to look for any other rebel ships. Sheridan goes to meet with Delenn, finding Garibaldi seeing the Nightwatch members off station, the ones they know about, at least. They'll have to be on guard for sabotage for a while.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A single {{Bridge Bunny}} leaves the deck when Sheridan gives permission for anyone to do so before the battle, in a deliberate subversion of the typical scene where everyone shows {{Undying Loyalty}} at such an order.

to:

** A single {{Bridge Bunny}} leaves the deck when Sheridan gives permission for anyone to do so before the battle, in a deliberate subversion of the typical scene where everyone shows {{Undying Loyalty}} at such an order. [[WordOfGod JMS later said]] that was a deliberate choice on his part, to show that even on the station not everyone believed in what Sheridan was doing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: Nightwatch's presence aboard the station in the aftermath of the attack. As Garibaldi grimly notes to Sheridan, they're shipping out everybody they detained in the previous episode. But, as this ''is'' Nightwatch, there are almost certainly more operatives or loyalists onboard the B5 team didn't know about or missed. So, Sheridan and Garibaldi both grimly anticipate acts of sabotage in the coming days and weeks (which leads into the next episode).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlayingBothSides: The Minbari that Delenn brings to Medlab confirms that the League worlds are being encouraged by the Shadows to be aggressive towards each other, in addition to using the Centauri.

to:

* PlayingBothSides: The Minbari that Ranger whom Delenn brings to Medlab confirms that the League worlds are being encouraged by the Shadows to be aggressive towards each other, in addition to using the Centauri.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlayingBothSides: The Minbari that Delenn brings to Medlab confirms that the League worlds are being encouraged by the Shadows to also be aggressive, using the Centauri (whom the Shadows also support) as [[EvilerThanThou the enemy]].

to:

* PlayingBothSides: The Minbari that Delenn brings to Medlab confirms that the League worlds are being encouraged by the Shadows to also be aggressive, aggressive towards each other, in addition to using the Centauri (whom the Shadows also support) as [[EvilerThanThou the enemy]].Centauri.

Changed: 264

Removed: 246

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForgottenSuperweapon: Ivanova and Sheridan debate asking for Draal's help. Sheridan wants to keep Draal a secret and wants the fight to be "clean" - Earthforce vs Earthforce. When the second wave of Earth ships arrives, it seems to be implied that Sheridan would give up.
** WordOfGod from JMS - Sheridan didn't want to give Clarke the excuse to try again and de-legitimize B5 in the eyes of the Earthforce rank and file. President Clark has the Shadows as allies and they would ambush the station later in the series.

to:

* ForgottenSuperweapon: Ivanova and Sheridan debate asking for Draal's help. Sheridan wants to keep Draal a secret and wants the fight to be "clean" - Earthforce vs Earthforce. When the second wave of Earth ships arrives, it seems to be implied that Sheridan would give up.
**
up. WordOfGod from JMS - is that Sheridan didn't want to give Clarke the excuse to try again and de-legitimize B5 in the eyes of the Earthforce rank and file. President Clark has the Shadows as allies and they would ambush the station later in the series.



* HilariousOuttakes: The gag reel for this episode includes a bit referencing Creator/RobertFoxworth getting double-booked to play Admiral Leyton in the "Homefront"/"Paradise Lost" two-parter on B5's rival show ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine''. Asked where Hague is, Bruce [=McGill=] (Major Ryan) responds completely deadpan:

to:

* HilariousOuttakes: The gag reel for this episode includes a bit referencing Creator/RobertFoxworth getting double-booked to play Admiral Leyton in the "Homefront"/"Paradise Lost" two-parter on B5's rival show ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine''. Asked where Hague is, Bruce [=McGill=] Creator/BruceMcGill (Major Ryan) responds completely deadpan:

Changed: 107

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[DefiedTrope Slightly defied]], as the female ISN anchor is seen in Season Four back at her old job.

to:

** [[DefiedTrope Slightly defied]], as the female ISN anchor Jane is seen in near the end of Season Four back at to have survived, albeit harrowed by her old job.experiences in one of Clark's prisons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Major Ryan meets with Sheridan and gives them a rundown of the situation, and it's not good. General Hague is dead, killed in the fight with the ''Clarkestown'', and public opinion is actually in favor of martial law, since it actually seems to be a benefit, and ISN can't say too much or they'll be shut down. The only hope is Mars' refusal of the order. Sheridan doesn't think Clark will be able to do much about it, but soon after a message comes that Earth Force is bombing Mars.

