Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MartyrdomCulture

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-> Even a man who has nothing can still have faith. Even a man who has nothing can still offer his life.

to:

-> Even ->''Even a man who has nothing can still have faith. Even a man who has nothing can still offer his life.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''FinalFantasyX'', the summoners and guardians who give their lives to destroy [[EldritchAbomination Sin]] and bring about the Calm (an era of peace) are lauded as heroes; in fact, the pilgrimages that the summoners and their parties take are practically treated as races. Too bad the whole process only perpetuates a cycle; the Calm doesn't last for very long until Sin returns again [[spoiler:as Yu Yevon simply uses the guardian who was sacrificed for the destruction ritual to recreate the beast, who is an armour of sorts for Yu Yevon himself]]. Only the Al Bhed seem to oppose this culture, [[FantasticRacism and are ostracised from society as a result]].



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** In addition, to deal with this problem, some Vikings interpreted a worthy death not simply as charging heroically but dying with a sword at hand. Thus, a ceremonial gesture of handing a sword to a hero in his deathbed was seen as a solution in some parts.

to:

**** In addition, order to deal with this problem, some Vikings interpreted a worthy death not the conditions for entering Valhalla simply as charging heroically but dying with your sword. Therefore, handing an aged hero a sword at hand. Thus, a ceremonial gesture of handing a sword to a hero in his deathbed was seen as a an acceptable solution in some parts.to this dilemma.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** In addition, to deal with this problem, some Vikings interpreted a worthy death not simply as charging heroically but dying with a sword at hand. Thus, a ceremonial gesture of handing a sword to a hero in his deathbed was seen as a solution in some parts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CyranoDeBergerac: This trope is deconstructed because the play shows it to his logical extreme: self-destruction. All the [[ProudWarriorRaceGuy Gascons]] sincerely believe that to die for one's beliefs is the only truly worthwhile thing one can do with one's life. A man who is convinced he is going to die young in battle doesn’t want to be friendly with others or compromise to make something of his life. He will throw his life for a [[BerserkButton minor reason]], act to others like a JerkAss at best or a HeroicSociopath at worst. [[DeathSeeker Who is the most popular among the Gascons? Cyrano]], [[MartyrWithoutACause the guy who burn his bridges and resist every chance of glory]] or [[LoveMartyr love he has.]] [[AllOfTheOtherReindeer Who is the most unpopular? De Guiche]], [[NoTrueScotsman the guy who dares to live like he has a future]] [[AmbitionIsEvil and compromises to get power.]]


to:

* CyranoDeBergerac: This trope is deconstructed ''deconstructed'' because the play shows it to his logical extreme: self-destruction. All the [[ProudWarriorRaceGuy Gascons]] sincerely believe that to die for one's beliefs is the only truly worthwhile thing one can do with one's life. A man who is convinced he is going to die young in battle doesn’t want to be friendly with others or compromise to make something of his life. He will throw his life for a [[BerserkButton minor reason]], act to others like a JerkAss at best or a HeroicSociopath at worst. [[DeathSeeker Who is the most popular among the Gascons? Cyrano]], [[MartyrWithoutACause the guy who burn his bridges and resist every chance of glory]] or [[LoveMartyr love he has.]] [[AllOfTheOtherReindeer Who is the most unpopular? De Guiche]], [[NoTrueScotsman the guy who dares to live like he has a future]] [[AmbitionIsEvil and compromises to get power.]]

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add a reference to Cyrano de Bergerac

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Teather]]
* CyranoDeBergerac: This trope is deconstructed because the play shows it to his logical extreme: self-destruction. All the [[ProudWarriorRaceGuy Gascons]] sincerely believe that to die for one's beliefs is the only truly worthwhile thing one can do with one's life. A man who is convinced he is going to die young in battle doesn’t want to be friendly with others or compromise to make something of his life. He will throw his life for a [[BerserkButton minor reason]], act to others like a JerkAss at best or a HeroicSociopath at worst. [[DeathSeeker Who is the most popular among the Gascons? Cyrano]], [[MartyrWithoutACause the guy who burn his bridges and resist every chance of glory]] or [[LoveMartyr love he has.]] [[AllOfTheOtherReindeer Who is the most unpopular? De Guiche]], [[NoTrueScotsman the guy who dares to live like he has a future]] [[AmbitionIsEvil and compromises to get power.]]

