Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* As Peter Parker inherited his powers from his parents in ''Fanfic/BornOfHellsKitchen'' instead of gaining them through spider bite, he certainly can't be called a mutate in this iteration. He would be more akin to a mutant, but there's no indication of others mutants existing in the continuity so it stays ambiguous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[folder: Western Animation]]
* Jinx in the DC comics is a bald Indian woman. Jinx from the 2003 ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' cartoon (and works that reuse that design, such as ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitansGo'' and ''WebAnimation/DCSuperHeroGirls'') is [[YouDontLookLikeYou completely different looking]]. She has pale ''[[AmazingTechnicolorPopulation grey]]'' skin and pink AnimeHair. She isn't clearly identifiable as any ethnicity.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 13 (click to see context) from:
* Yang in ''Fanfic/WhiteNoise'' is explicitly at least half-Asian. In ''RWBY'' canon she looks {{Mukokuseki}} and comes from a ConstructedWorld, but she has a Chinese name.
to:
* Yang and her half-sister Ruby in ''Fanfic/WhiteNoise'' is are explicitly at least half-Asian. In ''RWBY'' canon she looks they look {{Mukokuseki}} and comes come from a ConstructedWorld, but she Yang has a Chinese name.name like her father Taiyang.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* Yang in ''Fanfic/WhiteNoise'' is explicitly at least half-Asian. In ''RWBY'' canon she looks {{Mukokuseki}} and comes from a ConstructedWorld, but she has a Chinese name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 20 (click to see context) from:
* ''ComicStrip/{{Dilbert}} has the character of Asok, the naive young work experience intern who isn't even getting paid for what he does. Asok was originally intended to be an East Asian character to lampshade his ethnicity, its reputation for diligent conscientious hard work, and how this eventually becomes corrupted by contact with Americans like Wally and the corrosive effect of working at a succession of nonsensical non-jobs for the PointyHairedBoss. Unfortunately, the monochrome nature of newspaper publication meant this subtle point was lost (Asok's face and hands do become darker in the colour reprints) and the character was taken to be a white man with an odd name.
to:
* ''ComicStrip/{{Dilbert}} ''ComicStrip/{{Dilbert}}'' has the character of Asok, the naive young work experience intern who isn't even getting paid for what he does. Asok was originally intended to be an East Asian character to lampshade his ethnicity, its reputation for diligent conscientious hard work, and how this eventually becomes corrupted by contact with Americans like Wally and the corrosive effect of working at a succession of nonsensical non-jobs for the PointyHairedBoss. Unfortunately, the monochrome nature of newspaper publication meant this subtle point was lost (Asok's face and hands do become darker in the colour reprints) and the character was taken to be a white man with an odd name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* In ''RWBY'', the {{mukokuseki}} {{animesque}} art-style and ConstructedWorld makes it impossible to pin most characters as one ethnicity or another. ''Fanfic/RWBYScars'' goes for a FantasyCounterpartCulture approach, to a degree. For example, everything about Blake, from her character design to her real name ([[spoiler:"Hozuki Blake"]]), imply she's at minimum the equivalent of half-Japanese.
Changed line(s) 14 (click to see context) from:
[[folder:Film]]
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
another damn link
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
* ''ComicStrip/{{Dilbert}} has the character of Asok, the naive young work experience intern who isn't even getting paid for what he does. Asok was originally intended to be an East Asian character to lampshade his ethnicity, its reputation for diligent conscientious hard work, and how this eventually becomes corrupted by contact woth Americans like Wally and the corrosive effect of working at a succession of nonsensical non-jobs for the PointyHeadedBoss. Unfortunately, the monochrome nature of newspaper publication meant this subtle point was lost (Asok's face and hands do become darker in the colour reprints) and the character was taken to be a white man with an odd name.
