Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / SadlyMythtaken

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tomb Raider Thor room

Added DiffLines:

* In the first ''TombRaider'' game, Lara enters a room labelled "Thor" in an ancient temple complex in Greece and has to deal with smashing hammers. This was acknowledged by the creative team and corrected to "Hephaestus" in ''Tomb Raider: Anniversary''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Tons of examples in ''Franchise/PiratesOfTheCaribbean'', but mostly because the real legends behind the series' plotlines are tossed aside in favor of the RuleOfCool.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Dark Dawn'' does change the {{Horny Viking|s}} Thor's beard from blonde to red at least.

to:

** ''Dark Dawn'' does change the {{Horny Viking|s}} Thor's beard from blonde to red at least. He swaps out his hammer for a giant turbo fan in the process though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Even worse, in the original Japanese version, Frey and Freya's names were swapped. In either case Frey is female and doesn't really fit the character, but although Freya is an appropriate name for the chief goddess, it's not for a glorified gate guard.

to:

*** Even worse, in the original Japanese version, Frey and Freya's names were swapped. In either case Frey is female and doesn't really fit the character, mythological figure, but although Freya is an appropriate name for the chief goddess, it's not ''not'' an appropriate name for a glorified gate guard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unlike the others, the change in Hades isn't even {{Disneyfication}}. [[EverybodyHatesHades He wasn't an evil god]], (he was downright nice compared to some of [[DisproportionateRetribution the other]] [[JerkAssGods Greek Gods]], Zeus in particular) nor did he have any antagonistic relationship with Heracles. In fact, he was vital in helping Heracles finish his last labor. [[labelnote:More info]]Said labor was "bring me Cerberus." Heracles went to the Underworld and asked to borrow him, and Hades pretty much said "Bring him back when you're done" - which Heracles did.[[/labelnote]]

to:

** Unlike the others, the change in Hades isn't even {{Disneyfication}}. [[EverybodyHatesHades He wasn't an evil god]], (he was downright nice compared to some of [[DisproportionateRetribution the other]] [[JerkAssGods [[JerkassGods Greek Gods]], Zeus in particular) nor did he have any antagonistic relationship with Heracles. In fact, he was vital in helping Heracles finish his last labor. [[labelnote:More info]]Said labor was "bring me Cerberus." Heracles went to the Underworld and asked to borrow him, and Hades pretty much said "Bring him back when you're done" - which Heracles did.[[/labelnote]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unlike the others, the change in Hades isn't even {{Disneyfication}}. [[EverybodyHatesHades He wasn't an evil god]], (he was downright nice compared to some of [[DisproportionateRetribution the other]] [[JerkAssGods Greek Gods]], Zeus in particular) nor did he have any antagonistic relationship with Heracles. In fact, he was vital in helping Heracles finish his last labor. [[hottip:(more info):Said labor was "bring me Cerberus." Heracles went to the Underworld and asked to borrow him, and Hades pretty much said "Bring him back when you're done" - which Heracles did.]]

to:

** Unlike the others, the change in Hades isn't even {{Disneyfication}}. [[EverybodyHatesHades He wasn't an evil god]], (he was downright nice compared to some of [[DisproportionateRetribution the other]] [[JerkAssGods Greek Gods]], Zeus in particular) nor did he have any antagonistic relationship with Heracles. In fact, he was vital in helping Heracles finish his last labor. [[hottip:(more info):Said [[labelnote:More info]]Said labor was "bring me Cerberus." Heracles went to the Underworld and asked to borrow him, and Hades pretty much said "Bring him back when you're done" - which Heracles did.]][[/labelnote]]

Changed: 381

Removed: 288

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The plot-driver in ''Film/RaidersOfTheLostArk'' is that the Ark of the Covenant is some sort of magical weapon. Which, suffice it to say, does not quite match the description found in the Bible.
*** In one instance in the Old Testament, the Ark bestowed blessings on the man who kept it in his house. The film turned this up to eleven and gave the Ark properties similar to the Spear of Destiny. The bit about the Ark killing those who disrespected it is Biblically accurate however.

to:

