Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Supergirl2015

Go To

OR

Added: 161

Changed: 133

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Never mind, apparently he does.


** As it turns out, Batman actually does not have Kryptonite in this universe.

to:

** As it Later turns out, out Batman actually does not have Kryptonite in this universe.Kryptonite, but we don't know if Clark gave it to him or if he manufactured/stole some himself.



** Seeing as Clark and Lex used to be friends, it's entirely possible that Clark did the ObfuscatingStupidity/TheKlutz act so well Lex could never believe that his Clark is a Kryptonian superhero. He doesn't have any preconceived notions of Kara Danvers, though, so it's easier for him to believe she's Supergirl.

to:

** Seeing as Clark and Lex used to be friends, it's entirely possible that Clark did the ObfuscatingStupidity/TheKlutz ObfuscatingStupidity act so well Lex could never believe that his Clark is a Kryptonian superhero. He doesn't have any preconceived notions of Kara Danvers, though, so it's easier for him to believe she's Supergirl.
*** This is supported by ''Superman and Lois,'' where Lana--Clark's ''ex-girlfriend''--doesn't recognize Superman as Clark even at close range in broad daylight.



** Apparently, it still went on working for a while, then Rama Khan destroyed it, and then J'onn and Alex reform it.

to:

** Apparently, it still went on working for a while, then Rama Khan destroyed it, and then J'onn and Alex reform it.it at the end of the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As it turns out, Batman actually does not have Kryptonite in this universe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well, given all of his powers and experience, we can presume he's probably pretty good at it. Also, it's possible Kara helps support Alex--they share an apartment, after all, and it's doubtful Kara makes her sister pay rent. As for building and maintaining the super-attic, it's possible he "acquired" some DEO tech before he left.

to:

** Well, given all of his powers and experience, we can presume he's probably pretty good at it.it, and having spent over two centuries on Earth, it's safe to assume he has a fair bit of cash stowed away. Also, it's possible Kara helps support Alex--they share an apartment, after all, and it's doubtful Kara makes her sister pay rent. It's unclear whether Brainy is living with Nia; if he is, again, she won't be charging him rent (and Brainy could always hack an ATM if he wanted to). As for building and maintaining the super-attic, it's possible he J'onn "acquired" some DEO tech before he left.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** But why use a contingency if you don't have to? Mind-controlled Alex with a Kryptonite sword is both highly likely to kill Kara and not much threat to Non and his troops. Mind-controlled Kal may be able to kill her, may not, and if he gets free, he's much more of a threat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did Lord plant a camera on Alex in "Childish Things?" [[spoiler: Sure, he gets Supergirl's identity out of the deal]], but there's no way he could have predicted that. He only knows that Supergirl is an ally to the DEO, not that she has any personal relationship to one of their agents. And suppose that Alex went home and immediately put her bag in a closet instead of tossing them aside and sitting down to chat with the sister Lord didn't know existed prior to this moment? My point here is, there are a lot of things Lord didn't account for in this "plan" of his, which seems uncharacteristic of him.

to:

* Why did Lord plant a camera on Alex in "Childish Things?" [[spoiler: Sure, he gets Supergirl's identity out of the deal]], but there's no way he could have predicted that. He only knows that Supergirl is an ally to the DEO, not that she has any personal relationship to one of their agents. And suppose that Alex went home and immediately put her bag in a closet instead of tossing them it aside and sitting down to chat with the sister Lord didn't know existed prior to this moment? My point here is, there are a lot of things Lord didn't account for in this "plan" of his, which seems uncharacteristic of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did Lord plant a camera on Alex's shoes in "Childish Things?" [[spoiler: Sure, he gets Supergirl's identity out of the deal]], but there's no way he could have predicted that. He only knows that Supergirl is an ally to the DEO, not that she has any personal relationship to one of their agents. And suppose that Alex went home and immediately put those shoes away in a shoebox and/or closet instead of tossing them aside and sitting down to chat with the sister Lord didn't know existed prior to this moment? My point here is, there are a lot of things Lord didn't account for in this "plan" of his, which seems uncharacteristic of him.