to:
* ''ComicStrip/{{Dilbert}} has the character of Asok, the naive young work experience intern who isn't even getting paid for what he does. Asok was originally intended to be an East Asian character to lampshade his ethnicity, its reputation for diligent conscientious hard work, and how this eventually becomes corrupted by contact woth with Americans like Wally and the corrosive effect of working at a succession of nonsensical non-jobs for the PointyHeadedBoss.PointyHairedBoss. Unfortunately, the monochrome nature of newspaper publication meant this subtle point was lost (Asok's face and hands do become darker in the colour reprints) and the character was taken to be a white man with an odd name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
damn link
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
* ''NewspaperComic/{{Dilbert}}has the character of Asok, the naive young work experience intern who isn't even getting paid for what he does. Asok was originally intended to be an East Asian character to lampshade his ethnicity, its reputation for diligent conscientious hard work, and how this eventually becomes corrupted by contact woth Americans like Wally and the corrosive effect of working at a succession of nonsensical non-jobs for the PointyHeadedBoss. Unfortunately, the monochrome nature of newspaper publication meant this subtle point was lost (Asok's face and hands do become darker in the colour reprints) and the character was taken to be a white man with an odd name.
to:
* ''NewspaperComic/{{Dilbert}}has ''ComicStrip/{{Dilbert}} has the character of Asok, the naive young work experience intern who isn't even getting paid for what he does. Asok was originally intended to be an East Asian character to lampshade his ethnicity, its reputation for diligent conscientious hard work, and how this eventually becomes corrupted by contact woth Americans like Wally and the corrosive effect of working at a succession of nonsensical non-jobs for the PointyHeadedBoss. Unfortunately, the monochrome nature of newspaper publication meant this subtle point was lost (Asok's face and hands do become darker in the colour reprints) and the character was taken to be a white man with an odd name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dilbert's inadvertent race lift
Added DiffLines:
[[folder: Newspaper Comics]]
* ''NewspaperComic/{{Dilbert}}has the character of Asok, the naive young work experience intern who isn't even getting paid for what he does. Asok was originally intended to be an East Asian character to lampshade his ethnicity, its reputation for diligent conscientious hard work, and how this eventually becomes corrupted by contact woth Americans like Wally and the corrosive effect of working at a succession of nonsensical non-jobs for the PointyHeadedBoss. Unfortunately, the monochrome nature of newspaper publication meant this subtle point was lost (Asok's face and hands do become darker in the colour reprints) and the character was taken to be a white man with an odd name.
[[/folder]]
* ''NewspaperComic/{{Dilbert}}has the character of Asok, the naive young work experience intern who isn't even getting paid for what he does. Asok was originally intended to be an East Asian character to lampshade his ethnicity, its reputation for diligent conscientious hard work, and how this eventually becomes corrupted by contact woth Americans like Wally and the corrosive effect of working at a succession of nonsensical non-jobs for the PointyHeadedBoss. Unfortunately, the monochrome nature of newspaper publication meant this subtle point was lost (Asok's face and hands do become darker in the colour reprints) and the character was taken to be a white man with an odd name.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5,8 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In the 2006 ''ComicBook/XFactor'' series, she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white]], and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with darker complexion that ranged from light tan to darker tan & brown. During this period, she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation & how artists depict her facial features. WordOfGod said many fans complained early on, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden when she wasn't in Generation X, and PAD had her darkened later in the series as a result, though not still without complaints. In 2015 ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]] in the respective runs. But the flip-flopping started again in Pak's ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Many times, she was depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/dbObZql.png black]] with a noticeable brown complexion that contrasted the other characters. But just as often, she was depicted looking [[https://i.imgur.com/JjdFLhG.png white]] with little to no difference between her and Sabretooth or Deathstrike. Whether this is a race-change, or the colorist lightening her skin as a result of light source is questionable. Post-Weapon X she had two cameo appearances in ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2018'' and ''X-Men Black: Mojo'' where she is [[https://i.imgur.com/8LRpb99.png darker than she's been depicted since Generation X.]] Her next major appearance will be in ''ComicBook/JonathanHickmansXMen''. She's been shown on two covers for '''House of X'''. The [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1276927/1276927_900.jpg first cover she appeared]] has a yellow light shining over the cast, so a read on her complexion is difficult. However, [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1282158/1282158_900.jpg the following issue's cover]] shows her with a clear brown complexion that contrasts her white teammates. The Cover artist & colorist will also be doing the book's interiors. Thus far, it appears she isn't white this time around, but whether it will stay consistent from here out remains to be seen. Hickman has plans for the X-Franchise that he says will last some years to come. He also listed Monet as one of his top five favorite mutants, being a fan of her since her Generation X days. As a result, he may demand that her coloring stay brown like it started, or it could continue to fluctuate.