* The plot-driver in ''Film/RaidersOfTheLostArk'' is that the Ark of the Covenant is some sort of magical weapon. Which, suffice it to say, does not quite match the description found in the Bible.
***
weapon, and would make its owner invincible. In fact, one instance [[Literature/BooksOfSamuel in 1 Samuel]] where the Old Testament, Israelites tried to use it as a weapon merely caused the Ark bestowed blessings on to get ''very angry'' at their disrespect and let them lose the man who kept it in his house. The film turned this up to eleven and gave battle. [[spoiler:Given the Ark properties similar to simply wiped out the Spear of Destiny. The bit about Nazis who opened it, though, perhaps the Ark killing those who disrespected it is Biblically accurate however.part of retaliating against its owners was indeed noted.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PiersAnthony had used "Alicorn" to refer to a Winged Unicorn - An Alicorn is actually the substance a unicorn horn is made out of. However, he wasn't [[FriendshipIsMagic the most popular one]] to use it (see below).

to:

* PiersAnthony had used "Alicorn" to refer to a Winged Unicorn - An Alicorn is actually the substance a unicorn horn is made out of. However, he wasn't [[FriendshipIsMagic [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic the most popular one]] to use it (see below).



* ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' uses "Alicorn" to refer to the winged unicorn who act as royals. While far from the first to make this error (See "Literature" above), it became the most popular, causing no shortage of people familiar with mythology to tear their hair.

to:

* ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' uses "Alicorn" to refer to the winged unicorn who act as royals. While far from the first to make this error (See "Literature" above), it became the most popular, causing no shortage of people familiar with mythology to tear their hair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PiersAnthony had used "Alicorn" to refer to a Winged Unicorn - An Alicorn is actually the substance a unicorn horn is made out of. However, he wasn't the most popular one to use it.

to:

* PiersAnthony had used "Alicorn" to refer to a Winged Unicorn - An Alicorn is actually the substance a unicorn horn is made out of. However, he wasn't [[FriendshipIsMagic the most popular one one]] to use it.it (see below).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Wendigo is identified as a Comanche myth in ''Film/TheLoneRanger'', but it is actually Algonquian, who were prominent in what is now the northern US and Canada, and the Atlantic coast - it's indicative of long winters and desperation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[Film/PercyJacksonAndTheOlympians The Lightning Thief]]: The story centers around a summer solstice deadline, but Persephone is shown living in the underworld with Hades--something that's supposed to happen during the fall and winter months. What makes it stand out more is that she ''does'' acknowledge that she gets time away from Hades... though exactly ''when'' that is is never expanded on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed comment about the apocalypse being an allegory for the fall of the Roman Empire. This interpretation is generally not accepted by theologians, but in this entry it was written as if it were a proven fact.


** For that matter, the apocalypse itself. It was supposed to be an allegory for the fall of the Roman Empire, rather than TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding a little...

Added DiffLines:

** Might be slightly justifiable: fathers are notorious for constantly mashing their children's birthdays, hobbies and friends together and getting the wrong answers without a bit of help via being given the stink-eye to keep things straight. And, in Loki's defence: he had a lot of children as both Dad ''and'' Mum: must be a bit hard to keep track...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/{{Stargate}},'' the symbol they keep referring to as "The Eye of Ra" is actually "The Eye of Horus" and is also known as the "Wedjet"

to:

* In ''Film/{{Stargate}},'' the symbol they keep referring to as "The Eye of Ra" is actually "The Eye of Horus" and is also known as the "Wedjet""Wedjet".
* There's a brief but oft-quoted speech in the inspirational sports movie ''Film/RememberTheTitans'' where the coach of the titular football team encourages his players to aspire to be like their mythical namesakes, who were "greater even than the gods". He apparently forgot the part about the Titans being the fallen ''predecessors'' of the Gods. And the part where the leader of the Titans, Kronos, was murdered by his son after trying to cannibalize his own children.