to:

Major Ryan meets with Sheridan and gives them a rundown of the situation, and it's not good. General Hague is dead, killed in the fight with the ''Clarkestown'', and public opinion is actually in favor of martial law, since it actually seems to be a benefit, and ISN can't say too much or they'll be shut down. The only hope is Mars' refusal of the order. Sheridan doesn't think Clark will be able to do much about it, but soon after a message comes that Earth Force Earthforce is bombing Mars.



Afterwards, Ryan and Sheridan are discussing their situation, specifically, their pilots. Many of the ''Churchill's'' fighters are homeless, and Ryan asks Sheridan to take them on. He is going to leave, to split Earth Force's attention, and to look for any other rebel ships. Sheridan goes to meet with Delenn, finding Garibaldi seeing the Nightwatch members off station, the ones they know about, at least. They'll have to be on guard for sabotage for a while.

to:

Afterwards, Ryan and Sheridan are discussing their situation, specifically, their pilots. Many of the ''Churchill's'' fighters are homeless, and Ryan asks Sheridan to take them on. He is going to leave, to split Earth Force's Earthforce's attention, and to look for any other rebel ships. Sheridan goes to meet with Delenn, finding Garibaldi seeing the Nightwatch members off station, the ones they know about, at least. They'll have to be on guard for sabotage for a while.



* ForgottenSuperweapon: Ivanova and Sherridan debate asking for Draal's help. Sherridan wants to keep Draal a secret and wants the fight to be "clean" - Earthforce vs Earthforce. When the second wave of Earth ships arrives, it seems to be implied that Sheridan would give up.
** WordOfGod from JMS - Sherridan didn't want to give Clarke the excuse to try again and de-legitimize B5 in the eyes of the Earth Force rank and file. President Clark has the Shadows as allies and they would ambush the station later in the series.

to:

* ForgottenSuperweapon: Ivanova and Sherridan Sheridan debate asking for Draal's help. Sherridan Sheridan wants to keep Draal a secret and wants the fight to be "clean" - Earthforce vs Earthforce. When the second wave of Earth ships arrives, it seems to be implied that Sheridan would give up.
** WordOfGod from JMS - Sherridan Sheridan didn't want to give Clarke the excuse to try again and de-legitimize B5 in the eyes of the Earth Force Earthforce rank and file. President Clark has the Shadows as allies and they would ambush the station later in the series.



* TemptingFate: Corwin after the two opposing Earth Force destroyers are destroyed.

to:

* TemptingFate: Corwin after the two opposing Earth Force Earthforce destroyers are destroyed.



''[Cue second wave of Earth Force destroyers.]''
* VertigoEffect: One on Sheridan right after Hiroshi informs him that Earth Force is coming to seize control of the station.

to:

''[Cue second wave of Earth Force Earthforce destroyers.]''
* VertigoEffect: One on Sheridan right after Hiroshi informs him that Earth Force Earthforce is coming to seize control of the station.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Since none of the Narns give a reason for why they charged ahead, this is pure speculation.


* HonorBeforeReason: [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation The Narns' desire to defend their new home, honor the trust shown in them by B5 Command Staff and repay them for giving them a place to live may be]] [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation the]] '''''primary''''' [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation reason why they charged forward, instead of waiting for the bad guys to come for them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rick's fate is never revealed.

to:

** Rick's fate is never revealed.revealed, although when Jane reappears later, she mentions than many of those imprisoned by Clark were tortured and killed, so it doesn't look too good for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HilariousOuttakes: The gag reel for this episode includes a bit referencing Creator/RobertFoxworth getting double-booked to play Admiral Leyton in the "Homefront"/"Paradise Lost" two-parter on B5's rival show ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine''. Asked where Hague is, Bruce [=McGill=] (Major Ryan) responds completely deadpan:
-->"General Hague is doing ''Deep Space Nine''. ''(everyone on set cracks up)'' It seems he was double-booked by his agent, there was nothing to be done. You'll have to deal with me, sir."