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple of times, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. David Yardin, who did many of the X-Factor covers, would always depict her as black. In 2018, he made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
*** Even her family names change. Her mother's name has been Mere & Jamila.
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate [[Characters/GenerationX Jubilee]] has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple of times, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. David Yardin, who did many of the X-Factor covers, would always depict her as black. In 2018, he made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
*** Even her family names change. Her mother's name has been Mere & Jamila.
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate [[Characters/GenerationX Jubilee]] has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
to:
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple of times, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. David Yardin, who did many of the X-Factor covers, would always depict her as black. In 2018, he made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
*** Even her family names change. Her mother's name has been Mere & Jamila.
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate [[Characters/GenerationX
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In the 2006 ''ComicBook/XFactor'' series, she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white]], and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with darker complexion that ranged from light tan to darker tan & brown. During this period, she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation & how artists depict her facial features. WordOfGod said many fans complained early on, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden when she wasn't in Generation X, and PAD had her darkened later in the series as a result, though not still without complaints. In 2015 ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]] in the respective runs. But the flip-flopping started again in Pak's ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Many times, she was depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/dbObZql.png black]] with a noticeable brown complexion that contrasted the other characters. But just as often, she was depicted looking [[https://i.imgur.com/JjdFLhG.png white]] with little to no difference between her and Sabretooth or Deathstrike. Whether this is a race-change, or the colorist lightening her skin as a result of light source is questionable. Post-Weapon X she had two cameo appearances in ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2018'' and ''X-Men Black: Mojo'' where she is [[https://i.imgur.com/8LRpb99.png darker]] than she's been depicted since Generation X. Her next major appearance will be in ''ComicBook/JonathanHickmansXMen''. She's been shown on two covers for '''House of X'''. The [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1276927/1276927_900.jpg first cover she appeared]] has a yellow light shining over the cast, so a read on her complexion is difficult. However, [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1282158/1282158_900.jpg the following issue's cover]] shows her with a clear brown complexion that contrasts her white teammates. The Cover artist & colorist will also be doing the book's interiors. Thus far, it appears she isn't white this time around, but whether it will stay consistent from here out remains to be seen. Hickman has plans for the X-Franchise that he says will last some years to come. He also listed Monet as one of his top five favorite mutants, being a fan of her since her Generation X days. As a result, he may demand that her coloring stay brown like it started, or it could continue to fluctuate.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In the 2006 ''ComicBook/XFactor'' series, she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white]], and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with darker complexion that ranged from light tan to darker tan & brown. During this period, she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation & how artists depict her facial features. WordOfGod said many fans complained early on, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden when she wasn't in Generation X, and PAD had her darkened later in the series as a result, though not still without complaints. In 2015 ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]] in the respective runs. But the flip-flopping started again in Pak's ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Many times, she was depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/dbObZql.png black]] with a noticeable brown complexion that contrasted the other characters. But just as often, she was depicted looking [[https://i.imgur.com/JjdFLhG.png white]] with little to no difference between her and Sabretooth or Deathstrike. Whether this is a race-change, or the colorist lightening her skin as a result of light source is questionable. Post-Weapon X she had two cameo appearances in ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2018'' and ''X-Men Black: Mojo'' where she is [[https://i.imgur.com/8LRpb99.png darker]] darker than she's been depicted since Generation X. X.]] Her next major appearance will be in ''ComicBook/JonathanHickmansXMen''. She's been shown on two covers for '''House of X'''. The [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1276927/1276927_900.jpg first cover she appeared]] has a yellow light shining over the cast, so a read on her complexion is difficult. However, [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1282158/1282158_900.jpg the following issue's cover]] shows her with a clear brown complexion that contrasts her white teammates. The Cover artist & colorist will also be doing the book's interiors. Thus