Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / HistoricalBadassUpgrade

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ancient Spartans are often depicted as top-of-the-top of soldierly skill, an elite and incorruptible ProudWarriorRace, but their actual track record in combat was a lot more lackluster. While having an edge over most other Greeks, their training methods were at best AwesomeButImpractical, their [[CripplingOverspecialization over-reliance on heavy infantry]] came back to bite them on multiple occasions, and at least some of their biggest victories can be attributed to enemy blunders or to having, for a change, cared to look at the bigger picture beyond immediate soldiering. Additionally, writers tend to upplay their performances against Persia, and downplay most other periods--they failed to dislodge Athens for decades in the Peloponnesian War due to their inability to sustain campaigns until they relied on Persian support, needed Persian aid again in the Corinthian War, were soundly defeated by Thebes in the Theban-Spartan War, and ended up utterly crushed by Macedon and again by Rome (under which rule their famously harsh culture became a trashy tourist attraction for Roman aristocrats). Curiously however, they were already on the receiving end of Badass Upgrade in their own times (by other Greeks to boot), so a writer trying to avoid it faces a weight of tradition to overcome.

to:

* The ancient Spartans are often depicted as top-of-the-top of soldierly skill, an elite and incorruptible ProudWarriorRace, but their actual track record in combat was a lot more lackluster. While having an edge over most other Greeks, their training methods were at best AwesomeButImpractical, their [[CripplingOverspecialization over-reliance on heavy infantry]] came back to bite them on multiple occasions, and at least some of their biggest victories can be attributed to enemy blunders or to having, for a change, cared to look at the bigger picture beyond immediate soldiering. Additionally, writers tend to upplay their performances against Persia, and downplay most other periods--they failed to dislodge Athens for decades in the Peloponnesian War due to their inability to sustain campaigns until they relied on Persian support, needed Persian aid again in the Corinthian War, were soundly defeated by Thebes in the Theban-Spartan War, and ended up utterly crushed by Macedon and again by Rome (under which rule their [[TheSpartanWay famously harsh culture culture]] became a trashy tourist attraction for Roman aristocrats). Curiously however, they were already on the receiving end of Badass Upgrade in their own times (by other Greeks to boot), so a writer trying to avoid it faces a weight of tradition to overcome.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ancient Spartans are often depicted as top-of-the-top of soldierly skill, but their actual track record in combat was a lot more lackluster. While having an edge over most other Greeks, their training methods were at best AwesomeButImpractical, their [[CripplingOverspecialization over-reliance on heavy infantry]] came back to bite them on multiple occasions, and at least some of their biggest victories can be attributed to enemy blunders or to having for a change cared to look at the bigger picture beyond immediate soldiering. Additionally, writers tend to upplay their performances against Persia, and downplay most other periods--they failed to dislodge Athens for decades in the Peloponnesian War due to their inability to sustain campaigns until they relied on Persian support, needed Persian aid again in the Corinthian War, were soundly defeated by Thebes in the Theban-Spartan War, and ended up utterly crushed by Macedon and Rome. Curiously however, they were already on the receiving end of Badass Upgrade in their own times (by other Greeks to boot), so a writer trying to avoid it faces a weight of tradition to overcome.

to:

* The ancient Spartans are often depicted as top-of-the-top of soldierly skill, an elite and incorruptible ProudWarriorRace, but their actual track record in combat was a lot more lackluster. While having an edge over most other Greeks, their training methods were at best AwesomeButImpractical, their [[CripplingOverspecialization over-reliance on heavy infantry]] came back to bite them on multiple occasions, and at least some of their biggest victories can be attributed to enemy blunders or to having having, for a change change, cared to look at the bigger picture beyond immediate soldiering. Additionally, writers tend to upplay their performances against Persia, and downplay most other periods--they failed to dislodge Athens for decades in the Peloponnesian War due to their inability to sustain campaigns until they relied on Persian support, needed Persian aid again in the Corinthian War, were soundly defeated by Thebes in the Theban-Spartan War, and ended up utterly crushed by Macedon and Rome.again by Rome (under which rule their famously harsh culture became a trashy tourist attraction for Roman aristocrats). Curiously however, they were already on the receiving end of Badass Upgrade in their own times (by other Greeks to boot), so a writer trying to avoid it faces a weight of tradition to overcome.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheSpanishPrincess'' featured Catherine of Aragon [[PregnantBadass donning a suit of armor and partaking in a battle while pregnant]]- even personally killing James IV of Scotland. While the real Catherine ''did'' navigate England through wartime despite being heavily pregnant, and is agreed to have given a RousingSpeech to the English troops to boost their morale, she did not directly participate in the battle, and she certainly didn't kill James VI herself.

