Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / CultureChopSuey

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Avatar as a whole counts. The different nations might borrow strongly from individual cultures, but in the end they're "Generic Asian".

to:

** Avatar as a whole counts. The different nations might borrow strongly from individual cultures, but in the end they're "Generic Asian".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There was a small controversy regarding the Pandarans being too Japanese. This offended China's government and they were redesigned to be more Chinese.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The whole ''IronGrip'' series lives and breathes this trope, in addition to being chock-full of PunkPunk SchizoTech. Example : The Fahrongi are a nation that has many similarities to the HolyRomanEmpire, the Byzantine empire ''and Napoleonic France''. As if this wasn't enough, they have an UpToEleven CrystalDragonJesus ChurchMilitant with KnightTemplar attitudes and [[AcheyScars medieval-esque flagellants...]] [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything who serve as volunteer suicide bombers...]] The ruler of the country is something like a cross between a Byzantine emperor and an Islamic calif.

to:

* The whole ''IronGrip'' series lives and breathes this trope, in addition to being chock-full of PunkPunk SchizoTech. Example : The Fahrongi are a nation that has many similarities to the HolyRomanEmpire, the Byzantine empire ''and Napoleonic France''. As if this wasn't enough, they have an UpToEleven CrystalDragonJesus ChurchMilitant with KnightTemplar attitudes and [[AcheyScars medieval-esque flagellants...]] [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything who serve as volunteer suicide bombers...]] The ruler of the country is something like a cross between a [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caesaropapism#Caesaropapism_in_the_Eastern_Church Byzantine emperor emperor]] and an Islamic calif.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Which isn't a big deal, 'cause the animé series, as the manga, were created in Japan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ...which they reach after crossing a frozen strait and passing through what looks a lot like the Pacific Northwest. Funny how that actually works with real life geography (the teepees should be in the Plains, not the Southwest, though).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The ruins of ''[[LaMulana La-Mulana]]'' have design motifs that echo those of numerous ancient real-world cultures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Dune is a completely justified example - while it is less chop suey and more cultural broth, it is reasonable to assume that after so long in the stars, all the cultures that have been subsumed into the Sublime Padishah Empire will mingle - although there is a heavily pronounced islamic strain, suggesting some sort of Islamic or neo-Islamic period.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Alfredo Yu. That is all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Agatean Empire, as featured in InterestingTimes, is itself a mixture of various FantasyCounterpartCulture elements, borrowed mainly from Japanese and Chinese history: We have both samurai and a thinly-veiled Terracotta Army taking part in the climactic battle. Needless to say, as this is {{Discworld}} we're talking about, [[RuleOfFunny Funny reigns supreme]].

to:

** The Agatean Empire, as featured in InterestingTimes, ''Discworld/InterestingTimes'', is itself a mixture of various FantasyCounterpartCulture elements, borrowed mainly from Japanese and Chinese history: We have both samurai and a thinly-veiled Terracotta Army taking part in the climactic battle. Needless to say, as this is {{Discworld}} we're talking about, [[RuleOfFunny Funny reigns supreme]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Uberwald is, well, {{Uberwald}}, but Bonk's chocolate museum and mad fretwork that make the buildings look like cuckoo clocks sounds more like the Black Forest. Fat soup was inspired by a signing tour in Poland, and the Unholy Empire's crest parodies that of the Russian Empire. Basically, anywhere east of France where [[VampireVords v and w are the same letter]].
** WordOfGod describes Ankh-Morpork as a cross between Renaissance Florence, 18th century London, 19th century Seattle and 20th century New York. (This is a simplification - it also has elements of 19th and 20th century London, post-Imperial Rome, medieval Prague, and pretty much any other city with some interesting stories attached to it.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I cringe at their Mandarin and I can't speak a word of it, but it just sounds wrong. Sure, they tried, and get points for that... but really, the Browncoats are basically Americans with some Chinesey window-dressing going on. Still an awesome series and movie, but if they were going for a Chinese/American hybrid culture, it really could have been done better. Arguably, they may be speaking some highly Mandarinified English translated into Standard American for the viewers' benefit, but culturally there's not much to separate them from colonial/"Western" America.

to:

