History ProperlyParanoid / VideoGames

** He feels that Arthur is plotting against him, which is somewhat true, as Dutch's deteriorating sanity later in the game makes it hard for many gang members to trust him, causing them to turn to Arthur instead. He interprets Arthur's decision to [[spoiler:rescue John from prison]] as an act of disloyalty and going behind his back, though it's strong implied that Dutch wouldn't have bothered trying to [[spoiler:rescue John]] at all. Not to mention that [[spoiler:a dishonorable Arthur aims to steal the gang's money in the end]].

** Tying into this, Arthur and John openly question Dutch's actions throughout the story, and rightfully so, with conversations indicating that John was already doubting Dutch after the Blackwater incident. Due to his increasing paranoia that there is a traitor among them, Dutch, however, sees this as his "sons" conspiring and wanting to betray him.

* In ''VideoGame/CrusaderKings'' and its sequel, the "Paranoid" character trait gives a slight boost to that character's Intrigue stat, which dictates how vulnerable they are to assassination. However, it's a net loss; because a paranoid character ''constantly'' suspects his spouse of adultery and his court of plotting to murder him, it becomes difficult to sort out your character's paranoid fantasies from legitimate threats. Overreacting and becoming a tyrant or hermit is dangerous, but equally dangerous is assuming your paranoid character is jumping at shadows when someone actually is looking to put a knife in their back. As a general rule of thumb, if you're a paranoid character, hire a competent, non-paranoid spymaster who likes you. Then, don't assume any plot is real unless your spymaster says it is.
* In ''VideoGame/CryingSuns'', Emperor Oberon feared the possibility of a [[TurnedAgainstTheirMasters machine uprising]] and took many precautions against it, one of which was a set of restrictions that would prevent the [[ArtificialIntelligence OMNIs]] from communicating with each other. The ending shows that he was right to do so: [[spoiler:the Shutdown was caused by someone removing these restrictions, allowing the [=OMNIs=] to form a consensus and ascend to godhood.]]
* ''VideoGame/DanganronpaAnotherEpisodeUltraDespairGirls'': For much of the game Toko is suspicious of Shirokuma, a rogue Monokuma with an AI who's been helping out the adult resistance against the Warriors of Hope. At the end of the game, [[spoiler: not only was Shirokuma the one who hijacked the Big Bang Monokuma and went on a rampage, but the epilogue reveals he was working with Kurokuma all along to provoke the war between adults and children in Towa City.]]

** ''VideoGame/DarkSoulsII'' teaches players not to take ''anything'' for granted. In all three games, you can see the ghost images of other players running around the same areas, but in some areas of ''DSII'', those ghost images can turn out to actually be enemies ''pretending to be'' ghost images. Similarly, at least two areas of the game have enemies who are completely invisible unless you have the Priestess's Eye from Eleum Loyce, teaching you both to fear empty space and to treat treasure chests as an opportunity for an enemy you can't even see to stab you in the back.

* In both ''VideoGame/DeusEx'' and ''VideoGame/DeusExHumanRevolution'', you will run into people frequently who will claim that the government and corporations are behind some plot to take over the world and to enslave the masses. Given the plot of both games, they aren't crazy at all...
** More specific examples are if you kill [[spoiler: the gatekeeper or Joe Greene before being asked to. Characters will comment that you are becoming more like the Illuminati (paranoid), but will also comment that your method of thinking is correct.]]
* In ''VideoGame/DoubleSwitch'', Eddie set up traps all over the building out of apparent paranoia. [[spoiler: The scary thing is that he is both right and wrong. He is right because there are Mafia goons as well as secret society members who start running loose in the building. He is wrong because he is dangerously insane and wants an Egyptian statue that everyone is after.]]

