Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AllGenesAreCodominant

Go To

OR

Changed: 19

Removed: 846

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter.


* In HarryPotter, this appears to be J. K. Rowling's approach with the half-giant Hagrid. Normal giants are 20-25 feet tall, with extremely large bodies, and are not as intelligent as wizards. Hagrid is "Twice as tall as a normal man, and five times as wide," and [[BoisterousBruiser somewhat]] [[DumbIsGood bumbling]].
** Justified in that human height depends on multiple genes that dominate unpredictably; thus human height varies continuously rather than discretely, and offspring normally have a height between their parents'. If a human and a giant crossbred, some of the giant's "tall" alleles would dominate, as would some of the human's "short" ones. The real question is how the two could produce viable offspring at all.
*** With the exception of size, there doesn't appear to be any drastic differences between humans and giants. Giants might be a HumanSubspecies, in which case producing viable offspring is not much of a stretch (wolves and dogs, for instance, can produce viable offspring).
** Madame Maxime is also half-giant, and, while she's the same size as Hagrid, she is very intelligent. The bumbling would appear to just be Hagrid's personality.

to:

* In HarryPotter, ''Literature/HarryPotter'', this appears to be J. K. Rowling's JKRowling's approach with the half-giant Hagrid. Normal giants are 20-25 feet tall, with extremely large bodies, and are not as intelligent as wizards. Hagrid is "Twice as tall as a normal man, and five times as wide," and [[BoisterousBruiser somewhat]] [[DumbIsGood bumbling]].
** Justified in that human height depends on multiple genes that dominate unpredictably; thus human height varies continuously rather than discretely, and offspring normally have a height between their parents'. If a human and a giant crossbred, some of the giant's "tall" alleles would dominate, as would some of the human's "short" ones. The real question is how the two could produce viable offspring at all.
*** With the exception of size, there doesn't appear to be any drastic differences between humans and giants. Giants might be a HumanSubspecies, in which case producing viable offspring is not much of a stretch (wolves and dogs, for instance, can produce viable offspring).
** Madame Maxime is also half-giant, and, while she's the same size as Hagrid, she is very intelligent. The bumbling would appear to just be Hagrid's personality.
bumbling]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Dungeons and Dragons does this with many races and monsters. 3rd and 3.5's Half-Orcs and Half-Elves were both fairly infamous for being weaker than either parent race in terms of stats and racial abilities. In 4E, they abandoned the idea of half-elves being "halfway to an elf," so to speak, and expanded on the idea that they were inherently versatile ([[AcceptableBreaksFromReality which makes a lot less sense, but works a lot better]]).

to:

* Dungeons and Dragons DungeonsAndDragons does this with many races and monsters. 3rd and 3.5's Half-Orcs and Half-Elves were both fairly infamous for being weaker than either parent race in terms of stats and racial abilities. In 4E, they abandoned the idea of half-elves being "halfway to an elf," so to speak, and expanded on the idea that they were inherently versatile ([[AcceptableBreaksFromReality which makes a lot less sense, but works a lot better]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding an example

Added DiffLines:

* TheOrderOfTheStick has a half-elf with one pointy ear and one round ear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Pretty well averted in ''{{Farscape}}]] by Scorpius. Scorpius looks like something intermediate between a Scarran and a Sebacean, but his two halves are at war with each other, since Scarrans produce excess body heat naturally and Sebaceans are very intolerant of heat, entering a coma-like state when their internal body temperature (which they cannot regulate) gets too high. Scorpius compensates for this disability with an internal cooling apparatus. Scorpius also possesses an ability due to his hybrid nature that is unique to him and not present in either of his parents' species: he can see heat patterns and detect when a being is lying. Interestingly, Scorpius's appearance is similar to the more humanoid, upper-caste Scarrans.

to:

* Pretty well averted in ''{{Farscape}}]] ''{{Farscape}} by Scorpius. Scorpius looks like something intermediate between a Scarran and a Sebacean, but his two halves are at war with each other, since Scarrans produce excess body heat naturally and Sebaceans are very intolerant of heat, entering a coma-like state when their internal body temperature (which they cannot regulate) gets too high. Scorpius compensates for this disability with an internal cooling apparatus. Scorpius also possesses an ability due to his hybrid nature that is unique to him and not present in either of his parents' species: he can see heat patterns and detect when a being is lying. Interestingly, Scorpius's appearance is similar to the more humanoid, upper-caste Scarrans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding \"farscape\" example