to:

* ''Series/TheSpanishPrincess'' featured Catherine of Aragon [[PregnantBadass donning a suit of armor and partaking in a battle while pregnant]]- even personally killing James IV of Scotland. While the real Catherine ''did'' navigate England through wartime despite being heavily pregnant, and is agreed to have given a RousingSpeech to the English troops to boost their morale, she did not directly participate in the battle, and she certainly didn't kill James VI herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheSpanishPrincess'' featured Catherine of Aragon [[PregnantBadass donning a suit of armor and partaking in a battle while pregnant]]- even personally killing James IV of Scotland. While the real Catherine ''did'' navigate England through wartime despite being heavily pregnant, and is agreed to have given a RousingSpeech to the English troops to boost their morale, she did not directly participate in the battle, and she certainly didn't kill James VI herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/BloodMeridian'' this happens to the supposedly real figure simply known as Judge Holden, whose only record of existence comes from Samuel Chamberlain's memoir ''My Confession: Recollections of a Rogue''. Chamberlain described the Holden he knew as the type who would only engage in a fight if his side had the clear advantage and would avoid fighting otherwise. While the Yumas attacked Glanton's gang, Chamberlain had to go rescue Holden from being circled by them, then shortly afterwards he tied up Holden with the intention of leaving him to die, although he later felt guilty about it and went back to free him. ''Blood Meridian'', meanwhile, turns Judge Holden into an AmbiguouslyHuman, nigh-unstoppable force of nature who never shies away from violence, gets away from the Yumas himself, and the other survivors of Glanton's gang are completely unable to shake him off for good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheKingsMan'': In addition to his usual HistoricalVillainUpgrate, this version of UsefulNotes/GrigoriRasputin is presented as being an excellent fighter in combat and [[MasterSwordsman with the sword]], fighting the movie's good guys ''at once''. That's a far cry from the historical Rasputin who was basically a NonActionGuy and a preacher and mystic.

to:

* ''Film/TheKingsMan'': In addition to his usual HistoricalVillainUpgrate, HistoricalVillainUpgrade, this version of UsefulNotes/GrigoriRasputin is presented as being an excellent fighter in combat and [[MasterSwordsman with the sword]], fighting the movie's good guys ''at once''. That's a far cry from the historical Rasputin who was basically a NonActionGuy and a preacher and mystic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheKingsMan'': In addition to his usual HistoricalVillainUpdate, this version of UsefulNotes/GrigoriRasputin is presented as being an excellent fighter in combat and [[MasterSwordsman with the sword]], fighting the movie's good guys ''at once''. That's a far cry from the historical Rasputin who was basically a NonActionGuy and a preacher and mystic.

to:

* ''Film/TheKingsMan'': In addition to his usual HistoricalVillainUpdate, HistoricalVillainUpgrate, this version of UsefulNotes/GrigoriRasputin is presented as being an excellent fighter in combat and [[MasterSwordsman with the sword]], fighting the movie's good guys ''at once''. That's a far cry from the historical Rasputin who was basically a NonActionGuy and a preacher and mystic.

Added: 361

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"So, all in all, just a normal day in the life of Creator/LeonardoDaVinci. Turn lead into gold, paint the most famous portrait of all time, and invent the first hang glider. And I bet it’s not even 9 AM."''

to:

->''"So, all in all, just a normal day in the life of Creator/LeonardoDaVinci. Turn lead into gold, paint the most famous portrait of all time, and invent the first hang glider. And I bet it’s it’s not even 9 AM."''


Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheKingsMan'': In addition to his usual HistoricalVillainUpdate, this version of UsefulNotes/GrigoriRasputin is presented as being an excellent fighter in combat and [[MasterSwordsman with the sword]], fighting the movie's good guys ''at once''. That's a far cry from the historical Rasputin who was basically a NonActionGuy and a preacher and mystic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The real Miyamoto Iori was noted by UsefulNotes/MiyamotoMusashi to be a rather poor swordsman, with his talents laying more in bureaucracy. In ''VideoGame/FateSamuraiRemnant'', he's shown to be capable of holding his own against Servants and the website describes him as a mage capable of using magecraft when his swords fail him against certain enemies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/CelebrityDeathmatch'': Most celebrities and historical figures get this treatment by humorously exaggerating their public personas. A few examples:
** Creator/BillMurray wielding a functional [[Film/Ghostbusters1984 proton pack]].
** {{Creator/Chris Tucker}}'s MotorMouth comedy style manifesting as outright SuperSpeed.
** Music/WillieNelson hiding a magical, laser-shooting ThirdEye behind his signature [[NeverBareheaded bandana]].
** Music/MissyElliott shrugging off '''[[LosingYourHead decapitation]]''' (''"What, you thought that music video [[labelnote:*]]referring to an infamous CGI bit in "Lose Control"[[/labelnote]] was just special effects?!"'').

Added: 295

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Anime and Manga]]

to:

[[folder:Anime and & Manga]]



* ''ComicBook/TheManhattanProjects'' feature robot Wernher Von Braun, irradiated skull Harry Daghlian, [[spoiler: cannibal Evil Twin of]] Oppenheimer, [[spoiler: evil parallel universe]] Einstein, and FDR [[spoiler:AI]] meeting aliens, discovering wormholes and fighting robots zen powered by death monks.

to:

* ''ComicBook/TheManhattanProjects'' feature robot Wernher Von Braun, irradiated skull Harry Daghlian, [[spoiler: cannibal [[spoiler:cannibal Evil Twin of]] Oppenheimer, [[spoiler: evil [[spoiler:evil parallel universe]] Einstein, and FDR [[spoiler:AI]] meeting aliens, discovering wormholes and fighting robots zen powered by death monks.



** Bossa Nova Heartstrings, Blue's older identical twin brother, is based on Jesse Garon Presley, Music/ElvisPresley's older identical twin brother who came out [[TragicStillbirth stillborn]]. While he came out stillborn like his character inspiration, Bossa Nova was adopted by the [[TheGrimReaper Three Deaths]], giving him a ([[MassiveNumberedSiblings rather large]]) surrogate family of his own. His noble upbringing influenced him to eventually become something great - an [[PhysicalGod Alicorn god]] - despite being dead, and being a Death god means he's still rather powerful despite not being a "[[TheAce prodigy]]" deity like his younger brother.

to:

** Bossa Nova Heartstrings, Blue's older identical twin brother, is based on Jesse Garon Presley, Music/ElvisPresley's older identical twin brother who came out [[TragicStillbirth stillborn]]. While he came out stillborn like his character inspiration, Bossa Nova was adopted by the [[TheGrimReaper Three Deaths]], giving him a ([[MassiveNumberedSiblings rather large]]) surrogate family of his own. His noble upbringing influenced him to eventually become something great - -- an [[PhysicalGod Alicorn god]] - -- despite being dead, and being a Death god means he's still rather powerful despite not being a "[[TheAce prodigy]]" deity like his younger brother.


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Music]]
* Music/JonathanCoulton gives one to Kenesaw Mountain Landis in his song of the same name, which claims that Landis was 17 feet tall and put a stop to corruption in pro baseball by flying over a stadium in a blimp and shooting Shoeless Joe Jackson's middle finger off.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Atrocitology: The 100 Deadliest Human Achievements'' by Matthew White. In the "Off the hook" section of the summary, we get this subsection:
--> VIKINGS, SAMURAI, SPARTANS, SIKHS, AND OTHERS
--> A lot of people who have reputations as total badasses have not killed very many people, while other nations that are widely ridiculed as losers, cowards, and sissies did.
:: Elsewhere in the book, we learn that between various civil wars, Napoleon and colonialism, the French are responsible for millions of deaths.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


See HistoricalRelationshipOverhaul for other changes a HistoricalDomainCharacter may receive.

Top