** ''VideoGame/DragonAgeOrigins'' has Loghain, a national hero who along with King Maric, helped free Ferelden from Orlesian occupation decades ago and still harbours his old grudge towards their former conquerors. This brings him into contention with Maric's son, Cailan, who desires to foster peace with their former adversaries, particularly when Cailan desires to bring Orlesian forces to aid in the battle against the Darkspawn. Compounding on that, Cailan also wishes to include Grey Wardens in the battle and bolster their numbers with the large contingent of their order from Orlais. On the eve of battle, Loghain deserts the field with his forces, leaving the King and most of the Wardens to die and pinning the blame for the King's death on the Wardens. It's implied that he did so believing he foiled an Orlesian plot to prevent an invasion, using the Blight as an excuse to enact a coup. In the ''Return to Ostagar DLC'', it turns out he was ''[[RightForTheWrongReasons partially]]'' right. [[spoiler: Turns out Cailan ''was'' attempting to forge an alliance with Empress Celene and possibly intended to turn Ferelden into a client-state of the Orlesian Empire. But Loghain's belief that Cailan was planning to enact a coup with Orlesian forces at Ostagar ''wasn't'' right and the threat of the Blight was very much ''real''. Similarly, the Wardens had nothing to do with whatever Cailan may or may not have been planning. Presumably, his belief that the Wardens were traitors was fostered due to their failed rebellion against King Arland, two centuries earlier, which given his constant allusions to their Order's exile, seems very likely. In particular, Cailan was planning on divorcing his wife (Loghain's daughter) and marrying Celene. Alistair and Wynne list this as proof that he was working towards peace. Loghain immediately pegs it as Orlais trying to regain control of Ferelden, and dismisses peace as "fighting someone else's enemies in someone else's war for someone else's reasons." ''Literature/TheMaskedEmpire'' reveals Orlais ''is'' trying to reconquer Fereleden, and Celene only pursued the marriage so she could use Ferelden troops to fight her wars.]]
*** [[spoiler:Loghain's distrust towards the Wardens comes from another source. The order was only recently allowed back into Ferelden, meaning their numbers were very small. With a Blight brewing, the Wardens had planned to bolster their strength by bringing in their forces from Orlais. This made Loghain decidedly uncomfortable.]]
*** To top it off, the one he SHOULD have been paranoid about causing a nation-decimating coup was [[spoiler:Arl Howe, who is literally responsible for half of the issues that the factions of Ferelden are dealing with: HE planned the betrayal of Cailan and the Wardens, convincing Loghain and making him think it was his own idea, hired a young blood mage to assassinate Arl Eamon AND teach Eamon's son dangerous demon magic, sold elves to the Tevinters to raise funds, and hired an unstable (ready to be demonically possessed) mage to assault the Circle tower. And murdered a family of nobles, including the youngest son. And all so that he could obtain the land that he felt was rightfully his, even if it had to be razed to the ground first.]] Confirmed in ''VideoGame/DragonAgeOriginsAwakening'': [[spoiler:his daughter calls him a monster, right in front of her brother]]. So it's a case of being properly paranoid, but choosing the wrong allies and methods to deal with the situation.
** [[PlayingWithATrope Played with]] using Knight-Commander Meredith in ''VideoGame/DragonAgeII'', who becomes more stringent in her measures to crack down on apostates and blood mages, and is highly suspicious that [[TheArchmage First Enchanter Orsino]] is sheltering some of them himself. While Kirkwall does have plenty of blood mages, [[spoiler: and Orsino was covering up some shady stuff,]] the common counter-argument is that most of those mages only turned to blood magic in the first place [[SelfFulfillingProphecy because of her brutality.]] By the end of the game, she's accusing any Templars who dare to question her command of being blood mage thralls. [[spoiler:It doesn't help her case that the lyrium idol that she fashioned into a sword is also affecting her judgment.]]
* ''VideoGame/{{Drakensang}}'': Archmage Rakorium sees [[spoiler: [[ReptilesAreAbhorrent Lizardmen]]]] conspiring behind every corner. Turns out [[spoiler: the first game's main plot actually ''is'' about a huge conspiracy spearheaded by Lizardmen!]]
* ''Franchise/TheElderScrolls''

** In ''[[VideoGame/TheElderScrollsIIIMorrowind Morrowind]]'', Balmora Mages Guild Stewardess Ranis Athrys has a major grudge against the [[EvilSorcerer Telvanni]], [[spoiler:likely due to them having [[MyParentsAreDead killed her parents]]]], and believes that they have spies within the Guild. [[spoiler:As a later quest reveals, she is absolutely right about that]].

** In ''[[VideoGame/TheElderScrollsVSkyrim Skyrim]]'', most players develop the habit of smashing, shooting, burning, etc., any entombed Draugr who isn't naked, as they tend to come to life and attack you (this is also pretty good way to get a sneak attack on them).
* Played with in ''VideoGame/EternalDarkness'' during Maximillian Roivas' chapter. He's right to believe that body-snatching {{Eldritch Abomination}}s are out to get him; some of his servants are possessed, and he is forced to kill them. However, the encounter leads him to actual paranoia and insanity, and he comes to believe ''all'' his servants are monsters. One round of cold-blooded murders later, he is committed to an insane asylum.
* Tsugumi of ''VisualNovel/{{Ever17}}'' is convinced the entire disaster is some sort of setup. Obviously since it's on this page, she's right. [[spoiler:Tsugumi and Sora's routes have Lieblich trying to cover up they just released Tief Blau onto the world by shutting in any survivors, and You and Sara's routes have the disaster being entirely a GambitRoulette based on a real event that Tsugumi was involved in before.]]

* In ''VideoGame/FalloutNewVegas'', one of the Vaults was filled with almost nothing but former mental patients who were drugged until they forgot that they were ever insane, and then split into red and blue factions who lived on opposite, locked sections of the Vault filled with HAL-esque security cameras to fuel their paranoia. Naturally, one of them figured it out, but he could no longer trust himself when he knew he was insane.
** Also, Mr. House was able to predict the war before it happened and had defense systems set up all over Vegas. He would have completed it too had the war not happened a day earlier than his completion date causing him to never receive the Platinum Chip that would've upgraded his defense systems. Still, his defenses were effective enough that Vegas is left mostly intact. Another example of him is his non-negotiable request for you to wipe out the Brotherhood of Steel. While it may just seem like Kicking the Dog, it's shown in the Wild Card ending that [[spoiler:without the NCR actively curbing them, the Brotherhood of Steel will start stealing any bit of advanced technology they find from anybody they meet. That and the fact that House relies on robots to enforce his authority means that the Brotherhood would naturally oppose him.]]
** Also, Regis of the Great Khans is the only one to actively distrust Caesar's Legion and be opposed to the alliance. However, he will not speak out unless you can give him evidence he can use.
* In ''Videogame/Fallout4'', Piper Wright's articles accusing Mayor [=McDonough=] of being a [[RidiculouslyHumanRobot Synth]] spy come off as accusatory slander that borders on yellow journalism. [[spoiler:Eventually however, [=McDonough=] is revealed to be an Institute Synth, which proves her right (even if it was just her relying on her paranoia)]].

