Follow TV Tropes

Following

History PlayingWith / PoliticallyCorrectHistory

Go To

OR

Added: 183

Changed: 259

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The bigotry manages to become historically inaccurate. While people may look down on Alice for being a lesbian in Chicago in the 1970s she couldn't be arrested for that explicitly.



* '''Zig Zagged''': ???

to:

* '''Zig Zagged''': ???An alternate history mixes various levels. While gender roles are rigidly enforced more approrpiate to the 1800s than the 1980s transgender people are accepted regardless of their birth sex. The situation with homosexuality however is about the same still.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The work takes place in a setting is a WretchedHive. One of its very few upsides is that nobody gives a damn about who or what anyone is. Deserters, pirates, murderers, thieves, and traitors prowl the city and everyone knows it. Given the amount of 'bad people' nobody is likely to care about lesser issues like some excommunicated clergy marrying two men even if it would incite a riot in. Besides [[BullyingADragon mocking a pirate captain over liking men is likely to get you stabbed.]]

to:

** The work takes place in a setting is a WretchedHive. One of its very few upsides is that nobody gives a damn about who or what anyone is. Deserters, pirates, murderers, thieves, and traitors prowl the city and everyone knows it. Given the amount of 'bad people' nobody is likely to care about lesser issues like some excommunicated clergy marrying two men even if it would incite a riot in.in more 'respectable' cities. Besides [[BullyingADragon mocking a pirate captain over liking men is likely to get you stabbed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The work takes place in a setting is a WretchedHive. One of its very few upsides is that nobody gives a damn about who or what anyone is. Deserters, pirates, murderers, thieves, and traitors prowl the city and everyone knows it. Given the amount of 'bad people' nobody is likely to care about lesser issues like some excommunicated clergy marrying two men even if it would incite a riot in. Besides [[BullyingADragon mocking a pirate captain over liking men is likely to get you stabbed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alice does well but the dress shop is 'officially' owned by and Alice is 'employed' [[ExceptionallyTolerant a generous white man who despises racism]] who is really a silent partner to give a veneer of acceptability to society. This shields her from the worst of the problems as racists can rationalize her as merely a good servant of someone 'proper'.

Added: 930

Changed: 834

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice is a BlackBestFriend or a MagicalNegro to a white lead

to:

** Alice Alice's blackness is a BlackBestFriend or a MagicalNegro later revealed to have been based upon a historical misinterpretation. When accounts described her as dark skinned and from Africa they meant she was well tanned and from Boer farmers who immigrated. She was still white leadand considered as such.



** Alice is revealed to have been real



* '''Lampshaded''': ???

to:

* '''Lampshaded''': ???A note flashes at the beginning noting that casting was done both colorblind and genderblind with minimal line changes resulting in the politically correct history - with bizarre implications.



* '''Deconstructed''': While everything seems peachy at first there but it becomes increasingly clear that something wrong is happening with the timeline. [[AnachronismStew A few anachronisms]] [[OrphanedEtymology and inconsistent names start slipping through]] into society. It turns out that there is a heavy degree of meddling to achieve this tolerant history and it may result in some very nasty side effects....

to:

* '''Deconstructed''': '''Deconstructed''':
**
While everything seems peachy at first there but it becomes increasingly clear that something wrong is happening with the timeline. [[AnachronismStew A few anachronisms]] [[OrphanedEtymology and inconsistent names start slipping through]] into society. such as referring to things as lynch mobs metaphorically despite that /never/ happening after the war. It turns out that there is a heavy degree of meddling to achieve this tolerant history and it may result in some very nasty side effects....effects far worse than the cognitive dissonance.
** Alternatively it is shown just how extreme circumstances and efforts would be to force the Antebellum South to accept Alice in spite of the prejudices of the day and the damage caused by forcing it. Alice has to be a 'successful businesswoman' in the same sense as AlCapone. She may get treated with modern respect but it is only because everyone is so afraid of her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Deconstructed''': While everything seems peachy at first there but it becomes increasingly clear that something wrong is happening with the timeline. [[AnachronismStew A few anachronisms ]][[OrphanedEtymology and inconsistent names start slipping through]] into society. It turns out that there is a heavy degree of meddling to achieve this tolerant history and it may result in some very nasty side effects....

to:

* '''Deconstructed''': While everything seems peachy at first there but it becomes increasingly clear that something wrong is happening with the timeline. [[AnachronismStew A few anachronisms ]][[OrphanedEtymology anachronisms]] [[OrphanedEtymology and inconsistent names start slipping through]] into society. It turns out that there is a heavy degree of meddling to achieve this tolerant history and it may result in some very nasty side effects....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* '''Deconstructed''': While everything seems peachy at first there but it becomes increasingly clear that something wrong is happening with the timeline. [[GlitchInTheMatrix A few anachronisms ]][[OrphanedEtymology and inconsistent names start slipping through]] into society. It turns out that there is a heavy degree of meddling to achieve this tolerant history and it may result in some very nasty side effects....