** I cringe at their Mandarin and I can't speak a word of it, but it just sounds wrong. Sure, they tried, and get points for that... but really, the Browncoats ex-Independents are basically Americans with some Chinesey window-dressing going on.on (the Alliance is more Britishy, of course, being the bad guys). Still an awesome series and movie, but if they were going for a Chinese/American hybrid culture, it really could have been done better. Arguably, they may be speaking some highly Mandarinified English translated into Standard American for the viewers' benefit, but culturally there's not much to separate them from colonial/"Western" America.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I cringe at their Mandarin and I can't speak a word of it, but it just sounds wrong. Sure, they tried, and get points for that... but really, the Browncoats are basically Americans with some Chinesey window-dressing going on. Still an awesome series and movie, but if they were going for a Chinese/American hybrid culture, it really could have been done better. Arguably, they may be speaking some highly Mandarinified English translated into Standard American for the viewers' benefit, but culturally there's not much to separate them from colonial/"Western" America.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* An early episode of ''OnePiece'' had Rice Balls (edited out by 4Kids to be cookies), even through the pirates are somewhat based on Western fictional depictions of pirates.

to:

* An early episode of ''OnePiece'' had Rice Balls (edited out by 4Kids to be cookies), even through the pirates are somewhat based on Western fictional depictions of pirates. The characters also drink sake, wield katanas, make Japanese-language puns, etc.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Some cultural mash-ups are common enough to warrant their own pages: AncientGrome, {{Mayincatec}}, {{Scotireland}}, {{Spexico}}, and some versions of NorseByNorsewest.

to:

Some cultural mash-ups are common enough to warrant their own pages: AncientGrome, FarEast, {{Mayincatec}}, {{Scotireland}}, {{Spexico}}, and some versions of NorseByNorsewest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Thread moding. Please alter the entry itself, if it is innaccurate.


** That game, ''Dash Dingo'', is an obvious and surprisingly accurate parody of ''CrashBandicoot'', which was at the height of its popularity. ''The Simpsons'' is pretty good at averting PacManFever.
* Sokka from ''AvatarTheLastAirbender'' carries a boomerang, despite his water tribe culture being based off of the Inuit people.

to:

** That game, ''Dash Dingo'', is an obvious clear and surprisingly accurate parody of ''CrashBandicoot'', which was at the height of its popularity. ''The Simpsons'' is pretty good at averting PacManFever.
* Sokka from ''AvatarTheLastAirbender'' carries a boomerang, despite his water tribe culture being largely based off of the Inuit people.



** The boomerang isn't a completely unique Australian Aboriginer weapon. Archeologists and ethnologists have proven already years ago, that boomerang-like weapons were invented independently of one another by various native cultures around the world (the same way the bow was in the Neolithic). Though Inuits never used boomerangs, some northern Amerindian tribes did - so, with a bit of FanWank, you can postulate the Northern Water Tribe is the originator of the weapon (since they're the more Aleut/Alaskan kind of Native Americans, instead of being clear-cut [[FantasyCounterpartCulture fantasy Inuits]] like the Southerners). Then again, the Southern Water Tribes also have whalebone scimitars in addition to the more mundane harpoons.

to:

** The boomerang isn't a completely unique Australian Aboriginer weapon. Archeologists and ethnologists have proven already years ago, that boomerang-like weapons were invented independently of one another by various native cultures around the world (the same way the bow was in the Neolithic). Though Inuits never used boomerangs, some northern Amerindian tribes did - so, with a bit of FanWank, you can postulate the Northern Water Tribe is the originator of the weapon (since they're the more Aleut/Alaskan kind of Native Americans, instead of being clear-cut [[FantasyCounterpartCulture fantasy Inuits]] like the Southerners). Then again, the Southern Water Tribes also have whalebone scimitars in addition to the more mundane harpoons.

Changed: 39

Removed: 348

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Clarification and natter reduction.


* ''JadeEmpire'', which is based on AncientChina, includes [[{{Golem}} golems]], which are from Jewish folklore.
** Golems are an [=RPG=] mainstay going back to the original ''DragonQuest'', yet there are currently at least zero (0) role playing games based on Jewish folklore.
** OlderThanTheyThink - Whether you call them golems, homunculus, or what have you, the idea of an artificially created lifeform created through magic is a lot older than Dragon Quest.

to:

* ''JadeEmpire'', which is based on AncientChina, Ancient China, includes creatures specifically identified as [[{{Golem}} golems]], which are from Jewish folklore.
** Golems are an [=RPG=] mainstay going back to the original ''DragonQuest'', yet there are currently at least zero (0) role playing games based on Jewish folklore.
** OlderThanTheyThink - Whether you call them golems, homunculus, or what have you, the idea of an artificially created lifeform created through magic is a lot older than Dragon Quest.
folklore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** OlderThanTheyThink - Whether you call them golems, homunculus, or what have you, the idea of an artificially created lifeform created through magic is a lot older than Dragon Quest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->"They are four great families feuding. The Hongs, the Fongs, the Tangs, and the [=McSweeneys=]."