** Hubert is the poor bastard whose job it is to protect the tenth crown heir of the Adrestian Empire from assassins. We say 'tenth', because everyone before her in the line of succession has been brutally murdered. So [[spoiler:Hubert's willingness to threaten literally everyone she talks to and subvert her more merciful commands]] kind of makes sense. [[GreyAndGreyMorality Kind of.]] The story doesn't judge either way.
** Seteth strongly distrusts [[PlayerCharacter Byleth]] at first, strenuously objecting to Rhea's decision to make them a teacher at the Academy and later entrust the [[SwordOfPlotAdvancement Sword of the Creator]] to someone with a largely unknown history whose motives cannot be vouched for. Not an unreasonable position, all things considered, [[spoiler:and should you take the Crimson Flower route his fears are borne out as you side with Edelgard to destroy the Church.]]
** After the birth of the main character Byleth, their father Jeralt became fearful of the Archbishop Rhea as Byleth’s mother had died giving birth and the fact that Byleth never cried once as a baby, being completely silent and missing a heartbeat despite seeming perfectly healthy. No longer trusting the church he served, he faked both his an Byleth’s deaths and moved around the continent to avoid being found. While Byleth’s condition wasn’t Rhea’s fault, [[spoiler: as Byleth was actually stillborn, causing their mother to get Rhea to transplant the crest stone in her heart to act as Byleth’s own, resulting in Byleth’s TroublingUnchildlikeBehaviour and their mother’s death, Rhea did plan on taking advantage of the situation by attempting to use Byleth as a vessel to resurrect Sothis,]] justifying Jeralt’s fears.
* ''VideoGame/GodOfWarIII'': When the ghostly Athena confronts him in the Underworld and states her intent to help him kill Zeus, Kratos is suspicious, since in [[VideoGame/GodOfWarII the previous game]], Athena had [[HeroicSacrifice sacrificed her life]] to save Zeus from Kratos' wrath. [[spoiler:Athena claims she sees truths she didn't before, but during the ending, it turns out Kratos was right to be suspicious; Athena was just using him to take Zeus out so she could become the sole god of Greece and rule over mankind for herself.]]
* ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoSanAndreas'' has The Truth, who at first glance looks like your average [[TheStoner perpetually stoned]] NewAgeRetroHippie. But as the game goes on, more and more of the weird, seemingly random and/or insane stuff he talks about turns out to be true.
** In ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoV'' Online, players in one of the heist quests have to rescue Avi Schwarzmann, a CloudCuckoolander engineer who went into extreme hiding on an island after his phone calls were intercepted by police agents who have him surrounded.
* Father Grigori in ''VideoGame/HalfLife2'' mentions that he built most of his anti-zombie traps before the zombies ever hit.
** In that same area, players get into the habit of shooting corpses a couple of times before walking past them. If they're really a "hibernating" headcrab zombie, this will wake them up. This is because most players have had just a few too many times when the innocent-looking corpse they just passed walks up behind them and knocks their head off.
*** There's an easy trick to figure out which are still alive. Did you not kill them yourself? Do they have a headcrab still on their head? Is the corpse intact? If all 3, then they are still alive. NO EXCEPTIONS.
* As in the original short story, Ted in ''VideoGame/IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream'' game is described as being pathologically paranoid. However, he does not come across any more suspicious as any of the other main characters. When you are in a world controlled by an insane godlike AI who has been torturing you for over a century, being paranoid is completely warranted.

* ''VideoGame/JumpStartAdventures4thGradeHauntedIsland'' players frequently used the [[WarpWhistle map]] to warp around the island. Not just because it was faster, but because if you walked around the island, you might get jumped by Repsac. Answer his question wrong, he'll steal your health -- and lose enough you get warped into the labyrinth... and he can still jump you ''inside'' the labyrinth. Use the WarpWhistle? He can't get you.
* ''VideoGame/KingdomHeartsBirthBySleep'' gives us Eraqus, whom both the [[InformedWrongness narrative]] and the [[UnreliableNarrator Xehanort Reports]] would have you view as a blinded KnightTemplar of Light. However, [[BalanceBetweenGoodAndEvil Balance Between Light and Darkness]] has repeatedly proven to be a BrokenAesop throughout the entire franchise, with LightIsGood heroes and DarkIsEvil threats indeed being the predominant themes. Additionally, Xehanort himself, while not entirely wrong about Eraqus's "absolutes", is far worse of a {{Sociopath}} of Darkness and repeatedly engages in KickTheDog behavior via said power, meaning that Eraqus doesn't have any actual reason to change his mind. [[spoiler:And while Eraqus does end up finally snapping and trying to kill Ven and Terra for the greater good, it retroactively turns out to be a mercy compared to their eventual ([[VideoGame/KingomHearts3 albeit temporarily]]) fates... and even then, Eraqus still ultimately invokes MyGodWhatHaveIDone and decides to atone by using his Heart to later shield Terra's from the full brunt of Xehanort's Darkness -- which, by the way, wouldn't have even remotely worked if Eraqus wasn't indeed so devoted to Light.]]
* Rean Schwarzer from ''VideoGame/TheLegendOfHeroesTrailsOfColdSteel'' is always paranoid and scared that his SuperpoweredEvilSide will one day go out of control and will harm his friends and family or even just random strangers. He ends up being correct come ''Cold Steel III'' where [[spoiler:he loses control of his powers at the worst possible way and kills the corrupted Divine Beast that was the only reason why the curse of Erebonia is kept at bay.]]