Added DiffLines:

* Pretty well averted in ''{{Farscape}}]] by Scorpius. Scorpius looks like something intermediate between a Scarran and a Sebacean, but his two halves are at war with each other, since Scarrans produce excess body heat naturally and Sebaceans are very intolerant of heat, entering a coma-like state when their internal body temperature (which they cannot regulate) gets too high. Scorpius compensates for this disability with an internal cooling apparatus. Scorpius also possesses an ability due to his hybrid nature that is unique to him and not present in either of his parents' species: he can see heat patterns and detect when a being is lying. Interestingly, Scorpius's appearance is similar to the more humanoid, upper-caste Scarrans.
** With D'argo's half-Sebacean son, Jothee, this trope is played straight. Jothee is essentially the ''Farscape'' version of a Klingon-Human hybrid. Intermediate physical features, physically stronger than a Sebacean but weaker than a full Luxan, possesses his father's stinging tongue but isn't as coordinated with it, and has a weaker sense of smell than a full Luxan that is still superior to a Sebacean's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Dhampyr}}s in ''{{Durarara}}'' appear to work this way, if [[spoiler:Ruri Hirijibe]] is anything to go by. Being quarter-vampire, [[spoiler:she]] has more common vampiric traits and weaknesses in a diluted form (for example, [[spoiler:she]] hates direct sunlight and garlic, possesses a moderate level of SuperStrength, [[HealingFactor heals noticeably faster than normal]], and has a thing for rare meat with a high iron content).

to:

* {{Dhampyr}}s in ''{{Durarara}}'' appear to work this way, if [[spoiler:Ruri Hirijibe]] Hijiribe]] is anything to go by. Being quarter-vampire, [[spoiler:she]] has more common vampiric traits and weaknesses in a diluted form (for example, [[spoiler:she]] hates direct sunlight and garlic, possesses a moderate level of SuperStrength, [[HealingFactor heals noticeably faster than normal]], and has a thing for rare meat with a high iron content).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Dhampyr}}s in ''{{Durarara}}'' appear to work this way, if [[spoiler:Ruri Hirijibe]] is anything to go by. Being quarter-vampire, [[spoiler:she]] has more common vampiric traits and weaknesses in a diluted form (for example, [[spoiler:she]] hates direct sunlight, possesses a moderate level of SuperStrength, [[HealingFactor heals noticeably faster than normal]], and has a thing for rare meat with a high iron content).

to:

* {{Dhampyr}}s in ''{{Durarara}}'' appear to work this way, if [[spoiler:Ruri Hirijibe]] is anything to go by. Being quarter-vampire, [[spoiler:she]] has more common vampiric traits and weaknesses in a diluted form (for example, [[spoiler:she]] hates direct sunlight, sunlight and garlic, possesses a moderate level of SuperStrength, [[HealingFactor heals noticeably faster than normal]], and has a thing for rare meat with a high iron content).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* {{Dhampyr}}s in ''{{Durarara}}'' appear to work this way, if [[spoiler:Ruri Hirijibe]] is anything to go by. Being quarter-vampire, [[spoiler:she]] has more common vampiric traits and weaknesses in a diluted form (for example, [[spoiler:she]] hates direct sunlight, possesses a moderate level of SuperStrength, [[HealingFactor heals noticeably faster than normal]], and has a thing for rare meat with a high iron content).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Subverted in [[WorldOfWarcraft]], as a Half-Draenei Half-Orc (which, evolutionarily speaking makes NO sense) will show that Draenei genes are almost all recessive save for the eyes.

to:

* Subverted in [[WorldOfWarcraft]], [[WorldOfWarcraft Warcraft]], as a Half-Draenei Half-Orc (which, evolutionarily speaking makes NO sense) will show that Draenei genes are almost all recessive save for the eyes.

Changed: 183

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Subverted in [[WorldOfWarcraft]], as a Half-Draenei Half-Orc (which, evolutionarily speaking makes NO sense) will show that Draenei genes are almost all recessive save for the eyes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Except Ligers have their own special weakness...they are so large, that they often have problems with their joints.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** With the exception of size, there doesn't appear to be any drastic differences between humans and giants. Giants might be a HumanSubspecies, in which case producing viable offspring is not much of a stretch (wolves and dogs, for instance, can produce viable offspring).

