Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / NorthangerAbbey

Go To

OR

Changed: 855

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SacredHospitality: Played straight by Henry and Eleanor. Subverted by General Tilney.

to:

* SacredHospitality: Played straight by General Tilney invites Catherinr in his house because he wants her to marry his son Henry. One day, he suddenly throws her out with a lame excuse and sends her away in a public coach with no attending servant. (This doesn't sound so horrible today, but back then it meant deliberate insult.) The reason for all that was, he found out she wasn't as rich as he thought. His violation of Sacred Hospitality is how the reader fully sees his true colours. His children Henry and Eleanor. Subverted Eleanor are distressed by General Tilney.his treatment of Catherine.



* ShoutOut: To numerous pieces of literature from its day.

to:

%% * ShoutOut: To numerous pieces of literature from its day.



* SuddenlySuitableSuitor: The ''deus ex machina'' ending.
* TearsOfRemorse: Catherine, after Henry disillusions her about his mother's death.

to:

* SuddenlySuitableSuitor: The ''deus ex machina'' ending.
ending. Eleanor is able to marry her love because he unexpectedly inherited money and aristocratic title.
* TearsOfRemorse: Catherine, Catherine cries after Henry disillusions her about his mother's death.



* UnableToSupportAWife: Eleanor's lover, though this isn't mentioned until the end.

to:

* UnableToSupportAWife: Eleanor's lover, lover wasn't rich enough to marry her, though this isn't mentioned until the end.end. However, it's possible that he ''was'' able to marry and have fairly comfortable income, only his income wasn't good enough for Eleanor's gold-digging father. The young man unexpectedly inherits title and fortune.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LadyInRed: In the ITV version, Isabella is seen walking with Captain Tilney, wearing a red dress. They enter a room and when she's seen again, she's shown curled up in bedsheets, implying she had sex with Captain Tilney.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HateSink: John Thorpe is James Morland’s friend and a boorish GoldDigger who seeks to marry Catherine Morland, mistakenly believing her to be a rich heiress. Desiring to have Catherine all to himself, Thorpe makes repeated attempts to sabotage her attempts to make friends with the Tilney family, making shameless lies to force her to spend time with him. Thorpe also lies to General Tilney about Catherine’s wealth to get him to drive up his own prospects. When this backfires with the General pushing Catherine towards his son Henry, Thorpe slanders Catherine to General Tilney by projecting his own situation onto Catherine’s family, prompting him to throw Catherine, who is staying with the Tilneys at this point, out of the house in the dead of night. A shameless liar who talks of nothing but carriages and horses and [[SirSwearsALot speaks with crude language]], John Thorpe is the closest thing to a BigBad in Creator/JaneAusten’s novels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding detail


* HugeGuy,TinyGirl: In the ITV adaptation, JJ Feild’s Henry looms over Felicity Jones’ Catherine.

to:

* HugeGuy,TinyGirl: HugeGuyTinyGirl: In the ITV adaptation, JJ Feild’s Henry looms over Felicity Jones’ Catherine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding detail


* Huge Guy, Tiny Girl: In the ITV adaptation, JJ Feild’s Henry looms over Felicity Jones’ Catherine.

to:

* Huge Guy, Tiny Girl: HugeGuy,TinyGirl: In the ITV adaptation, JJ Feild’s Henry looms over Felicity Jones’ Catherine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding detail

Added DiffLines:

* Huge Guy, Tiny Girl: In the ITV adaptation, JJ Feild’s Henry looms over Felicity Jones’ Catherine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The definitive [[GothicHorror Gothic]] parody, ''Northanger Abbey'' was Creator/JaneAusten's first completed novel, which she wrote as "Susan"; it developed farther the satiric vein found in her juvenilia, such as ''Literature/LoveAndFreindship''. However, circumstances prevented the novel from being published until after her death in 1817.

to:

The definitive [[GothicHorror Gothic]] parody, ''Northanger Abbey'' was Creator/JaneAusten's first completed novel, which she wrote as "Susan"; it developed farther further the satiric vein found in her juvenilia, juvenalia, such as ''Literature/LoveAndFreindship''. However, circumstances prevented the novel from being published until after her death in 1817.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GoodParents: Catherine's parents, Mr and Mrs Morland are loving, reasonable and responsible people who value happiness of all their children. Mr Morland agrees to James' engagement to Isabella Thorpe; a girl he loves but who has no dowry. James and Catherine think that their father is both supportive and fair and gives them as much as he can, considering his large family, while the Thorpes think Mr Morland is being mean and should give them more. Mrs Morland is very good, practical and kind, though she fails to see that Catherine is actually lovesick when she returns home from the Abbey. She's also very nice to Henry when she does not hold his father's rudeness to Catherine against him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DramaticSitDown: After Catherine hears from her friend Eleanor that she's being thrown out of their house unceremoniously, she sits down breathless and speechless. It was a major breach of the SacredHospitality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RightForTheWrongReasons: Catherine's mistrust of General Tilney. Is he a murderer? No. But he ''is'' an untrustworthy Jerkass who emotionally abuses his children and kicks a teenage girl out of his house all her own with no care as to how she'll get home.