to:

* '''Deconstructed''': While everything seems peachy at first there but it becomes increasingly clear that something wrong is happening with the timeline. [[GlitchInTheMatrix [[AnachronismStew A few anachronisms ]][[OrphanedEtymology and inconsistent names start slipping through]] into society. It turns out that there is a heavy degree of meddling to achieve this tolerant history and it may result in some very nasty side effects....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The work is set in the modern days with the viewpoints of the past still unchanged [[DeliberateValueDissonance with all of its flaws]]. Alice is still considered property in an otherwise modern 2017.

to:

** The work is set in the modern days with the viewpoints of the past still unchanged [[DeliberateValueDissonance [[DeliberateValuesDissonance with all of its flaws]]. Alice is still considered property in an otherwise modern 2017.

Added: 621

Changed: 64

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The work is set in the modern days with the viewpoints of the past still unchanged [[DeliberateValueDissonance with all of its flaws]]. Alice is still considered property in an otherwise modern 2017.



* '''Deconstructed''': While everything seems peachy at first there but it becomes increasingly clear that something wrong is happening with the timeline. [[GlitchInTheMatrix A few anachronisms ]][[OrphanedEtymology and inconsistent names start slipping through]] into society. It turns out that there is a heavy degree of meddling to achieve this tolerant history and it may result in some very nasty side effects....



Back to PoliticallyCorrectHistory

to:

Back to PoliticallyCorrectHistoryYou and your ahistorical tolerance are perfectly welcome back in PoliticallyCorrectHistory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alice has to deal with racism that was appropriate for the time period, but doesn't deal with the type of sexism that was normal in that era.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even implying that she was (somewhat) better off as a slave.

to:

** The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even implying that she was (somewhat) [[HappinessInSlavery better off as a slave.slave]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Parodied''': ???

to:

* '''Parodied''': ???For some bizarre reason, ''UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler'' is depicted as openly promoting peace and equality between all people.

Added: 223

Changed: 89

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Exaggerated''': Not only does it feature the above situation, but the main characters are a FiveTokenBand

to:

* '''Exaggerated''': '''Exaggerated''':
**
Not only does it feature the above situation, but the main characters are a FiveTokenBandFiveTokenBand
** The depiction of history is so sanitized that [[ExceptionallyTolerant all kinds of bigotry and prejudice are glaringly absent]].

Added: 25

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** DeliberateValuesDissonance: Minorities (be they racial, sexual, religious, or anything else) are just as marginalized in-story as they would be in RealLife.

to:

** DeliberateValuesDissonance: Minorities (be they racial, sexual, religious, or anything else) are just as marginalized in-story as they would be have been in RealLife.


Added DiffLines:

** ArtisticLicenseHistory
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's a true story, or BasedOnATrueStory
** AlternateHistory is in effect.

to:

** It's a true story, or BasedOnATrueStory
BasedOnATrueStory.
** This is an AlternateHistory is in effect.story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Averted''': DeliberateValuesDissonance
** Minorities (be they racial, sexual, religious, or anything else) are just as marginalized in-story as they would be in RealLife.
** [[MonochromeCasting The cast consists entirely of]] {{White Male Lead}}s.

to:

* '''Averted''': DeliberateValuesDissonance
'''Averted''':
** DeliberateValuesDissonance: Minorities (be they racial, sexual, religious, or anything else) are just as marginalized in-story as they would be in RealLife.
RealLife.
** [[MonochromeCasting The cast consists entirely of]] {{White Male Lead}}s.

Changed: 31

Removed: 35

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's an Alternate Reality

to:

** It's an Alternate RealityAlternateHistory is in effect.



%%* '''Plotted A Good Waste''': ???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's an Alternate Reality

Changed: 161

Removed: 146

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Averted''':

to:

* '''Averted''':'''Averted''': DeliberateValuesDissonance



* '''Defied''': DeliberateValuesDissonance
** People just aren't ready to accept Alice, so they don't buy her dresses... and Alice eventually loses her business and goes back to square one.

to:

* '''Defied''': DeliberateValuesDissonance
**
People just aren't ready to accept Alice, so they don't buy her dresses... and Alice eventually loses her business and goes back to square one.