*** Wrex once worked for Saren as a hired gun for a job. However after actually seeing his employer for the first time, his instincts gave him such a bad feeling about Saren that he left without even waiting to get paid. He was right again; every other merc from that job was found dead within a week.

** [[TheDragon Saren]] himself is paranoid that [[spoiler:[[SapientShip his ship]] [[BigBad Sovereign]]]] is [[MoreThanMindControl indoctrinating him.]] [[spoiler:He's right]].

** In ''Mass Effect 3'', Dalatress Linron tries to convince Shepard to sabotage the genophage cure because she sees the krogan as bloodthirsty animals who will turn on the galaxy after the Reapers are defeated just as they did after the rachni were defeated. If Wrex died in ''Mass Effect 1'' and Urdnot Wreav is clan leader, she's completely right - Wreav orders his troops to observe weaknesses in his "allies" and makes it clear he intends to create a new krogan empire after the Reapers fall.
* In ''VideoGame/MegaManX5'', [[TheMedic Lifesaver]] begins to suspect a connection between Zero and [[TheVirus The Maverick Virus]] after Zero shows odd reactions to it. In [[MultipleEndings the good ending]], his theory leads to X and Zero [[LetsYouAndHimFight fighting each other]]. [[AGodAmI The bad ending proves him right.]]
** Remember how, in ''VideoGame/MegaManX4'', Repliforce was labeled Maverick on a whim (Though [[HonorBeforeReason they certainly didn't help their case]])? Well, in ''VideoGame/MegaManX6'', Gate's Inspectors are similarly labeled Mavericks on a whim, but this time, they really ''are'' villainous.
** There's a variant in ''X4'', Sigma tries to convince General to go maverick, explains that humanity intends to destroy any reploid that doesn't obey them perfectly. VideoGame/MegaManZero proves that this would eventually become the case, but at the time, Sigma was wrong, and [[SelfFulfillingProphecy his own actions ended up contributing to this development heavily]].
* In ''VideoGame/MetalGearSolidVThePhantomPain'', Miller is quite adamant on his distrust of Quiet and Huey Emmerich, as the former was an agent of XOF and the latter was complicit in the downfall of Militaires Sans Frontieres. [[spoiler:Turns out, he was ''completely right'': Quiet was sent to infect Big Boss's new private army with a biological weapon, only stopping after having [[HeelFaceTurn a change of heart]]; while Huey was secretly working to repair Metal Gear Sahelanthropus for Eli, as well as releasing a biological weapon upon Big Boss's army to sell to their nemesis, Cipher.]]
* In ''VideoGame/{{Minecraft}}'', most of the mobs create this feeling for players. All of the common ones like Skeleton Archers, Zombies, and Spiders can spawn ''anywhere'' that is large and dark enough, even if it's been previously explored. Creepers are especially dangerous: Remember to properly light up explored areas, or your character will suddenly come face to face with an imminent explosion.
** Also, if you're playing on a server without very active admins, adopting a paranoid play style (to the point of coating ones subterranean obsidian bunker with lava and iron/coal ore) is the best defense against thieves and griefers.
* ''VideoGame/MinecraftStoryMode'': Magnus refuses to leave his tower because he thinks the Griefers will try to usurp him. [[spoiler:Guess what happens when ''you'' become king?]]

** The Council chambers are locked behind four consecutive gates. One of them is always guarded and requires blood verification. One of them opens onto a platform ''in outer space'', that will suffocate anyone not wearing a helmet. One of them won't open for anyone not holding a chunk of [[EldritchAbomination god]] flesh. And the player only finds this out because all of those precautions failed and the Council were massacred. [[TheHero Lady]] can't even reach the crime scene for most of the game because the Council were so tight-lipped about how to do it.
** Monserrat, leader of the council, was ''especially'' paranoid, and many feared that he was turning into a tyrant. When Lady finds [[spoiler:the demon that likely]] killed him, it's bleeding out from a gunshot wound. She speculates that it attacked the Council while they were waking up, killing them almost instantly. Because Monserrat was so wary, only he was ready to fight back.
*** There's also the fact that Monserrat got his position by killing the previous leader. You don't sit easy on a throne like that.

* Downplayed with Dutch in ''VideoGame/RedDeadRedemptionII''.
** He feels Arthur is plotting against him, which is somewhat true, as Dutch's deteriorating sanity later in the game makes it hard for many gang members to trust him and turn to Arthur instead. He interpreted Arthur's decision to [[spoiler: rescue John from prison]] as an act of disloyalty and going behind his back, though it's strong implied that Dutch wouldn't have bothered trying to [[spoiler: rescue John]] at all. Also, not to mention that [[spoiler: a dishonorable Arthur aims to steal the gang's money in the end.]]
** Dutch is completely right there is an informant in the gang, just that he suspected John and Abigail instead of the actual traitor. However, there is some rationality for his growing mistrust of John and Abigail, as John did leave the gang for one year before returning and that Abigail inexplicitly managed to escape the Pinkertons while John was only arrested and not killed, compared to [[spoiler: Hosea and Lenny]].
** Tying into this, Arthur and John have been openly questioning Dutch's actions throughout the story and rightfully so, with conversations indicating John was already doubting Dutch after the Blackwater incident. Due to his increasing paranoia there is a traitor among them, Dutch however sees this as his "sons" conspiring and wanting to betray him.

