Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ArtisticLicenseChemistry

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It could also be construed as a slightly careless wording. Those materials are _made_of_ medium atomic weights and not of transuranics.

to:

** It could also be construed as a slightly careless wording. Those materials are _made_of_ "made" "of" medium atomic weights and not of transuranics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It could also be construed as a slightly careless wording. Those materials are _made_of_ medium atomic weights and not of transuranics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''StarTrekGenerations'', Trilithium is able to stop all fusion inside a star, causing it to implode on itself and then go supernova-- thus destroying the star and all of its inner planets. This involves the same problems as "Dilithium," below.

to:

* In ''StarTrekGenerations'', Trilithium is able to stop all fusion inside a star, causing it to implode on itself and then go supernova-- thus destroying the star and all of its inner planets. This involves the same problems as "Dilithium," below."dilithium," below, plus the added problem that the writers had already given the name "trilithium" to a different fictional substance.



* In ''Film/{{Spider-Man}} 2'', Dr. Octavius requires some tritium for his experiments. He obtains it in form of a gray metallic ball. Tritium is gaseous under normal conditions, but it's possible that the gold object is a second layer of containment in addition to the glass ball around it. He also mentions how tritium is one of the rarest elements on Earth. Tritium is actually an isotope of hydrogen, which is the most ''abundant''.
* In ''Film/IronMan 2'', Tony Stark's power supply uses a palladium core that is slowly poisoning him. He finds that a "new element" can be a suitable replacement for palladium, but his supercomputer informs him it's "impossible to synthesize", so he builds a particle accelerator in his basement to... create the new element. Another way of saying "create" would be "synthesize". He's right, the computer is wrong.

to:

* In ''Film/{{Spider-Man}} 2'', Dr. Octavius requires some tritium for his experiments. He obtains it in form of a gray metallic ball. Tritium is gaseous under normal conditions, but it's possible that the gold object is a second layer of containment in addition to the glass ball around it. He also mentions how tritium is one of the rarest elements on Earth. Tritium is actually an isotope of hydrogen, which is isotope, not an element, and it's so common that glow in the most ''abundant''.
dark watches are made with it.
* In ''Film/IronMan 2'', Tony Stark's power supply uses a palladium core that is slowly poisoning him. Okay so far, since palladium does cause blood poisoning and its catalytic properties have made it popular in attempts at cold fusion. He finds that a "new element" can be a suitable replacement for palladium, but his supercomputer informs him it's "impossible to synthesize", so he builds a particle accelerator in his basement to... create the new element. Another way of saying "create" would be "synthesize". He's right, the computer is wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''BatmanSupermanWorldsFinest'', dissolving kryptonite in acid means it's "disappeared", and Superman is back to full strength. In the real world, dissolving radioactive isotopes in acid leaves you with a radioactive acid.

to:

* Kryptonite is {{Unobtanium}} and, to an extent, can behave however the writers want. But it's still a radioactive mineral. In ''BatmanSupermanWorldsFinest'', the DCAnimatedUniverse movie ''Superman & Batman: World's Finest'', dissolving kryptonite in acid means it's "disappeared", and Superman is back to full strength. In the real world, dissolving radioactive isotopes in acid leaves you with a radioactive acid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''BatmanSupermanWorldsFinest'', dissolving kryptonite in acid means it's "disappeared", and Superman is back to full strength. In the real world, dissolving radioactive isotopes in acid leaves you with a radioactive acid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Evolution}}'' did this for selenium. They {{hand wave}}d it by saying that selenium was to the alien creatures' nitrogen-based biochemistry as arsenic is to carbon-based life forms, because they're in the ''same relative position on the periodic table''. This handwave made it clear that nobody involved in the movie understands the concept of valence electrons[[hottip:*:In real life, arsenic is poisonous because of its relative position to ''phosphorus'', which it can impersonate as far as certain core enzymes are concerned, but it is not quite similar enough that, say, an RNA molecule made with arsenate links instead of phosphate ones will actually fit into a ribosome]]. Besides, the Rule of Funny dictated they ''had'' to defeat the EldritchAbomination amoeba with gallons of anti-dandruff shampoo.

to:

* ''{{Evolution}}'' ''Film/{{Evolution}}'' did this for selenium. They {{hand wave}}d it by saying that selenium was to the alien creatures' nitrogen-based biochemistry as arsenic is to carbon-based life forms, because they're in the ''same relative position on the periodic table''. This handwave made it clear that nobody involved in the movie understands the concept of valence electrons[[hottip:*:In real life, arsenic is poisonous because of its relative position to ''phosphorus'', which it can impersonate as far as certain core enzymes are concerned, but it is not quite similar enough that, say, an RNA molecule made with arsenate links instead of phosphate ones will actually fit into a ribosome]]. Besides, the Rule of Funny dictated they ''had'' to defeat the EldritchAbomination amoeba with gallons of anti-dandruff shampoo.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n** If we assume by "iron" they mean "group 8 element on the periodic table", then the first transuranic element would be hassium, which has a maximum half-life of about 10 seconds. Presumably, fights involving Thanagarians are short ones.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Or the fact that bad breath is only related to tooth decay in that both are bacterial actions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Respiration, as we carbon-based life forms do it, would also be impossible for Si-based life forms. CO2 is a gas. SiO2 is a solid.

to:

*** Respiration, as we carbon-based life forms do it, would also be impossible for Si-based life forms. CO2 [=CO=][[subscript:2]] is a gas. SiO2 [=SiO=][[subscript:2]] is a solid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** However, note that they don't necessarily die from the lack of nitrogen - if they developed in a world without free oxygen (or other strong oxidizer; if they had to resort to nitrogen...), their "lungs" would probably rapidly oxidize. The atmosphere would be as comfortable to them as an acidic atmosphere to us.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correcting an entry.


* Tiberium from ''CommandAndConquer''. However, like kryptonite in ''SupermanReturns'', it's stated to be a compound rather than an element - ''Tiberian Sun: Firestorm'' gives it as 42.5% phosphorus, 32.5% iron, 15.25% calcium, 5.75% copper, 2.5% silica (itself a compound), 1.5% unknown.

to:

* Tiberium from ''CommandAndConquer''. However, like kryptonite in ''SupermanReturns'', it's stated to be a compound rather than an element - ''Tiberian Sun: Firestorm'' Dawn'' gives it as 42.5% phosphorus, 32.5% iron, 15.25% calcium, 5.75% copper, 2.5% silica (itself a compound), 1.5% unknown.

Added: 555

Changed: 754

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Likewise diamond saw bores are mostly just small bits of diamond stuck on a plate, they're not anything super complicated or refined.



* DanBrown has stated several times that, in his opinion, antimatter is the future of energy supply. He fails to realise that what he's describing is the molecular equivalent of a perpetual-motion machine -- any attempt to make antimatter will inevitably cost more energy than annihilating the antimatter will yield (probably ''vastly'' more, as at present). As those more knowledgable have pointed out, wood is only a viable energy source because the vast energy cost of growing trees is met free by the Sun; if trees had to be grown under artificial light, the energy needed to do so would be far in excess of that given off by burning the wood.

to:

** It falls into YMMV pretty hard. P[[subscript:e]]+(P[[subscript:e]])r makes absolutely no sense logically. If they had wanted something that was funny and still made some measure of sense, 2Pe + R would have conveyed the same thing without being overly silly.
* DanBrown has stated several times that, in his opinion, antimatter is the future of energy supply. He fails to realise that what he's describing is the molecular equivalent of a perpetual-motion machine -- any attempt to make antimatter will inevitably cost more energy than annihilating the antimatter will yield (probably ''vastly'' more, as at present). As those more knowledgable have pointed out, wood is present where it can only a viable energy source because the vast energy cost of growing trees is met free by the Sun; if trees had to be grown under artificial light, the energy needed to do so would be far found briefly in excess of that given off by burning the wood.particle accelerators).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
s/radioactivity/fissile capabilities


** "Duranium-235" occasionally referenced here and there ("duranium" being a strong building material used for most ''sane'' space vessels in the TrekVerse) implies an isotope of an element... thing is, if there is an interesting property of any isotope with atomic weight 235 (protons and neutrons like to band together in particular configurations, making an atomic weight very likely to give away what element the atom is), it's almost certainly good ol' uranium (U-235 being the isotope of uranium prized for its radioactivity). If "duranium" is instead a future term for "depleted uranium" (a common fan theory; canon avoids clarification), well, that would be U-238.

to:

** "Duranium-235" occasionally referenced here and there ("duranium" being a strong building material used for most ''sane'' space vessels in the TrekVerse) implies an isotope of an element... thing is, if there is an interesting property of any isotope with atomic weight 235 (protons and neutrons like to band together in particular configurations, making an atomic weight very likely to give away what element the atom is), it's almost certainly good ol' uranium (U-235 being the isotope of uranium prized for its radioactivity).fissile capabilities). If "duranium" is instead a future term for "depleted uranium" (a common fan theory; canon avoids clarification), well, that would be U-238.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''RuneQuest'' has mineable bronze. However, said bronze veins are the bones of dead gods buried under the surface of a flat world, so chemistry isn't the ''only'' science that's irrelevant here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** However, they were partially correct, as matter is made up of particles that individually give atoms their properties. And, of course, transmutation, which occurs daily in any nuclear reaction, from fusion to decay. The problem with Alchemy was mostly due to scale and the fact that it still had some lingering "magical" notions. Some things were right in front of them the whole time, like with the universal solvent - turns out its water. Of course, nobody wanted to admit that, they just kept looking for that cool acid that desolves everything instantaneously. Thus, alchemy isn't a science. Its IdenticalGrandson, chemistry, is however.