Changed: 26

Removed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Defied''':
** DeliberateValuesDissonance

to:

* '''Defied''':
**
'''Defied''': DeliberateValuesDissonance

Added: 175

Changed: 143

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Defied''': People just aren't ready to accept Alice, so they don't buy her dresses...and Alice eventually loses her business and goes back to square one.

to:

* '''Defied''': '''Defied''':
** DeliberateValuesDissonance
**
People just aren't ready to accept Alice, so they don't buy her dresses...dresses... and Alice eventually loses her business and goes back to square one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
unfortunate implications need citations


** The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even [[UnfortunateImplications implying that she was (somewhat) better off as a slave]].

to:

** The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even [[UnfortunateImplications implying that she was (somewhat) better off as a slave]].slave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Straight''': A story that takes place in the DeepSouth ''just'' after the AmericanCivilWar depicts Alice, a black woman, running a very successful business. None of the other characters blink.

to:

* '''Straight''': A story that takes place in the DeepSouth ''just'' after the AmericanCivilWar UsefulNotes/AmericanCivilWar depicts Alice, a black woman, running a very successful business. None of the other characters blink.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice is a FishOutOfTemporalWater from the modern era, and time-travels into a ball, where she gets funny looks for the color of her skin and the fact that she's wearing pants instead of a dress.

to:

** Alice is a FishOutOfTemporalWater from the modern era, and time-travels into a ball, where she gets funny looks for the color of her skin and the fact that she's wearing pants instead of a dress. The guards are also surprised when it turns out she can handle herself in a fight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She still gets to do things that ''any'' woman at the time, let alone a black woman, would get to do, and she's still very sympathetic to the audience.

to:

** She still gets to do things that ''any'' woman at the time, let alone a black woman, would be unlikely to get to do, and she's still very sympathetic to the audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice is not very well off at the beginning, but she gets married to Bob, a wealthy white man (who happens to be the son of her owner.)

to:

** Alice is not very well off at the beginning, but [[BlackGalOnWhiteGuyDrama she gets married to Bob, Bob]], a wealthy white man (who happens to be the son of her former owner.)

Added: 1191

Changed: 926

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
minor indentation fix


* '''Basic Trope''': A work that takes place in a different time period has situations and character relations suited to the tastes of modern audiences.

to:

* '''Basic Trope''': A work that takes place in a different time period has situations and character relations suited to the tastes of modern audiences.
audiences.



* '''Downplayed''': Some subtle hints that Alice might be [[AmbiguouslyGay a lesbian]] or [[BiTheWay bisexual]] are dropped.

to:

* '''Downplayed''': '''Downplayed''':
**
Some subtle hints that Alice might be [[AmbiguouslyGay a lesbian]] or [[BiTheWay bisexual]] are dropped.



* '''Justified''': Alice just has such a knack for business that no one cares ''what'' color she is or what her genitals look like.

to:

* '''Justified''': '''Justified''':
**
Alice just has such a knack for business that no one cares ''what'' color she is or what her genitals look like.



* '''Inverted''': The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even [[UnfortunateImplications implying that she was (somewhat) better off as a slave]].

to:

* '''Inverted''': '''Inverted''':
**
The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even [[UnfortunateImplications implying that she was (somewhat) better off as a slave]].



* '''Subverted''': Alice is [[TheOldestProfession a brothel madam]]. Most of her girls are young black women, and most of the clients are sleazy white men.

to:

* '''Subverted''': '''Subverted''':
**
Alice is [[TheOldestProfession a brothel madam]]. Most of her girls are young black women, and most of the clients are sleazy white men.



* '''Double Subverted''': She's managed to buy her way into high society, in an era where that would have been extraordinarily difficult for someone like Alice.

to:

* '''Double Subverted''': Subverted''':
**
She's managed to buy her way into high society, in an era where that would have been extraordinarily difficult for someone like Alice.



* '''Averted''': Minorities (be they racial, sexual, religious, or anything else) are just as marginalized in-story as they would be in RealLife.

to:

* '''Averted''': '''Averted''':
**
Minorities (be they racial, sexual, religious, or anything else) are just as marginalized in-story as they would be in RealLife.



* '''Enforced''': PositiveDiscrimination
** "We need to make our HistoricalDrama more palatable to women, gays, Jews, and people of color. Let's put in a RaceLift or something."

to:

* '''Enforced''': '''Enforced''':
**
PositiveDiscrimination
** "We need to make our HistoricalDrama historical drama more palatable to women, gays, Jews, and people of color. Let's put in a RaceLift or something."



