Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / DaddyHadAGoodReasonForAbandoningYou

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I'm surprised that ''StarWars'' isn't on here yet! First off we have Obi-Wan's infamous JediTruth. Then, of course, [[LukeIAmYourFather the big reveal]]. But [[DisappearedDad Anakin]] had no choice but to "abandon" [[SeparatedAtBirth Luke and Leia]], because ''[[MuggleFosterParents he didn't even know that they were still alive]]''! As soon as he learned otherwise, [[WeCanRuleTogether he planned a nice family bonding experience so that they could get to know each other]].

to:

* I'm surprised that ''StarWars'' isn't on here yet! First off we have has Obi-Wan's infamous JediTruth. Then, of course, JediTruth, leading to [[LukeIAmYourFather the big reveal]]. But [[DisappearedDad Anakin]] had no choice but to "abandon" [[SeparatedAtBirth Luke and Leia]], because ''[[MuggleFosterParents he didn't even know that they were still alive]]''! As soon as he learned otherwise, [[WeCanRuleTogether he planned a nice family bonding experience so that they could get to know each other]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the anime version of ''AngelicLayer'', Misaki's MissingMom Shuko is revealed to have [[spoiler:been confined [[IllGirl to a wheelchair due to a neurological disease]], and she'd gone to Tokyo to do research on it to help look for a cure]] and hence hasn't seen her daughter for years. This is notably [[PragmaticAdaptation exclusive only to the anime]], while in the manga Shuko's excuse is that ''she's pathologically shy''. The manga explanation [[{{Moe}} is cuter]], but the anime explanation makes more sense [[spoiler:[[ValuesDissonance considering Japan' treatment of the disabled]]: Shuuko mentions that she doesn't want people to look down on Misaki for having "a useless mother"]].

to:

* In the anime version of ''AngelicLayer'', Misaki's MissingMom Shuko is revealed to have [[spoiler:been confined [[IllGirl to a wheelchair due to a neurological disease]], and she'd gone to Tokyo to do research on it to help look for a cure]] and hence hasn't seen her daughter for years. This is notably [[PragmaticAdaptation exclusive only to the anime]], while in the manga Shuko's excuse is that ''she's pathologically shy''. The manga explanation [[{{Moe}} is cuter]], but the anime explanation makes more sense [[spoiler:[[ValuesDissonance considering Japan' Japan's treatment of the disabled]]: Shuuko mentions that she doesn't want people to look down on Misaki for having "a useless mother"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the anime version of ''AngelicLayer'', Misaki's MissingMom Shuko is revealed to have [[spoiler:been confined [[IllGirl to a wheelchair due to a neurological disease]], and she'd gone to Tokyo to do research on it to help look for a cure]] and hence hasn't seen her daughter for years. This is notably [[PragmaticAdaptation exclusive only to the anime]], while in the manga Shuko's excuse is that ''she's pathologically shy''. The manga explanation [[{{Moe}} is cuter]], but the anime explanation makes more sense [[spoiler:[[ValuesDissonance considering Japan treatment of the disabled]]: Shuuko mentions that she doesn't want people to look down on Misaki for having "an useless mother"]].

to:

* In the anime version of ''AngelicLayer'', Misaki's MissingMom Shuko is revealed to have [[spoiler:been confined [[IllGirl to a wheelchair due to a neurological disease]], and she'd gone to Tokyo to do research on it to help look for a cure]] and hence hasn't seen her daughter for years. This is notably [[PragmaticAdaptation exclusive only to the anime]], while in the manga Shuko's excuse is that ''she's pathologically shy''. The manga explanation [[{{Moe}} is cuter]], but the anime explanation makes more sense [[spoiler:[[ValuesDissonance considering Japan Japan' treatment of the disabled]]: Shuuko mentions that she doesn't want people to look down on Misaki for having "an "a useless mother"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[spoiler: Further along the plotline, the initial reason she left them was to bring the guy ''back'' to the CIA.]]

to:

*** [[spoiler: Further along the plotline, the initial reason she left them was to bring the guy ''back'' to the CIA.CIA, since he was the initial Intersect, that had failed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: Further along the plotline, the initial reason she left them was to bring the guy ''back'' to the CIA.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In HarryPotter, Dean Thomas's father was an example of this. [[spoiler: He was asked to join the Death Eaters, but refused and ran away to protect his wife and baby son. He ended up getting killed.]] Dean never finds out about this.
** Neither do most readers, because this info is WordOfGod.
* Five words - PercyJacksonAndTheOlympians.

