Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / WelcomeToNightVale

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


** And it's been established that astral pojection exists in Nightvale (and that teachers are banned from using it to teach classes), so that's another possibility

to:

** And it's been established that astral pojection projection exists in Nightvale (and that teachers are banned from using it to teach classes), so that's another possibility
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**And it's been established that astral pojection exists in Nightvale (and that teachers are banned from using it to teach classes), so that's another possibility

Added: 34

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do people refer to Kevin as Cecil's double? Cecil's double would be indistinguishable from Cecil, like how nobody knows if Dana is the original Dana or her double (including Dana herself). Kevin is Cecil's counterpart or maybe doppelganger, like Grandma Josephine for Old Woman Josie or Mayor Pablo Mitchell for Mayor Pamela Winchell.

to:

* Why do people refer to Kevin as Cecil's double? Cecil's double would be indistinguishable from Cecil, like how nobody knows if Dana is the original Dana or her double (including Dana herself). Kevin is Cecil's counterpart or maybe doppelganger, like Grandma Josephine for Old Woman Josie or Mayor Pablo Mitchell for Mayor Pamela Winchell. Winchell.
*In what sense *is* it a dog park?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She is one entity, but bears the living-in relation to many homes. What's the problem?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Why do people refer to Kevin as Cecil's double? Cecil's double would be indistinguishable from Cecil, like how nobody knows if Dana is the original Dana or her double (including Dana herself). Kevin is Cecil's counterpart or maybe doppelganger, like Grandma Josephine for Old Woman Josie or Mayor Pablo Mitchell for Mayor Pamela Winchell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In 49/Old Oak Doors Part B, Steve refered to Cecil as his step-brother. If Cecil moved in with the Carlsbergs after 33/Cassette or Mr. Palmer married one of Steve's parents, then Cecil wouldn't have to be related to Janice to be her uncle as his (step-)brother is her (step-) father. If Cecil thought Steve was neglectful, then he might step in to be Janice's cool uncle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Also depends on whether "doing tests on the trees" was actually code for "Hey let's go make out against this tree" or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Given that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] is in charge of Desert Bluffs, and the place is ''downright terrifying'' by its description seen here in the transcript of Episode 19 B - "Sandstorm" http://cecilspeaks.tumblr.com/post/59578106876/episode-19b-the-sandstorm-desert-bluffs It may very well be Cecil's clairvoyance telling him that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] has sinister plans for Night Vale. And while Night Vale may not exactly be a utopia, it wouldn't be hard to imagine the awful things that would happen ''if'' [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] got their full control of the town. [[spoiler: Kevin's studio is pure NightmareFuel.]]

to:

** Given that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] is in charge of Desert Bluffs, and the place is ''downright terrifying'' by its description seen here in the transcript of Episode 19 B - "Sandstorm" http://cecilspeaks.[[http://cecilspeaks.tumblr.com/post/59578106876/episode-19b-the-sandstorm-desert-bluffs here]] in the transcript of Episode 19 B - "Sandstorm" It may very well be Cecil's clairvoyance telling him that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] has sinister plans for Night Vale. And while Night Vale may not exactly be a utopia, it wouldn't be hard to imagine the awful things that would happen ''if'' [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] got their full control of the town. [[spoiler: Kevin's studio is pure NightmareFuel.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*So Night Vale is in the desert but the number's station is WZZZ [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Call_signs_in_North_America#K_and_W denoting a station east of the Mississippi.]] Is WZZZ one of the stations that got a name before modern radio callsigns? Is there a desert east of the Mississippi? Is the license holder for the station east of the Missippi? Were the East Coast writers of the show lazy about radio callsigns?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It could be that Cecil's brother is Janice's father, and Janice's mother is no blood relation to Cecil. Janice's father died, or her parents divorced, and her mother remarried, to Steve Carlsburg. Making him Janice's (neglectful) stepfather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This is half-headscratcher and half-suspicion that it's intentional, but in the latest episode (44/Cookies) Cecil reveals that his hatred of Steve Carlsburg is at least somewhat related to the fact that he's the stepdad to Cecil's niece. Given the mention of said niece's mother, this would mean Cecil has a sister. However, in previous episode 33/Cassette, the young Cecil Gershwin Palmer makes mention of his mother and brother... but no sister. Where did she come from? Given Night Vale, it's unlikely that this is a mistake, and it probably means something. But that's for WMG, I suppose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I wrote \'house\' instead of \'home\': her name is the Faceless Old Woman Who Secretly Lives In Your Home