far, it appears she isn't white this time around, but whether it will stay consistent from here out remains to be seen. Hickman has plans for the X-Franchise that he says will last some years to come. He also listed Monet as one of his top five favorite mutants, being a fan of her since her Generation X days. As a result, he may demand that her coloring stay brown like it started, or it could continue to fluctuate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5,6 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In the 2006 ''ComicBook/XFactor'' series, she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white]], and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with darker complexion that ranged from light tan to darker tan & brown. During this period, she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation & how artists depict her facial features. WordOfGod said many fans complained early on, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden when she wasn't in Generation X, and PAD had her darkened later in the series as a result, though not still without complaints. In 2015 ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]] in the respective runs. But the flip-flopping started again in Pak's ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Many times, she was depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/dbObZql.png black]] with a noticeable brown complexion that contrasted the other characters. But just as often, she was depicted looking [[https://i.imgur.com/JjdFLhG.png white]] with little to no difference between her, Mentallo, Sabretooth or Deathstrike. Whether this is a race-change, or the colorist lightening her skin as a result of light source is questionable. Post-Weapon X she had two cameo appearances in ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2018'' and '''X-Men Black: Mojo''' where she is [[https://i.imgur.com/8LRpb99.png darker than she's been depicted since Generation X. Her next major appearance will be in ''ComicBook/JonathanHickmansXMen''. She's been shown on two covers for '''House of X'''. The [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1276927/1276927_900.jpg first cover she appeared]] has a yellow light shining over the cast, so a read on her complexion is difficult. However, [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1282158/1282158_900.jpg the following issue's cover]] shows her with a clear brown complexion that contrasts her white teammates. The Cover artist & colorist will also be doing the book's interiors. Thus far, it appears she isn't white this time around, but whether it will stay consistent from here out remains to be seen. Hickman has plans for the X-Franchise that he says will last some years to come. He also listed Monet as one of his top five favorite mutants, being a fan of her since her Generation X days. As a result, he may demand that her coloring stay brown like it started, or it could continue to fluctuate.
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple of times, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. CDavid Yardin, who did many of the X-Factor covers, would always depict her as black. In 2018, he made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple of times, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. CDavid Yardin, who did many of the X-Factor covers, would always depict her as black. In 2018, he made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In the 2006 ''ComicBook/XFactor'' series, she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white]], and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with darker complexion that ranged from light tan to darker tan & brown. During this period, she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation & how artists depict her facial features. WordOfGod said many fans complained early on, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden when she wasn't in Generation X, and PAD had her darkened later in the series as a result, though not still without complaints. In 2015 ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]] in the respective runs. But the flip-flopping started again in Pak's ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Many times, she was depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/dbObZql.png black]] with a noticeable brown complexion that contrasted the other characters. But just as often, she was depicted looking [[https://i.imgur.com/JjdFLhG.png white]] with little to no difference between her, Mentallo, her and Sabretooth or Deathstrike. Whether this is a race-change, or the colorist lightening her skin as a result of light source is questionable. Post-Weapon X she had two cameo appearances in ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2018'' and '''X-Men ''X-Men Black: Mojo''' Mojo'' where she is [[https://i.imgur.com/8LRpb99.png darker darker]] than she's been depicted since Generation X. Her next major appearance will be in ''ComicBook/JonathanHickmansXMen''. She's been shown on two covers for '''House of X'''. The [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1276927/1276927_900.jpg first cover she appeared]] has a yellow light shining over the cast, so a read on her complexion is difficult. However, [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1282158/1282158_900.jpg the following issue's cover]] shows her with a clear brown complexion that contrasts her white teammates. The Cover artist & colorist will also be doing the book's interiors. Thus far, it appears she isn't white this time around, but whether it will stay consistent from here out remains to be seen. Hickman has plans for the X-Franchise that he says will last some years to come. He also listed Monet as one of his top five favorite mutants, being a fan of her since her Generation X days. As a result, he may demand that her coloring stay brown like it started, or it could continue to fluctuate.
