Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / PovertyPorn

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Filipino indie filmmaker Brillante Mendoza is known for making films that depict the harsh realities of Filipino society. Some of his movies gained recognition from various international film festivals such as the Cannes Film Festival etc. However, several domestic film critics noted that his films are "poverty porn" which led to the misconception that Filipino indie films are all about poverty despite that not all indie films are about that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC: PSAs]]

to:

[[AC: PSAs]]Public Service Announcements]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: PSAs]]
* "Great Nations Eat" invoked this trope in two ads by depicting America as the poverty-ridden country in question where 20% of children suffer malnourishment, and the comparatively better off nations of [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WpOEViZHB3A Germany]] and [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBcX2EBwnNI China]] appealing to their citizenry to aid American children.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:{{Film}}]]

to:

[[AC:{{Film}}]][[AC:{{Film}} -- Live-Action]]

Added: 4

Changed: 2592

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Discussed in ''Film/BloodDiamond''. Maddy, an American journalist, starts writing a report about the social ravaging caused by the wars in Sierra Leone, but grows frustrated because she feels it won't make real effect, comparing to advertisements of starving children. Guilted by her vexation, the listening Archer starts admitting his inside knowledge of the blood diamond trade, giving her report a stronger call to political action.

to:

* Discussed in ''Film/BloodDiamond''. ''Film/BloodDiamond'': {{Discussed}}. Maddy, an American journalist, starts writing a report about the social ravaging caused by the wars in Sierra Leone, Leone but grows frustrated because she feels it won't make any real effect, comparing effect. She compares it to advertisements of featuring starving children. Guilted by her vexation, the listening Archer starts admitting his inside knowledge of the blood diamond trade, giving her report a stronger call to political action.



* This was a frequent criticism of ''Film/SlumdogMillionaire'', in that to Indian viewers it came off as depicting the real life hardships of slums in India as merely a backdrop to a Cinderella-esque story.
* Brazilian cinema is sometimes called on this in the country, due to the sheer number of films exploting the favelas as a backdrop (''Film/CityOfGod'' and ''Film/TheEliteSquad'' being the most notorious examples), to the point that the term "Favela Movie" was coined by some journalists and cinema critics.

to:

* ''Film/SlumdogMillionaire'': This was a frequent criticism of ''Film/SlumdogMillionaire'', the film, in that to Indian viewers it came off as depicting the real life real-life hardships of slums in India as merely a backdrop to a Cinderella-esque story.
* Brazilian cinema is sometimes called on this in the country, due to the sheer number of films exploting exploiting the favelas as a backdrop (''Film/CityOfGod'' and ''Film/TheEliteSquad'' being the most notorious examples), to the point that the term "Favela Movie" was coined by some journalists and cinema critics.



* Both {{Discussed}} and {{Deconstructed}} in ''Series/AdamRuinsEverything'' when Emily is quick to understand the good intentions of "Buy One, Give One" companies, in which Adam appropriately points out the flaws. She also demonstrates how she's a typical victim of "poverty porn" as she describes to Adam how she picture that would-be less-fortunate African and her visual interpretation is so stereotypical yet crass and offensive that she stops in the middle of it, realizing its "condescending" implications.
* {{Parodied}} in the ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' sketch "39 Cents" where Creator/BillHader plays Charles Daniels, an old white man asking for viewers at home to send a check of 39 cents to help the poor country he's in (while the natives are adamant that more than 39 cents in cash should be sent instead). Daniels makes the big mistake of guessing the country he's in is [[AfricaIsACountry Africa]], prompting the natives to hold him for a ransom of $200 cash.
* On ''Series/MyNameIsEarl'', Earl recalls that back when he and Joy were still married (before he began working on [[ListOfTransgressions The List]]), they watched a commercial like this for some organization helping children in Africa, which inspired them to start a FakeCharity. Earl gave up on it after a while, but Joy kept it up, even long after she divorced Earl and married Darnell. She sent a picture to her primary "donor" of a boy named "Mbungo," which was really just a picture of Earl Jr. and a fly. She also got some of the other trailer park women in on her scam, with each of them invoking this trope in their own ways for their fake charity scams. [[spoiler: After a series of disasters ensues, these women are left in dire straits for real, [[LaserGuidedKarma in ways very similar to what they had faked photos of and lied about]]. The old man that they were scamming wrote them checks anyway, saying how it felt good to give, and to forgive.]]

