History NightmareFuel / BattleForDreamIsland

* Four becoming thin (even thinner than Donut did when he was sucked out of him) and [[DisproportionateRetribution killing Baseball]] [[KilledOffScreen off-screen]] for calling him [[YouAreFat "pudgy"]]!

* Four becoming thin (even thinner than Donut did when he was sucked out of him) and [[DisproportionateRetribution killing Baseball]] [[KilledOffScreen off-screen]] for calling him [[YouAreFat "pudgy"]]!

* Four becoming thin (even thinner than Donut did when he was sucked out of him) and [[DisproportionateRetribution killing Baseball]] [[KilledOffScreen off-screen]] for calling him [[YouAreFat "pudgy"]]!
-> di

* Ice Cube and Teardrop's "happy thoughts" in "The Four is Lava" are disturbing. Ice Cube thinks of her own friends burning for revenge. Teardrop's is her disturbingly smashing windows with a hammer, and Pillow tells her she can't do that, but smashes Pillow anyway. To make matters even worse, she screams.

* Ice Cube and Teardrop's "happy thoughts" in "The Four is Lava" are disturbing. Ice Cube thinks of her own friends burning for revenge. Teardrop's is her disturbingly smashing windows with a hammer, and Pillow tells her she can't do that, but smashes Pillow anyway. To make matters even worse, she screams.
* The entirety of BFB 16. Not funny at all.

* The contestants ripping Leafy in half to see the “real Leafy”. [[PlayedForLaughs However, all tension is thrown out the window when it’s revealed that she’s actually a football/rugby ball.]]

* Ice Cube and Teardrop's "happy thoughts" in "The Four is Lava" are disturbing. Ice Cube thinks of her own friends burning for revenge. Teardrop's is her disturbingly smashing windows with a hammer, and Pillow tells her she can't do that, but smashes Pillow anyway. To make matters even worse, she screams.

* Ice Cube and Teardrop's "happy thoughts" in "The Four is Lava" are disturbing. Ice Cube thinks of her own friends burning for revenge. Teardrops disturbingly smashes things with a hammer, and Pillow says she can't break that, but smashes Pillow anyway. To make matters even worse, she screams.

* Ice Cube and Teardrops "happy thoughts" in "The Four is Lava" are disturbing. Ice Cube thinks of her own friends burning for revenge. Teardrops disturbingly smashes things with a hammer, and Pillow says she can't break that, but smashes Pillow anyway. To make matters even worse, she screams.

* In BFB 14, several arms wriggle out of Four's mouth one by one like snakes as the background gets darker and the music slows down. [[spoiler:Fortunately, it's just the arms of [[ItMakesSenseInContext Death P.A.C.T. members inside Four]].]]

* In BFB 14, several arms wriggle out of Four's mouth one by one like snakes as the background gets darker and the music slows down.

* In BFB 14, several arms wriggle out of Four's mouth one by one like snakes as the background gets darker and the music is distorted.

* In BFB 14 Several arms wriggle out of Four's mouth one by one like snakes as the background gets darker and the music is distorted.

* In "Happy Birthday, Battle for BFDI", the contestants are eating Cake. Yes, Cake with a capital "C", their friend and fellow competitor.

Yes, even a child-friendly, lighthearted show like Battle for Dream Island can have its [[NightmareFuel scary moments]].

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/cfe4e8cd_9242_45ac_b293_5e49fb9decd3.jpeg]]

[[caption-width-right:350:”[[TemptingFate We should be safe here...]]”]]

* ''A lot'' of stuff in BFB 7. The violence of the contestants. The "data void" Robot Flower is in ([[spoiler: And then it downloads a bomb.]]). Remote's condition. And [[AndIMustScream Loser flying off into endless space.]] Oh my gosh.

* The contestants ripping Leafy in half to see the “real Leafy”. [[PlayedForLaughs However, all tension is thrown out the window when it’s revealed that she’s actually a football/rugby ball.]]

* Not like the actual Leafy was that better when she reappeared in the same episode. She tried to murder Gelatin, Needle and Puffball by throwing knives at them and successfully dodged several “Acid Spitballs” the three shot back at her.

** This troper is pretty sure the leg X had broken was the same one he had bandaged up in “Fortunate Ben”.

* Eraser's fear of pentagons. Sure, it's mostly PlayedForLaughs, but it can be pretty ubsettling, e.g. the stinger of BFB 12.

* Eraser's fear of pentagons. Sure, it's mostly [[PlayedForLaughs]], but it can be pretty ubsettling, e.g. the stinger of BFB 12.

* ''A lot'' of stuff in BFB 7. The violence of the contestants. The "data void" Robot Flower is in ([[Spoiler And then it downloads a bomb.]]). Remote's condition. And [[AndIMustScream Loser flying off into endless space.]] Oh my gosh.

* Fanny's death by decapitation in BFB 11 is rather unsettling. Rather than dying violently or cartoonishly like other contestants, she just lays there lifelessly after she is killed. [[spoiler: In BFB 12, it's revealed [[DisneyDeath she survived her decapitation]], but she has to drag her head on the ground because it's only connected to her body by its cable. The way she looks when decapitated is both disturbing and [[BlackComedy funny]].]]

Yes, even a child-friendly, lighthearted show like BFDI can have its [[NightmareFuel scary moments]].

BFDI is supposed to be a light hearted cartoon. But then there are THESE moments.

* For starters, Evil Leafy. Sure she’s just a color swap of Leafy with bulging eyes. But then she reappeared in “Get Digging”. In that episode, she chased down Book, Ice Cube and Spongy, teleported over to them over a long while away (pictured) and then randomly sank into Spongy when he collapsed. [[CrossesTheLineTwice Pencil and Match seemed pretty happy about the latter.]]

* There's something pretty creepy about the Jumpscare of the pentagon shaking around in the first few seconds of "Getting Teardrop to Talk".

* Fanny's death by decapitation in BFB 11 is rather unsettling. Rather than dying violently or cartoonishly like other contestants, she just lays there lifelessly after she is killed. [[spoiler: In BFB 12, it's revealed she survived her decapitation, but she has to drag her head on the ground because it's only connected to her body by its cable. The way she looks when decapitated is both disturbing and [[BlackComedy funny]].]]

** This troper is pretty sure the leg X had broken was the same one he had bandaged up in “Fortunate Ben”.

** It's implied she's a Genius Loci as well. Why? BFDIA 5B is a game set inside Evil Leafy after Freesmart, Golf Ball, Tennis Ball and Rocky are swallowed by her. It's actually pretty creepy. A red ground, grey skies, spike death traps... and what is with that music?

** Even without Four, the eliminations are still unsettling. Case in point's [[spoiler:8-Ball]] he flat out '''dies''' form getting crushed by the earth and the moon.[[spoiler:He gets better in BFB 10, but is sucked into Four not even a second after being resurrected.]]

* One of the ways the contestants try bringing Four back is by breaking X’s legs. The last attempt is Firey stabbing Donut with a syringe and then pulling on it. Sure, they got Four back (albeit liquified), but it looked like they sucked out some of Donut’s insides along with it.

* One of the ways the contestants try bringing Four back is by breaking X’s legs. The last attempt is Firey stabbing Donut with a syringe and then pulling on it. Sure, they got Four back (albeit liquified), but it looked like they sucked out some of Donut’s inside along with it.