Changed: 356

Removed: 381

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One allele is dominant, and the other is recessive, so [[CaptainObvious the offspring will display the trait that the dominant gene codes for]]. (Brown-eyed daddy and blue-eyed mommy makes brown-eyed baby.)
** UNLESS the brown-eyed daddy was heterozygous for the brown-eyed gene. If B means brown eye pigment and b means no brown eye pigment, and brown is dominant, either Bb or BB will make a brown-eyed person, but only bb will mean blue eyes. BB x bb = Bb 100% of the time, but Bb x bb can = bb 50% of the time. [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punnett_square Punnett squares]] know all.

to:

* One allele is dominant, and the other is recessive, so [[CaptainObvious the offspring will display the trait that the dominant gene codes for]]. (Brown-eyed daddy For example, blue eyes are bb, brown eyes can be either BB (homozygous) or Bb (heterozygous). The B allele is dominant, and blue-eyed mommy makes brown-eyed baby.)
** UNLESS
blue eyes only appear if it is not present. From this, heterozygous people can be 'carriers' of traits without displaying them, which may appear in their children if the brown-eyed daddy was other parent either has the recessive trait or is also heterozygous for the brown-eyed gene. If B means brown eye pigment and b means no brown eye pigment, and brown is dominant, either Bb or BB will make a brown-eyed person, but only bb will mean blue eyes. BB x bb = Bb 100% of the time, but Bb x bb can = bb 50% of the time. [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punnett_square Punnett squares]] know all.it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Notably averted in the case of Spock, who is pretty much indistinguishable from full-blooded Vulcans.
** To humans, that is. I'm fairly sure Vulcans can tell the difference.

to:

** Averted with the teeth of half-Klingons K'Ehleyr from ''TNG'' and B'Elanna Torres from ''StarTrekVoyager'', which are human EternallyPearlyWhiteTeeth instead of FangThpeak-inducing Klingon yuckiness.
* Notably In ''StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'', it is averted in the case of Spock, who is pretty much indistinguishable from full-blooded Vulcans.
** To humans, that is. I'm fairly sure Vulcans can
Vulcans--to humans (Vulcans seem to be able to tell the difference.difference. Somehow). Spock was not revealed to be only half-Vulcan until they decided he was....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding an example.

Added DiffLines:

* In the KieshaRa Series by Amelia Atwater Rhodes, the shapeshifters were all once humans who were either granted second forms by elementals, or created with the help of other species. Eventually, the monarchs of the Avians and Serpiente work together to bridge their 2000 year old war and the heirs to the thrones intermarry. It was not believed that they would be able to have children at first, but there apparently was enough human in their genes to make it work, and the child is a wyvern who has a pure Hawk form, a pure Cobra form, and a form that has traits of both.
**This codiminance of genes only works for these two breeds, since among the birds the Hawk gene is dominant, and among the snakes the Cobra gene is dominant.
**It should be noted that the combination of the power of the two species makes it so that it would be dangerous for any wyvern (or any HalfBreed ) to have children themselves, but they are not actually sterile.

Added: 193

Changed: 236

Removed: 482

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:TableTopGames]]
* Dungeons and Dragons does this with many races and monsters. 3rd and 3.5's Half-Orcs and Half-Elves were both fairly infamous for being weaker than either parent race in terms of stats and racial abilities.
** In 4E, they abandoned the idea of half-elves being "halfway to an elf," so to speak, and expanded on the idea that they were inherently versatile ([[AcceptableBreaksFromReality which makes a lot less sense, but works a lot better]]).
*** One could, in fact, see half-elves' constitution bonus as a result of hybrid vigour. Actually, that's about the only way it makes sense, as neither humans nor elves have a bonus to constitution, and 3rd Edition's elves actually had a penalty.

to:

[[folder:TableTopGames]]
[[folder:TabletopGames]]
* Dungeons and Dragons does this with many races and monsters. 3rd and 3.5's Half-Orcs and Half-Elves were both fairly infamous for being weaker than either parent race in terms of stats and racial abilities.
**
abilities. In 4E, they abandoned the idea of half-elves being "halfway to an elf," so to speak, and expanded on the idea that they were inherently versatile ([[AcceptableBreaksFromReality which makes a lot less sense, but works a lot better]]).
*** One could, in fact, see half-elves' constitution bonus as a result of hybrid vigour. Actually, that's about the only way it makes sense, as neither humans nor elves have a bonus to constitution, and 3rd Edition's elves actually had a penalty.
better]]).