to:

* Why did Lord plant a camera on Alex's shoes Alex in "Childish Things?" [[spoiler: Sure, he gets Supergirl's identity out of the deal]], but there's no way he could have predicted that. He only knows that Supergirl is an ally to the DEO, not that she has any personal relationship to one of their agents. And suppose that Alex went home and immediately put those shoes away her bag in a shoebox and/or closet instead of tossing them aside and sitting down to chat with the sister Lord didn't know existed prior to this moment? My point here is, there are a lot of things Lord didn't account for in this "plan" of his, which seems uncharacteristic of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Apparently, it still went on working for a while, then Rama Khan destroyed it, and then J'onn and Alex reform it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Martians have a lot of powers, however their weakness (fire, and intense heat generally) [[WeaksauceWeakness is incredibly easy to come by]]. While they can trade punches equally with a Kryptonian, heat vision will take them down pretty fast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Presumably, it's a repository of publicly available knowledge (like super huge encyclopedia). It's likely a lot of the Eradicator research was kept private, and so was never collected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Same reason as always--the writers don't like having him around because he's too much of a story-breaker.


Added DiffLines:

** Well, given all of his powers and experience, we can presume he's probably pretty good at it. Also, it's possible Kara helps support Alex--they share an apartment, after all, and it's doubtful Kara makes her sister pay rent. As for building and maintaining the super-attic, it's possible he "acquired" some DEO tech before he left.


Added DiffLines:

**''Superman and Lois'', Diggle cameo aside, has had so many continuity snarls and retcons that it's pretty much its own show.

Added: 1387

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How the hell was Kara contained in that cage in "The Darkest Place" if she still had her powers? Yeah, they say it was indestructible Nth metal, and presumably that applies to the locking mechanism, too, but couldn't Kara just fly through the floor, or fly up and rip the cage out of the floor? And if the cage had six sides and is built into the floor (which doesn't seem to be the case, given how we see it was removed without disrupting the floor at the end of the episode) why not just grab the bars and fly in one directio, and fly out the the building, to the DEO with the cage? Wounldn't be Mon-El's most comfortable flight, but he's nigh invulnerable. And even if she couldn't get out or move, she could still use her heat vision to threaten Rhea and the guards when they came in? And even if Kara won't kill or even torture to save herself and her friend, and Cadmus is certain of this, couldn't she at least stop Rhea from shooting Mon-el? Yeah, plot convienence, but they could just have had them under red-solar lamps or kryptonite, and aside from having to rewrite the introduction of Mon-el's weakness and Kara risking her life for him, little in the plot would change.

to:

* How the hell was Kara contained in that cage in "The Darkest Place" if she still had her powers? Yeah, they say it was indestructible Nth metal, and presumably that applies to the locking mechanism, too, but couldn't Kara just fly through the floor, or fly up and rip the cage out of the floor? And if the cage had six sides and is built into the floor (which doesn't seem to be the case, given how we see it was removed without disrupting the floor at the end of the episode) why not just grab the bars and fly in one directio, and fly out the the building, to the DEO with the cage? Wounldn't be Mon-El's most comfortable flight, but he's nigh invulnerable. And even if she couldn't get out or move, she could still use her heat vision to threaten Rhea and the guards when they came in? And even if Kara won't kill or even torture to save herself and her friend, and Cadmus is certain of this, couldn't she at least stop Rhea from shooting Mon-el? Mon-El? Yeah, plot convienence, but they could just have had them under red-solar lamps or kryptonite, and aside from having to rewrite the introduction of Mon-el's weakness and Kara risking her life for him, little in the plot would change.


