Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Taken

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** That one guy at the auction actually explains it quite well "In this business, you have no refunds, no returns, no discounts, no buybacks. All sales are final." They are not kidnapping for ransoms, but to provide a product and fulfill purchase orders. And I guess the types making those purchase orders would not appreciate if the product was sold elsewhere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Except, you know, that he proceeds to do ''exactly that''. He doesn't get all the customers, but he kills the Albanian suppliers and the ringleader (and most of {{Mooks}}, too).

to:

*** Except, you know, that he proceeds to do ''exactly that''. He doesn't get all the customers, sellers, customers and whatever other personnel might be involved, but he kills the Albanian suppliers and the their ringleader (and most of many vital {{Mooks}}, too).

Added: 106

Changed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stripping spoilers.


!Per wiki policy, Headscratchers pages are Administrivia/SpoilersOff. Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned!
----



*** To be fair, there's that one scene where he takes one girl from a brothel in ([[spoiler:she had a jacket that her daughter was wearing the last time he saw her]]), and you could tell just by the look on his face as he was cleaning out the drugs from her system that he felt bad for her. I mean, it's not like he doesn't care about other girls being sold on the market, but the important thing was '[[PapaWolf My baby's missing, and I'm kicking ass just to get her back]]'.

to:

*** To be fair, there's that one scene where he takes one girl from a brothel in ([[spoiler:she (she had a jacket that her daughter was wearing the last time he saw her]]), her), and you could tell just by the look on his face as he was cleaning out the drugs from her system that he felt bad for her. I mean, it's not like he doesn't care about other girls being sold on the market, but the important thing was '[[PapaWolf My baby's missing, and I'm kicking ass just to get her back]]'.



* The villains switch from [[spoiler:smuggling in and enslaving illegal immigrants]] to [[spoiler:kidnapping several rich white foreigners PER DAY]], and from [[spoiler:luring their targets to abandoned buildings]] to [[spoiler:nabbing them out of their rooms WHILE THEY ARE ON THE PHONE]].
** In regards to [[spoiler:switching over to rich white foreigners]], this troper's International Perspectives on Women professor (who saw this movie on this troper's recommendation while we were covering sex-trafficking in class) claimed that this [[RealityIsUnrealistic made sense]] because [[spoiler:said foreigners are going to have a much healthier pedigree than poorer European women and fetch a higher price from wealthier clients]].

to:

* The villains switch from [[spoiler:smuggling smuggling in and enslaving illegal immigrants]] immigrants to [[spoiler:kidnapping kidnapping several rich white foreigners PER DAY]], DAY, and from [[spoiler:luring luring their targets to abandoned buildings]] buildings to [[spoiler:nabbing nabbing them out of their rooms WHILE THEY ARE ON THE PHONE]].
PHONE.
** In regards to [[spoiler:switching switching over to rich white foreigners]], foreigners, this troper's International Perspectives on Women professor (who saw this movie on this troper's recommendation while we were covering sex-trafficking in class) claimed that this [[RealityIsUnrealistic made sense]] because [[spoiler:said said foreigners are going to have a much healthier pedigree than poorer European women and fetch a higher price from wealthier clients]].clients.



*** No it wasn't, [[spoiler:remember how the auctioneer referred to her? "As usual, we've saved the best for last"]], and she was clearly doped up.

to:

*** No it wasn't, [[spoiler:remember remember how the auctioneer referred to her? "As usual, we've saved the best for last"]], last", and she was clearly doped up.



*** Because after he invited them to the Party, they proceed to tell him they are alone, and where they live inside the building. We need a translator, but I guess he then told his peeps: "Hey, let´s just grab em right there, nobody will know." or does so off screen. It could also just have been a thing to keep the "friendly" facade...

to:

*** Because after he invited them to the Party, they proceed to tell him they are alone, and where they live inside the building. We need a translator, but I guess he then told his peeps: "Hey, let´s just grab em right there, nobody will know." or does so off screen. It could also just have been a thing to keep the "friendly" facade...



* Nothing is ever done to show if [[spoiler:Amanda's family was ever notified of their daughter's murder by overdose, or what actions they took if they were.]]

to:

* Nothing is ever done to show if [[spoiler:Amanda's Amanda's family was ever notified of their daughter's murder by overdose, or what actions they took if they were.]]