* [[spoiler: Bosco]] from ''[[VideoGame/SamAndMaxFreelancePolice Sam & Max: Freelance Police]]''. (Obscuring the name doesn't make this much less of a spoiler, because he is SUCH a perfect example of this trope that I couldn't possibly be talking about anyone else.)
** In the 4th game of Season 1, "Abe Lincoln Must Die", you find that there is [[spoiler: a homing beacon for [=ICBMs=] hidden in his store. Earlier on, he built a satellite missile defense system and if you try to launch a nuke at him this system will kick in and stop the missile. There's also a spy camera in his store.]]
*** In season 2, it's revealed [[spoiler: his mother has (inadvertently) had him under surveillance since before he was born... There's also a PI spying on him.]]

** ''VideoGame/KnightsOfTheOldRepublic'': Carth never passes up an opportunity to voice the opinion that something stinks in the setup; that it's a little odd your character survived, that it's also really odd that Bastila made the request to transfer you aboard, that the Jedi Council is up to some dirty trick... Turns out, he's dead right.
** ''VideoGame/KnightsOfTheOldRepublicIITheSithLords'': The Peragus Security Officer suspected that someone was sabotaging the facility to sneak you off to turn you in for your bounty. He hid a stealth field generator in a footlocker, tied an override switch to the droids on the administration level AND the prison's forcefield, stocked security with sonic and ion charges and suspected that someone would turn the droids on them, so he asked to know the damage the droids could do to them. Didn't help him survive much longer, but ''he was right''.

* ''VideoGame/TeamFortress2'' has the Spy. That guy who looks like he's guarding the intelligence could be a Spy. The Sniper on the sniper deck could be a Spy. ''Your own team's Spy'' could be a Spy. It could be ''you''. It could be ''me''! It could even be--oops, a Spy just killed you.
** [[DontExplainTheJoke Which justifies one of the most ubiquitous actions in the game: shooting your allies to find Spies. Since team-mates don't take damage when they shoot each other, but Spies do, firing a few shots at your allies ("spy-checking") can be a life-saver.]]
*** That spy checking is easy, effective, and ubiquitous, and yet Spies are ''still one of the most popular classes'' gives you some idea of what we're dealing with here...
*** The Dead Ringer item for the Spy makes this even worse. When a Spy receives any damage with the Dead Ringer activated, they will drop a fake corpse and instantly turn invisible. If you killed a Spy in one shot, you probably didn't. Experienced Spies can activate the Dead Ringer at the very last second before death, making it nigh impossible to determine if you actually got him.
** Also in a level of irony, a Spy is pretty paranoid at all times on whether the other team knows he is a Spy or not.
** Then there are Pyros. While it is usually a standard to spy-check suspicious teammates, a Pyro can take it to the extreme. Since their primary weapon (the flamethrower) allows them to make continuous sweeps and Spies who catch on fire often die from it due to their low health, that Pyros will often set aflame everyone they come across or just burn empty space in case a Spy is cloaked and hiding there. The class is almost required to play like this since they are the Spy's natural enemy.
*** Added the fact that when an enemy spy is set aflame, they'll also glow on the color of their true affiliation. This might look like unnecessary fluff, because receiving damage is all the evidence a player will need to hunt down a spy, but remember that a corner or a fray is all they need to switch costumes or go invisible. This little effect will ensure that not even that will help them, as everyone around will notice, not only the attacking player.
* Sam, one of Lara's friends and crewmates in ''VideoGame/TombRaider2013'' began recording a video diary because she thought that Dr. Whitman would take credit for any discoveries Lara made, which Lara brushes off. Later on, you can find a letter Whitman wrote to his wife asking her not to divorce him just yet... because Lara found something and he's going to get rich by claiming the discovery as his own. [[spoiler: An undead Japanese soldier got to him, though.]]
* In ''VideoGame/VampireTheMasqueradeBloodlines'' there is a conspiracy theorist who is a constant caller on a late night radio station. His calls start off with conspiracies regarding aliens and area 51 but at the end of the game he reveals the entire plot of the game so far and the Vampire conspiracy but gets laughed off as being crazy.
* In ''Videogame/WorldOfWarcraft'' there's reference to an assassin known as [[TheButcher The Bonebreaker]] who broke the legs of her targets after killing them, because one time a target wasn't actually dead yet and came after her for revenge.
** Sargeras' personal assassin Akaari kidnaps Rogue players and locks them in her citadel. Even after being empowered by Kil'jaeden, she sends her guards after the player, including detectors, in an attempt to make sure the player can't reach her. Contrast most Legion agents who believe themselves invincible only to die at the player's hands, not that it saves her.

* In ''Videogame/TheOuterWorlds'' Phineas Welles will never leave his bulletproof glass room when you're around, making him the only character you can't kill whenever you want. If asked, he'll state that he doesn't trust you to suddenly turn violent and will even use your actions to prove his point if you've resolved the Edgewater questlines by killing the faction leaders. Of course, in the ending where you [[spoiler: betray Welles, he's out of his glass room, and you can kill him.]]