* Is there one Faceless Old Woman Who Secretly Lives In Your House who lives in all of our houses, or are there multiple distinct Faceless Old Women, or is each Faceless Old Woman each a facet of one, singular, Faceless Old Woman?

to:

* Is there one Faceless Old Woman Who Secretly Lives In Your House Home who lives in all of our houses, homes, or are there multiple distinct Faceless Old Women, or is each Faceless Old Woman each a facet of one, singular, Faceless Old Woman?



*** She could also live in only one house but no one knows which one. Alternatively she lives in Cecil's house and he is in denial about being her only target.

to:

*** She could also live in only one house home but no one knows which one. Alternatively she lives in Cecil's house home and he is in denial about being her only target.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** She could also live in only one house but no one knows which one. Alternatively she lives in Cecil's house and he is in denial about being her only target.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[MathematiciansAnswer Yes]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Is there one Faceless Old Woman Who Secretly Lives In Your House who lives in all of our houses, or are there multiple distinct Faceless Old Women, or is each Faceless Old Woman each a facet of one, singular, Faceless Old Woman?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It really depends on what kind of "tests" he did. There are plenty of tests he could know how to do without specializing in studying plants- especially if he's had a lot of education. We also don't know how the trees looked or what about them made Carlos want to experiment on them in the first place, so he could really be doing anything to them. Maybe he scraped a bit off to see if it was a different color underneath if the tree was a strange color or something; we don't have enough information to know what tests he did. That said, Carlos is described as being preoccupied with science, and also of a somewhat nervous disposition. It's a definite possibility that he was both showing off for Cecil and trying to do something with himself out of fear of seeming awkward.

Added: 605

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] is in charge of Desert Bluffs, and the place is ''downright terrifying'' by its description seen here in the transcript of Episode 19 B - "Sandstorm" http://cecilspeaks.tumblr.com/post/59578106876/episode-19b-the-sandstorm-desert-bluffs It may very well be Cecil's clairvoyance telling him that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] has sinister plans for Night Vale. And while Night Vale may not exactly be a utopia, it wouldn't be hard to imagine the awful things that would happen ''if'' [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] got their full control of the town. [[spoiler: Kevin's studio is pure NightmareFuel.]]

to:

* ** Given that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] is in charge of Desert Bluffs, and the place is ''downright terrifying'' by its description seen here in the transcript of Episode 19 B - "Sandstorm" http://cecilspeaks.tumblr.com/post/59578106876/episode-19b-the-sandstorm-desert-bluffs It may very well be Cecil's clairvoyance telling him that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] has sinister plans for Night Vale. And while Night Vale may not exactly be a utopia, it wouldn't be hard to imagine the awful things that would happen ''if'' [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] got their full control of the town. [[spoiler: Kevin's studio is pure NightmareFuel.]]]]
** Well, when Cecil visits Desert Bluffs he's clearly horrified by what he finds, so blood and viscera everywhere must not be normal for Night Vale. As long as he can put two and two together and come up with Desert Bluffs, he'd probably be able to guess that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] is ''not'' something you want in charge of your life. Especially since it seems to be a lot more personally involved in people's lives than the council and a lot more involved in pushing everyone to work until they drop. I get the sense there's no personal freedom at all in Desert Bluffs, even less so than in Night Vale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In Episode 38, Carlos says, "[D]o know that I don’t specialize in botany or dendrology. I am a scientist. I study science, not plants or nature." Yet in Episode 27, Carlos does some tests on the trees to see if they're "normal". If he doesn't specialize in dendrology, how did he know how to perform tests on the trees? Was he just showing off for Cecil's benefit?