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple of times, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another.CDavid David Yardin, who did many of the X-Factor covers, would always depict her as black. In 2018, he made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple of times, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In the 2006 ''ComicBook/XFactor'' series, she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white]], and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with darker complexion that ranged from light tan to darker tan & brown. During this period, she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation & how artists depict her facial features. WordOfGod said many fans complained early on, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden when she wasn't in GenX, and PAD had her darkened later in the series as a result, though not still without complaints. In 2015 ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]] in the respective runs. But the flip-flopping started again in Pak's ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017]]. Many times, was depicted as [[ black with a noticeable brown complexion]], contrasting the other characters. But just as often, she was depicted looking [[https://i.imgur.com/JjdFLhG.png white]] where there seemed to be [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1260064/1260064_900.jpg little to no difference between her & Sabretooth or Deathstrike]]. Whether this is a race-change, or the colorists lightening her skin as a result of different light sources is questionable. When the series ended, she had two cameo appearances in ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2018'' and the X-Men Black: Mojo one-shot where she is darker than she's been depicted since GenX. Her next major appearance will be in ''ComicBook/JonathanHickmansXMen''. She's been shown on two covers for '''House of X'''. The [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1276927/1276927_900.jpg first cover she appeared]] has a yellow light shining over the cast, so a read on her complexion is difficult. However, [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1282158/1282158_900.jpg the following issue's cover]] shows her with a clear brown complexion that contrasts her white teammates. The Cover artist & colorist will also be doing the book's interiors. Thus far, it appears she isn't white this time around, but whether it will stay consistent from here out remains to be seen. Hickman has plans for the X-Franchise that he says will last some years to come. He also listed Monet as one of his top five favorite mutants, being a fan of her since her GenX days. As a result, he may demand that her coloring stay brown like it started, or it could continue to fluctuate.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In the 2006 ''ComicBook/XFactor'' series, she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white]], and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with darker complexion that ranged from light tan to darker tan & brown. During this period, she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation & how artists depict her facial features. WordOfGod said many fans complained early on, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden when she wasn't in GenX, Generation X, and PAD had her darkened later in the series as a result, though not still without complaints. In 2015 ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]] in the respective runs. But the flip-flopping started again in Pak's ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017]]. ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Many times, she was depicted as [[ black [[https://i.imgur.com/dbObZql.png black]] with a noticeable brown complexion]], contrasting complexion that contrasted the other characters. But just as often, she was depicted looking [[https://i.imgur.com/JjdFLhG.png white]] where there seemed to be [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1260064/1260064_900.jpg with little to no difference between her & her, Mentallo, Sabretooth or Deathstrike]]. Deathstrike. Whether this is a race-change, or the colorists colorist lightening her skin as a result of different light sources source is questionable. When the series ended, Post-Weapon X she had two cameo appearances in ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2018'' and the X-Men '''X-Men Black: Mojo one-shot Mojo''' where she is [[https://i.imgur.com/8LRpb99.png darker than she's been depicted since GenX.Generation X. Her next major appearance will be in ''ComicBook/JonathanHickmansXMen''. She's been shown on two covers for '''House of X'''. The [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1276927/1276927_900.jpg first cover she appeared]] has a yellow light shining over the cast, so a read on