Added: 538

Changed: 534

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
formatting


*** "Chapter 108: Ahab and the Carpenter: The Deck—First Night Watch" -> ''What's Prometheus about there? --the blacksmith, I mean --what's he about? He must be forging the buckle-screw, sir, now. Right. It's a partnership; he supplies the muscle part. He makes a fierce red flame there! Aye, sir; he must have the white heat for this kind of fine work. Um-m. So he must. I do deem it now a most meaning thing, that that old Greek, Prometheus, who made men, they say, should have been a blacksmith, and animated them with fire; for what's made in fire must properly belong to fire; and so hell's probable.''

to:

*** "Chapter 108: Ahab and the Carpenter: The Deck—First Night Watch" -> ''What's Watch":
--->''What's
Prometheus about there? --the blacksmith, I mean --what's he about? He must be forging the buckle-screw, sir, now. Right. It's a partnership; he supplies the muscle part. He makes a fierce red flame there! Aye, sir; he must have the white heat for this kind of fine work. Um-m. So he must. I do deem it now a most meaning thing, that that old Greek, Prometheus, who made men, they say, should have been a blacksmith, and animated them with fire; for what's made in fire must properly belong to fire; and so hell's probable.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Well, seeing that the sisters, who are never referred to as Norns, are really only named after the Norns.

to:

*** Well, seeing that the sisters, who are never referred to as Norns, are really only [[InNameOnly named after after]] [[NamesTheSame the Norns.Norns]].

Added: 123

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' uses "Alicorn" to refer to the winged pegasi who act as royals. While far from the first to make this error (See "Literature" above), it became the most popular, causing no shortage of people familiar with mythology to tear their hair.

to:

* ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' uses "Alicorn" to refer to the winged pegasi unicorn who act as royals. While far from the first to make this error (See "Literature" above), it became the most popular, causing no shortage of people familiar with mythology to tear their hair.
** It would seem most fans know its just that the Winged Unicorns in the show are a mix of Unicorn, Pegasus and Earth pony.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Charmed}}'': In "Oh My Goddess!" it's said that the Greek gods were actually mortals the Elders infused with power in order to stop the Titans. This is not a problem in itself -- the problem is that Gaea was stated to be one of these mortals, when in mythology she wasn't an Olympian, but the ''mother of the titans.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added link to Incredibly Lame Pun where it says \"morbidly obsessed with death\" (Mythology, 4th bullet point)


* Pick any media where [[EgyptianMythology Anubis]] appears. The mistaken uses of Anubis as evil, tremendously powerful, or the chief god of death in the Egyptian pantheon are so rampant and constant that they qualify as perhaps one of the most egregious examples of CriticalResearchFailure in current culture. To be specific: Anubis was the ''guardian'' of the resting places of the dead, and the judge of dead souls. These were his only roles, making him a minor deity in the everyday life of the egyptians, but more important when it came to death, which the Egyptians were morbidly obsessed with - hence he appears all over their tombs and therefore has become very recognizable. The chief deity of the dead was Osiris, and ''nothing'' to do with death was inherently ''evil''. In actuality, given his role as guardian Anubis could be considered one of the more benevolent deities of the Egyptian pantheon, so long as you don't mess with his charges.

to:

* Pick any media where [[EgyptianMythology Anubis]] appears. The mistaken uses of Anubis as evil, tremendously powerful, or the chief god of death in the Egyptian pantheon are so rampant and constant that they qualify as perhaps one of the most egregious examples of CriticalResearchFailure in current culture. To be specific: Anubis was the ''guardian'' of the resting places of the dead, and the judge of dead souls. These were his only roles, making him a minor deity in the everyday life of the egyptians, but more important when it came to death, which the Egyptians were morbidly [[IncrediblyLamePun morbidly]] obsessed with - hence he appears all over their tombs and therefore has become very recognizable. The chief deity of the dead was Osiris, and ''nothing'' to do with death was inherently ''evil''. In actuality, given his role as guardian Anubis could be considered one of the more benevolent deities of the Egyptian pantheon, so long as you don't mess with his charges.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This frequently happens to any god, no matter how benign, who happens to have any dominion over death or the underworld, due to BadPowersBadPeople.

to:

This frequently happens to any god, no matter how benign, who [[EverybodyHatesHades happens to have any dominion over death or the underworld, underworld]], due to BadPowersBadPeople.