to:

* ''Series/AdamRuinsEverything'': Both {{Discussed}} and {{Deconstructed}} in ''Series/AdamRuinsEverything'' when Emily is quick to understand the good intentions of "Buy One, Give One" companies, in which Adam appropriately points out the flaws. She also demonstrates how she's a typical victim of "poverty porn" as she describes to Adam how she picture that would-be less-fortunate African and her visual interpretation is so stereotypical yet crass and offensive that she stops in the middle of it, realizing its "condescending" implications.
* {{Parodied}} in the ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' sketch "39 Cents" where Creator/BillHader plays Charles Daniels, an old white man asking for viewers at home to send a check of 39 cents to help the poor country he's in (while the natives are adamant that more than 39 cents in cash should be sent instead). Daniels makes the big mistake of guessing the country he's in is [[AfricaIsACountry Africa]], prompting the natives to hold him for a ransom of $200 cash.
* On ''Series/MyNameIsEarl'',
''Series/MyNameIsEarl'': Earl recalls that back when he and Joy were still married (before he began working on [[ListOfTransgressions The List]]), they watched a commercial like this for some organization helping children in Africa, which inspired them to start a FakeCharity. Earl gave up on it after a while, but Joy kept it up, even long after she divorced Earl and married Darnell. She sent a picture to her primary "donor" of a boy named "Mbungo," which was really just a picture of Earl Jr. and a fly. She also got some of the other trailer park women in on her scam, with each of them invoking this trope in their own ways for their fake charity scams. [[spoiler: After a series of disasters ensues, these women are left in dire straits for real, [[LaserGuidedKarma in ways very similar to what they had faked photos of and lied about]]. The old man that they were scamming wrote them checks anyway, saying how it felt good to give, and to forgive.]]
* ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'': {{Parodied}} in the sketch "39 Cents" where Creator/BillHader plays Charles Daniels, an old white man asking for viewers at home to send a check of 39 cents to help the poor country he's in (while the natives are adamant that more than 39 cents in cash should be sent instead). Daniels makes the big mistake of guessing the country he's in is [[AfricaIsACountry Africa]], prompting the natives to hold him for a ransom of $200 cash.



* Parodied in a ''Website/CollegeHumor'' [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_ZwY99womA sketch]] about an "Adopt-A-Graduate" program, that parodies those "sponsor a child" programs. It features recent college grads staring forlornly into the camera and crying because GrowingUpSucks.

to:

* Parodied ''Website/CollegeHumor'': {{Parodied}} in a ''Website/CollegeHumor'' [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_ZwY99womA sketch]] about an "Adopt-A-Graduate" program, that parodies those "sponsor a child" programs. It features recent college grads staring forlornly into the camera and crying because GrowingUpSucks.



* Joãosinho Trinta noted this as a reason for why he chose to create lavish costumes and floats for Carnival, [[FollowTheLeader creating a trend]]: "Only intellectuals like poverty, the poor people like luxury."

to:

* Joãosinho Trinta noted this as a reason for why he chose to create lavish costumes and floats for Carnival, [[FollowTheLeader creating a trend]]: "Only intellectuals like poverty, the poor people like luxury.""
----


This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations with images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) who fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation of JustPenniesADay" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it).

to:

This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations with images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) who fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation of JustPenniesADay" [[PaymentPlanPitch just pennies a day]]" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking jpad (surprised it hadn't been earlier tbh) and improving snl desc


This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations with images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) who fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it).

to:

This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations with images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) who fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation" donation of JustPenniesADay" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it).



