Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / SandIsWater

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another slight subversion, considering that the ground only worked like water for the sand whale, and not the rowboat.
ccoa MOD

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Italicize media names please


* Meredith Ann Pierce's TheDarkangelTrilogy had a Sea of Dust, over which the heroine sails a skiff in the second book. It's even got fisherfolk, whales, and sea serpents.

to:

* Meredith Ann Pierce's TheDarkangelTrilogy ''TheDarkangelTrilogy'' had a Sea of Dust, over which the heroine sails a skiff in the second book. It's even got fisherfolk, whales, and sea serpents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Meredith Ann Pierce's ''Darkangel Trilogy'' had a Sea of Dust, over which the heroine sails a skiff in the second book. It's even got fisherfolk, whales, and sea serpents.

to:

* Meredith Ann Pierce's ''Darkangel Trilogy'' TheDarkangelTrilogy had a Sea of Dust, over which the heroine sails a skiff in the second book. It's even got fisherfolk, whales, and sea serpents.

Changed: 404

Removed: 794

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''[[AvatarTheLastAirbender Avatar: The Last Airbender]]'', the nomadic Earthbender offshoot Sandbenders specialize in manipulating the sand that surrounds them; consequentally, their movements are more akin to those of a waterbender. They apply this power to use small sand skifs to sail around in.

to:

* In ''[[AvatarTheLastAirbender Avatar: The Last Airbender]]'', the nomadic Earthbender offshoot Sandbenders specialize in manipulating the sand that surrounds them; consequentally, their movements are more akin to those of a waterbender. They apply this power to use small sand skifs skiffs to sail around in.



* Scrooge [=McDuck=] from ''DuckTales'' could swim in his money, literally! There are at least two instances of other characters trying to do the same, only to bang their head hard and painfully when landing on the coins, mumbling, "[[LampshadeHanging How does he do that]]?"
** And then there was one story where Scrooge turned the money in his vault into a literal ocean, with the help of Gyro Gearloose building oceanic physics into the building that housed it. It didn't last long: Magica Despell turned the tides against him, and amassing the number of coins needed to simulate an ocean destroyed his financial liquidity.
** Another story had a slightly confused inventor selling a ray that temporarily negated friction and/or inertia on its targets to the Beagle Boys. Obviously, Duckburg is temporarily awash with a tsunami of coins.
* An episode of ''CourageTheCowardlyDog'' has the titular character forced by Eustace's mother to hunt a sand whale, who is trying to get his accordian back from Eustace's mother. And Courage is forced to row a boat in the sand.

to:

* Scrooge [=McDuck=] from ''DuckTales'' could swim in his money, literally! There are at least two instances of other characters trying to do the same, only to bang their head hard and painfully when landing on the coins, mumbling, "[[LampshadeHanging How does he do that]]?"
** And then there was one story where Scrooge turned the money in his vault into a literal ocean, with the help of Gyro Gearloose building oceanic physics into the building that housed it. It didn't last long: Magica Despell turned the tides against him, and amassing the number of coins needed to simulate an ocean destroyed his financial liquidity.
** Another story had a slightly confused inventor selling a ray that temporarily negated friction and/or inertia on its targets to the Beagle Boys. Obviously, Duckburg is temporarily awash with a tsunami of coins.
* An episode of ''CourageTheCowardlyDog'' has the titular character forced by Eustace's mother to hunt a sand whale, who is trying to get his accordian accordion back from Eustace's mother. And Courage is forced to row a boat in the sand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In RayBradbury's ''Martian Chronicles'', Martians had sand ships.

to:

* In RayBradbury's ''Martian Chronicles'', ''TheMartianChronicles'', Martians had sand ships.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** And since the franchise is being run by massive nerds, in the 4E update of the setting they decided that wasn't good enough. Now the entire Sea of Silt is an injury to the fabric of reality and that the Elemental Chaos is leaking through and changing local physics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArthurCClarke's ''A Fall of Moondust'' is based on the idea that some lunar basins are filled with very fine dust that behaves like a liquid.

to:

* ArthurCClarke's ''A ''{{A Fall of Moondust'' Moondust}}'' is based on the idea that some lunar basins are filled with very fine dust that behaves like a liquid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Sand ships and sand dolphins can be purchased in the ridiculously advanced future of {{Doraemon}}; in one NonSerialMovie, Nobita and company discover that Sinbad the Sailor (of the ArabianNights) was the beneficiary of such gifts courtesy from a time traveler.