her complexion is difficult. However, [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1282158/1282158_900.jpg the following issue's cover]] shows her with a clear brown complexion that contrasts her white teammates. The Cover artist & colorist will also be doing the book's interiors. Thus far, it appears she isn't white this time around, but whether it will stay consistent from here out remains to be seen. Hickman has plans for the X-Franchise that he says will last some years to come. He also listed Monet as one of his top five favorite mutants, being a fan of her since her GenX Generation X days. As a result, he may demand that her coloring stay brown like it started, or it could continue to fluctuate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white, and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with a darker complexion where she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range until early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/AsXdwvj clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/5U5JUfu looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. Though it didn't start in X-Factor, Monet was depicted as white for 90% of it. Eventually they made her more tan European in appearance. But during her stints of appearing more white, cover artist David Yardin would always depict her as black on the covers, and made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In ''ComicBook/XFactor'', the 2006 ''ComicBook/XFactor'' series, she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white, white]], and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with a darker complexion where that ranged from light tan to darker tan & brown. During this period, she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more [[https://i.imgur.com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation. interpretation & how artists depict her facial features. WordOfGod said many fans complained, complained early on, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly sudden when she wasn't in that range until early 2015. GenX, and PAD had her darkened later in the series as a result, though not still without complaints. In 2015 ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing black]] in the line respective runs. But the flip-flopping started again in ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared Pak's ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017]]. Many times, was depicted as [[ black most of the time, having with a [[https://imgur.com/AsXdwvj clear noticeable brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/5U5JUfu But just as often, she was depicted looking more white]]. This [[https://i.imgur.com/JjdFLhG.png white]] where there seemed to be [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1260064/1260064_900.jpg little to no difference between her & Sabretooth or Deathstrike]]. Whether this is possibly due to a race-change, or the lighting in those particular instances, rather than colorists lightening her skin as a race change. But given the track record, it's result of different light sources is questionable. When the series ended, she had two cameo appearances in ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2018'' and the X-Men Black: Mojo one-shot where she is darker than she's been depicted since GenX. Her next major appearance will be in ''ComicBook/JonathanHickmansXMen''. She's been shown on two covers for '''House of X'''. The [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1276927/1276927_900.jpg first cover she appeared]] has a yellow light shining over the cast, so a read on her complexion is difficult. However, [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1282158/1282158_900.jpg the following issue's cover]] shows her with a clear brown complexion that contrasts her white teammates. The Cover artist & colorist will also be doing the book's interiors. Thus far, it appears she isn't white this time around, but whether it will stay consistent from here out remains to be seen. Hickman has plans for the X-Franchise that he says will last some years to come. He also listed Monet as one of his top five favorite mutants, being a fan of her since her GenX days. As a result, he may demand that her coloring stay brown like it started, or it could continue to fluctuate.
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple oftimes as well, times, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. Though it didn't start in X-Factor, Monet was depicted as white for 90% CDavid Yardin, who did many of it. Eventually they made her more tan European in appearance. But during her stints of appearing more white, cover artist David Yardin the X-Factor covers, would always depict her as black on the covers, and black. In 2018, he made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].whitewashing]].