* {{Parodied}} on the ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' Season 40 episode hosted by Bill Hader as the latter played Charlie Daniels, an wannabe old white guy asking for viewers at home to send a check of 39 cents to help the poor country he's in while the natives are adamant that more than 39 cents in cash should be sent instead. It even gets worse when Daniels makes the big mistake of guessing the country he's in is Africa (a continent) that the natives decided to hold him ransom for $200 cash.

to:

* {{Parodied}} on in the ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' Season 40 episode hosted by Bill Hader as the latter played Charlie sketch "39 Cents" where Creator/BillHader plays Charles Daniels, an wannabe old white guy man asking for viewers at home to send a check of 39 cents to help the poor country he's in while (while the natives are adamant that more than 39 cents in cash should be sent instead. It even gets worse when instead). Daniels makes the big mistake of guessing the country he's in is Africa (a continent) that [[AfricaIsACountry Africa]], prompting the natives decided to hold him for a ransom for of $200 cash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations in which images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it).

to:

This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations in which with images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) who fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The critic Diana George says many organizations have such a hard time convincing people living in first-world Western civilizations (particularly in America) that real poverty is actually out there that they resort to this in order to gain favor.

to:

* The critic Diana George says many organizations have such a hard time convincing people living in first-world Western civilizations (particularly in America) that real poverty is actually out there that they resort to this in order to gain favor.favor.
* Joãosinho Trinta noted this as a reason for why he chose to create lavish costumes and floats for Carnival, [[FollowTheLeader creating a trend]]: "Only intellectuals like poverty, the poor people like luxury."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"Rich people will travel great distances to look at poor people."''
-->-- From the liner notes to '''''[[Music/TalkingHeads "Stop Making Sense"]]'''''

to:

->''"Rich ->''Rich people will travel great distances to look at poor people."''
''
-->-- From the liner notes to '''''[[Music/TalkingHeads "Stop ''[[Music/TalkingHeads Stop Making Sense"]]'''''
Sense]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

--> "You're right. It's shit. It's like one of those infomercials with African kids with swollen bellies and flies in their eyes. See here I've got dead mothers, I've got severed limbs, but it's ''nothing'' new. Sure, it might make some people cry if they read it, maybe even write a check. But it's not going to be enough to make it stop!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Brazilian cinema is sometimes called on this in the country, due to the sheer number of films exploting the favelas as a backdrop (''Film/CityOfGod'' and ''Film/TheEliteSquad'' being the most notorious examples), to the point that the term "Favela Movie" was coined by some journalists and cinema critics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Parodied in a ''CollegeHumor'' [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_ZwY99womA sketch]] about an "Adopt-A-Graduate" program, that parodies those "sponsor a child" programs. It features recent college grads staring forlornly into the camera and crying because GrowingUpSucks.

to:

* Parodied in a ''CollegeHumor'' ''Website/CollegeHumor'' [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_ZwY99womA sketch]] about an "Adopt-A-Graduate" program, that parodies those "sponsor a child" programs. It features recent college grads staring forlornly into the camera and crying because GrowingUpSucks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: Web Original]]
* Parodied in a ''CollegeHumor'' [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_ZwY99womA sketch]] about an "Adopt-A-Graduate" program, that parodies those "sponsor a child" programs. It features recent college grads staring forlornly into the camera and crying because GrowingUpSucks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Not to be confused with PoorMansPorn, were it possible. Also see AppealToWorseProblems and FirstWorldProblems.

to:

Not to be confused with PoorMansPorn, were it possible. Also see AppealToWorseProblems and FirstWorldProblems.
FirstWorldProblems, as well as DarkestAfrica.




to:

* On ''Series/MyNameIsEarl'', Earl recalls that back when he and Joy were still married (before he began working on [[ListOfTransgressions The List]]), they watched a commercial like this for some organization helping children in Africa, which inspired them to start a FakeCharity. Earl gave up on it after a while, but Joy kept it up, even long after she divorced Earl and married Darnell. She sent a picture to her primary "donor" of a boy named "Mbungo," which was really just a picture of Earl Jr. and a fly. She also got some of the other trailer park women in on her scam, with each of them invoking this trope in their own ways for their fake charity scams. [[spoiler: After a series of disasters ensues, these women are left in dire straits for real, [[LaserGuidedKarma in ways very similar to what they had faked photos of and lied about]]. The old man that they were scamming wrote them checks anyway, saying how it felt good to give, and to forgive.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Parodied}} on the ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' Season 40 episode hosted by Bill Hader as the latter played Charlie Daniels, an wannabe old white guy asking for viewers at home to send a check of 39 cents to help the poor country he's in while the natives are adamant that more than 39 cents should be sent instead. It even gets worse when Daniels makes the big mistake of assuming the country he's in is an African one that the natives decided to hold him ransom for a check of $200.

to:

* {{Parodied}} on the ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' Season 40 episode hosted by Bill Hader as the latter played Charlie Daniels, an wannabe old white guy asking for viewers at home to send a check of 39 cents to help the poor country he's in while the natives are adamant that more than 39 cents in cash should be sent instead. It even gets worse when Daniels makes the big mistake of assuming guessing the country he's in is an African one Africa (a continent) that the natives decided to hold him ransom for a check of $200.
$200 cash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--from the liner notes to '''''[[Music/TalkingHeads "Stop Making Sense"]]'''''

to:

-->--from -->-- From the liner notes to '''''[[Music/TalkingHeads "Stop Making Sense"]]'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''Not to be confused with PoorMansPorn, were it possible.''

to:

->''Not ->''"Rich people will travel great distances to be confused with PoorMansPorn, were it possible.''
look at poor people."''
-->--from the liner notes to '''''[[Music/TalkingHeads "Stop Making Sense"]]'''''



Also see AppealToWorseProblems and FirstWorldProblems.

to:

Not to be confused with PoorMansPorn, were it possible. Also see AppealToWorseProblems and FirstWorldProblems.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->''Not to be confused with PoorMansPorn, were it possible.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Formatting.


Also see Appeal To Worse Problems and First World Problems

to:

Also see Appeal To Worse Problems AppealToWorseProblems and First World Problems
FirstWorldProblems.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


Also see Appeal To Worse Problems and First World Problems
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope examples should be specific; vague "this happens a lot" pronouncements aren't allowed (and this one in particular is just repeating what's already been said in the trope description)


* Who hasn't seen that one commercial of a well-meaning charity, whether that would-be abandoned dog with multiple bruises or a starving child in a would-be underdeveloped country like some in Africa and felt some kind of pity that you felt the urge to make a donation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse of Exact Words


* Both {{Discussed}} and {{Deconstructed}} in ''Series/AdamRuinsEverything'' when Emily is quick to understand the good intentions of "Buy One, Give One" companies, in which Adam appropriately points out the flaws. She also demonstrates how she's a typical victim of "poverty porn" as she describes to Adam how she picture that would-be less-fortunate African and her visual interpretation is so stereotypical yet crass and offensive that she stops in the middle of it, realizing it's [[ExactWords "condescending"]] implications.

to:

* Both {{Discussed}} and {{Deconstructed}} in ''Series/AdamRuinsEverything'' when Emily is quick to understand the good intentions of "Buy One, Give One" companies, in which Adam appropriately points out the flaws. She also demonstrates how she's a typical victim of "poverty porn" as she describes to Adam how she picture that would-be less-fortunate African and her visual interpretation is so stereotypical yet crass and offensive that she stops in the middle of it, realizing it's [[ExactWords "condescending"]] implications. its "condescending" implications.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Taking out some of the unnecessary sarcasm and fixing some of the grammar in this example.