Added DiffLines:

* In ''Game/{{Munchkin}}'', the Half-Race card allows the player to choose either all the strengths and none of the weaknesses from one race, or all strengths ''and'' weaknesses from two races.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is never explained in the books. Sure, Filch is in Hogwarts, but it\'s unlikely it suddenly goes invisible if a witch/wizard deliberately brings you in (think: Myrtle\'s parents were said to have gone to Hogwarts after Myrtle died. Why was she killed? Because she was muggle-born!)


*** Squibs also have some abilities that regular Muggles do not, such as being able to see places which are hidden to Muggles (such as Hogwarts), or using certain magical objects.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** To humans, that is. I'm fairly sure Vulcans can tell the difference.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Notably averted in the case of Spock, who is pretty much indistinguishable from full-blooded Vulcans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleting that comment since magic being recessive doesn\'t mean we\'re dealing with only one gene here.


*** Magic can't be recessive because if a pure muggle and anybody with magic always produce magical children (with the exception of the Squib mutation). Clearly, magic isn't wholly genetic.

to:

*** Magic can't be recessive because if a pure muggle and anybody with magic always produce Squibs also have some abilities that regular Muggles do not, such as being able to see places which are hidden to Muggles (such as Hogwarts), or using certain magical children (with the exception of the Squib mutation). Clearly, magic isn't wholly genetic.objects.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''StarTrekTheNextGeneration,'' Deanna Troi has a (telepathic) Betazoid mother and a (non-telepathic) human father, and is herself empathic: she can sense emotions psychically but not read individual thoughts ([[DependingOnTheWriter usually]]).

to:

* In ''StarTrekTheNextGeneration,'' Deanna Troi has a (telepathic) Betazoid mother and a (non-telepathic) human father, and is herself empathic: she can sense emotions psychically but not read individual thoughts ([[DependingOnTheWriter usually]]). [[http://pictures.pichaus.com/xl/6b9a222c0dffcdeaad6366d9740ea3caf1e43f69?AWSAccessKeyId=0K4RZZKHSB5N2XYJWF02&Expires=1292980000&Signature=X09xUdxqk7KG0vKRnyCRMA8sZ5w%3D This is her superpower.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This happens to be my expert field. I couldn\'t let it pass.

Added DiffLines:

** ''Depending'', of course, on which kind of black, and ditto white, you are working on. Different types of black/white hybrids could be '''1)''' Black; '''2)''' White; '''3)''' "Blue" (which is [[NonIndicativeName actually grey]]); '''4)''' Mottled black and white; '''5)''' Barred, brown, pencilled, whatever, showing little resemplance to either parent colour.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Cross a black chicken with a white chicken, and (once the babies grow feathers) you'll get mottled black-and-white chickens!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a note to the superman thing

Added DiffLines:

** And that's disregarding the [[http://www.rawbw.com/~svw/superman.html mechanical difficulties]] inherent in human-Kryptonian intercourse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Magic can't be recessive because if a pure muggle and anybody with magic always produce magical children (with the exception of the Squib mutation). Clearly, magic isn't wholly genetic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** UNLESS the brown-eyed daddy was heterozygous for the brown-eyed gene. If B means brown and b means blue, and brown is dominant, either Bb or BB will make a brown-eyed person, but only bb will mean blue eyes. BB x bb = Bb 100% of the time, but Bb x bb can = bb 50% of the time. [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punnett_square Punnett squares]] know all.

to:

** UNLESS the brown-eyed daddy was heterozygous for the brown-eyed gene. If B means brown eye pigment and b means blue, no brown eye pigment, and brown is dominant, either Bb or BB will make a brown-eyed person, but only bb will mean blue eyes. BB x bb = Bb 100% of the time, but Bb x bb can = bb 50% of the time. [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punnett_square Punnett squares]] know all.

Changed: 279

Removed: 460

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''DragonHalf'': The daughter of a dragon and a human was a CuteMonsterGirl with horns, wings, and fire breath.
** Let's not forget about the simply ''inhuman'' physical strength and agility.

to:

* ''DragonHalf'': The daughter of a dragon and a human was a CuteMonsterGirl with horns, wings, and fire breath.
** Let's not forget about the simply
breath. As well as ''inhuman'' physical strength and agility.