Added: 307

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** By ''Halo 3'' the [[ProudWarriorRace Elites]] have changed sides as they find the Humans they were previously fighting against more to their liking.

to:

** By ''Halo 3'' [[spoiler: the [[ProudWarriorRace Elites]] have changed sides as they find the Humans they were previously fighting against more to their liking.]]
** Among the Elites, there is the position of Arbiter, a rank which disgraced Elite commanders can be given to go on suicide missions and die as the will of the Prophets. The irony should not be lost that [[spoiler: the last Arbiter appointed ended up leading the Elites in rebellion against the Prophets.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The name of the WarriorCaste segment of the Polaris, in EscapeVelocity Nova, translates to "Fallen Leaves". They are taught to consider themselves already dead in the service of their people. They seek no personal glory in death, instead they dedicate their lives to protecting the lives and values of their people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Jem'Hadar aren't really a good example. They don't seek to die in battle, they already consider themselves dead in the service of their LivingGods, the Founders, (there is NO OTHER DEATH for a Jem'Hadar). They know the Founders consider them to be disposable soldiers and regard themselves as such as well. The only reason they even try to survive a battle is so that the Founders will have the benefit of veteran soldiers (living as long as 14 years is enough to earn "Honored Elder" status for a Jem'Haddar). Their BattleCry actually seems to be an inverse of the Klingons' own: Where the Klingons say "Today '''is''' a good day to die!", the Jem'hadar say "Victory is ''Life''!" They want to win the battle so they can ''live to serve their gods some more''.

to:

** The Jem'Hadar aren't really a good example. They don't seek to die in battle, they already consider themselves dead in the service of their LivingGods, PhysicalGods, the Founders, (there is NO OTHER DEATH for a Jem'Hadar). They know the Founders consider them to be disposable soldiers and regard themselves as such as well. The only reason they even try to survive a battle is so that the Founders will have the benefit of veteran soldiers (living as long as 14 years is enough to earn "Honored Elder" status for a Jem'Haddar). Their BattleCry actually seems to be an inverse of the Klingons' own: Where the Klingons say "Today '''is''' a good day to die!", the Jem'hadar say "Victory is ''Life''!" They want to win the battle so they can ''live to serve their gods some more''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Jem'Hadar aren't really a good example. They don't seek to die in battle, they seek to serve the founders (which often sees them dying in battle). Their BattleCry actually seems to be an inverse of the Klingons' own: Where the Klingons say "Today '''is''' a good day to die!", the Jem'hadar say "Victory is ''Life''!" They want to win the battle so they can ''live to serve their gods some more''.

to:

** The Jem'Hadar aren't really a good example. They don't seek to die in battle, they seek to serve already consider themselves dead in the founders (which often sees service of their LivingGods, the Founders, (there is NO OTHER DEATH for a Jem'Hadar). They know the Founders consider them dying in battle).to be disposable soldiers and regard themselves as such as well. The only reason they even try to survive a battle is so that the Founders will have the benefit of veteran soldiers (living as long as 14 years is enough to earn "Honored Elder" status for a Jem'Haddar). Their BattleCry actually seems to be an inverse of the Klingons' own: Where the Klingons say "Today '''is''' a good day to die!", the Jem'hadar say "Victory is ''Life''!" They want to win the battle so they can ''live to serve their gods some more''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:{{Anime/Manga}}]]
* In DoubleArts, the Sisters are an order of teenaged girls trained as sympathetic healers of a deadly disease. They have a heightened resistance to the disease, but because they absorb the symptoms of their patients, they are shunned by society and few of them live to be twenty years old...and yet they go about their work cheerfully and willingly, and many of them openly consider it to be an honor. This freaks the male lead out severely, particularly as he gets to know [[spoiler:and love]] one of the Sisters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted, strangely enough, with the [[StarWars Mandalorians]]. They're fine with dying in battle, but are rather pragmatic about it. They revere those who live long enough to raise families and pass on their ways. Their BattleCry translates to "Today is a good day for someone else to die!"

to:

* Averted, strangely enough, with the [[StarWars Mandalorians]]. They're fine with dying in battle, but are rather pragmatic about it. They revere those who live long enough to raise families and pass on their ways. Their BattleCry translates to "Today is a good day for someone else to die!"
die!"
* In ''TheLostFleet'' series, after spending a century locked in a ForeverWar, both sides are churning through troops so fast that they actively promote HonorBeforeReason mindsets, lacking the time and will for any proper military training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Lakota Dog Soldiers pinned the ends of their breechclouts to the ground and faced their enemies. Given that the average Native American combat was not about fighting to the death, someone who did that was supremely badass.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Shofixti from ''StarControl'', going BeyondTheImpossible. Each of their ships is described as having a "Glory Device" strapped onto it. At the beginning of ''Star Control II'', you are told that rather than be enslaved by the Ur-Quan they blew up their sun, wiping out their entire planet, race, and a good chunk of the Ur-Quan fleet.