Changed: 351

Removed: 348

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] is in charge of Desert Bluffs, and the place is ''downright terrifying'' by its description seen here in the transcript of Episode 19 B - "Sandstorm" http://cecilspeaks.tumblr.com/post/59578106876/episode-19b-the-sandstorm-desert-bluffs
It may very well be Cecil's clairvoyance telling him that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] has sinister plans for Night Vale. And while Night Vale may not exactly be a utopia, it wouldn't be hard to imagine the awful things that would happen ''if'' [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] got their full control of the town. [[spoiler: Kevin's studio is pure NightmareFuel.]]

to:

* Given that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] is in charge of Desert Bluffs, and the place is ''downright terrifying'' by its description seen here in the transcript of Episode 19 B - "Sandstorm" http://cecilspeaks.tumblr.com/post/59578106876/episode-19b-the-sandstorm-desert-bluffs
com/post/59578106876/episode-19b-the-sandstorm-desert-bluffs It may very well be Cecil's clairvoyance telling him that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] has sinister plans for Night Vale. Vale. And while Night Vale may not exactly be a utopia, it wouldn't be hard to imagine the awful things that would happen ''if'' [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] got their full control of the town. town. [[spoiler: Kevin's studio is pure NightmareFuel.]]

Added: 350

Changed: 272

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Given that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] is in charge of Desert Bluffs, and the place is ''downright terrifying'' by its description seen here in the transcript of Episode 19 B - "Sandstorm" http://cecilspeaks.tumblr.com/post/59578106876/episode-19b-the-sandstorm-desert-bluffs
It may very well be Cecil's clairvoyance telling him that [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] has sinister plans for Night Vale. And while Night Vale may not exactly be a utopia, it wouldn't be hard to imagine the awful things that would happen ''if'' [[spoiler: Strexcorp]] got their full control of the town. [[spoiler: Kevin's studio is pure NightmareFuel.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is it that Cecil never [[spoiler:encouraged rebellion against]] the city council, but he's now doing so [[spoiler:against Strexcorp]]? Yes, [[spoiler:Strexcorp]] is now [[spoiler:likely planning something awful for a bunch of children]], but is there any reason to think it's worse than anything the city council or sheriff's secret police have done? After all, the council and mayor apparently allowed [[spoiler:the local boy scout organization and those mysterious children to turn scouts to preserve scouts and put them in a glass case after they became eternal scouts]].

to:

* Why is it that Cecil never [[spoiler:encouraged rebellion against]] the city council, but he's now doing so [[spoiler:against Strexcorp]]? Yes, [[spoiler:Strexcorp]] is now [[spoiler:likely planning something awful for a bunch of children]], but is there any reason to think it's worse than anything the city council or sheriff's secret police have done? After all, the council and mayor apparently allowed [[spoiler:the local boy scout organization and those mysterious children to turn scouts to preserve scouts and put them in a glass case after they became eternal scouts]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Why is it that Cecil never [[spoiler:encouraged rebellion against]] the city council, but he's now doing so [[spoiler:against Strexcorp]]? Yes, [[spoiler:Strexcorp]] is now [[spoiler:likely planning something awful for a bunch of children]], but is there any reason to think it's worse than anything the city council or sheriff's secret police have done? After all, the council and mayor apparently allowed [[spoiler:the local boy scout organization and those mysterious children to turn scouts to preserve scouts and put them in a glass case after they became eternal scouts]].