* Critic Diana George says many organizations have a hard time convincing people living in first-world Western citizens (cough, cough, Americans) that real poverty is really out there that they resort to this in order to gain favor.

to:

* Critic The critic Diana George says many organizations have such a hard time convincing people living in first-world Western citizens (cough, cough, Americans) civilizations (particularly in America) that real poverty is really actually out there that they resort to this in order to gain favor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

Added: 412

Changed: 387

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations in which images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it). Your feelings at this point are supposed to be mixed feelings of pity and outrage. The tactic instills this response in you and then gives you an "opportunity" to act out your outrage while still showing your pity to these less fortunate people. Certain images are utilized in this way so often that they are practically "cash cows" for the well-meaning charity organization to show you.

to:

This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations in which images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it).
[[EveryoneHasStandards
Your feelings at this point are supposed to be mixed feelings of pity and outrage. outrage.]] The tactic instills this response in you and then gives you an "opportunity" to act out your outrage while still showing your pity to these less fortunate people. Certain images are utilized in this way so often that they are practically "cash cows" for the well-meaning charity organization to show you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A tactic most commonly seen on TV, "poverty porn" is essentially when the condition of impoverished people is exploited in order to generate the necessary sympathy for selling a product (e.g. newspapers), or increasing charitable donations (or general support) for a given cause. This tactic can be in any type of media — be it written, photographed, or filmed.

to:

A tactic most commonly seen on TV, "poverty porn" is essentially when the condition of impoverished people is exploited in order to generate the necessary sympathy for selling a product (e.g. newspapers), or increasing charitable donations (or general support) for a given cause. This tactic can be in any type of media — be media, whether it written, photographed, or filmed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Created from YKTTW

Added DiffLines:

A tactic most commonly seen on TV, "poverty porn" is essentially when the condition of impoverished people is exploited in order to generate the necessary sympathy for selling a product (e.g. newspapers), or increasing charitable donations (or general support) for a given cause. This tactic can be in any type of media — be it written, photographed, or filmed.
This is usually seen in commercials asking for donations in which images of abandoned dogs with bruises ([[{{Jerkass}} implicitly caused by their former pet owner]]) fail to stand inside a cage, or of starving children in an [[CrapsackWorld undeveloped, war-ridden homeland that's under a dictatorship.]] Then the would-be-celebrity appears on the screen to guilt trip you into making a "small donation" (the "bare minimum" as they professionally call it). Your feelings at this point are supposed to be mixed feelings of pity and outrage. The tactic instills this response in you and then gives you an "opportunity" to act out your outrage while still showing your pity to these less fortunate people. Certain images are utilized in this way so often that they are practically "cash cows" for the well-meaning charity organization to show you.
----

!!Examples

[[AC:{{Film}}]]
* Discussed in ''Film/BloodDiamond''. Maddy, an American journalist, starts writing a report about the social ravaging caused by the wars in Sierra Leone, but grows frustrated because she feels it won't make real effect, comparing to advertisements of starving children. Guilted by her vexation, the listening Archer starts admitting his inside knowledge of the blood diamond trade, giving her report a stronger call to political action.
* This was a frequent criticism of ''Film/SlumdogMillionaire'', in that to Indian viewers it came off as depicting the real life hardships of slums in India as merely a backdrop to a Cinderella-esque story.

[[AC:LiveActionTV]]
* Both {{Discussed}} and {{Deconstructed}} in ''Series/AdamRuinsEverything'' when Emily is quick to understand the good intentions of "Buy One, Give One" companies, in which Adam appropriately points out the flaws. She also demonstrates how she's a typical victim of "poverty porn" as she describes to Adam how she picture that would-be less-fortunate African and her visual interpretation is so stereotypical yet crass and offensive that she stops in the middle of it, realizing it's [[ExactWords "condescending"]] implications.
* {{Parodied}} on the ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' Season 40 episode hosted by Bill Hader as the latter played Charlie Daniels, an wannabe old white guy asking for viewers at home to send a check of 39 cents to help the poor country he's in while the natives are adamant that more than 39 cents should be sent instead. It even gets worse when Daniels makes the big mistake of assuming the country he's in is an African one that the natives decided to hold him ransom for a check of $200.

[[AC:RealLife]]
* Who hasn't seen that one commercial of a well-meaning charity, whether that would-be abandoned dog with multiple bruises or a starving child in a would-be underdeveloped country like some in Africa and felt some kind of pity that you felt the urge to make a donation.
* Critic Diana George says many organizations have a hard time convincing people living in first-world Western citizens (cough, cough, Americans) that real poverty is really out there that they resort to this in order to gain favor.

Top