* It's never really made clear [[spoiler:how long it took Bryan and Kim to get back to America, considering Bryan's all bandaged up and would have possibly needed to chat with the French authorities about that long list of murder victims he's tallied up.]]
** The implication is that [[spoiler:the entire French legal system in this regard is corrupt. In that scenario it makes more sense for the French to let Bryan leave quietly and quickly, since if he was brought up on charges the whole story had a good chance of coming out, not to mention the diplomatic implications for the US and France at large given Bryan's former occupation.]]
** I'd like to know how they even got off the ''boat!'' Presumably it had a crew separate from all the mooks. [[spoiler:Did Bryan kill them too, or were they OK with just dropping Bryan and Kim off after he'd explained why he'd just murdered their employer and all his bodyguards?]]
** [[spoiler:The crew can maybe bar brawl but do you want to fight with a man who just single handedly murdered almost everyone on board? Lifeboats are also a possibility, they weren't that far from shore if I remember it right.]]
* Nor have there been any mention of [[spoiler:Jean-Claude. Was he arrested or kicked out of the department for his connections to the traffickers? What did his wife think of her husband now that she knew of his connections?]]
*** [[spoiler:Jean-Claude]] never had any connections to the traffickers; he was aware that his boss was involved, but was only too happy to look the other way.

to:

* It's never really made clear [[spoiler:how how long it took Bryan and Kim to get back to America, considering Bryan's all bandaged up and would have possibly needed to chat with the French authorities about that long list of murder victims he's tallied up.]]
up.
** The implication is that [[spoiler:the the entire French legal system in this regard is corrupt. In that scenario it makes more sense for the French to let Bryan leave quietly and quickly, since if he was brought up on charges the whole story had a good chance of coming out, not to mention the diplomatic implications for the US and France at large given Bryan's former occupation.]]
occupation.
** I'd like to know how they even got off the ''boat!'' Presumably it had a crew separate from all the mooks. [[spoiler:Did Did Bryan kill them too, or were they OK with just dropping Bryan and Kim off after he'd explained why he'd just murdered their employer and all his bodyguards?]]
bodyguards?
** [[spoiler:The The crew can maybe bar brawl but do you want to fight with a man who just single handedly murdered almost everyone on board? Lifeboats are also a possibility, they weren't that far from shore if I remember it right.]]
right.
* Nor have there been any mention of [[spoiler:Jean-Claude. Jean-Claude. Was he arrested or kicked out of the department for his connections to the traffickers? What did his wife think of her husband now that she knew of his connections?]]
connections?
*** [[spoiler:Jean-Claude]] Jean-Claude never had any connections to the traffickers; he was aware that his boss was involved, but was only too happy to look the other way.



** Probably [[spoiler:Jean-Claude greased the wheels to get it all covered up. And the wife doesn't really get the ''whole'' story from Bryan, he probably talked his way out of it.]]

to:

** Probably [[spoiler:Jean-Claude Jean-Claude greased the wheels to get it all covered up. And the wife doesn't really get the ''whole'' story from Bryan, he probably talked his way out of it.]]



*** He aborted a mission once just to visit his daughter...he got reassigned to Alaska for that. It´s not like he didn´t want to, it's more like that he would see her LESS if he tried to see her more.

to:

*** He aborted a mission once just to visit his daughter...he got reassigned to Alaska for that. It´s not like he didn´t want to, it's more like that he would see her LESS if he tried to see her more.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Is that nifty miniature phone device Mills uses in the second film a real product? Even if, say, only accessible to spy agencies?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** He appears in the sequel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** read about [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Amy_Lynn_Bradley Amy Lynn Bradley. she disappeared from a freaking cruise ship and was seen over the years by various people who she begged for help, but nobody did on time and she eventually disappeared completely. that's the most depressing story I ever heard

to:

** read about [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Amy_Lynn_Bradley Amy Lynn Bradley.Bradley]]. she disappeared from a freaking cruise ship and was seen over the years by various people who she begged for help, but nobody did on time and she eventually disappeared completely. that's the most depressing story I ever heard
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** read about [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Amy_Lynn_Bradley Amy Lynn Bradley. she disappeared from a freaking cruise ship and was seen over the years by various people who she begged for help, but nobody did on time and she eventually disappeared completely. that's the most depressing story I ever heard
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In a way Brian did save other victims, when he found Marko there were quite a few women around the building, odds are the police found them along with the dead gangsters. Not to mention those men on the boat weren't a bunch of street thugs, they were Albanian Mob bosses. So techincally speaking, Brian crippled their operation by going after his daughter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Brian was laser-focused on saving Kim. He already knew that Amanda had been taken, and didn't even try to negotiate for her on the phone.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since English is not the Albanians' natural language, it's possible they can't tell a French accented Anglophone from an "Irish" accented one. Brian's accent isn't very Irish certainly on the American side of Irish. Many Europeans who are very fluent in English have accents that tend towards either American or English depending on who they learned from.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There is nothing in that phrasing that implies any of that at all. "Specific" does not mean obscure or trivial. You are ''inferring'' that and drawing a meaning from the line that was never intended and is not at all implied by the line itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* "Very specific set of skills" implies that the person has an obscure and trivial ability that would almost never come in handy, like the ability to list all of the Byzantine emperors in order or craft authentic 14th century Inca baskets or identify any [=ZZ=] Top song from one line of lyrics. Bryan's combat, stealth, interrogation, investigation, and killing skillset is, in fact, quite broad and not at all specific. Why does he say this?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** English is a lingua franca in Europe. Which in itself is very ironic since French used to be the lingua franca -- it's even in the name. But many, many Europeans will choose English as one of their second languages almost automatically, especially in proximity to the British Isles (the whole U.K. sea border: Denmark 85%, Netherlands 90%, Germany 70%, France 40%). It's probably more unusual for the Albanians to understand English than to understand French, true, and almost as unexpected for Bryan as "Jean-Claude" to be speaking English from the very moment he walked in, but they deal with enough "rich clientele" and with enough tourists that they probably had to pick it up just to function, and it was evidently the correct guess anyway -- that they knew English and not French.