Added: 520

Changed: 1141

Removed: 952

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


::Cecil's wording clearly implies that Kevin's eyes are different from his own. However, Kevin states that Cecil's eyes are the same as his. So which is it? Is one of them lying? If so, why?
** There are a few possibilities here. Cecil's eyes might be "black as obsidian" like Kevin's, and Cecil is just unaware of this for some reason- or, Cecil's eyes might be similar in some way(s) to Kevin's eyes EXCEPT for their color. For example, some fans have the headcanon that Cecil's eyes are just white, without a visible iris or pupil. If Kevin's eyes are completely black without a visible iris or pupil, then Cecil would be correct in saying that his eyes are different, and Kevin would be technically correct if what he's saying is that they have the same TYPE of eyes.

to:

Although Kevin is described as Cecil's double, there are definitely notable differences between the two. Indeed, they seem to be more like mirror opposites to each other. The other doubles in Night Vale are so identical, in voice, appearance, and (apparently) personality, that Cecil literally can not tell who survived between intern Dana (who he knew very well) and her double. But Cecil and Kevin are completely opposite in personality, ideologies, political leanings, as well as the pitch of their voices.

::Cecil's wording clearly implies that Kevin's eyes are different from his own. However, Kevin states that Cecil's eyes are the same as like his. So which is it? Is one of "Like" could imply them lying? If so, why?
being similar but different.
** There are a few possibilities here. Cecil's eyes might be "black as obsidian" like Kevin's, and Cecil is just unaware of this for some reason- or, Cecil's eyes might be similar in some way(s) to Kevin's eyes EXCEPT for their color. For example, some fans have the headcanon that Cecil's eyes are just white, without a visible iris or pupil. If Kevin's eyes are completely black without a visible iris or pupil, then Cecil would be correct in saying that his eyes are different, and Kevin would be technically correct if what he's saying is that they have the same TYPE of eyes.



** It's possible that in Night Vale, the people of the town already know what Cecil look like. To them, he doesn't need to explain anything-- the out-of-universe reason is to preserve the loose descriptions in radio plays, so every listener can have their own Cecil.
** Over at the WMG, there's a theory that – because people don't keep pictures of themselves on their own desks – the picture on Cecil's desk was a picture of Carlos, and the picture on Kevin's desk was of Kevin's love interest, some kind of DesertBluffs!Carlos. This would mean Cecil looks like DesertBluffs!Carlos, except for the eyes and smile, and Kevin looks like Carlos, except for the smile. And Cecil didn't meet Kevin in the portal, he met DesertBluffs!Carlos, while Kevin met Cecil's Carlos.
*** Or, if Cecil never went so far as to take and put a picture of Carlos on his desk before the events of "One Year Later", maybe it's a picture of someone else entirely - but ''who?'' Earl Harlan? A family member?

to:

** It's possible that in Night Vale, the people of the town already know what Cecil look like. To them, he doesn't need to explain anything-- the out-of-universe reason is to preserve the loose descriptions in radio plays, so every listener can have their own Cecil.
** Over at the WMG, there's a theory that – because people don't keep pictures of themselves on their own desks – the picture on Cecil's desk was a picture of Carlos, and the picture on Kevin's desk was of Kevin's love interest, some kind of DesertBluffs!Carlos. This would mean Cecil looks like DesertBluffs!Carlos, except for the eyes and smile, and Kevin looks like Carlos, except for the smile. And Cecil didn't meet Kevin in the portal, he met DesertBluffs!Carlos, while Kevin met Cecil's Carlos.
*** Or, if Cecil never went so far as to take and put a picture of Carlos on his desk before the events of "One Year Later", maybe it's a picture of someone else entirely - but ''who?'' Earl Harlan? A family member?
plays.



*** Cecil also mentions getting faxes and phone calls from listeners on various occurrences in town.



*** There's been strong evidence in the "technical difficulties" section in the episode that happens after the "station managers" episode that may have been...either replaced, or that he's been changed from his initial form in some way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What's up with that inn in Switz where Cecil and his travelling partner keep rolling out of all night long? Wouldn't they, at some point, come up with the idea of closing the door or just sleeping at right angles to the slope instead of parallel to it?

to:

* What's up with that inn in Switz where Cecil and his travelling partner the man he was traveling with keep rolling out of all night long? Wouldn't they, at some point, come up with the idea of closing the door or just sleeping at right angles to the slope instead of parallel to it?



