Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Manga / KanojoNiNaruHi

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StepfordSmiler: Kurokawa hides a seething mass of guilt under her calm, cool, kind exterior and her secret joy that Sagara has emerged is just one more thing to feel guilty about. She even tells Shima "The real me is ugly" after he discovers her secret.

to:

* StepfordSmiler: Kurokawa hides a seething mass of guilt and self loathing under her calm, cool, kind exterior and her secret joy that Sagara has emerged is just one more thing to feel guilty about. She even tells Shima "The real me is ugly" after he discovers she tells him her secret.

Added: 489

Changed: 108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoolBigSis: Nao and Miki are still extremely close. Miki's friends even comment on Nao's "Big Sister Complex"

to:

* CoolBigSis: Nao and Miki are still extremely close.close and she spoils Miki unmercifully. Miki's friends even comment on Nao's "Big Sister Complex"



* TheGadfly: Shima needles Sagara and Kurokawa relentlessly until he discovers their secrets... then appears taken aback by what her learns, especially from Kurokawa.



* KnightTemplarBigSister: Nao. Played for laughs when she harasses Narumi.



* OneHeadTaller: Narumi and Sagara, underscoring their OTP status
* TheNickNamer: Miki. Kurokawa is "Ayaya" and Sagara is "Rinrin". Ironically she doesn't have a nickname for her oldest friend, Narumi, though she is on a first name basis with him.



* StepfordSmiler: Kurokawa hides a seething mass of guilt under her calm, cool, kind exterior, and her secret joy that Sagara has emerged is just one more thing to feel guilty about.

to:

* StepfordSmiler: Kurokawa hides a seething mass of guilt under her calm, cool, kind exterior, exterior and her secret joy that Sagara has emerged is just one more thing to feel guilty about.about. She even tells Shima "The real me is ugly" after he discovers her secret.

Added: 369

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoolBigSis: Mamiya Miki practically worships her big sister Nao.



* CoolBigSis: Nao and Miki are still extremely close. Miki's friends even comment on Nao's "Big Sister Complex"



* HeroOfAnotherStory: Mamiya Nao's little sister is a classmate, and Nao herself is Narumi's neighbor and Sagara's therapist.

to:

* HeroOfAnotherStory: Mamiya Nao's little sister Miki is a classmate, and Narumi's lifelong friend. Nao herself is Narumi's neighbor and Sagara's therapist.


Added DiffLines:

* RememberTheNewGuy: Miki doesn't show up as a named character until Chapter 10, though she is depicted as an extra in Chapter One (as the girl who accidentally squirts Sagara with the hose.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the sequel ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another'' Sagara, a short, slight, and girly-looking boy who has cultivated a tough-guy image to compensate emerges as a girl during his third year of middle school and is forced to confront a stark choice between maintaining his identity as a boy and forging a new identity as a girl, a choice only complicated by a new attraction to Narumi, his rival for the affections of the cool, collected class representative Kurokawa.

to:

In the sequel ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another'' Sagara, a short, slight, and girly-looking boy who has cultivated a tough-guy image to compensate emerges as a girl during halfway through his third second year of middle school and is forced to confront a stark choice between maintaining his identity as a boy and forging a new identity as a girl, a choice only complicated by a new attraction to Narumi, his rival for the affections of the cool, collected class representative Kurokawa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** FirstLawOfGenderBending: Reversions to male are not unheard of but very rare..

to:

** FirstLawOfGenderBending: Emergence is always male to female. Reversions to male are not unheard of but very rare..rare.

Added: 182

Changed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StepfordSmiler: Kurokawa hides a seething mass of guilt under her calm, cool, kind exterior, and her secret joy that Sagara has emerged is just one more thing to feel guilty about.