to:

* RightForTheWrongReasons: Catherine's mistrust of General Tilney. Is he a murderer? No. But he ''is'' an untrustworthy Jerkass who emotionally abuses his children and kicks a teenage girl out of his house all her own with no care as to how she'll get home.home, for no crime other than being the subject of ''his'' false assumptions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DoubleStandard: In an inversion from the usual. When Catherine is upset at Captain Tilney's flirting with Isabella, whom he knows to be engaged, Henry and Eleanor point out that Isabella is actively courting his attentions.


Added DiffLines:

* FalseFriend: The Thorpe siblings for the Morland siblings. John Thorpe is a dishonest braggart; Catherine pegs him as one instantly but James sees no fault in him until much later. Isabella is just as bad, using Catherine as a convenient source of entertainment and pursing James only because she believes him rich.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Isabella fears this from James's parents, for [[WrongGenreSavvy no good reason]].

to:

** Isabella fears this from James's parents, for [[WrongGenreSavvy no good reason]].parents. She actually seems disappointed when Catherine assures her that Mr. and Mrs. Morland wouldn't do such a thing. (Possibly because it means that their family finances are less unequal than Isabella had hoped.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Gaslighting: John and Isabella Thorpe both accuse Catherine of having promised everything from a dance to a ride to an engagement of marriage, and when she protests, they try to convince her that she has a terrible memory.

to:

* Gaslighting: {{Gaslighting}}: John and Isabella Thorpe both accuse Catherine of having promised everything from a dance to a ride to an engagement of marriage, and when she protests, they try to convince her that she has a terrible memory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultsAreUseless: Mrs. Allen fails to do her job when it comes to advising Catherine on etiquette. She fails at it so completely, in fact, that Catherine finally complains that she's being left dangerously to her own devices.

to:

* AdultsAreUseless: Mrs. Allen fails to do her job when it comes to advising Catherine on etiquette. She fails at it so completely, in fact, that Catherine finally complains that she's being left dangerously to her own devices. Mr. Allen is somewhat more useful in that he takes some pains to find out if Henry Tilney is a respectable young man after Catherine is introduced to him.

Added: 186

Changed: 115

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlondBrunetteRedhead: Isabella Thorpe, Catherine Morland and Eleanor Tilney in the ITV version.

to:

* BlondBrunetteRedhead: BlondeBrunetteRedhead: Isabella Thorpe, Catherine Morland and Eleanor Tilney in the ITV version.



* ChekhovsGunman: In ITV's TV version, John Thorpe first appears at the assembly where Catherine meets Henry, staring at Catherine as she and Henry dance. He also shows up as a dastardly villain in one of her dreams, pursuing Catherine and Henry on a rainy night and dueling Henry.

to:

* ChekhovsGunman: In ITV's TV version, John Thorpe first appears at the assembly where Catherine meets Henry, staring at Catherine as she and Henry dance. He also shows up as a dastardly villain in one of her dreams, pursuing Catherine and Henry on a rainy night and dueling Henry. By the same token, Isabella Thorpe appears talking with John in the tea room in a scene cut from the DVD version.


Added DiffLines:

* PerpetualFrowner: General Tilney in the ITV version. The only time he smiles is when Catherine accepts his invitation to come to Northanger Abbey, and it comes off as a PsychoticSmirk.

Added: 534

Removed: 534

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Diary}}: Whether Catherine actually keeps one is never mentioned in the novel, but Henry jokingly assumes that all young women do, and goes on to speculate that that's why they're (supposedly) so good at letter-writing. This is an early (perhaps the first) example of the word "journal" used as a verb. Henry speaks several times about "journaling", making the whole conversation sound oddly modern. Played straight in the 2007 movie, in which she is revealed, two seconds after this conversation, to be writing about the events.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Diary}}: Whether Catherine actually keeps one is never mentioned in the novel, but Henry jokingly assumes that all young women do, and goes on to speculate that that's why they're (supposedly) so good at letter-writing. This is an early (perhaps the first) example of the word "journal" used as a verb. Henry speaks several times about "journaling", making the whole conversation sound oddly modern. Played straight in the 2007 movie, in which she is revealed, two seconds after this conversation, to be writing about the events.