* Early on in ''VideoGame/AlanWake'', you meet an old woman who always carries around an electric lantern, won't walk down a hallway because the light's burnt out, and frequently talks about getting faulty bulbs replaced. Then you go through the Washington forests at night, get attacked by creatures of darkness, and find out there's a very good reason for this. [[spoiler:Even more than you think: the woman's the Lady of the Light, giving you the means to defeat the darkness.]]
* Steven Heck from ''VideoGame/AlphaProtocol''. He repeatedly references various crazy sounding conspiracy theories, such as operation Acoustic Kitty, which supposedly involved CIA operatives sticking receivers to the tails of cats for use in spying, which is actually TruthInTelevision.
** The conspiracies he references falls into three categories: TruthInTelevision (like Acoustic Kitty), Confirmed In Universe (like a scheme to manipulate the price of strawberries for testing purposes) and finally stuff that, because of the other two categories, there is that niggling feeling that maybe it isn't entirely wrong, after all...
* Every ''Franchise/AssassinsCreed'' assassination target who voices concern about the Assassin's presence -- since all are done within earshot of the Assassin.
** In [[VideoGame/AssassinsCreedI the first game]] there's a model example in Sibrand who is first seen (by Altaïr) threatening a Scholar whose white robes are similar to those of the Assassins. Unfortunately, although that's ''why'' the Assassins wear those robes--which the scholar correctly points out--Sibrand cuts him down anyway. Eventually, this isn't enough "security" for Sibrand, who then flees to a boat that's quite off-shore, correctly believing that the Assassins are still hunting him. There's also a conversation between two Templar troops who are discussing the Assassin and Sibrand's growing paranoia, only to have Sibrand stomp up toward them and berate them for being so suspiciously secretive. Then Sibrand turns around, convinced that Assassins are watching them, and yells at the passing crowd at the top of his lungs that he knows the Assassins are out there, listening and watching right now. The hilarious thing is that Altair actually ''is'' listening in right at that very moment, so Sibrand's paranoia is justified.
* In ''VideoGame/BaldursGate 2: Throne of Bhaal'', meeting Gromnir Il-Khan causes him to spout paranoid ramblings about how [[spoiler:Melissan is an evil backstabbing witch trying to manipulate all the Bhaalspawn into killing each other]] before he attacking you for thinking you're out to get him. As it later turns out, he was right: [[spoiler:Melissan really ''was'' trying to kill all the Bhaalspawn and sent you after Gromnir because she knew he'd try to kill you.]]
* It's always fun to slowly make the henchman paranoid and terrified enough to shoot off wildly at the tiniest noise in the predator sections of the ''VideoGame/BatmanArkhamSeries''. Some of their buddies will try to calm them down saying Batman's not all that. But boy oh boy do you get to prove them wrong.
** Also, people tend to question Batman's possible overestimations of The Joker's plans.

** In Chapter 1, there's an audio recording of Thomas Connor, a repairman who is creeped out by the ink everywhere in Joey Drew Studios. He says it's unnatural. By the time Henry returns to the studio, there are monsters made of ink, and any standing ink could potentially form into a monster and attack.
** In Chapter 4, there's an audio recording of Lacie Benton. Henry finds it where she used to help build Bendy Land, an amusement park that was never completed. She complains about an animatronic version of Bendy that gives her the creeps and swears that it's moving when her back is turned. It's unknown if she was right about that in particular, but there are a lot of monsters to worry about by the time of the game. A HostileAnimatronics version of Bendy isn't implausible, and in fact [[spoiler: there is another machine moving around and trying to kill someone on its own - [[WasOnceAMan Bertrum Piedmont]]]].
* ''VideoGame/{{BioShock|1}}'' has [[spoiler:Peach Wilkins. A fisherman and smuggler who has holed himself up in Fontaine Fisheries, he believes you are just a troublesome agent of his supposedly dead boss Frank Fontaine, who he currently has a VERY low opinion of (justifiably, Fontaine was a crook and a slimeball). He was right. Sure, you didn't know it at the time, as Fontaine was masquerading as the sympathetic Irishman Atlas.]]

* Takumi in ''VisualNovel/ChaosHead'' is correct about a surprisingly large amount of his paranoid thoughts, thought not all of them. [[spoiler:Like that Yua had ulterior motives for being nice to him, some invisible godlike presence is watching him or that some sort of conspiracy surrounding Shogun is targeting him. Even about the idea that someone always seems to be watching him and that he is the avatar of someone else the same way Knight-Hart is his own in ESO.]]

** He feels Arthur is plotting against him, which is somewhat true, as Dutch's deteriorating sanity later in the game makes it hard for many gang members to trust him and turn to Arthur instead. He interpreted Arthur's decision to rescue John from prison as an act of disloyalty and going behind his back, though it's strong implied that Dutch wouldn't have bothered trying to rescue John at all. Also, not to mention that [[spoiler: a dishonorable Arthur aims to steal the gang's money in the end.]]

** Tying into this, Arthur and John have been openly questioning Dutch's actions throughout the story and rightfully so, with conversations indicating John was already doubting Dutch after the Blackwater incident. Due to his increasing paranoia and knowledge there is a traitor among them, Dutch however sees this as his "sons" conspiring and wanting to betray him.

** He feels Arthur is plotting against him, which is somewhat true, as Dutch's deteriorating sanity later in the game makes it hard for the rest of the gang to trust him and turn to Arthur instead. He interpreted Arthur's decision to rescue John from prison as an act of disloyalty and going behind his back, though it's strong implied that Dutch wouldn't have bothered trying to rescue John at all. Also, not to mention that [[spoiler: a dishonorable Arthur aims to steal the gang's money in the end.]]
** Dutch is completely right there is an informant in the gang, just that he suspected [[spoiler: John and Abigail]] instead of the actual traitor. However, there is some rationality for his growing mistrust of [[spoiler: John and Abigail]], as [[spoiler: John]] did leave the gang for one year before returning and that [[spoiler: Abigail]] inexplicitly managed to escape the Pinkertons while [[spoiler: John]] was arrested and not killed, compared to [[spoiler: Hosea and Lenny]].