Added DiffLines:

*** Given how loud the stereo was, the residents downstairs would probably be more likely to roll their eyes and call the police about a noise complaint than they would be to call in a kidnapping in progress, assuming they could hear her screaming at all or assume it was anything other than a pair of "ditzy American brats". (French opinions of the U.S. are often more unkind than vice versa, and the vice versa is already quite unkind. ;-)) Given that Mills finds no evidence of police investigation, the general apathy of the population is almost certainly at work here. Modern police often have to canvass the whole neighbourhood to get people to come forward with any details ''when there's a shooting just outside their homes''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
bloody hell, That Other Wiki is poisoning me


** All of this is sort of moot on the basis that the auctioneer was astounded at the $500,000 sum, and [[TheDragon]] acting on behalf of the Sheikh didn't want to pay that much either -- it was Bryan who reached over and thumbed the button. In fact, reading probably a little too far into it, the Sheikh would have been ''pissed'' if he had overpaid for a sex slave, and so wanted to have her immediately to verify whether she was worth it... and/or whether the Dragon's head would roll, since there's no way he would have kept it had he spent that much of the Sheikh's money without telling his boss what happened.

to:

** All of this is sort of moot on the basis that the auctioneer was astounded at the $500,000 sum, and [[TheDragon]] TheDragon acting on behalf of the Sheikh didn't want to pay that much either -- it was Bryan who reached over and thumbed the button. In fact, reading probably a little too far into it, the Sheikh would have been ''pissed'' if he had overpaid for a sex slave, and so wanted to have her immediately to verify whether she was worth it... and/or whether the Dragon's head would roll, since there's no way he would have kept it had he spent that much of the Sheikh's money without telling his boss what happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** All of this is sort of moot on the basis that the auctioneer was astounded at the $500,000 sum, and the [[Dragon]] acting on behalf of the Sheikh didn't want to pay that much either -- it was Bryan who reached over and thumbed the button. In fact, reading probably a little too far into it, the Sheikh would have been ''pissed'' if he had overpaid for a sex slave, and so wanted to have her immediately to verify whether she was worth it... and/or whether the Dragon's head would roll, since there's no way he would have kept it had he spent that much of the Sheikh's money without telling his boss what happened.

to:

** All of this is sort of moot on the basis that the auctioneer was astounded at the $500,000 sum, and the [[Dragon]] [[TheDragon]] acting on behalf of the Sheikh didn't want to pay that much either -- it was Bryan who reached over and thumbed the button. In fact, reading probably a little too far into it, the Sheikh would have been ''pissed'' if he had overpaid for a sex slave, and so wanted to have her immediately to verify whether she was worth it... and/or whether the Dragon's head would roll, since there's no way he would have kept it had he spent that much of the Sheikh's money without telling his boss what happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** All of this is sort of moot on the basis that the auctioneer was astounded at the $500,000 sum, and the [[Dragon]] acting on behalf of the Sheikh didn't want to pay that much either -- it was Bryan who reached over and thumbed the button. In fact, reading probably a little too far into it, the Sheikh would have been ''pissed'' if he had overpaid for a sex slave, and so wanted to have her immediately to verify whether she was worth it... and/or whether the Dragon's head would roll, since there's no way he would have kept it had he spent that much of the Sheikh's money without telling his boss what happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The guy who taught Batman to batman.


Added DiffLines:

** Natalee Holloway, anyone?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Or he might be Franco-American, with a French father and American mother, hence the American English.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** What are you talking about? Is this supposed to be responding to a different question?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** If it bothers viewers enough to suspend their disbelief, then yes, it does matter. And they ''didn't'' tie up the loose end, because they didn't bother adding in even a two-second line of dialogue to clarify if her parents were notified or not.

Top