* SadisticChoice: Poor Sagara. A relationship with Narumi would force him to publicly re-identify as a girl, but a relationship with Kurokawa would also require him to admit to being a girl in private even if he remained a boy in public. Either course requires surrendering some aspect of his identity.

to:

* SadisticChoice: Poor Sagara. A relationship with Narumi would might force him to publicly re-identify as a girl, but a relationship with Kurokawa would also require him to admit to being be a girl in private even if he remained a boy in public. Either course requires surrendering some aspect of his identity. Kurokawa recognises the dilemma, even if Sagara does not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge. But their more-or-less friendly rivalry is broken when Mamiya is hospitalized and turns into a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is maintained by a process called "emergence": when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]]. While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

to:

Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge. But their more-or-less friendly rivalry is broken when Mamiya is hospitalized and turns into a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is maintained by a process called "emergence": when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]]. While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

Added: 458

Changed: 478

Removed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Kanojo ni Naru Hi (The day he became a girl)

Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge, until the day Mamiya collapses and is hospitalized for weeks turning into a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is maintained by a process called "emergence": when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]]. While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

to:

Kanojo ni Naru Hi (The day he became a girl)

girl) is a Manga series by Ogura Akane

Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge, until the day challenge. But their more-or-less friendly rivalry is broken when Mamiya collapses and is hospitalized for weeks turning and turns into a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is maintained by a process called "emergence": when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]]. While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.



Manga by Ogura Akane



* AlwaysSecondBest: Miyoshi is constantly challenging and losing to Mamiya, be it soccer, Aikido, or academics...until she emerges. She still beats him in academics



* IfItsYouItsOK: Mamiya takes advantage of this to help Miyoshi work through his gynephobia, but later decides it's also the reason why Miyoshi is the only boy she's interested in.

to:

* IfItsYouItsOK: Mamiya takes advantage of this to help Miyoshi work through his gynephobia, but gynephobia and later decides it's also the reason why Miyoshi is the only boy she's interested in. [[spoiler: It also inspires her to extend her second emergence until she's sure she'll remain a girl for Miyoshi's sake and ironically she emerges just after he finally admits that he'd still love her if she turned back into a boy.]]



* StepfordSmiler: Mamiya keeps up a solid front and only breaks down when it becomes apparent she can no longer compete physically with Miyoshi.



* ReplacementGoldfish: Kurokawa is a voluntary replacement goldfish for her older sister Aya, because of the guilt she feels over her sister's death.



* TheMindIsThePlaythingOfTheBody: subverted: gender identity and presentation appear subject more to social pressures than biology. Their is no indication that either Sagara or Kurokawa's sexuality was affected by their transformations and their choices of gender identity and presentation appear to be due more to timing and social circumstances. Kurokawa emerged in elementary school and may not have been able to hide it even if she wanted to, presuming her parents would have allowed it, whereas Sagara was already compensating for his girly appearance.

to:

* TheMindIsThePlaythingOfTheBody: subverted: gender identity and presentation appear subject more to social pressures than biology. Their There is no indication that either Sagara or Kurokawa's sexuality was affected by their transformations and their choices of gender identity and presentation appear to be due more to timing and social circumstances. Kurokawa emerged in elementary school and may not have been able to hide it even if she wanted to, presuming was promptly turned into a ReplacementGoldfish for her parents would have allowed it, dead sister by her parents, whereas Sagara was already compensating for his girly appearance.

Added: 170

Changed: 255

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BecauseYouWereNiceToMe: A recursive example: Sagara is grateful for Kurokawa's kindness, unaware that she's repaying him for his kindness in the past.

to:

* BabiesEverAfter: the sequel reveals that Mamiya and Miyoshi eventually did get married and Mamiya, despite her fears, is a happy young mother.
* BecauseYouWereNiceToMe: A recursive example: Sagara is grateful for Kurokawa's kindness, unaware that she's repaying him for his the kindness he showed her in the past.grade school.



* ThirdLawOfGenderBending: subverted, which actually causes more problems for Sagara than playing it straight: the boy's uniform fits him poorly now and he can't remove his jacket or his sweatsuit top during gym.

to:

* ThirdLawOfGenderBending: subverted, which actually causes more problems for Sagara than playing it straight: the boy's uniform fits uniforms fit him poorly now and he can't remove his jacket or his sweatsuit top during gym.no matter how hot he gets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge, until the day Mamiya collapses and is hospitalized for weeks as he turns into a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is maintained by a process called "emergence": when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]]. While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

to:

Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge, until the day Mamiya collapses and is hospitalized for weeks as he turns turning into a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is maintained by a process called "emergence": when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]]. While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