Removed: 526

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Read the trope description


* BerserkButton: Both Sheridan's and Delenn's are pressed in this episode.
** Delenn's is hit when she hears that the Grey Council refuses to take a stand, saying "the problems of others are not our concern." Delenn... [[{{Understatement}} takes exception to this]]. It's a good thing Minbari aren't supposed to kill other Minbari, because her facial expression when she's told that this was their response is positively ''murderous''.
** Sheridan's is visibly hit when Clark starts bombing Mars, which has rejected martial law.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Which would be why they used the jump gate to arrive. Jump engines take time to charge up, using a local jump gate means you have fully charged jump engines in case you need to beat a hasty retreat. . . and three Minbari warcruisers and an unidentified ship commanded by a righteously pissed Minbari is a very good reason to decide to be somewhere else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To the Clark-loyalist fleet:
-->"Only one Human captain has survived battle with a Minbari fleet. ''He'' is behind me. ''You'' are in front of me. If you value your lives, '''''be somewhere else.'''''"

to:

** To the Clark-loyalist fleet:
-->"Only
fleet, upon being told not to "force them" to engage her:
-->"[[BringIt Why not?]] Only
one Human captain has survived battle with a Minbari fleet. ''He'' is behind me. ''You'' are in front of me. If you value your lives, '''''be somewhere else.'''''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Merged w Deadline News


* IntrepidReporter: Rick from ISN. Doubles as a RedShirtReporter. [[ItHasBeenAnHonor Knowing that ISN]] is about to be shutdown, he interrupts a live news cast [[IDieFree to expose]] (as much as he can) what Clark's regime has been keeping underwraps for the past year. He is clearly afraid, but pushes through anyway. We never see him again, sadly, suggesting that [[HeroicSacrifice he might not have survived this]].

to:

* IntrepidReporter: Rick from ISN. Doubles as a RedShirtReporter. [[ItHasBeenAnHonor Knowing that ISN]] is about to be shutdown, he interrupts a live news cast [[IDieFree to expose]] (as much as he can) what Clark's regime has been keeping underwraps for the past year. He is clearly afraid, but pushes through anyway. We never see him again, sadly, suggesting that [[HeroicSacrifice he might not have survived this]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Fighting is fierce and losses are heavy on both sides. Garibaldi goes to repel a boarding crew, but the Narns [[LeeroyJenkins rush ahead]] of him and get caught in a killing zone. The ''Churchill'' takes catastrophic damage and rams an enemy destroyer, [[RammingAlwaysWorks destroying both ships]]. Ivanova collides with another fighter and is forced to eject, while the boarding action has devolved into a giant brawl in close quarters. Finally the last enemy ship is destroyed, but almost immediately a new wave arrives. Then a set of jump points form right next to the station, but it's three Minbari warcruisers, and the ''White Star''. Delenn declares that Babylon 5 is under her protection, and when the loyalists try to protest, she practically dares them to try something. The attack fleet leaves rather than engage Minbari ships.

to:

Fighting is fierce and losses are heavy on both sides. Garibaldi goes to repel a boarding crew, but the Narns [[LeeroyJenkins rush ahead]] of him and get caught in a killing zone. The ''Churchill'' takes catastrophic damage and rams an enemy destroyer, [[RammingAlwaysWorks destroying both ships]]. Ivanova collides with another fighter and is forced to eject, while the boarding action has devolved into a giant brawl in close quarters. Finally the last enemy ship is destroyed, but almost immediately a new wave arrives. Then a set of jump points form right next to the station, but it's three Minbari warcruisers, and the ''White Star''. Delenn declares that Babylon 5 is under her protection, and when the loyalists try to protest, she practically dares them to try something.something, going as far as to remind them that Babylon 5 is commanded by the only Earthforce captain who managed to defeat a Minbari fleet. The attack fleet leaves rather than engage Minbari ships.



** Said second wave gets the hell out of B5 space when they realize the fact the Minbari are protecting the only Earthforce captain who managed to defeat a Minbari warship means they're screwed.

to:

** Said second wave gets the hell out of B5 space when they realize the fact the Minbari are protecting the only Earthforce captain who managed to defeat a Minbari warship one of their warships means they're screwed.

Top