History NightmareFuel / BattleForDreamIsland

[[/folder]]

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/img_7675.png]]

%% Image selected per Image Pickin' thread: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=17023706690.86677700

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/i_am_next_level_mad.png]]
[[caption-width-right:350:I. AM NEXT LEVEL. '''''MAD.''''']]
%%
%% Caption selected per most recent thread. Please don't change or remove without approval from here:
%% https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=1404492079030138900
%%

** Yellow Face gets eliminated at the Cake At Stake, but instead of being flung to the WTF he instead gets trapped in the Eifel Tower and dies from being submerged in acid instead, with his screams being heard while he does so.

*** Also the way the acid itself seems to crawl like a living thing.

** Puffball Speaker Box [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill mutilates Book]] for [[DisproportionateRetribution reading the word "lips" in the compactor chamber]] because she read Ruby's lips before in a case of ExactWords. The animation becomes much smoother in this segment to better sell Book's violent demise.

* In BFDIA 9, Puffball Speaker Box [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill mutilates Book]] for [[DisproportionateRetribution reading the word "lips" in the compactor chamber]] because she read Ruby's lips before in a case of ExactWords. The animation becomes much smoother in this segment to better sell Book's violent demise.

* In "Don't Lose Your Marbles", the remaining contestants and the recommended characters willingly threw themselves into a pit of Hydrochloric Acid so that they could grab the [[{{Sadist}} Announcer's]] marble collection to earn 15 bonus points.

* In "Don't lose your marbles" the remaining contestants and the recommended characters willingly threw themselves into a pit of Hydrochloric Acid so that they could grab the [[{{Sadist}} Announcer's]] marble collection to earn 15 bonus points.
* Snowball unintentionally causing more than a single death he caused, due to Leafy's ball just bouncing off of Pencil in Don't Lose Your Marbles.

* In BFDIA 9, Puffball [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill mutilates Book]] for [[DisproportionateRetribution reading the word "lips" in the compactor chamber]] because she read Ruby's lips before in a case of ExactWords. The animation becomes much smoother in this segment to better sell Book's violent demise.

* In BFDIA 9, Puffball [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill mutilates Book]] for [[DisproportionateRetribution reading the word "lips" in the compactor chamber because she read Ruby's lips before in a case of ExactWords. The animation becomes much smoother in this segment to better sell Book's violent demise.

* How about that time a bunch of contestants and also recommended characters willingly threw themselves into a pit of Hydrochloric Acid so that they could grab the [[{{Sadist}} Announcer's]] marble collection?

*** Also with Two, there is a subtle hint that they're EvilAllAlong, as it is shown where Pie is. In a hotel that's upside down. She can't leave ever. She can't starve (as objects can't starve),[[AndIMustScream nor can she kill herself]]. And what makes this even worse is the fact that it is implied ''all the eliminated contestants suffered a similar fate.''

** The stinger for the episode, Coiny approaches Fries and "deep fries" his breaths. And by "deep fries", we mean dunking his body into '''''BOILING''''' oil and screaming while Fries screams at him to stop, [[GoryDiscretionShot which we cut away from]]. And then there is Leafy, who is still AxCrazy, and tries to stab both Fries and Coiny before being deeply disturbed by what she sees and hides away.

* Lollipop scams Death P.A.C.T. with fork repellent, essentially exploiting their HonorBeforeReason as the fork repellant at first repels forks as advertised in BFB 3, but in BFB 4, it starts to attract forks, and the forks start flying towards Four, meaning that Death P.A.C.T. was risking getting ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice.

** Even without Four, the eliminations are still unsettling. Case in point's 8-Ball, he flat out '''dies''' from getting crushed by the earth and the moon. While the death itself isn't scary, halfway through being crushed, his face goes to a teeth frown with his eyes spreading out, indicating he died sad. He gets better in BFB 10, but is sucked into Four not even a second after being resurrected. Loser gets eliminated as well, and gets trapped in a giant jawbreaker like how Taco did, only this time inside-out meaning that Loser cannot hear anything outside.