Added: 508

Removed: 508

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ConversationalTroping: EVERYWHERE!
* ConspiracyTheorist: Catherine has all these suspicions about the Tilneys and the abbey, all of them based on nothing except conventions of Gothic novels, and jumping to wild conclusions based on tiny discrepancies in what she thinks someone's behaviour should be. For this, she earns the title of IdiotHero, because although she tends to be smart if naive in other matters, here she drops down right into deep stupidity. She [[CharacterDevelopment gets better, though]].



* ConversationalTroping: EVERYWHERE!
* ConspiracyTheorist: Catherine has all these suspicions about the Tilneys and the abbey, all of them based on nothing except conventions of Gothic novels, and jumping to wild conclusions based on tiny discrepancies in what she thinks someone's behaviour should be. For this, she earns the title of IdiotHero, because although she tends to be smart if naive in other matters, here she drops down right into deep stupidity. She [[CharacterDevelopment gets better, though]].

Added: 104

Removed: 104

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AristocratsAreEvil: Mrs. Morland is unaware of this, and does not warn her daughter against the peril.



* AristocratsAreEvil: Mrs. Morland is unaware of this, and does not warn her daughter against the peril.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Catherine is described as "almost pretty" and Tilney as "if not quite handsome ... very near it." In the 2007 ITV adaptation they are played by Creator/FelicityJones and J.J. Feild, respectively.
--> '''Henry''': Nothing would give me greater pleasure, sir. *smirks at Catherine*


Added DiffLines:

* DoubleEntendre:
--> '''General Tilney''' (who has been aggressively pushing Catherine and Henry together throughout the entire novel, as he believes she is an heiress, on the morning of his departure from Northanger): I trust you will be able to entertain our guest ''properly'' while I am gone, Henry?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Gaslighting: John and Isabella Thorpe both accuse Catherine of having promised everything from a dance to a ride to an engagement of marriage, and when she protests, they try to convince her that she has a terrible memory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Countering the AdaptationOverdosed tendency of Austen's other works, this has to be the least adapted of all her works. It was twice adapted into {{Made for TV Movie}}s, once by Creator/TheBBC in 1986 and once by {{ITV}} in 2007. The Creator/{{PBS}} series ''Series/{{Wishbone}}'' also used it as the basis of an episode, with the eponymous dog in the role of Henry. Marvel Illustrated released a ComicBookAdaptation starting November 2011, script by Nancy Butler, pencils and inks by Janet Lee, and covers by Julian Totino Tedesco. It was also the second book given a modern day SettingUpdate by The Austen Project, written by [[Series/WireInTheBlood Val McDermid]].

to:

Countering the AdaptationOverdosed tendency of Austen's other works, this has to be the least adapted of all her works. It was twice adapted into {{Made for TV Movie}}s, once by Creator/TheBBC in 1986 and once by {{ITV}} Creator/{{ITV}} in 2007. The Creator/{{PBS}} series ''Series/{{Wishbone}}'' also used it as the basis of an episode, with the eponymous dog in the role of Henry. Marvel Illustrated released a ComicBookAdaptation starting November 2011, script by Nancy Butler, pencils and inks by Janet Lee, and covers by Julian Totino Tedesco. It was also the second book given a modern day SettingUpdate by The Austen Project, written by [[Series/WireInTheBlood Val McDermid]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CommicallyMissingThePoint: After Isabella and James are officially engaged, John Thorpe makes a pass at Catherine by saying that they will go to the wedding and try the truth of the old song "Going To One Wedding Brings On Another".

to:

* CommicallyMissingThePoint: ComicallyMissingThePoint: After Isabella and James are officially engaged, John Thorpe makes a pass at Catherine by saying that they will go to the wedding and try the truth of the old song "Going To One Wedding Brings On Another".

Added: 541

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BookEnds: The 1986 BBC adaptation opens and closes with Catherine hearing her little sister calling for her.



* DreamSequence: Catherine has several of these in the ITV version. They go in this order:

to:

* DreamSequence: DreamSequence / FantasySequence: Catherine has several of these in the ITV version. They go in this order:


Added DiffLines:

* EightiesHair: Isabella's hairdo in the 1986 version is a colossal mass of curls.
* ImagineSpot: In the BBC adaptation, Catherine has two before the opening credits, involving being in IHaveYouNowMyPretty situations with ruffians who [[AndYouWereThere strangely resemble people she will meet in Bath]]. The second one reoccurs when Catherine is at the Abbey, with Henry riding in on a white horse to rescue her from the villains.