Added: 312

Changed: 47

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SadisticChoice: Poor Sagara. A relatioship with apparently straight Narumi will probably force him to publically re-identify as a girl, but a relationship with Kurokawa would probably also require him to admit to being a girl in private even if he remained a boy in public. Either course requires surrendering some aspect of his identity

to:

* SadisticChoice: Poor Sagara. A relatioship relationship with apparently straight Narumi will probably would force him to publically publicly re-identify as a girl, but a relationship with Kurokawa would probably also require him to admit to being a girl in private even if he remained a boy in public. Either course requires surrendering some aspect of his identityidentity.
* SecretKeeper: Narumi and Kurokawa both agree to keep Sagara's secret, each for their own reasons.


Added DiffLines:

* ThirdLawOfGenderBending: subverted, which actually causes more problems for Sagara than playing it straight: the boy's uniform fits him poorly now and he can't remove his jacket or his sweatsuit top during gym.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoggedNiceGuy: Miyoshi [[spoiler: dogged enough that he's willing to wait ''five years'' for Mamiya to wake from her coma.]]

to:

* DoggedNiceGuy: Miyoshi [[spoiler: dogged enough that he's willing to wait ''five years'' for Mamiya to wake from her coma.second emergence.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for two weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]] in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

to:

Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, challenge, until the day Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for two weeks, only to return weeks as he turns into a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: maintained by a process called "emergence": when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]] in a process known as "emergence".girls]]. While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.



* AttractiveBentGender: A common result of emergence, which conversely just serves to reinforce prejudice against emerged people.

to:

* AttractiveBentGender: A common result of emergence, which conversely just serves to reinforce is one reason why there's a lot of prejudice against emerged people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DoggedNiceGuy: Miyoshi [[spoiler: dogged enough that he's willing to wait ''five years'' for Mamiya to wake from her coma.]]

Added: 566

Changed: 25

Removed: 105

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllergicToLove: Mamiya has severe intimacy issues stemming from the breakup of her parent's marriage.



* CompensatingForSomething: Mamiya's drive to excel at everything turns out to have some very ugly roots.



* FreudianExcuse: Mamiya's deep psychological need to excel at everything--even femininity-- comes from her sense of ParentalAbandonment, which her emergence only complicates by making her resemble the mother she hates.

to:

* FreudianExcuse: Mamiya's deep psychological need to excel at everything--even femininity-- comes femininity--comes from her sense of ParentalAbandonment, which her emergence only complicates by making her resemble the mother she hates.who abandoned her.



** SecondLawOFGenderBending: Played with Mamiya seems to throw herself into feminity the same way she's attacked every other challenge, but Miyoshi soon realizes she's masking deeper psychological issues.

to:

** SecondLawOFGenderBending: Played with Mamiya seems to throw herself into feminity femininity the same way she's attacked every other challenge, but Miyoshi soon realizes she's masking deeper psychological issues.



* LastNameBasis: Miyoshi and Mamiya don't use each other's given names, Kyousuke and Nao. In fact, they don't even start using each other's given names until Miyoshi proposes, after they'd been dating for years and already have a sexual relationship



* CompensatingForSomething: Mamiya's drive to excel at everything turns out to have some very ugly roots.


Added DiffLines:

* StarCrossedLovers: Mamiya and Miyoshi, especially since they keep unintentionally friendzoning each other.

Added: 276

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]] in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

to:

Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several two weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]] in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.



* AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable and freely given and returned.

to:

* AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable unequivocal and freely given and returned.


Added DiffLines:

* IfItsYouItsOK: Mamiya takes advantage of this to help Miyoshi work through his gynephobia, but later decides it's also the reason why Miyoshi is the only boy she's interested in.


Added DiffLines:

* ShamelessFanserviceGirl: Mamiya in her first bikini. Miyoshi figures she's overcompensating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Metamorphosis}}:the method of transformation, including cocoons.

Added: 160

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable and freely given and returned

to:

* AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable and freely given and returnedreturned.
* AttractiveBentGender: A common result of emergence, which conversely just serves to reinforce prejudice against emerged people.