** Maybe they were actually having adventurous sex sessions both in the inn and outside, and "rolling" is just a euphemism. He says he didn't know this partner or remember where he met him, so maybe the partner was a prostitute or one-night-stand he picked up while drunk. This theory has some weight to it, as every time sex has come up, it's only been hinted at, or a euphemism was used (like when Cecil wanted to "look at Carlos' medical equipment", or in the SF Booksmith show, when Cecil [[spoiler: says there was "something more" with Carlos, but proceeds to cut himself off]]).
** Maybe they were just enjoying it. He mentions that they were laughing. Rolling down hills is fun and everything, especially with someone you ambiguously seem to ''like''-like. Or maybe there was some kind of {{Bizarrchitecture}} thing going on where you'd end up rolling downhill no matter what. Or since it may have been a hallucination, maybe they were just weirdly confused and incompetent the way people sometimes are in dreams.

to:

** Maybe It's possible they were actually having adventurous sex sessions both in the inn and outside, and "rolling" is just a euphemism. He says he didn't know this partner or remember where he met him, so maybe the partner man was a prostitute or one-night-stand he picked up while drunk. This theory has some weight to it, as every time sex has come up, it's only been hinted at, or a euphemism was used (like when Cecil wanted to "look at Carlos' medical equipment", 'beakers' and 'buzzing electrical equipment'", or in the SF Booksmith show, when Cecil [[spoiler: says there was "something more" with Carlos, but proceeds to cut himself off]]).
** Maybe Or maybe they were just enjoying it.rolling down the hill literally. He mentions that they were laughing. Rolling down hills is fun and everything, especially with someone you ambiguously seem to ''like''-like. Or maybe there was some kind of {{Bizarrchitecture}} thing going on where you'd end up rolling downhill no matter what. Or since it may have been a hallucination, maybe they were just weirdly confused and incompetent the way people sometimes are in dreams.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Now that we know that Cecil [[spoiler: apparently cannot be around mirrors that are no covered]], it seems likely that the reason he keeps a picture of himself is to remind himself of his own appearance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maybe they were actually having adventurous sex sessions both in the inn and outside, and "rolling" is just a euphemism. He says he didn't know this partner or remember where he met him, so maybe the partner was a prostitute or one-night-stand he picked up while drunk.

to:

** Maybe they were actually having adventurous sex sessions both in the inn and outside, and "rolling" is just a euphemism. He says he didn't know this partner or remember where he met him, so maybe the partner was a prostitute or one-night-stand he picked up while drunk. This theory has some weight to it, as every time sex has come up, it's only been hinted at, or a euphemism was used (like when Cecil wanted to "look at Carlos' medical equipment", or in the SF Booksmith show, when Cecil [[spoiler: says there was "something more" with Carlos, but proceeds to cut himself off]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** This theory has support from Cecil Baldwin himself, who mentioned it at the 2013 LA Podcast Festival.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One fanon interpretation is that Cecil is the personification of Night Vale and so he knows all the things that are happening and tells them as he sees them. Any government corrections are mentioned as a sort of overwriting the town memory of the event.

to:

** One fanon interpretation is that Cecil is the personification of Night Vale and so he knows all the things that are happening and tells them as he sees them. Any government corrections are mentioned as a sort of overwriting the town memory of the event.event.

------
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In Episode 15, Cecil mentions getting updates from an intern through his headset. Maybe interns attend various meetings and events and update Cecil via mundane tech so he can report it in a timely fashion. After all, he does have Dana's number and she continues to report to him from the dog park, possibly out of habit. Though it doesn't explain how he was able to spend so much time at the Arby's parking lot...

Top