to:

** However, they were partially correct, as matter is made up of particles that individually give atoms their properties. And, of course, transmutation, which occurs daily in any nuclear reaction, from fusion to decay. The problem with Alchemy was mostly due to scale and the fact that it still had some lingering "magical" notions. Some things were right in front of them the whole time, like with the universal solvent - turns out its water. Of course, nobody wanted to admit that, they just kept looking for that cool acid that desolves dissolves everything instantaneously. Thus, alchemy isn't a science. Its IdenticalGrandson, chemistry, is however.is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
see \"You Keep Using That Word\"


** It is also depicted as being far less ''flammable'' than it actually is. Uranium and Plutonium metal are both pyrophoric and can burn when exposed to air at room temperatures. This is why depleted Uranium is the substance of choice for anti-tank projectiles as they not only punch through the armour, but [[RuleOfCool also immolate whatever's inside]]. Of course this is also why early nuclear reactors using Uranium metal had a tendency to [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windscale_fire catch fire]].

to:

** It is also depicted as being far less ''flammable'' than it actually is. Uranium and Plutonium metal are both pyrophoric and can burn when exposed to air at room temperatures. This is why depleted Uranium is the substance of choice for anti-tank projectiles as they not only punch through the armour, but [[RuleOfCool also immolate ignite whatever's inside]]. Of course this is also why early nuclear reactors using Uranium metal had a tendency to [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windscale_fire catch fire]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not to mention when they were hydrogen an ignition source would create an explosion with the oxygen in the air. If they made it to lithium any amount of liquid water would react violently with the lithium, releasing the hydrogen and heat which would likely cause an explosion. Yay!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''{{Team Fortress 2}}'' website has a little fun with [[http://www.teamfortress.com/engineerupdate/v00.php Australium]].

to:

* The ''{{Team Fortress 2}}'' website has gives us Australium, an element [[CaptainObvious only found in Australia]]. The fact that overexposure to Australium leads to TestosteronePoisoning says a little fun with [[http://www.teamfortress.com/engineerupdate/v00.php Australium]].
lot about accuracy in this game.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/{{Spider-Man}} 2'' Dr. Octavius requires some tritium for his experiments. He obtains it in form of a gray metallic ball. Tritium is gaseous under normal conditions, but it's possible that the gold object is a second layer of containment in addition to the glass ball around it.

to:

* In ''Film/{{Spider-Man}} 2'' 2'', Dr. Octavius requires some tritium for his experiments. He obtains it in form of a gray metallic ball. Tritium is gaseous under normal conditions, but it's possible that the gold object is a second layer of containment in addition to the glass ball around it. He also mentions how tritium is one of the rarest elements on Earth. Tritium is actually an isotope of hydrogen, which is the most ''abundant''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: Music]]
* An odd aversion is Kate and Anna McGarrigle's "NaCl (Sodium Chloride)" - it's actually pretty accurate (setting aside the anthropomorphizing of atoms, of course).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** No discussion of the Trek universe's chemistry and physics would be complete without the [[http://www.midwinter.com/~koreth/particles/ list of particles in Star Trek]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one of the later films, ''{{Godzilla}} VS Mechagodzilla'', it's stated that Mechagodzilla is made of [[InSpace Space Titanium]]. We would like to know how it's different from regular-old everyday titanium, which, by the way, you can already find in outer space (not least because it's a good metal for some parts of our spacecraft).

to:

** In one of the later films, ''{{Godzilla}} VS Mechagodzilla'', it's stated that Mechagodzilla is made of [[InSpace [[RecycledInSpace Space Titanium]]. We would like to know how it's different from regular-old everyday titanium, which, by the way, you can already find in outer space (not least because it's a good metal for some parts of our spacecraft).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
arsenic toxicity


* ''{{Evolution}}'' did this for selenium. They {{hand wave}}d it by saying that selenium was to the alien creatures' nitrogen-based biochemistry as arsenic is to carbon-based life forms, because they're in the ''same relative position on the periodic table''. This handwave made it clear that nobody involved in the movie understands the concept of valence electrons. Besides, the Rule of Funny dictated they ''had'' to defeat the EldritchAbomination amoeba with gallons of anti-dandruff shampoo.

to:

* ''{{Evolution}}'' did this for selenium. They {{hand wave}}d it by saying that selenium was to the alien creatures' nitrogen-based biochemistry as arsenic is to carbon-based life forms, because they're in the ''same relative position on the periodic table''. This handwave made it clear that nobody involved in the movie understands the concept of valence electrons.electrons[[hottip:*:In real life, arsenic is poisonous because of its relative position to ''phosphorus'', which it can impersonate as far as certain core enzymes are concerned, but it is not quite similar enough that, say, an RNA molecule made with arsenate links instead of phosphate ones will actually fit into a ribosome]]. Besides, the Rule of Funny dictated they ''had'' to defeat the EldritchAbomination amoeba with gallons of anti-dandruff shampoo.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Not to be confused with ElementalRockPaperScissors; granted, elements don't work ''that'' way either in RealLife. Compare ParodicTableOfTheElements.

to:

Not to be confused with ElementalRockPaperScissors; granted, elements don't work ''that'' way either in RealLife. Compare ParodicTableOfTheElements.
ParodicTableOfTheElements. MirrorChemistry is often a specific form of this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****** Given the environmental controls that they can manage (ranging from changing the internal atmosphere, isolating hallways section by section, and spot-control over gravity), it isn't unreasonable to believe that Starfleet ships could turn their entire internal environment into a refrigerator if they wanted to.

Changed: 99

Removed: 346

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
just cutting some natter


* In the Kurt Vonnegut novel ''[[CatsCradle Cat's Cradle]]'' a single synthetic ice-crystal called "Ice-Nine," formed of ordinary oxygen and hydrogen, is able to freeze all liquid water that it touches, into identical crystals of "Ice Nine" via chain-reaction--eventually freezing all water on Earth. This is impossible due to the simple state of hydrogen-bonds that form liquid H[-2-]O and ice, preventing any such strange isomer-crystal.

to:

* In the Kurt Vonnegut novel ''[[CatsCradle Cat's Cradle]]'' a single synthetic ice-crystal called "Ice-Nine," formed of ordinary oxygen and hydrogen, is able to freeze all liquid water that it touches, into identical crystals of "Ice Nine" "Ice-Nine" via chain-reaction--eventually freezing all water on Earth. This is impossible due to the simple state of hydrogen-bonds that form liquid H[-2-]O and ice, preventing any such strange isomer-crystal.



* In H.G.Wells' ''WarOfTheWorlds'', the Martian's Black Smoke is said to be made of an unknown element that reacts with the Argon in the atmosphere, causing devastating effects on humans. Argon, being a noble gas is extremely difficult to react and the reaction will never happen in the atmosphere, especially considering the absolutely tiny amounts of noble gases in general in the atmosphere.

to:

* In H.G.Wells' ''WarOfTheWorlds'', the Martian's Black Smoke is said to be made of an unknown element that reacts with the Argon in the atmosphere, causing devastating effects on humans. Argon, being a noble gas gas, is extremely difficult to react and the reaction will never happen in the atmosphere, especially considering the absolutely tiny amounts of noble gases in general in the atmosphere.



** Noble gases in general are rare, for sure, but argon comprises nearly one per cent of air - that is, it's about one-twentieth as abundant as oxygen, and present at a far higher concentration than carbon dioxide. Hundreds of thousands of tons of the stuff are isolated and used industrially every year. That aside, Wells needed a slap for this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Not entirely true. Gamma rays that energetic can easily photo-disassociate nuclei, possibly producing a radioactive nuclide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In the DCAnimatedUniverse (or at least insofar as ''Batman: Vengeance'' is concerned, Promethium is a chemical compound used in cryogenics. It also blows up reeeeal good, hence the name (after Prometheus, bringer of fire). [[WildMassGuessing One assumes, however, that this use of "Promethium" is the result of a brand name.]]

Changed: 124

Removed: 501

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, the ''Science of Discworld'' books introduce several elements -- chelonium, elephantigen, deitygen, and of course narrativium -- that play a crucial role in the Discworld's cosmology and physical sciences. A subversion, as elements that aren't even possible in our universe Really ''Do'' Work That Way in the Discworld's reality.

to:

** Also, the ''Science of Discworld'' books introduce several elements -- chelonium, elephantigen, deitygen, and of course narrativium -- that play a crucial role in the Discworld's cosmology and physical sciences. A subversion, as elements that aren't even possible in our universe Really ''Do'' Work That Way in the Discworld's reality.



** Iridium armour has also turned up as an option for Tau Battlesuits. This may be a subversion, as while iridium is indeed used in crucibles and high-strength alloys, it has not yet been tested for weapons-grade durability. It's ridiculously dense and has a high melting point, though, which makes it a very good (if expensive and heavy) radiation shield, and at least a passable defense against lasers or particle beams. Its main problem would almost certainly be its rarity (more so than platinum).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Top