Added DiffLines:

* GiftOfTheMagiPlot: Chapter 13
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]] in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly changing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

to:

Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls]] in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly changing developing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.



* AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable and freely

to:

* AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable and freely given and returned
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FreudianExcuse: Mamiya's deep psychological need to excel at everything--even femininity-- comes from her sense of ParentalAbandonment, which her emergence only complicates by making him resemble the mother she hates.

to:

* FreudianExcuse: Mamiya's deep psychological need to excel at everything--even femininity-- comes from her sense of ParentalAbandonment, which her emergence only complicates by making him her resemble the mother she hates.



* StrongFamilyResemblance: Post-emergence Mamiya looks remarkably like her hated MissingMom,

to:

* StrongFamilyResemblance: Post-emergence Mamiya looks remarkably like the MissingMom who abandoned her, causing her hated MissingMom, much angst.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the sequel ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another'' Sagara, a short, slight, and girly-looking boy who has cultivated a tough-guy image to compensate becomes a girl during his third year of middle school and is forced to confront a stark choice between maintaining his identity as a boy and forging a new identity as a girl, a choice only complicated by a new attraction to Narumi, his rival for the affections of the cool, collected class representative Kurokawa.

to:

In the sequel ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another'' Sagara, a short, slight, and girly-looking boy who has cultivated a tough-guy image to compensate becomes emerges as a girl during his third year of middle school and is forced to confront a stark choice between maintaining his identity as a boy and forging a new identity as a girl, a choice only complicated by a new attraction to Narumi, his rival for the affections of the cool, collected class representative Kurokawa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MissingMom: Mamiya has severe abandonment issues that stem from being his mother, who abandoned Mamiya and his father only to turn right around and start a new family with another man.

to:

* MissingMom: Mamiya has severe abandonment issues that stem from being because his mother, who mother abandoned Mamiya and his father only to turn right around and start a new family with another man.

Added: 945

Changed: 2545

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable and freely returned

to:

* AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable and freely returned freely






* FantasticRacism: Turns out there can be a good deal of prejudice against the emerged.
* HeroOfAnotherStory: Mamiya Nao's little sister is a classmate, and Nao herself is Sagara's therapist.
* IncompatibleOrientation: After Sagara emerges Kurokawa reveals that neither he nor Narumi ever really had a chance with her because she's a lesbian.
* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Kurokawa breaks up with Sagara when it becomes obvious (to her, he's still clueless) that Sagara is really in love with Narumi.
* LateArrivalSpoiler: the two manga are published concurrently, meaning readers of the second already know that Mamiya and Miyoshi's sometimes rocky relaationship will have an eventual happy ending.

to:

* BecauseYouWereNiceToMe: A recursive example: Sagara is grateful for Kurokawa's kindness, unaware that she's repaying him for his kindness in the past.
* DifferentForGirls: Even though Sagara is hiding his GenderBender he still has to deal with his physical changes, mainly (aside from the obvious) decreased strength and increased flexibility.
* FantasticRacism: Turns It turns out there can be a good deal of prejudice against the emerged.
* HeroOfAnotherStory: Mamiya Nao's little sister is a classmate, and Nao herself is Narumi's neighbor and Sagara's therapist.
* IfItsYouItsOK: It's not clear if Kurokawa would be willing to accept a lover who is only physically female, though she does appear to be willing to give it a try. The jury's still out on Narumi.
* IncompatibleOrientation: After Sagara emerges Kurokawa reveals that neither he nor Narumi ever really had a chance with wooing her because she's a lesbian.
* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Kurokawa breaks up with Sagara when it becomes obvious (to her, he's still clueless) that Sagara is really in love actually smitten with Narumi.
* LadyLooksLikeADude: Sagara sucessfully hides his GenderBender because he's always been small and has no figure to speak of.
* LateArrivalSpoiler: the two manga are published concurrently, meaning readers of the second title already know that Mamiya and Miyoshi's sometimes rocky relaationship relationship will have an eventual happy ending.ending.
* ObliviousToLove: Sagara either can't understand or is unwilling to admit why Narumi flusters him.