Added DiffLines:

* One of the {{Impossible Task}}s in either ArabianNights or the Grimm Fairy Tales (or possibly both) is "create a ship that can sail on sand (or possibly land, it's been a while) as on water". The hero usually has to call in the help of [[AWizardDidIt some supernatural creature]] to assist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the era before CGI and colour film, special effects done using scale-models often used sand as an alternative to water due to the absurdly large relative size of water droplets to the models of ships, planes ect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Hercules and Xena series both featured man-eating sand sharks that could do this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WilliamGoldman described this in great detail in ''ThePrincesBride'' and later lampshades the research he did for it in ''The Color Of Light''.

to:

* WilliamGoldman described this in great detail in ''ThePrincesBride'' ''ThePrincessBride'' and later lampshades the research he did for it in ''The Color Of Light''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
grammar


Water is cool, but how much [[RuleOfCool cooler]] would it be if we replaced it with sand? Rivers, lakes, whirlpools, even whole oceans of sand that behaves more or less exactly like a body of water are common in desert settings. Bonus points if there are ships that sail said sandy seas (say that ten times really fast). You will even often find native life swimming in ([[FlyingSeafoodSpecial or above]]) these seas, with everything from Sand Guppies to full-blown {{Sand Worm}}s.

to:

Water is cool, but how much [[RuleOfCool cooler]] would it be if we replaced it with sand? Rivers, lakes, whirlpools, even whole oceans of sand that behaves behave more or less exactly like a body of water are common in desert settings. Bonus points if there are ships that sail said sandy seas (say that ten times really fast). You will even often find native life swimming in ([[FlyingSeafoodSpecial or above]]) these seas, with everything from Sand Guppies to full-blown {{Sand Worm}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And it's apparently somewhere near New York City. Any bets on it being NewJersey AfterTheEnd? [[AcceptableTargets At least there's less smog.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A commonly found type is the sand whirlpool, which works in a similar manner to [[QuicksandSucks quicksand]] in that anyone who steps into one will be quickly pulled down suffocate.

to:

A commonly found type is the sand whirlpool, which works in a similar manner to [[QuicksandSucks quicksand]] in that anyone who steps into one will be quickly pulled down and suffocate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

--> "It's fun to charter an accountant / And sail the wide accountant-sea. / To find, explore, the funds off-shore / and skirt the shoals of bankruptcy! / It can be manly in insurance; / We'll up your premiums semi-annually. / It's all tax-deductable; / We're fairly in-corruptible; / We're sailing on a wide accountant-sea!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is of course an instance of YouFailPhysicsForever. While sand can act like a fluid, it is a non-Newtonian fluid which means it won't act like water. You can stand on it when it is stationary, for example, but not when it is fluidised. Just about everyone must have seen the experiment where you blow air through sand, giving a fluidised bed that behaves like water. It's also extremely abrasive: anything with sand running over it or through it is likely to be scoured down to nothing fairly quickly unless it's [[strike: made of diamond]] harder than quartz, especially if it has mechanical parts. It's also a tad difficult to ''breathe'' sand, whether you attempt it with gills or lungs. But, hey, it's [[RuleOfCool cool enough]] so we can forgive it.

to:

This is of course an instance of YouFailPhysicsForever. While sand can act like a fluid, it is a non-Newtonian fluid which means it won't act like water. You can stand on it when it is stationary, for example, but not when it is fluidised. [[ViewersAreGeniuses Just about everyone must have seen the experiment experiment]] where you blow air through sand, giving a fluidised bed that behaves like water. It's also extremely abrasive: anything with sand running over it or through it is likely to be scoured down to nothing fairly quickly unless it's [[strike: made of diamond]] harder than quartz, especially if it has mechanical parts. It's also a tad difficult to ''breathe'' sand, whether you attempt it with gills or lungs. But, hey, it's [[RuleOfCool cool enough]] so we can forgive it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Figaro Castle in ''FinalFantasyVI'' was able to turn into a sand-submarine and move between two deserts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And of course, Hippopotas, Hippowdon and the recently revealed Meguroko all play with this trope by being ground-type hippos and crocodile respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Banjo-Kazooie}}'s'' sixth level, Gobi's Desert, there are pools of sand that appear to be boiling. [[CaptainObvious Obviously]], entering these pools without the Wading Boots is hazardous to your health.

to:

* ''{{Banjo-Kazooie}}'s'' On ''{{Banjo-Kazooie}}'''s sixth level, Gobi's Desert, there are pools of sand that appear to be boiling.have small waves going across them, almost like boiling water. [[CaptainObvious Obviously]], entering these pools without the Wading Boots is hazardous to your health.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Banjo-Kazooie}}'s'' sixth level, [[InstantDesertJustAddCactus Gobi's Desert]], there are pools of sand that appear to be boiling. [[CaptainObvious Obviously]], entering these pools without the Wading Boots is hazardous to your health.

to:

* ''{{Banjo-Kazooie}}'s'' sixth level, [[InstantDesertJustAddCactus Gobi's Desert]], Desert, there are pools of sand that appear to be boiling. [[CaptainObvious Obviously]], entering these pools without the Wading Boots is hazardous to your health.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Banjo-Kazooie}}''

to:

* ''{{Banjo-Kazooie}}'' ''{{Banjo-Kazooie}}'s'' sixth level, [[InstantDesertJustAddCactus Gobi's Desert]], there are pools of sand that appear to be boiling. [[CaptainObvious Obviously]], entering these pools without the Wading Boots is hazardous to your health.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''GoldenSun''

to:

* ''GoldenSun''''GoldenSun'' features an entire dungeon (Venus Lighthouse) devoted to solving puzzles with this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved Iron Man example from Soft Water

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/IronMan'': when Tony escapes from the terrorists in his Mk.1 suit, he falls from several hundred feet into a sand dune and suffers no major effects.
** If the sand is soft and sifted, it's possible to survive, since it contains a lot of air; he was also wearing it, which softened the impact. In any event, it's nothing compared to the smacks he takes later in the film, like flying into a wall while testing the boot-rockets.
*** The tagline of many scientists was "Tony Stark died seventeen times in this movie."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Rain Lady and her sand submarine to the Tank Girl movie

Added DiffLines:

** "Rain Lady" corresponds to the character "Sub Girl" from the comics, and plows her submarine through the desert for the ''FinalBattle''!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Sub Girl from Tank girl comics and her under-the-desert submarine.

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Comics]]
* Sub Girl, part of the Tank Girl, Jet Girl and Sub Girl trifecta from the ''TankGirl'' comics, pilots a submarine that sometimes travels underneath the desert sand.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Genuine "sand-swimming" vertebrates still have to remain very close to the surface to avoid suffocation. Most only "swim" far enough to cover themselves with a thin dusting of sand, thus acquiring camoflague and shielding themselves from the desert sun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Sand beaches, as well as dry lakebeds and salt flats, are favored terrain for the use of land yachts, as a fairly flat surface is needed for these lightweight wheeled vessels to remain stable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is of course an instance of YouFailPhysicsForever. While sand can act like a fluid, it is a non-Newtonian fluid which means it won't act like water. You can stand on it when it is stationary, for example, but not when it is fluidised. Just about everyone must have seen the experiment where you blow air through sand, giving a fluidised bed that behaves like water. It's also extremely abrasive: anything with sand running over it or through it is likely to be scoured down to nothing fairly quickly unless it's [[strike: made of diamond]] harder than quartz, especially if it has mechanical parts. It's also a tad difficult to ''breathe'' sand, which makes most depictions of sand-swimming carnivores hard to swallow. But, hey, it's [[RuleOfCool cool enough]] so we can forgive it.