to:

-->"They are four five great families feuding. The Hongs, the Fongs, the sungs, the Tangs, and the [=McSweeneys=]."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Invalid example


* {{Naruto}} has the Land of Iron, which is a Switzerland with samurai. Also, Konoha's culture is Japanese, but its attitude toward combat is distinctly American (never leave a man behind, improvise, show mercy upon surrendering enemies, DefeatMeansFriendship on a national level).

to:

* {{Naruto}} has the Land of Iron, which is a Switzerland with samurai. Also, Konoha's culture is Japanese, but its attitude toward combat is distinctly American (never leave a man behind, improvise, show mercy upon surrendering enemies, DefeatMeansFriendship on a national level).
samurai.

Changed: 14

Removed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->"Very old family."
-->"Oh."

to:

-->"Very old old, established family."
-->"Oh."
"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** May simply be something he picked up from his Japanese alchemy teacher. Breda once mentions in the first Anime that Japan exists, when somebody asks where the Shogi-board he's playing on came from.

to:

** May simply be something he picked up from his Japanese (well, with a name like Izumi, she's certainly not a full Amestrian) alchemy teacher. Breda once mentions in In the first Anime that anime's canon at least, a Japan exists, analogue exists; Breda is once shown playing shogi and is able to answer when somebody someone asks where the Shogi-board he's playing on it came from.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* {{Naruto}} has the Land of Iron, which is a Switzerland with samurai. Also, Konoha's culture is Japanese, but its attitude toward combat is distinctly American (never leave a man behind, improvise, show mercy upon surrendering enemies, DefeatMeansFriendship on a national level).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CultureChopSuey is basically what the Chinese elements in ''Firefly'' amount to. It's not really an equal blend of Western and Chinese culture; rather, it's a SpaceWestern where the characters supplement their English dialogue with (bad) Mandarin, eat Chinese dishes as well as Western ones, and in some cases (like the Tams) have Asian-ish surnames but look white.

to:

* CultureChopSuey is basically what the Chinese elements in ''Firefly'' ''{{Firefly}}'' amount to. It's not really an equal blend of Western and Chinese culture; rather, it's a SpaceWestern where the characters supplement their English dialogue with (bad) Mandarin, eat Chinese dishes as well as Western ones, and in some cases (like the Tams) have Asian-ish surnames but look white.

Changed: 1230

Removed: 862

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the process of [[WorldBuilding creating a fictional world]], it's a common practice to [[FantasyCounterpartCulture borrow]] from an existing real world culture. In doing so, writers will occasionally, either intentionally or unintentionally, mix the aspects of more than one real world culture into their fictional one. CultureChopSuey is a FantasyCounterpartCulture with the added presence of an element or elements that noticeably contrasts with the rest of the culture, or more specifically, with the real world analogue, because it belongs to another culture entirely. This can show up in the form of tangible things, like clothing, food, tools, weapons, or architecture, as well as less tangible things, like traditions, superstitions, or types of religions. These can range from minor differences to an otherwise very clear real world parallel, to significant elements from one or more other cultures, that can change the whole feel of a FantasyCounterpartCulture and sometimes muddle its origins. Though, one of them is usually still the dominant one.

Important to note is that this is a distinction to the audience, not the characters. These are not elements in the fictional culture that are stated or implied to be from a separate, in-universe foreign culture, nor is it something that the characters will regard as being unusual to their culture (except, perhaps if they're engaging in [[BreakingTheFourthWall fourth wall breaking]] behavior). So far as anyone can tell, this is a normal presence in their society. These are things that don't go together in the real world cultures that they're derived from, not the fictional one.

Some cultural mash-ups are common enough to warrant their own pages: AncientGrome, {{Mayincatec}}, {{Scotireland}}, {{Spexico}}, and some versions of NorseByNorsewest.

to:

In the process of [[WorldBuilding creating a fictional world]], it's a common practice to [[FantasyCounterpartCulture borrow]] from an existing real world culture. In doing so, writers will occasionally, either intentionally or unintentionally, mix the aspects of more than one real world culture into their fictional one. CultureChopSuey is a FantasyCounterpartCulture with the added presence of an element or elements that noticeably contrasts with the rest of the culture, or more specifically, with the real world analogue, because it belongs to another culture entirely. This can show up in the form of tangible things, like clothing, food, tools, weapons, or architecture, as well as less tangible things, like traditions, superstitions, or types of religions. These can range from minor differences to an otherwise very clear real world parallel, to significant elements from one or more other cultures, that can change the whole feel of a FantasyCounterpartCulture and sometimes muddle its origins. Though, one of them is usually still the dominant one.