* RescueRomance: Kurokawa is thrilled to discover that Sagara is now a girl because he saved her from bullies back in elementary school.
* SchoolgirlLesbians: Kurokawa is thrilled Sagara is physically a girl and wants him to be her girl in private, his insistence on maintaining an outward identity as a boy would just relieve her of the additional social burder of coming out of the closet on top of the stigma of being an emerged girl.
* TheMindIsThePlaythingOfTheBody: subverted: Gender identity and, to a lesser extent, Gender presentation appears more subject to social pressures than biology. Neither Sagara nor Kurokawa's sexuality appears to have been affected by their emergence and their gender presentation and identity appears to have been affected more by the timing and social circumstances of their emergence than the physical transformation itself.
* TheirAreNoTherapists: subverted. The protagonist of ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi'' is the protagonist's therapist in ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another''
* TriangRelations: Sagara always thought Kurokawa was the apex of a triangle with himself and Narumi but after he emerges it soon becomes obvious that Sagara is the apex of a love triangle with Narumi (straight) and Kurokawa (gay).

to:

* RescueRomance: Kurokawa is thrilled to discover that Sagara is now a girl female because he saved her from bullies back in elementary school.
* SchoolgirlLesbians: Kurokawa is thrilled Kurokawa, and she's willing to pursue a relationship with Sagara is now that he's physically a girl and wants him to be her girl in private, his insistence on maintaining an outward identity as a boy would just relieve her of the additional social burder of coming out of the closet on top of the stigma of being an emerged girl.
female.
* TheMindIsThePlaythingOfTheBody: subverted: Gender gender identity and, to a lesser extent, Gender and presentation appears more appear subject more to social pressures than biology. Neither Their is no indication that either Sagara nor or Kurokawa's sexuality appears to have been was affected by their emergence transformations and their choices of gender identity and presentation and identity appears appear to have been affected be due more by the to timing and social circumstances circumstances. Kurokawa emerged in elementary school and may not have been able to hide it even if she wanted to, presuming her parents would have allowed it, whereas Sagara was already compensating for his girly appearance.
* SadisticChoice: Poor Sagara. A relatioship with apparently straight Narumi will probably force him to publically re-identify as a girl, but a relationship with Kurokawa would probably also require him to admit to being a girl in private even if he remained a boy in public. Either course requires surrendering some aspect
of their emergence than the physical transformation itself.
his identity
* TheirAreNoTherapists: ThereAreNoTherapists: subverted. The protagonist of ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi'' is the protagonist's therapist in ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another''
* TriangRelations: Sagara always thought Kurokawa was he and Narumi were straight-up rivals for Kurokawa's affections only to learn he's actually the apex of a triangle with himself and Narumi but after he emerges it soon becomes obvious that Sagara is the apex of a their love triangle with Narumi (straight) and Kurokawa (gay).thanks to the revelations prompted by his emergence.

Added: 436

Changed: 372

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OldFriendNewGender: Sagara is surprised to discover that Kurokawa was the boy-turned-girl he defenced after she emerged back in elementary school
* SchoolgirlLesbians: Kurokawa is thrilled that Sagara is physically a girl but wants to maintain his identity as a boy, as this means she can have the relationship she always wanted without the additional social burder of coming out of the closet on top of the stigma of being an emerged girl.

to:

* OldFriendNewGender: Sagara is very surprised to discover that Kurokawa was the boy-turned-girl a boy he defenced after she emerged knew back in elementary school
school.
* NotSoDifferent: Sagara and Kurokawa on multiple levels. Both are emerged girls hiding important secrets.
* RescueRomance: Kurokawa is thrilled to discover that Sagara is now a girl because he saved her from bullies back in elementary school.
* SchoolgirlLesbians: Kurokawa is thrilled that Sagara is physically a girl but and wants him to maintain be her girl in private, his insistence on maintaining an outward identity as a boy, as this means she can have the relationship she always wanted without boy would just relieve her of the additional social burder of coming out of the closet on top of the stigma of being an emerged girl.