Added: 269

Changed: 40

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ClockKing: General Tilney.

to:

* ClockKing: General Tilney. And then he'll yell at you for rushing.
* CommicallyMissingThePoint: After Isabella and James are officially engaged, John Thorpe makes a pass at Catherine by saying that they will go to the wedding and try the truth of the old song "Going To One Wedding Brings On Another".
-->''Catherine:'' But I never sing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LeaveTheTwoLovebirdsAlone: During Catherine's walk with the Tilneys in the ITV version, Eleanor suddenly has to tie her shoe, leaving Catherine and Henry to talk alone for a few moments. Then flipped a few seconds later, when Eleanor's paramour rides up and they walk off to let her talk to him in private.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RightForTheWrongReasons: Catherine's mistrust of General Tilney. Is he a murderer? No. But he ''is'' an untrustworthy Jerkass who emotionally abuses his children and kicks a teenage girl out of his house all her own with no care as to how she'll get home.

Added: 734

Changed: 1161

Removed: 534

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing spoiler tags given Spoiler Policy on works of this age


* [[AscendedFanboy Ascended Fangirl]]: Gothic romance novel fangirl Catherine gets to spend some weeks in a Gothic abbey. [[spoiler: The trope is ultimately subverted, when Catherine is proven to be WrongGenreSavvy.]]

to:

* [[AscendedFanboy Ascended Fangirl]]: Gothic romance novel fangirl Catherine gets to spend some weeks in a Gothic abbey. [[spoiler: The trope is ultimately subverted, when Catherine is proven to be WrongGenreSavvy.]]



* ChekhovsGun: Deliberately invoked by the {{Narrator}} to ''deliberately narrowly avert'' an AssPull!

to:

* ChekhovsGun: Deliberately invoked by the {{Narrator}} to ''deliberately narrowly avert'' an AssPull!AssPull! It's thoroughly lampshaded by the narrator, who says she knows it's "against the rules" to introduce a character like this at the eleventh hour and therefore points to the laundry list as sufficient foreshadowing.



* DeusExMachina: General Tilney refused to let Catherine wed Henry only because [[spoiler:he did not want Henry to marry a poor girl]]. But when his daughter Eleanor marries a nobleman, it makes him happy enough to consent to his son's marrying whomever he wants (although it also doesn't hurt when he finds out that Catherine's [[spoiler: not as poor as he thought]]). By the way, [[ChekhovsGun remember]] the [[spoiler:laundry list? That was said rich man's]].

to:

* DeusExMachina: General Tilney refused to let Catherine wed Henry only because [[spoiler:he he did not want Henry to marry a poor girl]]. girl. But when his daughter Eleanor marries a nobleman, it makes him happy enough to consent to his son's marrying whomever he wants (although it also doesn't hurt when he finds out that Catherine's [[spoiler: not as poor as he thought]]). thought). By the way, [[ChekhovsGun remember]] the [[spoiler:laundry laundry list? That was said rich man's]].man's.



* ForegoneConclusion[=/=]MediumAwareness[=/=]SpoiledByTheFormat: "The anxiety, which ... must be the portion of [[spoiler:Henry and Catherine]] ... can hardly extend, I fear, to the bosom of my readers, [[LampshadeHanging who will see in the tell-tale compression of the pages before them]], that we are all hastening together to [[HappilyEverAfter perfect felicity]]."
** Subverted in editions that include ''Lady Susan'' and the unfinished novels; in these, the end of ''Northanger Abbey'' occurs when only halfway through the book.



* MoralityKitchenSink: A major part of the Aesop for Catherine.
* NaiveEverygirl: Catherine

to:

* MoralityKitchenSink: A major part of the Aesop for Catherine.
Catherine. General Tilney is a highly unpleasant man and difficult for his wife and children to live with, but that doesn't mean he was unaffected by her death. Captain Tilney is a careless flirt, but Henry and Eleanor still love him as their brother and his misbehavior accidentally saves James Morland from a bad marriage.
* NaiveEverygirl: CatherineCatherine.



* OhWaitThisIsMyGroceryList: Catherine finds some old papers, and imagines their terrifying contents just as the lights go out. When she gets some light and reads them, she finds a laundry list. [[spoiler:This is a ChekhovsGun]].

to:

* OhWaitThisIsMyGroceryList: Catherine finds some old papers, and imagines their terrifying contents just as the lights go out. When she gets some light and reads them, she finds a laundry list. [[spoiler:This is a ChekhovsGun]].Which actually becomes important later.