** He is right that a Low!Honor Arthur is plotting against him as [[spoiler: a dishonorable Arthur aims to steal the gang's money in the end.]]

* ''VideoGame/KingdomHeartsBirthBySleep'' gives us Eraqus, whom both the [[InformedWrongness narrative]] and the [[UnreliableNarrator Xehanort Reports]] would have you view as a blinded KnightTemplar of Light. However, [[BalanceBetweenGoodAndEvil Balance Between Light and Darkness]] has repeatedly proven to be a BrokenAesop throughout the entire franchise, with LightIsGood heroes and DarkIsEvil threats indeed being the predominant themes. Additionally, Xehanort himself, while not entirely wrong about Eraqus's "absolutes", is far worse of a {{Sociopath}} of Darkness and repeatedly engages in KickTheDog behavior via said power, meaning that Eraqus doesn't have any actual reason to change his mind. [[spoiler:And while Eraqus does end up finally snapping and trying to kill Ven and Terra for the greater good, it retroactively turns out to be a mercy compared to their eventual ([[VideoGame/KingomHearts3 albeit teporary]]) fates... and even then, Eraqus still ultimately invokes MyGodWhatHaveIDone and decides to atone by using his Heart to later shield Terra's from the full brunt of Xehanort's Darkness -- which, by the way, wouldn't have even remotely worked if Eraqus wasn't indeed so devoted to Light.]]

* ''VideoGame/KingdomHeartsBirthBySleep'' gives us Eraqus, whom both the [[InformedWrongness narrative]] and the [[UnreliableNarrator Xehanort Reports]] would have you view as a blinded KnightTemplar of Light. However, [[BalanceBetweenGoodAndEvil Balance Between Light and Darkness]] has repeatedly proven to be a BrokenAesop throughout the entire franchise, with LightIsGood heroes and DarkIsEvil threats indeed being the predominant themes. Additionally, Xehanort himself, while not entirely wrong about Eraqus's "absolutes", is far worse of a {{Sociopath}} of Darkness and repeatedly engages in KickTheDog behavior via said power, meaning that Eraqus doesn't have any actual reason to change his mind. [[spoiler:And while Eraqus does end up finally snapping and trying to kill Ven and Terra for the greater good, it retroactively turns out to be a mercy compared to their eventual fates... and even then, Eraqus still ultimately invokes MyGodWhatHaveIDone and decides to atone by using his Heart to later shield Terra's from the full brunt of Xehanort's Darkness -- which, by the way, wouldn't have even remotely worked if Eraqus wasn't indeed so devoted to Light.]]

** ''VideoGame/DragonAgeOrigins'' has Loghain, a national hero who along with King Maric, helped free Ferelden from Orlesian occupation decades ago and still harbours his old grudge towards their former conquerors. This brings him into contention with Maric's son, Cailan, who desires to foster peace with their former adversaries, particularly when Cailan desires to bring Orlesian forces to aid in the battle against the Darkspawn. Compounding on that, Cailan also wishes to include Grey Wardens in the battle and bolster their numbers with the large contingent of their order from Orlais. On the eve of battle, Loghain deserts the field with his forces, leaving the King and most of the Wardens to die and pinning the blame for the King's death on the Wardens. It's implied that he did so believing he foiled an Orlesian plot to prevent an invasion, using the Blight as an excuse to enact a coup. In the ''Return to Ostagar DLC'', it turns out he was ''[[RightForTheWrongReasons partially]]'' right. [[spoiler: Turns out Cailan ''was'' attempting to forge an alliance with Empress Celene and possibly intended to turn Ferelden into a client-state of the Orlesian Empire. But Loghain's belief that Cailan was planning to enact a coup with Orlesian forces at Ostagar ''wasn't'' right and the threat of the Blight was very much ''real''. Similarly, the Wardens had nothing to do with whatever Cailan may or may not have been planning. Presumably, his belief that the Wardens were traitors was fostered due to their failed rebellion against King Arland, two centuries earlier, which given his constant allusions to their Order's exile, seems very likely. In particular, Cailan was planning on divorcing his wife (Loghain's daughter) and marrying Celene. Alistair and Wynne list this as prove that he was working towards peace. Loghain immediately pegs it as Orlais trying to regain control of Ferelden, and dismisses peace as "fighting someone else's enemies in someone else's war for someone else's reasons." ''Literature/TheMaskedEmpire'' reveals Orlais ''is'' trying to reconquer Fereleden, and Celene only pursued the marriage so she could use Ferelden troops to fight her wars.]]

----

* Sam, one of Lara's friends and crewmates in ''VideoGame/TombRaider2013'' began recording a video diary because she thought that Dr. Whitman would take credit for any discoveries Lara made, which Lara brushes off. Later on, you can find a letter Whitman wrote to his wife asking her not to divorce him just yet... because Lara found something and he's going to get rich by claiming the discovery as his own.

* In ''Videogame/TheOuterWorlds'' Phineas Welles will never leave his bulletproof glass room when you're around, making him the only character you can't kill whenever you want. If asked, he'll state that he doesn't trust you to suddenly turn violent and will even use your actions to prove his point if you've resolved the Edgewater questlines by killing the faction leaders.

* It's always fun to slowly make the henchman paranoid and terrified enough to shoot off wildly at the tiniest noise in the predator sections of the ''VideoGame/BatmanArkhamSeries''. Some of their buddies will try to calm them down saying Batman's not all that. But boy do you get to prove them wrong.