Added: 198

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OvercompensatingForSomething: Mamiya's drive to excel at everything turns out to have some very ugly roots.
* StrongFamilyResemblence: Post-emergence Mamiya looks remarkably like her hated MissingMom,

to:

* OvercompensatingForSomething: CompensatingForSomething: Mamiya's drive to excel at everything turns out to have some very ugly roots.
* StrongFamilyResemblence: StrongFamilyResemblance: Post-emergence Mamiya looks remarkably like her hated MissingMom,



* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Kurokawa breaks up with Sagara when it becomes obvious (to her, he's still clueless) that Sagara is really in love with Narumi

to:

* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Kurokawa breaks up with Sagara when it becomes obvious (to her, he's still clueless) that Sagara is really in love with NarumiNarumi.
* LateArrivalSpoiler: the two manga are published concurrently, meaning readers of the second already know that Mamiya and Miyoshi's sometimes rocky relaationship will have an eventual happy ending.



* TheirAreNotTherapists: subverted. The protagonist of ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi'' is the protagonist's therapist ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another''

to:

* TheirAreNotTherapists: TheirAreNoTherapists: subverted. The protagonist of ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi'' is the protagonist's therapist in ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys {{Metamorphosis transform into girls}} in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly changing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

to:

Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys {{Metamorphosis [[{{Metamorphosis}} transform into girls}} girls]] in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children whose bodies are rapidly changing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults.

Added: 800

Changed: 1987

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys {{Metamorphosis transform into girls}} in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children who are growing rapidly anyway, the resulting stresses on the body are invariably fatal for adults and very dangerous for teenagers. Now unequivocally and seemingly unabashedly female, Refusingto mope Mamiya breezily returns to school determined to seize life as a girl and equally determined to help Miyoshi overcome his severe gynophobia. But Miyoshi soon comes to expect that Mamiya is not nearly as sanquine about her GenderBender as she is willing to let on.
In the sequel ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another'' Sagara, a short, slight, and girly-looking boy who has cultivated a tough-guy image to compensate becomes a girl during his third year of middle school and is forced to confront the stark choice between maintaining his identity as a boy and forging a new identity as a girl, a choice only complicated by his new attraction to his frenemy Narumi, who is also his rival for the affections of the cool, collected class representative Kurokawa.

to:


Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return as a girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the ratio between the sexes is fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys {{Metamorphosis transform into girls}} in a process known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children who whose bodies are growing rapidly changing anyway, otherwise the resulting stresses on the body are very dangerous to teenagers and invariably fatal for adults and very dangerous for teenagers. Now adults.

Refusing to mope Mamiya breezily returns to school
unequivocally and seemingly unabashedly female, Refusingto mope Mamiya breezily returns to school determined to seize life as a girl and equally determined to help Miyoshi overcome his severe gynophobia. But Miyoshi soon comes to expect suspect that Mamiya is not nearly as there's actually a great deal of turmoil going on beneath Mamiya's seemingly sanquine about her GenderBender as she is willing to let on.
surface.

In the sequel ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another'' Sagara, a short, slight, and girly-looking boy who has cultivated a tough-guy image to compensate becomes a girl during his third year of middle school and is forced to confront the a stark choice between maintaining his identity as a boy and forging a new identity as a girl, a choice only complicated by his a new attraction to his frenemy Narumi, who is also his rival for the affections of the cool, collected class representative Kurokawa. Kurokawa.



------



* IllGirl: Mamiya's emergence stressed her body a lot more than she lets on, and her health is a lot less robust than she would have people believe.

to:

* IllGirl: Mamiya's emergence stressed her body a lot more than she lets on, and her health is a lot less robust more fragile than she would have people believe.

Added: 3317

Changed: 1768

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return to school as a female, and seemingly determined to live out his life as a girl. For in Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the demographic balance between the sexes is preserved by a process called "{{Metamorphosis emergence}}".

to:

\n\nKanojo ni Naru Hi (The day he became a girl)
Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything. everything and completely unable to resist a challenge.. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return to school as a female, and seemingly determined to live out his life as a girl. For in girl. In Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the demographic balance ratio between the sexes is preserved by fixed: when there aren't enough women, some boys {{Metamorphosis transform into girls}} in a process called "{{Metamorphosis emergence}}".known as "emergence". While emergence isn't exactly uncommon (tens to hundreds of cases every year) it usually only happens in young children who are growing rapidly anyway, the resulting stresses on the body are invariably fatal for adults and very dangerous for teenagers. Now unequivocally and seemingly unabashedly female, Refusingto mope Mamiya breezily returns to school determined to seize life as a girl and equally determined to help Miyoshi overcome his severe gynophobia. But Miyoshi soon comes to expect that Mamiya is not nearly as sanquine about her GenderBender as she is willing to let on.
In the sequel ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another'' Sagara, a short, slight, and girly-looking boy who has cultivated a tough-guy image to compensate becomes a girl during his third year of middle school and is forced to confront the stark choice between maintaining his identity as a boy and forging a new identity as a girl, a choice only complicated by his new attraction to his frenemy Narumi, who is also his rival for the affections of the cool, collected class representative Kurokawa.
Manga by Ogura Akane
!!Tropes found in Kanojo ni Naru Hi:
*AloofBigBrother: Subverted. Mamiya's love for her baby half-sister is unequivicable and freely returned
* IllGirl: Mamiya's emergence stressed her body a lot more than she lets on, and her health is a lot less robust than she would have people believe.
* FreudianExcuse: Mamiya's deep psychological need to excel at everything--even femininity-- comes from her sense of ParentalAbandonment, which her emergence only complicates by making him resemble the mother she hates.
* GenderBender:
** FirstLawOfGenderBending: Reversions to male are not unheard of but very rare..
**SecondLawOFGenderBending: Played with Mamiya seems to throw herself into feminity the same way she's attacked every other challenge, but Miyoshi soon realizes she's masking deeper psychological issues.
** ThirdLawOfGenderBending: Mamiya's so determined to tackle femininity head on she practically demands to be treated according to the third law during her reintroduction to the class.
* MissingMom: Mamiya has severe abandonment issues that stem from being his mother, who abandoned Mamiya and his father only to turn right around and start a new family with another man.
*OvercompensatingForSomething: Mamiya's drive to excel at everything turns out to have some very ugly roots.
* StrongFamilyResemblence: Post-emergence Mamiya looks remarkably like her hated MissingMom,
* VictoriousChildhoodFriend: Mamiya, eventually
* WickedStepmother: Subverted. Mamiya's stepmother loves and supports her and is loved in return.
!!Tropes found in ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another'':
*FantasticRacism: Turns out there can be a good deal of prejudice against the emerged.
*HeroOfAnotherStory: Mamiya Nao's little sister is a classmate, and Nao herself is Sagara's therapist.
*IncompatibleOrientation: After Sagara emerges Kurokawa reveals that neither he nor Narumi ever really had a chance with her because she's a lesbian.
*IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Kurokawa breaks up with Sagara when it becomes obvious (to her, he's still clueless) that Sagara is really in love with Narumi
*OldFriendNewGender: Sagara is surprised to discover that Kurokawa was the boy-turned-girl he defenced after she emerged back in elementary school
*SchoolgirlLesbians: Kurokawa is thrilled that Sagara is physically a girl but wants to maintain his identity as a boy, as this means she can have the relationship she always wanted without the additional social burder of coming out of the closet on top of the stigma of being an emerged girl.
* TheMindIsThePlaythingOfTheBody: subverted: Gender identity and, to a lesser extent, Gender presentation appears more subject to social pressures than biology. Neither Sagara nor Kurokawa's sexuality appears to have been affected by their emergence and their gender presentation and identity appears to have been affected more by the timing and social circumstances of their emergence than the physical transformation itself.
* TheirAreNotTherapists: subverted. The protagonist of ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi'' is the protagonist's therapist ''Kanojo ni Naru Hi Another''
* TriangRelations: Sagara always thought Kurokawa was the apex of a triangle with himself and Narumi but after he emerges it soon becomes obvious that Sagara is the apex of a love triangle with Narumi (straight) and Kurokawa (gay).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Miyoshi is always competing and losing against his childhood friend, Mamiya, who is good at everything. One day, Mamiya collapses from illness and is hospitalized for several weeks, only to return to school as a female, and seemingly determined to live out his life as a girl. For in Mihoshi and Mamiya's world, the demographic balance between the sexes is preserved by a process called "{{Metamorphosis emergence}}".

Top