** So he's a reverse werewolf that turns into a human based on the moon...



*** It's explained that how a halfbreed appears is really luck of the draw. Jinenji's father was a bishonen if you've ever seen one, yet their kid is more ugly than a [[StarWars Hutt]] with his face caved in. Some come out to be beautiful and humanlike, others come out horrifying.

to:

*** ** It's explained that how a halfbreed appears is really luck of the draw. Jinenji's father was a bishonen if you've ever seen one, yet their kid is more ugly than a [[StarWars Hutt]] with his face caved in. Some come out to be beautiful and humanlike, others come out horrifying.



** [[{{Squick}} Engorgio Charm?]]
*** Don't you mean [[FetishFuel Engorgio Charm?]]



*** Meanwhile, a strange trait pops up in pureblooded families every once in awhile, which results in the occasional Squib child, like Argus Filch or Arabella Figg. This seems to just be a rather rare and unlucky condition. However, Rowling has mentioned something to the effect that Muggleborn witches and wizards could in fact be born from Squib ancestors, suggesting that the same strange quirk that causes loss of magic in some babies also causes the magic gene to reactivate in their effectively muggle descendants. (Or that magic is recessive and that squibs just got unlucky mutations on those genes, WordOfGod to the contrary [[YouFailBiologyForever notwithstanding]].)

to:

*** ** Meanwhile, a strange trait pops up in pureblooded families every once in awhile, which results in the occasional Squib child, like Argus Filch or Arabella Figg. This seems to just be a rather rare and unlucky condition. However, Rowling has mentioned something to the effect that Muggleborn witches and wizards could in fact be born from Squib ancestors, suggesting that the same strange quirk that causes loss of magic in some babies also causes the magic gene to reactivate in their effectively muggle descendants. (Or that magic is recessive and that squibs just got unlucky mutations on those genes, WordOfGod to the contrary [[YouFailBiologyForever notwithstanding]].)



** Also known as a Zonkey, Donbra, Zeedonk, Zebrinny, and Debra.
*** The standard for making [[PortmanteauCoupleName portmanteau hybrid names]] is to use the father's species first (unless there's a non-portmanteau name already in use).

to:

** Also known as a Zonkey, Donbra, Zeedonk, Zebrinny, and Debra. \n*** The standard for making [[PortmanteauCoupleName portmanteau hybrid names]] is to use the father's species first (unless there's a non-portmanteau name already in use).



*** Ligers are an example of getting all of the strengths, because they are larger (often as large as both parents put together) and stronger than either parent and the largest big cat on Earth. Tiglons are generally about the same size as their parent species, and less likely to survive birth, but they are not, by any means, small. However, in both cases they are often sterile and second-generation hybrids are rare.
**** Males are sterile, females are generally fertile.

to:

*** Ligers are an example of getting all of the strengths, because they are larger (often as large as both parents put together) and stronger than either parent and the largest big cat on Earth. Tiglons are generally about the same size as their parent species, and less likely to survive birth, but they are not, by any means, small. However, in both cases they males are often sterile and second-generation hybrids are rare.
**** Males are sterile,
females are generally fertile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Let's not forget about the simply ''inhuman'' physical strength and agility.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****Males are sterile, females are generally fertile.
**Mules as well, although they are also a bit mary-sueish (sterility aside), being described as "more patient, sure-footed, hardy and long-lived than horses, and they are considered less obstinate, faster, and more intelligent than donkeys."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As I said on the You Fail Biology Forever page, Word Of God be darned, that's not how recessive genes work.


*** Meanwhile, a strange recessive trait pops up in pureblooded families every once in awhile, which results in the occasional Squib child, like Argus Filch or Arabella Figg. This seems to just be a rather rare and unlucky condition. However, Rowling has mentioned something to the effect that Muggleborn witches and wizards could in fact be born from Squib ancestors, suggesting that the same strange quirk that causes loss of magic in some babies also causes the magic gene to reactivate in their effectively muggle descendants.

to:

*** Meanwhile, a strange recessive trait pops up in pureblooded families every once in awhile, which results in the occasional Squib child, like Argus Filch or Arabella Figg. This seems to just be a rather rare and unlucky condition. However, Rowling has mentioned something to the effect that Muggleborn witches and wizards could in fact be born from Squib ancestors, suggesting that the same strange quirk that causes loss of magic in some babies also causes the magic gene to reactivate in their effectively muggle descendants. (Or that magic is recessive and that squibs just got unlucky mutations on those genes, WordOfGod to the contrary [[YouFailBiologyForever notwithstanding]].)

Top