Added DiffLines:


[[folder: J'onn J'onz: Private Eye?]]
* Is J'onn still a PI? Once Alex and Brainy leave the DEO and the Superfriends set up shop in J'onn's super advanced attic at the end of Season 5, we rarely get to see the first floor of J'onn's shop again. Presumably this is how he makes his living now? How much is he charging, though, in order to build his super-attic AND pay Alex & Brainy living wages? After all, neither Alex nor Brainy have secondary jobs to help pay the bills like the rest of the group does.
[[/folder]]

[[folder: Running timeline?]]
* Has WordOfGod stated what the timeline is for the 2020/2021 seasons of the Arrowverse shows? I don't think it's ever stated exactly how long Kara was trapped in the Phantom Zone, but soon after escaping she mentions Iris' article about the Mirror Dimension, which means that plotline and the Leviathan/Lex plotline happened more or less at the same time. Does ''Superman & Lois'' take place after this show's Season 6? Is that why Diggle is completely healthy when he left the Flash feeling horrible headaches and vision flashes?
[[/folder]]

[[folder: Bank of all of Krypton's knowledge]]
* Kara's dad says that the computer at the Fortress of Solitude has all the remaining knowledge of Krypton. Why didn't Clark use it to learn about the Eradicator or his evil uncle? Why wasn't Jor-El's crystal hooked up to it or another Kelex?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Pre-Crisis, from what we see and hear, Superman's Rogues gallery likely included but was not limited to Lex Luthor, Reactron, General Zod, Doomsday, Lobo, and Bruno Manhiem. Not very extensive, but each of them are pretty heavy hitters in terms of villainy, so they're probably just the most notable. We also know he met The Legion of Superheroes before Kara, and there's also Darksied and (regular) Braniac that the show hasn't used. Plus, since Superman and Batman appear to have been the only heroes on Supergirl's earth before Supergirl and her allies became active, there are plenty of [[RoguesGalleryTransplant other DC villains this version of Superman has had to tackle.]]

to:

*** Pre-Crisis, from what we see and hear, Superman's Rogues gallery likely included but was not limited to Lex Luthor, Reactron, General Zod, Doomsday, Lobo, and Bruno Manhiem. Not very extensive, but each of them are pretty heavy hitters in terms of villainy, so they're probably just the most notable. We also know he met The Legion of Superheroes Super-Heroes before Kara, and there's also Darksied Darkseid and (regular) Braniac Brainiac that the show hasn't used. Plus, since Superman and Batman appear to have been the only heroes on Supergirl's earth before Supergirl and her allies became active, there are plenty of [[RoguesGalleryTransplant other DC villains this version of Superman has had to tackle.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Henshaw says he didn't let Alex come because it was too dangerous, as proven by Jemm killing the two other agents. This is to build tension before the ShockingSwerve that he's actually ComicBook/MartianManhunter. But how did the other agents' Neural Inhibitors get knocked off? If Henshaw knocked them off himself, he would still have killed them.

to:

* Henshaw says he didn't let Alex come because it was too dangerous, as proven by Jemm killing the two other agents. This is to build tension before the ShockingSwerve TheReveal that he's actually ComicBook/MartianManhunter. But how did the other agents' Neural Inhibitors get knocked off? If Henshaw knocked them off himself, he would still have killed them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's an easy way out, and she performed a similar trick before. Maybe she being unable to come with the plan this time, has something to do with her [[DumbBlonde hair color]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: What's the DEO doing?]]
* So, Alex and Brainy finally leave the DEO, eventually joining J'onn in his own private superhero business alongside Kara. ...What happened to the DEO afterwards? Yes, Lex was in charge before, but it's still a government agency. Are they still going around rounding up alien criminals? Do the remaining staff have any animosity with Alex? Is Lex still in charge?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Where the hell is Clark during Lex's new reign of terror?]]
* With Kara and her friends scrambling to deal with Lex's attempts to control the world and Leviathan's attempts to destroy it, why haven't they asked Clark for help? He can be there in literally a second if they need him, and he'd be more than happy to lend a cape, so why haven't they?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Pre-Crisis, from what we see and hear, Superman's Rogues gallery likely included but was not limited to Lex Luthor, Reactron, General Zod, Doomsday, Lobo, and Bruno Manhiem. Not very extensive, but each of them are pretty heavy hitters in terms of villainy, so they're probably just the most notable. We also know he met The Legion of Superheroes before Kara, and there's also Darksied and (regular) Braniac that the show hasn't used. Plus, since Superman and Batman appear to have been the only heroes on Supergirl's earth before Supergirl and her allies became active, there are plenty of [[RoguesGalleryTransplant other DC villains this version of Superman has had to tackle.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Did Kara really find that cage comfy?]]
* How the hell was Kara contained in that cage in "The Darkest Place" if she still had her powers? Yeah, they say it was indestructible Nth metal, and presumably that applies to the locking mechanism, too, but couldn't Kara just fly through the floor, or fly up and rip the cage out of the floor? And if the cage had six sides and is built into the floor (which doesn't seem to be the case, given how we see it was removed without disrupting the floor at the end of the episode) why not just grab the bars and fly in one directio, and fly out the the building, to the DEO with the cage? Wounldn't be Mon-El's most comfortable flight, but he's nigh invulnerable. And even if she couldn't get out or move, she could still use her heat vision to threaten Rhea and the guards when they came in? And even if Kara won't kill or even torture to save herself and her friend, and Cadmus is certain of this, couldn't she at least stop Rhea from shooting Mon-el? Yeah, plot convienence, but they could just have had them under red-solar lamps or kryptonite, and aside from having to rewrite the introduction of Mon-el's weakness and Kara risking her life for him, little in the plot would change.
[[/folder]]

Added: 314

Changed: 83

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Quite possibly because Jimmy Olsen is probably a lot better known than Steel.



** The episode specifically mentioned Cadmus having altered it not to effect humans, just like Eliza later modified it to only effect the White Martian cells in J'onn.

to:

** The episode specifically mentioned Cadmus having altered it not to effect affect humans, just like Eliza later modified it to only effect the White Martian cells in J'onn.





Added DiffLines:

** Seeing as Clark and Lex used to be friends, it's entirely possible that Clark did the ObfuscatingStupidity/TheKlutz act so well Lex could never believe that his Clark is a Kryptonian superhero. He doesn't have any preconceived notions of Kara Danvers, though, so it's easier for him to believe she's Supergirl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Micro author tracts, part 2]]
*There's a lot of bellyaching about how the problem with those darn kids these days is that we're always looking at our screens instead of paying attention to the real world. Except... the makers of these shows presumably want us to continue to watch their ''fictional shows'' on our ''TV screens.'' You can't have it both ways!
[[/folder]]

[[folder: WTF, villain costuming department]]
*How come in the season finale, Rama Khan wears civilian garb instead of his costume? A brown jacket doesn't exactly say "I'm the supreme badass who's actually behind half the "natural" disasters in your history books and I'm here to bury ''you'' next," and ''all'' the rest of Leviathan are fully suited up.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** May tie in to Lex being a sexist on top of his other issues; he may at least ''believe'' that a woman might 'need' a cover identity where he can't accept that someone as powerful as Superman would bother with one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Some sources have speculated that Supergirl may ''appear'' more powerful than Superman because she's had less practice with her abilities; basically, where Superman has spent years training himself not to use too much power in case he kills his opponents, Supergirl is sometimes portrayed as lacking that expertise, so she uses more raw power by relative accident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** ''Crisis on Infinite Earths'' confirms he truly, honestly can't believe Earth-38/Earth Prime Clark could be Superman, even after encountering another Superman who ''is'' Clark Kent. It's kind of silly, yes, but that's the explanation we've been given.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cousins

Added DiffLines:

** She may also have been curious how her cousin seems to someone who isn’t Kryptonian, an everyday Earthling.

Added: 506

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of the episodes in the Fortress (I forget which one) briefly shows a Legion ring. It's entirely probable he's using that to fly in space.