to:

* The Shofixti from ''StarControl'', going BeyondTheImpossible. Each of their ships is described as having a "Glory Device" strapped onto it. At the beginning of ''Star Control II'', you are told that rather than be enslaved by the Ur-Quan they blew up their sun, wiping out their entire planet, race, and a good chunk of the Ur-Quan fleet. Then it turns out [[NiceJobBreakingItHero those were the nicer Ur-Quan they just killed, and their less pleasant cousins no longer have obstacles in the way.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


At least according to Agent Scully of ''TheXFiles'', [[SoYouWantToLiveForever most people want to live forever.]] Of course, for most of us, that's rarely a [[SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsRealism realistic]] option, even in fiction. For some the inevitability of death is just [[CrapsackWorld the way things are]]. For the DeathSeeker, on the other hand, death can't come soon enough. In many modern societies, {{Death Seeker}}s are very rare, and in many they are regarded as mentally unstable, but sometimes, the DeathSeeker can become a role model.

to:

At least according to Agent Scully AgentScully of ''TheXFiles'', [[SoYouWantToLiveForever most people want to live forever.]] Of course, for most of us, that's rarely a [[SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsRealism realistic]] option, even in fiction. For some the inevitability of death is just [[CrapsackWorld the way things are]]. For the DeathSeeker, on the other hand, death can't come soon enough. In many modern societies, {{Death Seeker}}s are very rare, and in many they are regarded as mentally unstable, but sometimes, the DeathSeeker can become a role model.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In Irish culture, fasting and hunger striking has used as a tool of political redress since the time of the Brehon Laws in the 7th-8th century. The most famous recent example is the 1981 deaths by starvation of Bobby Sands and nine other prison inmates, in protest of British abuses in Northern Ireland. W.B. Yeats describes it thus:
-->For there is a custom,
-->An old and foolish custom, that if a man
-->Be wronged, or think that he is wronged, and starve
-->Upon another's threshold till he die,
-->The Common People, for all time to come,
-->Will raise a heavy cry against that threshold,
-->Even though it be the King's.

Changed: 408

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The Jem'Hadar aren't really a good example. They don't seek to die in battle, they seek to serve the founders (which often sees them dying in battle). Their BattleCry actually seems to be an inverse of the Klingons' own: Where the Klingons say "Today '''is''' a good day to die!", the Jem'hadar say "Victory is ''Life''!" They want to win the battle so they can ''live to serve their gods some more''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[OrSoIHeard I recall]] an old martial arts movie where a student at a martial arts school bows before the masters and a visiting champion. The champion proceeds to kill the student, and two younger students silently remove the body. It is explained that to die in the process of creating such a great master is an honor that students would compete to obtain.

to:

* [[OrSoIHeard I recall]] an An old martial arts movie where a student at a martial arts school bows before the masters and a visiting champion. The champion proceeds to kill the student, and two younger students silently remove the body. It is explained that to die in the process of creating such a great master is an honor that students would compete to obtain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Indirectly inverted in the famous opening (and entirely fictitious) speech of {{Patton}}:

to:

* Indirectly inverted in the famous opening (and entirely fictitious) speech of {{Patton}}:''{{Patton}}'':

Added: 151

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Forgotten Realms novels this became a big problem for new god of the dead Kelemvor when he tried to be more rewarding of heroism as people starting committing heroic suicide with alarming regularity and effective death cults started popping up. The experience was sufficently troubling that Kelemvor eventually changed his alignment from Neutral Good to Lawful Neutral and after he couldn't be bothered to really care.

to:

* In the Forgotten Realms novels this became a big problem for new god of the dead Kelemvor when he tried to be more rewarding of heroism as people starting committing heroic suicide with alarming regularity and effective death cults started popping up. The experience was sufficently sufficiently troubling that Kelemvor eventually changed his alignment from Neutral Good to Lawful Neutral and after he couldn't be bothered to really care.


Added DiffLines:

** By ''Halo 3'' the [[ProudWarriorRace Elites]] have changed sides as they find the Humans they were previously fighting against more to their liking.