*** Even her family names change. Her mother's name has been Mere & Jamila.
** To top things off, Monet's father has race-changed a couple of
*** Even her family names change. Her mother's name has been Mere & Jamila.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range until early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/AsXdwvj clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/5U5JUfu looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. Though it didn't start in X-Factor, Monet was depicted as white for 90% of it. Eventually they made her more tan European in appearance. But during her stints of appearing more white, cover artist David Yardin would always depict her as black on the covers, and made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.com/TKWt6i8.jpg black]]. black]], sharing the skin tone range with Synch. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1258678/1258678_900.png lighter & more ambiguous appearances]], which may be case of ButNotTooBlack. In ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was officially changed to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1227809/1227809_900.png more white, and remained that way for most of the series. Toward the end, she was depicted with a darker complexion where she could appear [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg com/jFYorjU.png black]] or more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]].com/tALGauk.jpg European]], depending on your interpretation. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range until early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/AsXdwvj clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/5U5JUfu looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. Though it didn't start in X-Factor, Monet was depicted as white for 90% of it. Eventually they made her more tan European in appearance. But during her stints of appearing more white, cover artist David Yardin would always depict her as black on the covers, and made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range until early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/AsXdwvj clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/5U5JUfu looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was a white man.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range until early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/AsXdwvj clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/5U5JUfu looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was a white. Even Marvel officials on the same book have contradicted one another. Though it didn't start in X-Factor, Monet was depicted as white man.for 90% of it. Eventually they made her more tan European in appearance. But during her stints of appearing more white, cover artist David Yardin would always depict her as black on the covers, and made a [[https://twitter.com/davidyardin/status/1037524266017669120 twitter statement that he intentionally did so because she had gotten shades lighter than what she originally was, even calling out Sunspot's whitewashing]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 6 (click to see context) from:
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate [[ComicBook/GenerationX/characters Jubilee]] has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
to:
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate [[ComicBook/GenerationX/characters [[Characters/GenerationX Jubilee]] has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 6 (click to see context) from:
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate ''ComicBook/GenerationX/characters Jubilee'' has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
to:
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate ''ComicBook/GenerationX/characters Jubilee'' [[ComicBook/GenerationX/characters Jubilee]] has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 6 (click to see context) from:
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate ''ComicBook/GenerationX/characters Jubilee’’ has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
to:
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate ''ComicBook/GenerationX/characters Jubilee’’ Jubilee'' has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* Monet’s erstwhile teammate ''ComicBook/GenerationX/characters Jubilee’’ has also been through this - canonically Chinese-American but often drawn by artists who didn't get the memo. Since about the mid-nineties she has been more consistently depicted as firmly Chinese in appearance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
[[folder:Comics]]
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range until early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was a white man.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range until early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in ''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX com/AsXdwvj clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 com/5U5JUfu looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was a white man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trying to condense passage amap
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]]. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was a white man.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - until early 2015. In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] being]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. Currently, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]].''ComicBook/WeaponX2017''. Her first appearance in issue 22, she appeared black most of the time, having a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking more white]]. This is possibly due to the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the confusion. He was introduce & consistently depicted as black in major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes where he was a white man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she had a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking white]]. This is possibly due to lighting, or just more uncertainty. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the conusion. He was introduced as black & consistently depicted as such in all major appearances, but two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone In ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'' & ''ComicBook/GenerationX2017'', she went back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, Currently, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] X-Force]]. Her first appearance in issue 22. Most 22, she appeared black most of the time, she had having a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking more white]]. This is possibly due to lighting, or just more uncertainty. the lighting in those particular instances, rather than a race change. But given the track record, it's questionable. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the conusion. confusion. He was introduced as black introduce & consistently depicted as such black in all major appearances, but had two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white.where he was a white man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she had a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking white]]. This is possibly due to lighting, or just more uncertainty. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the conusion. He was introduced as black & consistently depicted as such in all major appearances, but two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, Covenant / Generation Next, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]].[[https://imgur.com/oGctnLR caramel & darker brown]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she had a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX clear brown complexion]], contrasting to the other characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking white]]. This is possibly due to lighting, or just more uncertainty. Her father has race-changed a couple of times as well, which adds to the conusion. He was introduced as black & consistently depicted as such in all major appearances, but two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing sentence structure