Important to note is that this is a distinction to the audience, not the characters. These are not elements in the fictional culture that are stated or implied to be from a separate, in-universe foreign culture, nor is it something that the characters will regard as being unusual to their culture (except, perhaps if they're engaging in [[BreakingTheFourthWall fourth wall breaking]] behavior). So far as anyone can tell, this is a normal presence in their society. These are things that don't go
cobbled together in the real world cultures that they're derived from, not the fictional one.

Some cultural mash-ups are common enough to warrant their own pages: AncientGrome, {{Mayincatec}}, {{Scotireland}}, {{Spexico}}, and some versions of NorseByNorsewest.
from multiple real-world cultures.



These are cases where elements are of a contrasting culture, elements of technology from a contrasting time period are SchizoTech. When ninjas show up as part of a CultureChopSuey, that is also a McNinja. When a similar mix-and-match approach is taken with more than one worlds made by other writers, for the purpose of FanFiction, that's FanFicChopSuey.

A {{Ruritania}} is usually constructed using this trope.

Since the distinction between the cultures is the point, and no example is SelfExplanatory, when citing an example, please mention what real world cultures that the fictional one is based on.

to:

These are cases where elements are of a contrasting culture, elements of technology from a contrasting time period are SchizoTech. When ninjas show up as part of a CultureChopSuey, that is also a McNinja. When a similar mix-and-match approach is taken with more than one worlds made by other writers, for the purpose of FanFiction, that's FanFicChopSuey. \n\n A {{Ruritania}} is usually constructed using this trope.

Since Some cultural mash-ups are common enough to warrant their own pages: AncientGrome, {{Mayincatec}}, {{Scotireland}}, {{Spexico}}, and some versions of NorseByNorsewest.

'''Since
the distinction between the cultures is the point, and no example is SelfExplanatory, when citing an example, please mention what real world cultures that the fictional one is based on.
on.'''



*** I thought about the Terracotta Armies. Makes sense to me that in Fantasy-China they'd be replaced by golems.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The boomerang isn't a completely unique Australian Aboriginer weapon. Archeologists and ethnologists have proven already years ago, that boomerang-like weapons were invented independently of one another by various native cultures around the world (the same way the bow was in the Neolithic). Though Inuits never used boomerangs, more northern Amerindian tribes did - so, with a bit of FanWank, you can postulate the Northern Water Tribe is the originator of the weapon (since they're the more Aleut/Alaskan kind of Native Americans, instead of being clear-cut [[FantasyCounterpartCulture fantasy Inuits]] like the Southerners). Then again, the Southern Water Tribes also have whalebone scimitars in addition to the more mundane harpoons.

to:

** The boomerang isn't a completely unique Australian Aboriginer weapon. Archeologists and ethnologists have proven already years ago, that boomerang-like weapons were invented independently of one another by various native cultures around the world (the same way the bow was in the Neolithic). Though Inuits never used boomerangs, more some northern Amerindian tribes did - so, with a bit of FanWank, you can postulate the Northern Water Tribe is the originator of the weapon (since they're the more Aleut/Alaskan kind of Native Americans, instead of being clear-cut [[FantasyCounterpartCulture fantasy Inuits]] like the Southerners). Then again, the Southern Water Tribes also have whalebone scimitars in addition to the more mundane harpoons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The boomerang isn't a completely unique Australian Aboriginer weapon. Archeologists and ethnologists have proven already years ago, that boomerang-like weapons were invented independently of one another by various native cultures around the world (the same way the bow was in the Neolithic). Though Inuits never used boomerangs, more northern Amerindian tribes did - so, with a bit of FanWank, you can postulate the Northern Water Tribe is the originator of the weapon (since they're more of the Aleut/Alaskan kind of Native Americans, instead of being clear-t [[FantasyCounterpartCulture fantasy Inuits]] like the Southerners. Then again, the Southern Water Tribes also have whalebone scimitars in addition to the more mundane harpoons.

to:

** The boomerang isn't a completely unique Australian Aboriginer weapon. Archeologists and ethnologists have proven already years ago, that boomerang-like weapons were invented independently of one another by various native cultures around the world (the same way the bow was in the Neolithic). Though Inuits never used boomerangs, more northern Amerindian tribes did - so, with a bit of FanWank, you can postulate the Northern Water Tribe is the originator of the weapon (since they're the more of the Aleut/Alaskan kind of Native Americans, instead of being clear-t clear-cut [[FantasyCounterpartCulture fantasy Inuits]] like the Southerners.Southerners). Then again, the Southern Water Tribes also have whalebone scimitars in addition to the more mundane harpoons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The boomerang isn't a completely unique Australian Aboriginer weapon. Archeologists and ethnologists have proven already years ago, that boomerang-like weapons were invented independently of one another by various native cultures around the world (the same way the bow was in the Neolithic). Though Inuits never used boomerangs, more northern Amerindian tribes did - so, with a bit of FanWank, you can postulate the Northern Water Tribe is the originator of the weapon (since they're more of the Aleut/Alaskan kind of Native Americans, instead of being clear-t [[FantasyCounterpartCulture fantasy Inuits]] like the Southerners. Then again, the Southern Water Tribes also have whalebone scimitars in addition to the more mundane harpoons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
typo


* SamuraiChamploo, with it's rapping samurai (and graffiti ninja, and marijuana monks, and...), is more an example of AnachronismStew, but also worth mentioning in as the title's "champloo" refers to a dish not unlike chop suey, and is used in the same sense as the trope title.

to:

* SamuraiChamploo, with it's its rapping samurai (and graffiti ninja, and marijuana monks, and...), is more an example of AnachronismStew, but also worth mentioning in as the title's "champloo" refers to a dish not unlike chop suey, and is used in the same sense as the trope title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mantith perhaps averts this trend, given that all the nations on it are direct parallels to real Earth cultures, just heavily stereotyped around those nations' [[TheSeventies Seventies cultures]], albeit, [[SchizoTech with some 21st century anachronisms]]. Even so, caves feature CommieLand and {{Uberwauld}} cultures of [[OurVampiresAreDifferent Mosquatlons]] and [[OurWerewolvesAreDifferent Aviatets]].

to:

** Mantith perhaps averts this trend, given that all the nations on it are direct parallels to real Earth cultures, just heavily stereotyped around those nations' [[TheSeventies Seventies cultures]], albeit, [[SchizoTech with some 21st century anachronisms]]. Even so, caves feature CommieLand and {{Uberwauld}} {{Uberwald}} cultures of [[OurVampiresAreDifferent Mosquatlons]] and [[OurWerewolvesAreDifferent Aviatets]].

Added: 1746

Changed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* StationeryVoyagers has this with the Inktacto system.
** The planet of Statios has several nations, but only three of them are ever mentioned as being plot-relevant. These include [[CommieLand the Grimplite lands]], [[{{Ruritania}} Inkraine]], and Stato. Stato is a weird combination of [[MagicalNativeAmerican Navajoland and Apacheland]] with {{Magitek}} and modern-day southern California / Arizona, with villains who are very [[TheWarOnTerror Afghani]].
*** And the cabin where Pinkella learns of her father's extramarital affairs is modeled after one near Mt. Pleasant, Michigan.
** Whixtitout: a planet-sized HiddenElfVillage that combines [[TheWarOnStraw 1990s American public school sex ed politics]] (like the kind discussed in Berit Kjos' book ''Brave New Schools'') with what appears to be Japan, or China, [[AsLongAsItSoundsForeign or something]]. It's a place where [[KungFuMagic Mikloche]] is very special, with specialists [[EverybodyWasKungFuFighting training for their art]].
** Then there's Neothode: with some parts being TheMiddleAges and European and others being more [[UnitedSpaceOfAmerica American-like]] CityNoir with borderline RaygunGothic space centers.
** Drizad is mostly farms on the surface, and a combination of CommieLand and {{Mordor}} underneath.
** Markerterion is definitely [[{{Spexico}} California meets Spain]], with a pinch of New Orleans and Kalamazoo.
** Mantith perhaps averts this trend, given that all the nations on it are direct parallels to real Earth cultures, just heavily stereotyped around those nations' [[TheSeventies Seventies cultures]], albeit, [[SchizoTech with some 21st century anachronisms]]. Even so, caves feature CommieLand and {{Uberwauld}} cultures of [[OurVampiresAreDifferent Mosquatlons]] and [[OurWerewolvesAreDifferent Aviatets]].

Top