* '''Conversed''': ???

to:

* '''Conversed''': ???
----
Back to PoliticallyCorrectHistory
----
%% Optional items, added after Conversed, at your discretion:
%%
%%* '''Implied''': ???
%%* '''Deconstructed''': ???
%%* '''Reconstructed''': ???
%%* '''Plotted A Good Waste''': ???
%%* '''Played For Laughs''': ???
%%* '''Played For Drama''':
???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** MinorityShowGhetto

Added: 1091

Changed: 1367

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Downplayed''':

to:

* '''Downplayed''': Some subtle hints that Alice might be [[AmbiguouslyGay a lesbian]] or [[BiTheWay bisexual]] are dropped.
** YouHaveToHaveJews, even when religious or cultural background wouldn't be really important to the story.



* '''Inverted''': The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even [[UnfortunateImplications implying that she was (somewhat) better off as a slave]].
* '''Subverted''': Alice is [[TheOldestProfession a brothel madam]]. Most of her girls are young black women, and most of the clients are white men.

to:

** It's a true story, or BasedOnATrueStory
* '''Inverted''': The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even [[UnfortunateImplications implying that she was (somewhat) better off as a slave]].
slave]].
** Alice is a FishOutOfTemporalWater from the modern era, and time-travels into a ball, where she gets funny looks for the color of her skin and the fact that she's wearing pants instead of a dress.
* '''Subverted''': Alice is [[TheOldestProfession a brothel madam]]. Most of her girls are young black women, and most of the clients are sleazy white men.



** Alice is a BlackBestFriend or a MagicalNegro to a white lead



Parodied: ???
Zig Zagged: ???
Averted: ???
Enforced: ???
Lampshaded: ???
Invoked: ???
Exploited: ???
Defied: ???
Discussed: ???
Conversed: ???

to:

Parodied: ???\n Zig Zagged: ???\n Averted: ???\n Enforced: ???\n Lampshaded: ???\n Invoked: ???\n Exploited: ???\n Defied: ???\n Discussed: ???\n Conversed: ** She still gets to do things that ''any'' woman at the time, let alone a black woman, would get to do, and she's still very sympathetic to the audience.
*'''Parodied''': ???
*'''Zig Zagged''': ???
*'''Averted''': Minorities (be they racial, sexual, religious, or anything else) are just as marginalized in-story as they would be in RealLife.
** [[MonochromeCasting The cast consists entirely of]] {{White Male Lead}}s.
*'''Enforced''': PositiveDiscrimination
** "We need to make our HistoricalDrama more palatable to women, gays, Jews, and people of color. Let's put in a RaceLift or something."
** "Wow! This actress is so awesome, we ''have'' to cast her in this role! Sure, we meant that role to go to a white woman, but maybe the audience won't notice (or at least won't mind.)"
** "Eh, [[BlackVikings she's just an extra anyway]]."
*'''Lampshaded''': ???
*'''Invoked''': Alice finds herself in need of money to feed her family now that she's free. She has a real talent for sewing (in fact, that's what she did as a slave), so she finds a way to get the materials she needs and starts a lucrative dressmaking business. ''Everyone'' loves her dresses.
*'''Exploited''': Alice uses her place in society to advance civil rights.
*'''Defied''': People just aren't ready to accept Alice, so they don't buy her dresses...and Alice eventually loses her business and goes back to square one.
*'''Discussed''': ???
*'''Conversed''':
???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*'''Basic Trope''': A work that takes place in a different time period has situations and character relations suited to the tastes of modern audiences.

*'''Straight''': A story that takes place in the DeepSouth ''just'' after the AmericanCivilWar depicts Alice, a black woman, running a very successful business. None of the other characters blink.
*'''Exaggerated''': Not only does it feature the above situation, but the main characters are a FiveTokenBand
*'''Downplayed''':
*'''Justified''': Alice just has such a knack for business that no one cares ''what'' color she is or what her genitals look like.
*'''Inverted''': The work depicts Alice as having lost ''everything'', even [[UnfortunateImplications implying that she was (somewhat) better off as a slave]].
*'''Subverted''': Alice is [[TheOldestProfession a brothel madam]]. Most of her girls are young black women, and most of the clients are white men.
** Alice is not very well off at the beginning, but she gets married to Bob, a wealthy white man (who happens to be the son of her owner.)
*'''Double Subverted''': She's managed to buy her way into high society, in an era where that would have been extraordinarily difficult for someone like Alice.
** They married for love, and it's shown that Bob clearly cares about her and respects her as a human being. None of their neighbors make any negative comments about their interracial marriage (which is also a real, legally-binding marriage at a time when it wouldn't be), and anyone that does is shown to be a less-than-sympathetic character.
Parodied: ???
Zig Zagged: ???
Averted: ???
Enforced: ???
Lampshaded: ???
Invoked: ???
Exploited: ???
Defied: ???
Discussed: ???
Conversed: ???

Top