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she had a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX notably brown complexion, contrasting to the other characters]], and appears more light brown like her Phalanx Covenant self. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking very white]]. This is possibly due to lighting, or just more uncertainty. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black & consistently depicted as such in all major appearances, but two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she had a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX notably clear brown complexion, complexion]], contrasting to the other characters]], and appears more light brown like her Phalanx Covenant self.characters. However, some panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 looking very white]]. This is possibly due to lighting, or just more uncertainty. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. times as well, which adds to the conusion. He was introduced as black & consistently depicted as such in all major appearances, but two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family. white.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added link and shortening entry just trope fitting examples
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she had a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX notably brown complexion, contrast to the white & Asian characters]]. However, some panels, [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 she seeped over into white territory]] -possibly due to lighting, or just more uncertainty. The confusion likely from her mother being from Algeria, which, while in Africa, has a majority Arab native population, and a significant white French minority from its days as a French colony. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black, and was consistently depicted as such in all major appearances. But two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she had a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX notably brown complexion, contrast contrasting to the white & Asian characters]]. other characters]], and appears more light brown like her Phalanx Covenant self. However, some panels, panels did have her [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 she seeped over into white territory]] -possibly looking very white]]. This is possibly due to lighting, or just more uncertainty. The confusion likely from her mother being from Algeria, which, while in Africa, has a majority Arab native population, and a significant white French minority from its days as a French colony.uncertainty. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black, and was black & consistently depicted as such in all major appearances. But appearances, but two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she has a notably brown complexion when compared to Creed & Deathstrike, but some panels, she seeps over into white territory -possibly due to lighting. Or just more confusion. The confusion source likely from her mother being from Algeria, which, while in Africa, has a majority Arab native population, and a significant white French minority from its days as a French colony. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black, and was consistently depicted as such in all major appearances. But two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, she has had a [[https://imgur.com/n15R6vX notably brown complexion when compared complexion, contrast to Creed the white & Deathstrike, but Asian characters]]. However, some panels, [[https://imgur.com/pXiUWK7 she seeps seeped over into white territory territory]] -possibly due to lighting. Or lighting, or just more confusion. uncertainty. The confusion source likely from her mother being from Algeria, which, while in Africa, has a majority Arab native population, and a significant white French minority from its days as a French colony. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black, and was consistently depicted as such in all major appearances. But two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. If she'll stay black this time, or get changed again remains to be seen. The confusion likely from her mother being from Algeria, which, while in Africa, has a majority Arab native population, and a significant white French minority from its days as a French colony. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black, and was consistently depicted as such in all major appearances. But two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. If she'll stay black this However, she's towing the line in [[ComicBook/WeaponX2017 Weapon X-Force]] issue 22. Most of the time, or get changed again remains she has a notably brown complexion when compared to be seen. Creed & Deathstrike, but some panels, she seeps over into white territory -possibly due to lighting. Or just more confusion. The confusion source likely from her mother being from Algeria, which, while in Africa, has a majority Arab native population, and a significant white French minority from its days as a French colony. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black, and was consistently depicted as such in all major appearances. But two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. If she'll stay black this time, or get changed again remains to be seen. The confusion likely from her mother being from Algeria. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black, and was consistently depicted as such in all major appearances. But two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
to:
* [[Characters/GenerationX Monet St. Croix]] is the most controversial example in [[Creator/MarvelComics Marvel]]. When she first appeared in Phalanx Covenant, she was black, ranging from [[https://i.imgur.com/uA6XcwE.jpg light brown]] to [[https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/silverfang2/29185537/1226122/1226122_900.jpg caramel]]. When she went to ''ComicBook/GenerationX'', she [[https://i.imgur.com/y6gMcNS.jpg started off more ambiguous for the first 9 chapters]], and ping-ponged ever since. She was usually depicted as [[https://i.imgur.com/z45Emeo.jpg black]]. But she did have instances of going back to [[https://i.imgur.com/lHNSLjI.jpg more ambiguous appearances]], which may be cases of ButNotTooBlack. In 2006's ''ComicBook/XFactor'', she was changed to [[https://i.imgur.com/kUIXgsJ.png more white, or tan European]]. WordOfGod said many fans complained, asking why Monet was white all of a sudden. She stayed mostly in that range from 2006 - early 2015. Since ''ComicBook/UncannyXMen2015'', she's gone back to [[https://i.imgur.com/XhjFOBa.png appearing]] [[https://i.imgur.com/HlRGzWr.png black]]. If she'll stay black this time, or get changed again remains to be seen. The confusion likely from her mother being from Algeria.Algeria, which, while in Africa, has a majority Arab native population, and a significant white French minority from its days as a French colony. Her father has also race-changed a couple of times. He was introduced as black, and was consistently depicted as such in all major appearances. But two cameo showings in the X-Men volumes had him as white, further confusing the racial issue of the family.