to:

* In HarryPotter, ''HarryPotter,'' Dean Thomas's father was an example of this. [[spoiler: He was asked to join the Death Eaters, but refused and ran away to protect his wife and baby son. He ended up getting killed.]] Dean never finds out about this.
** Neither do most readers, because this info is WordOfGod.
WordOfGod. It was [[AbortedArc going to go in]] but didn't really fit anywhere in the plot, leading J.K. to build up Neville's subplot instead. (Which also sort of fits this trope, if not perfectly.)
* Five words - PercyJacksonAndTheOlympians.''PercyJacksonAndTheOlympians.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Variant in ''{{Bones}}''. Cam, it turns out, was an honorary stepmom to the daughter of her very serious boyfriend, but left the relationship (and, by proxy, the girl) when it turned out he had cheated on her. When the man was murdered and the team put on the case, the daughter is now a teenager and very annoyed at Cam [[spoiler: who ends up adopting her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** The threat of monsters coming to kill their children comes to mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''JadeCocoon'', Ricketz leaves his family and abandons his position as Cocoon Master of his village, because staying on would cause his wife to eventually die of a magically-induced cancerous disease, as the wives of all Cocoon Masters are women of the Nagi tribe who have a sacred duty to purify the demon-capturing cocoons their husbands inevitably accumulate in their role as magical protectors of their villages. [[spoiler:He also tries to discover a cure, in the process becoming the catalyst for the entire plot of the story.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Dinoverse}}'', the rebellious graffiti artist Janine resents how her mother is often not at home, forcing her to miss school in order to prepare the hotel for guests herself. As it turns out, her mother is keeping Janine from getting in trouble over the graffiti - she never confronted her daughter because she feared Janine would run away.

to:

* In ''{{Dinoverse}}'', ''Literature/{{Dinoverse}}'', the rebellious graffiti artist Janine resents how her mother is often not at home, forcing her to miss school in order to prepare the hotel for guests herself. As it turns out, her mother is keeping Janine from getting in trouble over the graffiti - she never confronted her daughter because she feared Janine would run away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also TellMeAboutMyFather, TurnOutLikeHisFather. Sometimes related to GiveHimANormalLife.

to:

See also TellMeAboutMyFather, TurnOutLikeHisFather. Sometimes related to GiveHimANormalLife. If the info is specifically withheld to increase tension even though there's no good reason to withhold it, see the RuleOfDrama

Changed: 760

Removed: 627

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* In {{Drowtales}}, [[TheWomanWearingTheQueenlyMask Quain]] is quite aloof towards her children, leaving them for months or even years at a time at boarding schools or under the care of a slave or older sibling. [[TheObiWan Quil'yate]] explains to [[FallenPrincess Ariel]] that this is not because the drow are evil, but because the clan believes that it is best for young nobles to learn to prove themselves, so that they can be strong leaders.
** However, it also turns out that [[spoiler: Quain isn't really Ariel's mother, but rather her grandmother; Ariel is the daughter of her 'crazy sister' Mel, and Zhor, an elf magically turned into a spider; Quain forced the unlikely couple to give up Ariel (including an apparent attempt to kill Zhor while they were at it), thinking the two could not provide a proper environment for a future clan matriarch and wanting to take the credit for herself.]]
** [[spoiler:Quain is also unable to have children, and it's strongly implied that the desire to have a [[HeirClubForMen suitable heir]] is part of her motivation as well.]]

to:

* In {{Drowtales}}, ''{{Drowtales}}'', Ariel comes to see her mother [[TheWomanWearingTheQueenlyMask Quain]] Quain'tana]] as this. She is quite aloof towards her children, leaving them for months or even years at a time at boarding schools or under the care of a slave or older sibling. [[TheObiWan Quil'yate]] explains to [[FallenPrincess Ariel]] Ariel that this is not because the drow are evil, but because the clan believes that it is best for young nobles to learn to prove themselves, so that they can be strong leaders.
** However,
leaders. This however [[UnreliableNarrator should be taken with a grain of salt]], since it also turns out that [[spoiler: Quain isn't really Ariel's mother, but rather her grandmother; Ariel is the daughter of her 'crazy sister' Mel, Mel'arnach, and Zhor, an elf magically turned into a spider; Quain forced the unlikely couple to give up Ariel (including an apparent attempt to kill Zhor while they were at it), thinking the two could not provide a proper environment for a future clan matriarch and wanting to take the credit for herself.]]
** [[spoiler:Quain
herself. Quain is also unable to have children, and it's strongly implied that the desire to have a [[HeirClubForMen suitable heir]] is part of her motivation as well.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And don't forget Palmer, the Tower Tycoon from Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum. He is the rival's father and while he claims to remember you as his son's friend, he is never once seen outside of Battle Tower.

Added: 415

Changed: 415

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''BaldursGate'' ''2'' Cernd left his wife and unborn son to pursue his calling as a druid. ''He'' thinks his commitment to maintaining the balance of nature is a good reason for abandoning his family. Nobody else does. Even the evil wizard who is about to sacrifice the baby to a lich calls him out on it, asking if Cernd even knows the kid's name. To be fair, he didn't know his wife was pregnant at the time.



* In ''BaldursGate'' ''2'' Cernd left his wife and unborn son to pursue his calling as a druid. ''He'' thinks his commitment to maintaining the balance of nature is a good reason for abandoning his family. Nobody else does. Even the evil wizard who is about to sacrifice the baby to a lich calls him out on it, asking if Cernd even knows the kid's name. To be fair, he didn't know his wife was pregnant at the time.

to:

* In ''BaldursGate'' ''2'' Cernd left his wife and unborn son to pursue his calling as a druid. ''He'' thinks his commitment to maintaining the balance of nature is a good reason for abandoning his family. Nobody else does. Even the evil wizard who is about to sacrifice the baby to a lich calls him out on it, asking if Cernd even knows the kid's name. To be fair, he didn't know his wife was pregnant at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''BaldursGate'' ''2'' Cernd left his wife and unborn son to pursue his calling as a druid. ''He'' thinks his commitment to maintaining the balance of nature is a good reason for abandoning his family. Nobody else does. Even the evil wizard who is about to sacrifice the baby to a lich calls him out on it, asking if Cernd even knows the kid's name. To be fair, he didn't know his wife was pregnant at the time.

to:

* In ''BaldursGate'' ''2'' Cernd left his wife and unborn son to pursue his calling as a druid. ''He'' thinks his commitment to maintaining the balance of nature is a good reason for abandoning his family. family. Nobody else does. does. Even the evil wizard who is about to sacrifice the baby to a lich calls him out on it, asking if Cernd even knows the kid's name. name. To be fair, he didn't know his wife was pregnant at the time.

Changed: 419

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''BaldursGate'' ''2'' Cernd left his wife and unborn son to pursue his calling as a druid. ''He'' thinks his commitment to maintaining the balance of nature is a good reason for abandoning his family. Nobody else does. Even the evil wizard who is about to sacrifice the baby to a lich calls him out on it, asking if Cernd even knows the kid's name. To be fair, he didn't know his wife was pregnant at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually that was only part of the reason, he also did it because sealing it inside Naruto was the best way to prevent a potential fourth world war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
killing wallbanger redlink


* In the anime version of ''AngelicLayer'', Misaki's MissingMom Shuko is revealed to have [[spoiler:been confined [[IllGirl to a wheelchair due to a neurological disease]], and she'd gone to Tokyo to do research on it to help look for a cure]] and hence hasn't seen her daughter for years. This is notably [[PragmaticAdaptation exclusive only to the anime]], while in the manga Shuko's excuse is that ''[[WallBanger she's pathologically shy]]''. The manga explanation [[{{Moe}} is cuter]], but the anime explanation makes more sense [[spoiler:[[ValuesDissonance considering Japan treatment of the disabled]]: Shuuko mentions that she doesn't want people to look down on Misaki for having "an useless mother"]].

to:

* In the anime version of ''AngelicLayer'', Misaki's MissingMom Shuko is revealed to have [[spoiler:been confined [[IllGirl to a wheelchair due to a neurological disease]], and she'd gone to Tokyo to do research on it to help look for a cure]] and hence hasn't seen her daughter for years. This is notably [[PragmaticAdaptation exclusive only to the anime]], while in the manga Shuko's excuse is that ''[[WallBanger she's ''she's pathologically shy]]''.shy''. The manga explanation [[{{Moe}} is cuter]], but the anime explanation makes more sense [[spoiler:[[ValuesDissonance considering Japan treatment of the disabled]]: Shuuko mentions that she doesn't want people to look down on Misaki for having "an useless mother"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[AvertedTrope Averted]] in ''OrderOfTheStick,'' where Eugene [[PetTheDog chooses not to follow a credible lead]] on [[BigBad Xykon]], whom he's sworn to destroy, because doing so would most likely mean abandoning his family and dying at best, and having Xykon hunt them down for revenge at worst. He ''did,'' however, continue to be a [[NeglectfulParent neglectful]] JerkAss to his oldest son, and [[BlatantLies specifically claimed that]] [[HiddenHeartOfGold he would have abandoned the family for his quest if given a chance]].

to:

* [[AvertedTrope Averted]] in ''OrderOfTheStick,'' where Eugene [[PetTheDog chooses not to follow a credible lead]] on [[BigBad Xykon]], whom he's sworn to destroy, because doing so would most likely mean abandoning his family and dying at best, and having Xykon hunt them down for revenge at worst. He ''did,'' however, continue to be a [[NeglectfulParent [[ParentalNeglect neglectful]] JerkAss to his oldest son, and [[BlatantLies specifically claimed that]] [[HiddenHeartOfGold he would have abandoned the family for his quest if given a chance]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''LegendOfDragoon''. One would think that being possessed by the spirit of a near-12,000 year old megalomaniacal Wingly dictator and forced to set off a series of events that would lead to TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt is a good reason for ParentalAbandonment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Naruto}}'', Naruto's father [[spoiler:Namikaze Minato, had [[ValuesDissonance what he believed was a good reason]]... Sealing the Kyuubi inside of Naruto to protect Konoha with a XanatosRoulette against Uchiha Madara.]] Turns out that his mom is not only dead, but [[spoiler:[[GenerationXerox was the ''previous'' Jinchuuriki of the Nine-Tails.]].]]

to:

* In ''{{Naruto}}'', Naruto's father [[spoiler:Namikaze Minato, Minato,]] had [[ValuesDissonance what he believed was a good reason]]... [[spoiler: Sealing the Kyuubi inside of Naruto to protect Konoha with a XanatosRoulette against Uchiha Madara.]] Turns out that his mom is not only dead, but [[spoiler:[[GenerationXerox was the ''previous'' Jinchuuriki of the Nine-Tails.]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Naruto}}'', Naruto's father [[spoiler:Namikaze Minato, had what he believed was a good reason... Sealing the Kyuubi inside of Naruto to protect Konoha with a XanatosRoulette against Uchiha Madara.]] Turns out that his mom is not only dead, but [[spoiler:[[GenerationXerox was the ''previous'' Jinchuuriki of the Nine-Tails.]].]]

to:

* In ''{{Naruto}}'', Naruto's father [[spoiler:Namikaze Minato, had [[ValuesDissonance what he believed was a good reason...reason]]... Sealing the Kyuubi inside of Naruto to protect Konoha with a XanatosRoulette against Uchiha Madara.]] Turns out that his mom is not only dead, but [[spoiler:[[GenerationXerox was the ''previous'' Jinchuuriki of the Nine-Tails.]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
FMA manga bias removed.


* Done with [[spoiler: Hohenheim]] in the anime version of ''FullmetalAlchemist'', although it sort of feels like a cowardly decision and the character comes across as not entirely doing the right thing by leaving.
** Much more justified in the manga where he [[spoiler:figured out the BigBad's evil plan and set out to stop him.]] He was also trying to [[spoiler: become mortal again, however, since he wanted to die with Trisha.]]

to:

* Done with [[spoiler: Hohenheim]] in the anime version of ''FullmetalAlchemist'', although it sort of feels like a cowardly decision and the character comes across as not entirely doing the right thing by leaving.
''FullmetalAlchemist''.
** Much more justified Also done in the manga where he [[spoiler:figured out the BigBad's evil plan and set out to stop him.]] He was also trying to [[spoiler: become mortal again, however, since he wanted to die with Trisha.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Quest for Glory example



to:

* In ''QuestForGlory 4'', the Burgomeister's grandfather disappeared shortly before he was to marry the Burgomeister's grandmother, leaving her alone and pregnant. This resulted in the child and grandchild becoming rather bitter individuals. When playing as a paladin, you end up finding the grandfather's sword in a wraith's barrow, proving that his abandonment was not intentional - Piotyr had been killed before the wedding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*MassEffect2 gives us [[ColdSniper Thane Krios]] who left his son [[HotBlooded Kolyat]], Thane didn't want Kolyat to be influenced by his fathers job as an assassin, either by becoming one himself or being connected to him for his enemies to find.