Added: 155

Changed: 91

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Indirectly inverted in the famous opening (and entirely fictitious) speech of {{Patton}}:
--> "I want you to remember that no bastard ever won a war by dying for his country. He won it by making the other poor, dumb bastard die for his country."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted, strangely enough, with the [[StarWars Mandalorians]]. They're fine with dying in battle, but are rather pragmatic about it. They revere those who live long enough to raise families and pass on their ways. Their Battle
Cry translates to "Today is a good day for someone else to die!"

to:

* Averted, strangely enough, with the [[StarWars Mandalorians]]. They're fine with dying in battle, but are rather pragmatic about it. They revere those who live long enough to raise families and pass on their ways. Their Battle
Cry
BattleCry translates to "Today is a good day for someone else to die!"

Added: 64

Changed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Averted, strangely enough, with the [[StarWars Mandalorians]]. They're fine with dying in battle, but are rather pragmatic about it. They revere those who live long enough to raise families and pass on their ways. Their Battle
Cry translates to "Today is a good day for someone else to die!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** To straighten the record about martyrdom in Islam, those who died in battle in service of God is automatically granted a place at the third highest level of heaven. The problem is deciding whether suicide bombers are considered martyrs (contrary to popular western perception, the majority of Muslims doesn't approve suicide bombing) as well [[LeeroyJenkins those who blindly charge towards the enemy]].

to:

*** ** To straighten the record about martyrdom in Islam, those who died in battle in service of God is automatically granted a place at the third highest level of heaven. The problem is deciding whether suicide bombers are considered martyrs (contrary to popular western perception, the majority of Muslims doesn't approve suicide bombing) as well [[LeeroyJenkins those who blindly charge towards the enemy]].

Added: 211

Changed: 321

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** On the other hand, "true-church" Protestants who took the New Testament at its word were especially eager to give up their lives in the service of [[ActualPacifist pacifism]], as a testament to their faith and commitment. Of course, the people torturing them were [[ChurchMilitant other Protestants]] and TheSpanishInquisition who claimed, in turn, that torture would have a cleansing effect if they recanted, not a punitive one.

to:

*** On the other hand, "true-church" Protestants who took the New Testament at its word were especially eager to give up their lives in the service of [[ActualPacifist pacifism]], as a testament to and "martyrdom stories" would be the primary accounts of their faith and commitment. church's development, with each church leader seeking to outdo the last in outrageous acts of asceticism.
***
Of course, the people torturing them were [[ChurchMilitant other Protestants]] and TheSpanishInquisition who claimed, in turn, that torture would have a cleansing effect if they recanted, not a punitive one.

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In some cases, the optimum death is an ObiWanMoment on a battlefield, for others it is a long and painful death, so one can not merely die, but ''suffer'' for one's beliefs. This can sometimes lead to a culture of {{Nightmare Fetishist}}s which [[BlueAndOrangeMorality may appear to be]] AlwaysChaoticEvil to outsiders {{squick}}ed by their rituals.

to:

In some cases, the optimum death is an ObiWanMoment on a battlefield, for others it is a long and painful death, so one can not merely die, but ''suffer'' for one's beliefs. This can sometimes lead to a culture of {{Nightmare Fetishist}}s which [[BlueAndOrangeMorality may appear to be]] be AlwaysChaoticEvil to outsiders {{squick}}ed by their rituals.
rituals; See BlueAndOrangeMorality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[AztecMythology The Aztecs]] started out as this, but you know... it's so much fun when the ''[[HumanSacrifice other guy]]'' sacrifices his life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** On the other hand, "true-church" Protestants who took the New Testament at its word were especially eager to give up their lives in the service of [[ActualPacifist pacifism]], as a testament to their faith and commitment. Of course, the people torturing them were [[ChurchMilitant other Protestants]] and TheSpanishInquisition who claimed, in turn, that torture would have a cleansing effect if they recanted, not a punitive one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

According to ''Science'' Magazine, being willing to die in battle for ones country, or comrades, is a form of in-group Martyrdom Culture known as [[http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/328/5984/1408 Parochial Altruism]] and is regulated by hormone-inducing stressful situations.

Changed: 26

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In some cases, the optimum death is an ObiWanMoment on a battlefield, for others it is a long and painful death, so one can not merely die, but ''suffer'' for one's beliefs. This can sometimes lead to a culture of {{Nightmare Fetishist}}s which may appear to be AlwaysChaoticEvil to outsiders {{squick}}ed by their rituals.

to:

In some cases, the optimum death is an ObiWanMoment on a battlefield, for others it is a long and painful death, so one can not merely die, but ''suffer'' for one's beliefs. This can sometimes lead to a culture of {{Nightmare Fetishist}}s which [[BlueAndOrangeMorality may appear to be be]] AlwaysChaoticEvil to outsiders {{squick}}ed by their rituals.

Top