!!Examples (that don't fit into the subtropes)

to:

!!Examples !Examples (that don't fit into the subtropes)


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '#KidIcarus''. The queen of the underworld is Medusa, [[DemonicSpider Pluton]] is a common enemy that steals your weapons, Pandora is a giant soap bubble and goddess of calamity and deceit, and Tanatos is a snake that lives in Medusa's hair.

to:

* '#KidIcarus''.''Videogame/KidIcarus''. The queen of the underworld is Medusa, [[DemonicSpider Pluton]] is a common enemy that steals your weapons, Pandora is a giant soap bubble and goddess of calamity and deceit, and Tanatos is a snake that lives in Medusa's hair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add qualification


** {{It Makes Sense in Context}} - and also, a straight comparison of a blacksmith to Hephaestus was something of a {{Dead Horse Trope}} at the time he was writing the novel.

to:

** {{It Makes Sense in Context}} (sort of) - and also, a straight comparison of a blacksmith to Hephaestus was something of a {{Dead Horse Trope}} at the time he was writing the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add quote

Added DiffLines:

**{{It Makes Sense in Context}} - and also, a straight comparison of a blacksmith to Hephaestus was something of a {{Dead Horse Trope}} at the time he was writing the novel.
*** "Chapter 108: Ahab and the Carpenter: The Deck—First Night Watch" -> ''What's Prometheus about there? --the blacksmith, I mean --what's he about? He must be forging the buckle-screw, sir, now. Right. It's a partnership; he supplies the muscle part. He makes a fierce red flame there! Aye, sir; he must have the white heat for this kind of fine work. Um-m. So he must. I do deem it now a most meaning thing, that that old Greek, Prometheus, who made men, they say, should have been a blacksmith, and animated them with fire; for what's made in fire must properly belong to fire; and so hell's probable.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One can forgive [[DantesInferno Dante's]] merging of Greek and Christian takes of the afterlife and mythology in his ''Divine Comedy'' as creative liberty, but one ''cannot'' forgive him for his use of the centaurs in the outer ring of the seventh circle of Hell, for one distinct reason: he put ''Chiron'', a DefectorFromDecadence and revered ''healer'' and ''sage'', as the ''leader'' of the centaurs driving the damned back into the boiling blood river, and put ''Nessus'', known for ''raping Hercules' second wife and tricking her into poisoning Hercules to death'', as the one the one who helps Dante and Virgil across the river. Apparently, all Dante ever knew about them was that they were both centaurs and Nessus carried someone across a river one time.

to:

* One can forgive [[DantesInferno Dante's]] Dante's merging of Greek and Christian takes of the afterlife and mythology in his ''Divine Comedy'' ''Literature/TheDivineComedy'' as creative liberty, but one ''cannot'' forgive him for his use of the centaurs in the outer ring of the seventh circle of Hell, for one distinct reason: he put ''Chiron'', a DefectorFromDecadence and revered ''healer'' and ''sage'', as the ''leader'' of the centaurs driving the damned back into the boiling blood river, and put ''Nessus'', known for ''raping Hercules' second wife and tricking her into poisoning Hercules to death'', as the one the one who helps Dante and Virgil across the river. Apparently, all Dante ever knew about them was that they were both centaurs and Nessus carried someone across a river one time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''Twilight'', Meyer describes varacolaci as being "a powerful undead being who could appear as a beautiful, pale-skinned human", while they are more famously known as wolf demons that cause solar and lunar eclipses by swallowing the sun and moon respectively. They also appear as ''dry'' pale-skinned humans, not beautiful. In ''Breaking Dawn'' and ''Midnight Sun'', Meyer cites the incubus and succubus as vampires who are known in mythology as being promiscuous and impregnating human women. Both of them were demons who were believed to be the cause of nightmares and wet dreams. Also in ''Breaking Dawn'', the cleaning lady at Bella and Edward's honeymoon site believes that Edward is a "libishomen", described as "a blood-drinking demon who preys exclusively on beautiful women". In reality, lobishomen (the real name of the libishomen in mythology) were monkey-like werewolves.

to:

** In ''Twilight'', Meyer describes varacolaci as being "a powerful undead being who could appear as a beautiful, pale-skinned human", while they are more famously known as wolf demons that cause solar and lunar eclipses by swallowing the sun and moon respectively. They also appear as ''dry'' pale-skinned humans, not beautiful. In ''Breaking Dawn'' and ''Midnight Sun'', Meyer cites the incubus and succubus as vampires who are known in mythology as being promiscuous and impregnating human women.seduced women and men, respectively. Both of them were demons who were believed to be the cause of nightmares and wet dreams. Also in ''Breaking Dawn'', the cleaning lady at Bella and Edward's honeymoon site believes that Edward is a "libishomen", described as "a blood-drinking demon who preys exclusively on beautiful women". In reality, lobishomen (the real name of the libishomen in mythology) were monkey-like werewolves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Anime/MazingerZ'' and another series of the ''{{Mazinger}}'' universe (''Anime/GreatMazinger'', ''ZMazinger'', ''Anime/ShinMazinger'') did this with the Greek myths.
** In the original myths Hades was the God of Underworld, his default shape was humanoid (but like all Greek deities he was a shape-shifter), and even though he was not exactly a nice guy, he was not worse than his relatives. In the Mazinverse he is a GodOfEvil whose (unchangeable) shape is that of a giant being of fire and wishes conquering the surface world.
** ZMazinger is worse in that regard: the Greek gods were {{Sufficiently Advanced Alien}}s that ancient Greeks mistook for gods, Zeus was a rebel turned on their comrades to protect the humans, and Mazinger was his own HumongousMecha.
** Again in ''ShinMazinger'' Zeus shows up but he is way different of the myth -let's say his severed hand is used to build the God Scrander-, and Hades is again a flaming, humongous GodofEvil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Leda: Fantastic Adventure of Yoko'' includes two characters named Lingam and Yoni, which are not only symbolic for Hindu deities, but refer to the male and female sex organs.

to:

* ''Leda: Fantastic Adventure of Yoko'' ''Anime/GenmuSenkiLeda'' includes two characters named Lingam and Yoni, which are not only symbolic for Hindu deities, but refer to the male and female sex organs.

Changed: 14

Removed: 227

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''SaintSeiya'' did so with Greek and Norse myth.

to:

* ''SaintSeiya'' ''Manga/SaintSeiya'' did so with Greek and Norse myth.



* Kinnikuman blundered badly with this. Supposedly, there are lots and lots of gods out there of various planets, yet there's still {{Satan}}, and he's still the mastermind of all the Akuma Choujin/Demon Supermen. But Choujin don't go to Hell, they go to an underworld led by Choujin Enma. Then there's Ashuraman, who at least is correct in his depiction as a three-faced, six-armed individual. Of course, then we find out about his teacher, [[Literature/TheBible Samson Teacher]] [[spoiler:who later becomes Satan Cross, one of the final BigBad's [[QuirkyMinibossSquad subordinates]],]] who displays similar similar anatomy but has no reference to biblical Samson [[spoiler:or Satan]] at all.

to:

* Kinnikuman ''{{Kinnikuman}}'' blundered badly with this. Supposedly, there are lots and lots of gods out there of various planets, yet there's still {{Satan}}, and he's still the mastermind of all the Akuma Choujin/Demon Supermen. But Choujin don't go to Hell, they go to an underworld led by Choujin Enma. Then there's Ashuraman, who at least is correct in his depiction as a three-faced, six-armed individual. Of course, then we find out about his teacher, [[Literature/TheBible Samson Teacher]] [[spoiler:who later becomes Satan Cross, one of the final BigBad's [[QuirkyMinibossSquad subordinates]],]] who displays similar similar anatomy but has no reference to biblical Samson [[spoiler:or Satan]] at all.



* Creator/JackChick does this with ''every'' religion he writes about, [[PoesLaw including the one he's supposed to be promoting]].
** This is a large part of why people thought his work was an example of StealthParody at first.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's definitely the latter given that Melville was a classically educated man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In Western media, due to the JesusTaboo and the like, pagan mythologies are more susceptible. The Japanese, on the other hand, have no qualms about bizarre portrayals of Christianity -- or Shinto.

to:

In Western media, due to the JesusTaboo and the like, pagan mythologies are more susceptible. The Japanese, on the other hand, have no qualms about bizarre portrayals of Christianity -- or Shinto.
Shinto, for that matter.

Top