*** To top it off, the one he SHOULD have been paranoid about causing a nation-decimating coup was [[spoiler:Arl Howe, who is literally responsible for half of the issues that the factions of Ferelden are dealing with: HE planned the betrayal of Cailan and the Wardens, convincing Loghain and making him think it was his own idea, hired a young blood mage to assassinate Arl Eamon AND teach Eamon's son dangerous demon magic, sold elves to the Tevinters to raise funds, and hired an unstable (ready to be demonically possessed) mage to assault the Circle tower. And murdered a family of nobles, including the youngest son. And all so that he could obtain the land that he felt was rightfully his, even if it had to be razed to the ground first.]]. Confirmed in ''VideoGame/DragonAgeOriginsAwakening'': [[spoiler:his daughter calls him a monster, right in front of her brother]]. So it's a case of being properly paranoid, but choosing the wrong allies and methods to deal with the situation.

** Seteth strongly distrusts [[PlayerCharacter Byleth]] at first, strenuously objecting to Rhea's decision to make them a teacher at the Academy and later entrust the [[SwordOfPlotAdvancement Sword of the Creator]] to someone with a largely unknown history whose motives cannot be vouched for. [[spoiler:Should you take the Crimson Flower route, his fears are borne out as you side with Edelgard to destroy the Church.]]

** Seteth strongly distrusts [[PlayerCharacter Byleth]] at first, strenuously objecting to Rhea's decision to make them a teacher at the Academy and later entrust the [[SwordOfPlotAdvancement Sword of the Creator]] to someone with a largely unknown history whose motives cannot be vouched for. [[spoiler:Should you take the Crimson Flower route, his suspicions are borne out as you side with Edelgard to destroy the Church.]]

* ''VideoGame/FireEmblemThreeHouses'' has Hubert, the poor bastard whose job it is to protect the tenth crown heir of the Adrestian Empire from assassins. We say 'tenth', because everyone before her in the line of succession has been brutally murdered. So [[spoiler:Hubert's willingness to threaten literally everyone she talks to and subvert her more merciful commands]] kind of makes sense. [[GreyAndGreyMorality Kind of.]] The story doesn't judge either way.

** ''VideoGame/DragonAgeOrigins'' has Loghain, a national hero who along with King Maric, helped free Ferelden from Orlesian occupation decades ago and still harbours his old grudge towards their former conquerors. This brings him into contention with Maric's son, Cailan, who desires to foster peace with their former adversaries, particularly when Cailan desires to bring Orlesian forces to aid in the battle against the Darkspawn. Compounding on that, Cailan also wishes to include Grey Wardens in the battle and bolster their numbers with the large contingent of their order from Orlais. On the eve of battle, Loghain deserts the field with his forces, leaving the King and most of the Wardens to die and pinning the blame for the King's death on the Wardens. It's implied that he did so believing he foiled an Orlesian plot to prevent an invasion, using the Blight as an excuse to enact a coup. In the ''Return to Ostagar DLC'', it turns out he was ''[[RightForTheWrongReasons partially]]'' right. [[spoiler: Turns out Cailan ''was'' attempting to forge an alliance with Empress Celene and possibly intended to turn Ferelden into a client-state of the Orlesian Empire. But Loghain's belief that Cailan was planning to enact a coup with Orlesian forces at Ostagar ''wasn't'' right and the threat of the Blight was very much ''real''. Similarly, the Wardens had nothing to do with whatever Cailan may or may not have been planning. Presumably, his belief that the Wardens were traitors was fostered due to their failed rebellion against King Arland, two centuries earlier, which given his constant allusions to their Order's exile, seems very likely. In particular, Cailan was planning on divorcing his wife (Loghain's daughter) and marrying Celene. Alistair and Wynne list this as prove that he was working towards peace. Loghain immediately pegs it as Orlais trying to regain control of Ferelden, and dismisses peace as "fighting someone else's enemies in someone else's war for someone else's reasons. ''Literature/TheMaskedEmpire'' reveals Orlais ''is'' trying to reconquer Fereleden, and Celene only pursued the marriage so she could use Ferelden troops to fight her wars.]]

** ''VideoGame/DragonAgeOrigins'' has Loghain, a national hero who along with King Maric, helped free Ferelden from Orlesian occupation decades ago and still harbours his old grudge towards their former conquerors. This brings him into contention with Maric's son, Cailan, who desires to foster peace with their former adversaries, particularly when Cailan desires to bring Orlesian forces to aid in the battle against the Darkspawn. Compounding on that, Cailan also wishes to include Grey Wardens in the battle and bolster their numbers with the large contingent of their order from Orlais. On the eve of battle, Loghain deserts the field with his forces, leaving the King and most of the Wardens to die and pinning the blame for the King's death on the Wardens. It's implied that he did so believing he foiled an Orlesian plot to prevent an invasion, using the Blight as an excuse to enact a coup. In the ''Return to Ostagar DLC'', it turns out he was ''[[RightForTheWrongReasons partially]]'' right. [[spoiler: Turns out Cailan ''was'' attempting to forge an alliance with Empress Celene and possibly intended to turn Ferelden into a client-state of the Orlesian Empire. But Loghain's belief that Cailan was planning to enact a coup with Orlesian forces at Ostagar ''wasn't'' right and the threat of the Blight was very much ''real''. Similarly, the Wardens had nothing to do with whatever Cailan may or may not have been planning. Presumably, his belief that the Wardens were traitors was fostered due to their failed rebellion against King Arland, two centuries earlier, which given his constant allusions to their Order's exile, seems very likely.]]