to:

This is of course an instance of YouFailPhysicsForever. While sand can act like a fluid, it is a non-Newtonian fluid which means it won't act like water. You can stand on it when it is stationary, for example, but not when it is fluidised. Just about everyone must have seen the experiment where you blow air through sand, giving a fluidised bed that behaves like water. It's also extremely abrasive: anything with sand running over it or through it is likely to be scoured down to nothing fairly quickly unless it's [[strike: made of diamond]] harder than quartz, especially if it has mechanical parts. It's also a tad difficult to ''breathe'' sand, which makes most depictions of sand-swimming carnivores hard to swallow.whether you attempt it with gills or lungs. But, hey, it's [[RuleOfCool cool enough]] so we can forgive it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is of course an instance of YouFailPhysicsForever. While sand can act like a fluid, it is a non-Newtonian fluid which means it won't act like water. You can stand on it when it is stationary, for example, but not when it is fluidised. Just about everyone must have seen the experiment where you blow air through sand, giving a fluidised bed that behaves like water. It's also extremely abrasive: anything with sand running over it or through it is likely to be scoured down to nothing fairly quickly unless it's [[strike: made of diamond]] harder than quartz, especially if it has mechanical parts. It's also a tad difficult to ''breathe'' dry sand, which makes most depictions of sand-swimming carnivores hard to swallow. But, hey, it's [[RuleOfCool cool enough]] so we can forgive it.

to:

This is of course an instance of YouFailPhysicsForever. While sand can act like a fluid, it is a non-Newtonian fluid which means it won't act like water. You can stand on it when it is stationary, for example, but not when it is fluidised. Just about everyone must have seen the experiment where you blow air through sand, giving a fluidised bed that behaves like water. It's also extremely abrasive: anything with sand running over it or through it is likely to be scoured down to nothing fairly quickly unless it's [[strike: made of diamond]] harder than quartz, especially if it has mechanical parts. It's also a tad difficult to ''breathe'' dry sand, which makes most depictions of sand-swimming carnivores hard to swallow. But, hey, it's [[RuleOfCool cool enough]] so we can forgive it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is of course an instance of YouFailPhysicsForever. While sand can act like a fluid, it is a non-Newtonian fluid which means it won't act like water. You can stand on it when it is stationary, for example, but not when it is fluidised. Just about everyone must have seen the experiment where you blow air through sand, giving a fluidised bed that behaves like water. It's also extremely abrasive: anything with sand running over it or through it is likely to be scoured down to nothing fairly quickly unless it's [[strike: made of diamond]] harder than quartz, especially if it has mechanical parts. But, hey, it's [[RuleOfCool cool enough]] so we can forgive it.

to:

This is of course an instance of YouFailPhysicsForever. While sand can act like a fluid, it is a non-Newtonian fluid which means it won't act like water. You can stand on it when it is stationary, for example, but not when it is fluidised. Just about everyone must have seen the experiment where you blow air through sand, giving a fluidised bed that behaves like water. It's also extremely abrasive: anything with sand running over it or through it is likely to be scoured down to nothing fairly quickly unless it's [[strike: made of diamond]] harder than quartz, especially if it has mechanical parts. It's also a tad difficult to ''breathe'' dry sand, which makes most depictions of sand-swimming carnivores hard to swallow. But, hey, it's [[RuleOfCool cool enough]] so we can forgive it.

Top