* Pretty much the entirety of BFB 7. Loser getting trapped in an inside-out jawbreaker by Donut, the "data void" Robot Flower is in ''(and then it downloads a bomb)'', Remote's glitch, [[AndIMustScream Loser flying off into endless space]], Stapy popping Balloony's head, Woody [[HalfTheWomanSheUsedToBe ripping Foldy in half]] (this is his first kill by the way), Naily impaling Bell just to take the Liar Ball from her (and Needle doing the same thing to Naily off-screen), and, albeit very brief, the giant Four coming towards the screen in space. His small, spread-apart eyes (compared to his cartoony, big eyes) bring up uncanny vibes.
** Also, notice how Fanny gets angrier and angrier as she rants toward Loser? It makes her sound serious and rather intimidating. This definitely falls into SugarWiki/HeReallyCanAct.
* The ways the contestants try to bring Four back are usually silly (Pillow licking Lollipop, Bottle hitting Golf Ball with a club, Gelatin bending a fork...). Then the contestants try breaking one of X's legs to make the shape of Four. Keep in mind that the leg X had broken was the same one he had bandaged up in “Fortunate Ben”. The last attempt is Firey stabbing Donut with a syringe and then getting whatever is inside of him through it. Sure, they got Four back (albeit liquified), but it looked like they sucked out some of Donut’s cherry filling along with it. He looks like an onion ring when Four is sucked out.

%% * Firey getting stuffed into the sun.

* Four's acid trip-like mirage from getting hurt by Firey Jr.'s flames in BFB 16. It borders on SugarWiki/{{Funny|Moments}} as well.

* BFB 20 has the Have Cots (except Lollipop, who got obliterated by a laser from Leafy) nearly ''suffocate due to lack of oxygen in space.''

** We find out in BFB 22. It's a [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin big rotating building]] in the sky spinning the eliminated contestants around in cages. While it's not as bad as isolating others, it still is torturing the characters with their fears, though at seem to get over it once Blocky releases 58 pages of Donut's diary online.
* During Woody's testimony in BFB 22, both Leafy and Taco look really creepy. Leafy has [[RedEyesTakeWarning red eyes]] and Taco has snakes coming out of her shell (although, they were actually jumping rope together). Four on the other hand...

* In BFB 23, Purple Face escapes from his box, chasing the members of the Have-Cots around the warehouse, and eventually eating them. ''Alive'' (although they manage to protect themselves from the stomach acid with Flower's sweaters).

* In BFDIA 5d, Yellow Face's corpse was left glued down in the desert. Cake encounters its skeleton ten years later in Gardening Zero. Also, any water it touches is apparently ''cursed.'' The Funny Plant immediately disintegrates upon coming into contact with the cursed water.

* Puffball forcing Death P.A.C.T Again to make a SadisticChoice, either they save Ice Cube from slowly dying in a very horrible and painful way, or complete their challenge, in TPOT 4.

* In BFDIA 5d, Freesmart drive the Supervan through the Goiky Canal, '''which is over 500 miles''', to get to Yoyleland. This means everyone on Freesmart dies multiple times throughout the journey as they are travelling through water with no oxygen to breath, meaning they have to be recovered multiple times. When they reach Yoyleland, thousands upon thousands of dead bodies litter the bed of the canal in the end. The fact that no music plays until the end of this part makes it more ominous.

** Special mention goes to the ending of Episode 5a. Freesmart gets swallowed up by Evil Leafy, and the remaining two minutes are Evil Leafy standing on the edge of a cliff with quiet music in the background. It's surprisingly unsettling.

* In BFDIA 5d, Freesmart travel through the Goiky Canal, '''which is over 500 miles''', to get to Yoyleland. This means everyone on Freesmart dies multiple times throughout the journey, meaning they have to be recovered multiple times. When they reach Yoyleland, thousands upon thousands of dead bodies litter the bed of the canal.

** The stinger for the episode, Coiny approaches Fries and "deep fries" his breaths. And by "deep fries" we mean dunking his body into '''''BOILING''''' oil and screaming while Fries screams at him to stop. And then there is Leafy, who is still AxCrazy, and tries to stab both Fries and Coiny before being deeply disturbed by what she sees and hides away.

* Lollipop scams Death P.A.C.T. with fork repellent, essentially exploiting their HonorBeforeReason as the fork repellant at first repels forks as advertised in BFB 3, but in BFB 4, it starts to attract forks, and the forks start flying towards Four meaning that Death P.A.C.T. was risking getting ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice.