** To be a bit more accurate, terrorists only make sense to themselves and to those who think like them. Unfortunately, the mindest of most terrorists is rather twisted, so it doesn't make sense to us.

to:

** To be a bit more accurate, terrorists only make sense to themselves and to those who think like them. Unfortunately, the mindest mindset of most terrorists is rather twisted, so it doesn't make sense to us.


Added DiffLines:

** There's also the LawOfConservationOfDetail. Sure, Kara and Alex may have time off work, but let's face it, how many people want to watch Kara and Alex snuggled up on a couch watching ''Film/ThePrincessBride?'' Their jobs are what provide the majority of drama.


Added DiffLines:

** Maybe Kara's being over-dramatic?


Added DiffLines:

** I know, I was hoping for an in-universe reason. Oh, well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Given that no Kryptonian ever seems to have trouble with the language when they come to Earth, it may just be that [[TheSimpsons by an astonishing coincidence, both of their languages are exactly the same]].

to:

** Given that no Kryptonian ever seems to have trouble with the language when they come to Earth, it may just be that [[TheSimpsons [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons by an astonishing coincidence, both of their languages are exactly the same]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** OP here. I wasn't really expecting her to be more powerful. I just remember in one episode (can't really remember which one) where one of the kryptonians (I think it was the one we now know as Non) was concerned about Superman, and when he brought up the idea that Superman would be more of a threat, Astra says (paraphrasing) "Don't be so sure." So I was just looking for some kind of edge that Supergirl might have over Franchise/{{Superman}} (other than the obvious "she's a girl" thing) and when I thought of how her heat vision is blue, I thought it might be because hers is hotter (as blue fire is to red) so maybe she's just got more juice, which got me thinking that maybe all her abilities are likewise suped up (it would also help to explain why Supergirl could beat Reactron, but Superman couldn't), which seemed like it could be reasonable due to my initial reasoning above (especially since we haven't really seen Superman do anything to compare with). I would have put this under WMG, but I wanted to make sure it made sense, so I thought I'd run it by the problem solvers at Headscratchers first, and I'm pleased to say all of you have been very helpful.

to:

** OP here. I wasn't really expecting her to be more powerful. I just remember in one episode (can't really remember which one) where one of the kryptonians (I think it was the one we now know as Non) was concerned about Superman, and when he brought up the idea that Superman would be more of a threat, Astra says (paraphrasing) "Don't be so sure." So I was just looking for some kind of edge that Supergirl might have over Franchise/{{Superman}} (other than the obvious "she's a girl" thing) and when I thought of how her heat vision is blue, I thought it might be because hers is hotter (as blue fire is to red) so maybe she's just got more juice, which got me thinking that maybe all her abilities are likewise suped up (it would also help to explain why Supergirl could beat Reactron, but Superman couldn't), which seemed like it could be reasonable due to my initial reasoning above (especially since we haven't really seen Superman do anything to compare with). I would have put this under WMG, but I wanted to make sure it made sense, so I thought I'd run it by the problem solvers at Headscratchers first, and I'm pleased to say all of you have been very helpful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


b

to:

b
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Most versions of Lex are at least aware that Superman has ''some'' secret identity; it was only one specific incarnation who refused to believe it entirely. Either Lex never figured out Clark was Superman, or he figured it out but never found a good time to make use of it. Hell, he knew Kara's identity for years and took advantage of it at least once (bringing Red Daughter to her apartment) before he dropped the big reveal on Lena, so it's entirely possible that he has been doing something with Clark's identity that Clark never noticed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Same reason why the Flash just doesn't automatically win against any villain that doesn't have super speed. If they did use their powers properly,the episode would end in five minutes.


Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Lex Luthor knowing Kara's secret identity]]
* So Lex's arrogance won't let him believe that Superman has a secret identity, but he is perfectly OK with his cousin having one? Or does this version of Lex also know that Clark Kent is really Supes and just doesn't care?
[[/folder]]

Top