Added: 489

Changed: 626

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Where do we begin in TalesOfSymphonia? Lets start with [[spoiler: Kratos and Lloyd. The reason Kratos abandoned Lloyd was because he saw him, Noshie, and the monster version of his wife fall over a [[NoOneCouldHaveSurviedThat a cliff.]] He thought they had died. Then Genis and Raine got abandoned because of a combination of FantasticalRacism in the second world and the portal closed before their mother could get through which sent her into HeroicBSOD.]]

to:

* Where do we begin in TalesOfSymphonia? Lets start with [[spoiler: Kratos and Lloyd. The ''TalesOfSymphonia'' has a couple.
** [[spoiler:The
reason Kratos abandoned Lloyd was because he saw him, Noshie, Noishe, and the monster version of his wife fall over a [[NoOneCouldHaveSurviedThat a cliff.]] He thought they had died. Then Genis and Raine got abandoned because of a combination of FantasticalRacism in the second world and the portal closed before their mother could get through which sent her into HeroicBSOD.]]
** Genis and Raine got abandoned because [[spoiler:Raine was so intelligent, the Imperial Research Academy wanted to kidnap her and keep her imprisoned with other half-elves to work on science projects for them. Their parents sent them through a magical portal to the "mythical land" of Sylvarant, where they hoped the children would be safe from FantasticRacism. They had no way of knowing that Sylvarant was poor and mana-starved, and suffered from just as much racism as Tethe'alla...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Likewise [[DoctorWho Rose]]'s dad, minus the alien enslavement part.

Added: 152

Changed: 478

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* I'm surprised that ''StarWars'' isn't on here yet! First off we have Obi-Wan's infamous JediTruth. Then, of course, [[LukeIAmYourFather the big reveal]]. But [[DisappearedDad Anakin]] had no choice but to "abandon" [[SeparatedAtBirth Luke and Leia]], because ''[[MuggleFosterParents he didn't even know that they were still alive]]''! As soon as he learned otherwise, [[WeCanRuleTogether he planned a nice family bonding experience so that they could get to know each other]].
** And of course we can't forget Leia, whose [[HappilyAdopted other daddy]] had an equally good reason for "[[EarthShatteringKaboom abandoning]]" her...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Pokemon}} Special'', Ruby has a deep resentment for his father, Norman, for leaving the family for five years. [[spoiler:In reality, a frenzied Salamence assaulted Ruby and Sapphire, and the injuries inflicted by Ruby caused it to careen into the Weather Institute. Norman covered it up and was disqualified from his gym leader certification trial as a result. The change in Ruby's behavior left bad blood between both of them. Norman gave Ruby the go-ahead with his Contest campaign after a prolonged battle at the ruined Weather Institute five years later (would have been a birthday gift if Ruby stuck around). Then Ruby found out the motives for Norman's actions. Dood...]]

to:

* In ''{{Pokemon}} Special'', ''PokemonSpecial'', Ruby has a deep resentment for his father, Norman, for leaving the family for five years. [[spoiler:In reality, a frenzied Salamence assaulted Ruby and Sapphire, and the injuries inflicted by Ruby caused it to careen into the Weather Institute. Norman covered it up and was disqualified from his gym leader certification trial as a result. The change in Ruby's behavior left bad blood between both of them. Norman gave Ruby the go-ahead with his Contest campaign after a prolonged battle at the ruined Weather Institute five years later (would have been a birthday gift if Ruby stuck around). Then Ruby found out the motives for Norman's actions. Dood...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And the reason their mom left them? [[spoiler: She was a CIA agent working undercover and an insane international weapons dealer fell in love with her. She had to leave because she was afraid of what would happen if the guy found out about her family.]]

Top