* Pretty much the entirety of BFB 7. Loser getting trapped in an inside out jawbreaker by Donut, the "data void" Robot Flower is in ''(and then it downloads a bomb)'', Remote's glitch, [[AndIMustScream Loser flying off into endless space]], Stapy popping Balloony's head, Woody [[HalfTheWomanSheUsedToBe ripping Foldy in half]] (this is his first kill by the way), Naily impaling Bell just to take the Liar Ball from her (and Needle doing the same thing to Naily off-screen), and, albeit very brief, the giant Four coming towards the screen in space. His small, spread-apart eyes (compared to his cartoony, big eyes) bring up uncanny vibes.

* Four pulling four fingers out of Balloony's hand. It's just unexpected and it sounds like Four is [[AccidentalInnuendo doing something questionable with him when taken out of context]]. Not to mention how he's sounding like he's in pure agony.

* In the stinger for Take the Tower, Lollipop has to put up with Ruby and Leafy's awful singing, and she falls into a SanitySlippage. Doubles as a SugarWiki/{{FunnyMoment|s}}.

* Much like BFB 7, BFB 19 is also chock full of NightmareFuel. Lollipop's continued (and arguably worse than before) torment in the beginning, Woody burning to death (''all on screen, no less''), X still burning (and he survives it), and the Have Nots burning to death near the sun. The cherry on top? This is Loser's first death. ''Ye gods...''

-->'''Four''': Just watch this: I'll be a constant presence! You'll NEVER get rid of me! (Melts into the floor) ''Mwahahahahaha, I'll be here'' '''''FOREVER!'''''

* Four becoming next-level mad. ''Definitely'' the angriest we ever see Four. Holy crap. The sky turning red with the menacing angle and Four's eyes becoming black help sell the scene.

* Lollipop also scams others with fork attractant. [[ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice Think about it.]]

** Pencil's elimination where she screams and gets sucked into Four in a split second.
** Liy "restraining herself" in Fortunate Ben.
** Even without Four, the eliminations are still unsettling. Case in point's 8-Ball he flat out '''dies''' from getting crushed by the earth and the moon. While the death itself isn't scary, halfway through being crushed, his face goes to a teeth frown with his eyes spreading out, indicating he died sad. He gets better in BFB 10, but is sucked into Four not even a second after being resurrected. Loser gets eliminated as well, and got trapped in a giant jawbreaker like how Taco did.

* Four's acid trip-like mirage from getting hurt by Firey Jr.'s flames in BFB 16.

* Ice Cube has her moments of being AxCrazy. She once left a bunch of contestants to fall off of a cliff for being mistreated by some. Another time, she imagines some of former [=FreeSmart=] burning to death.

* Ice Cube and Teardrop's "happy thoughts" in "The Four is Lava" are disturbing. Ice Cube thinks of her own friends burning for revenge. Teardrop's is her disturbingly smashing windows with a hammer, and Pillow tells her she can't do that, but smashes Pillow anyway. To make matters even worse, she screams.

* Pillow. Yes, most of her moments are PlayedForLaughs, but imagine a human genuinely acting like her.

** Pillow's AxCrazy personality is taken up a notch when she starts murdering the rest of her team one by one, since she believes the challenge is ''really'' about "two teams--completely wiped out--". She eventually decides to cover herself in Book's remains and, on top of that, gets a chunk torn out of her by Price Tag, making her look almost terrifying.
** Two in their zombified state is... unnerving, to say the least. They're locked into a blank pose with an equally-blank facial expression, the few lines they get before we actually see them are whispered by Niall Burns in a voice that barely sounds anything like them, they ''glide'' instead of walking, they only seem to care about teleporting the contestants to the elimination area, and they get more sloppily-drawn between the two times they appear -- almost as if their appearance is uncontrollably degrading.

* The contestants ripping Leafy in half to see the "real Leafy". It's played for laughs, but seems that would be cruel enough. [[MoodWhiplash However, all tension is thrown out the window when it’s revealed that she’s actually a football/rugby ball.]]

* Leafy's anger issues. Period. She tried to murder Gelatin, Needle and Puffball by throwing knives at them and successfully dodged several “Acid Spitballs” they shot at her. Just because [[DisproportionateRetribution Needle slapped her.]]

* In “Welcome Back”, Evil Leafy shows up in the science museum for a split second.