* ParentsAsPeople: Mr. and Mrs. Morland love their many children, but their greatest compliment to their daughter is to say that she is "almost pretty today." (It actually doesn't bother Catherine at all because she's always been an OutdoorsyGal who's only recently learned to care about being pretty.) They also read James' letter of heartbreak and betrayal about Isabella and conclude that it's probably good for him to have it happen at a young age because he'll recover and know better. Similarly, while they're angry at General Tilney they feel that Catherine's long journey was a good learning experience to manage herself, and can't figure out that her low spirits are more from her ill-treatment until handsome Henry turns up.



* PoorCommunicationKills

to:

* %%* PoorCommunicationKills



** [[spoiler:Isabella Thorpe for James Morland.]]
** [[spoiler:John Thorpe for Catherine. He's not much of one, though; Catherine perceives him as a {{Jerkass}} from day one and is never truly interested in him in the first place, only doing things with him because he is James's friend and Isabella's brother.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Isabella Isabella Thorpe for James Morland.]]
Morland.
** [[spoiler:John John Thorpe for Catherine. He's not much of one, though; Catherine perceives him as a {{Jerkass}} from day one and is never truly interested in him in the first place, only doing things with him because he is James's friend and Isabella's brother.]]



* SpoiledByTheFormat: Lampshaded (see ForegoneConclusion, above). [[invoked]]

to:

* SpoiledByTheFormat: Lampshaded (see ForegoneConclusion, above). [[invoked]][[invoked]] "The anxiety, which ... must be the portion of Henry and Catherine ... can hardly extend, I fear, to the bosom of my readers, [[LampshadeHanging who will see in the tell-tale compression of the pages before them]], that we are all hastening together to [[HappilyEverAfter perfect felicity]]." (Subverted in editions that include ''Lady Susan'' and the unfinished novels; in these, the end of ''Northanger Abbey'' occurs when only halfway through the book.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The definitive [[GothicHorror Gothic]] parody, ''Northanger Abbey'' was Creator/JaneAusten's first completed novel, which she wrote as "Susan"; it developed farther the satiric vein found in her juvenilia, such as ''Literature/LoveAndFreindship''. However, circumstances prevented the novel from being published until ''after her death'' in 1817.

to:

The definitive [[GothicHorror Gothic]] parody, ''Northanger Abbey'' was Creator/JaneAusten's first completed novel, which she wrote as "Susan"; it developed farther the satiric vein found in her juvenilia, such as ''Literature/LoveAndFreindship''. However, circumstances prevented the novel from being published until ''after after her death'' death in 1817.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AluminumChristmasTrees: After the 2007 adaptation was broadcast, a letter to the ''RadioTimes'' complained that the scriptwriter had added a jarring reference to baseball. That passage came word for word from the book. In fact, the OED records it as the first mention of baseball (by that name) in literature.

to:

* AluminumChristmasTrees: After the 2007 adaptation was broadcast, a letter to the ''RadioTimes'' ''Magazine/RadioTimes'' complained that the scriptwriter had added a jarring reference to baseball. That passage came word for word from the book. In fact, the OED records it as the first mention of baseball (by that name) in literature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Countering the AdaptationOverdosed tendency of Austen's other works, this has to be the least adapted of all her works. It was twice adapted into {{Made for TV Movie}}s, once by Creator/TheBBC in 1986 and once by {{ITV}} in 2007. The Creator/{{PBS}} series ''Series/{{Wishbone}}'' also used it as the basis of an episode, with the eponymous dog in the role of Henry. Marvel Illustrated released a ComicBookAdaptation starting November 2011, script by Nancy Butler, pencils and inks by Janet Lee, and covers by Julian Totino Tedesco. It was also the second book given a modern day SettingUpdate by The Austen Project, written by [[WireInTheBlood Val McDermid]].

to:

Countering the AdaptationOverdosed tendency of Austen's other works, this has to be the least adapted of all her works. It was twice adapted into {{Made for TV Movie}}s, once by Creator/TheBBC in 1986 and once by {{ITV}} in 2007. The Creator/{{PBS}} series ''Series/{{Wishbone}}'' also used it as the basis of an episode, with the eponymous dog in the role of Henry. Marvel Illustrated released a ComicBookAdaptation starting November 2011, script by Nancy Butler, pencils and inks by Janet Lee, and covers by Julian Totino Tedesco. It was also the second book given a modern day SettingUpdate by The Austen Project, written by [[WireInTheBlood [[Series/WireInTheBlood Val McDermid]].

Top