Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / SuperMarioOdyssey

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Assuming Daisy is canon in Odyssey, where is Sarasaland?
* This is a very minor headscratcher, but what is up with the red and green hammers that are owned by the Mario Bros.? Appearance wise, they're the same type of hammers wielded by the Sprixie Princesses. Are they special in some way?

to:

* Assuming Daisy is canon in Odyssey, where is Sarasaland?
* This is a very minor headscratcher, but what is up with the red and green hammers that are owned by the Mario Bros.? Appearance wise, they're the same type of hammers wielded by the Sprixie Princesses. Are they special in some way?
Sarasaland?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Assuming Daisy is canon in Odyssey, where is Sarasaland?

to:

* Assuming Daisy is canon in Odyssey, where is Sarasaland?Sarasaland?
* This is a very minor headscratcher, but what is up with the red and green hammers that are owned by the Mario Bros.? Appearance wise, they're the same type of hammers wielded by the Sprixie Princesses. Are they special in some way?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Yup. [[ShoutOut Just like in]] VideoGame/AnimalCrossing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Simple: Cappy possessed Mario's cap.

to:

** Simple: I thought it was obvious that Cappy possessed Mario's cap.cap. He is, after all, a spirit-like being.



** There's no evidence that the "real world" exists in the canon of the Mario games. Mario is likely from New Donk city, and it even fits in with the timeline. Also, one of the main themes for Odyssey is "contrast", so perhaps the photo-realistic aspects of the game were done on purpose.

to:

** There's no evidence that the "real world" exists in the canon of the Mario games. Mario is likely from New Donk city, and it even fits in with the timeline. Also, one of the main themes for Odyssey is "contrast", so perhaps the photo-realistic aspects of the game were done on purpose.for that reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's no evidence that the "real world" exists in the canon of the Mario games. Mario is likely from New Donk city, and it even fits in with the timeline.

to:

** There's no evidence that the "real world" exists in the canon of the Mario games. Mario is likely from New Donk city, and it even fits in with the timeline. Also, one of the main themes for Odyssey is "contrast", so perhaps the photo-realistic aspects of the game were done on purpose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's probably just them teleporting or is an actual visual identifier of them reviving like Mario does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's no evidence that the "real world" exists in the canon of the Mario games. Mario is likely from New Donk city, and it even fits in with the timeline.

to:

** There's no evidence that the "real world" exists in the canon of the Mario games. Mario is likely from New Donk city, and it even fits in with the timeline.timeline.
* Assuming Daisy is canon in Odyssey, where is Sarasaland?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why are certain characters, like the T-Rex and the New Donkers, portrayed photo realistically? When there's a jarring change in design aesthetics like that there's usually an in-story reason, like if Mario had been transported to the real world or something. But there's no evidence of that, New Donk city is vastly different to New York City.

to:

* Why are certain characters, like the T-Rex and the New Donkers, portrayed photo realistically? When there's a jarring change in design aesthetics like that there's usually an in-story reason, like if Mario had been transported to the real world or something. But there's no evidence of that, New Donk city is vastly different to New York City.City.
** There's no evidence that the "real world" exists in the canon of the Mario games. Mario is likely from New Donk city, and it even fits in with the timeline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** My headcanon? [[VillainsOutShopping They're on vacation]].

to:

** My headcanon? [[VillainsOutShopping They're on vacation]]. Where on vacation, you might ask? Isle Delfino.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** My headcanon? [[VillainsOutShopping They're on vacation]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's quite obviously both metaphorical, and literal in the sense that Mario is the only human seen leaping in the air.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Simple: Cappy possessed Mario's cap.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So, uh...people seem to be pretty casual about eating stew that a giant bird vomited into, don't they?

to:

* So, uh...people seem to be pretty casual about eating stew that a giant bird vomited into, don't they?they?
* Why are certain characters, like the T-Rex and the New Donkers, portrayed photo realistically? When there's a jarring change in design aesthetics like that there's usually an in-story reason, like if Mario had been transported to the real world or something. But there's no evidence of that, New Donk city is vastly different to New York City.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of the game, you're supposed to escape the moon's underground caverns by capturing Bowser and then come across a power line and capture a Lil Sparky. How can Mario capture two things at once?

to:

* At the end of the game, you're supposed to escape the moon's underground caverns by capturing Bowser and then come across a power line and capture a Lil Sparky. How can Mario capture two things at once?once?
*So, uh...people seem to be pretty casual about eating stew that a giant bird vomited into, don't they?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** this is Bowser's kingdom, not Bowser's castle. the kingdom is his home, and all the volcano-ey lava filled castles are just there and he sets up there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He isn't sure, because he doesn't know about it. It was Paper Bowser (and Peach) who went through that, not main Bowser. Paper Jam revealed that each Mario series is set in its own world.

to:

** He isn't sure, because he doesn't know about it. It was Paper Bowser (and Peach) who went through that, not main Bowser. Paper Jam revealed that each Mario series is set in its own world.world.
* At the end of the game, you're supposed to escape the moon's underground caverns by capturing Bowser and then come across a power line and capture a Lil Sparky. How can Mario capture two things at once?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How is Bowser so sure that he can marry Peach without creating [[VideoGame/SuperPaperMario another Chaos Heart]] and dooming the multiverse again?

to:

* How is Bowser so sure that he can marry Peach without creating [[VideoGame/SuperPaperMario another Chaos Heart]] and dooming the multiverse again?again?
** He isn't sure, because he doesn't know about it. It was Paper Bowser (and Peach) who went through that, not main Bowser. Paper Jam revealed that each Mario series is set in its own world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** You answered your own question. Enemies "Poofing" in Mario games does not translate to an actual death.

to:

** You answered your own question. Enemies "Poofing" in Mario games does not translate to an actual death.death.
* How is Bowser so sure that he can marry Peach without creating [[VideoGame/SuperPaperMario another Chaos Heart]] and dooming the multiverse again?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The citizens are wearing hats from the different Crazy Cap stores. That woman (and her dog) decided on a space helmet, much like some of the Luncheon Kingdom forks wear snorkles or the Shiverian yetis wear sombreros.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I'm thinking either A. Nintendo wanted to try something different, B. They wanted to come up with a Japan-inspired world, but couldn't figure out where to put it, or C. Bowser is basically a Kappa, which is a ''Japanese'' mythical creature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Mario wins against a boss, are they destroyed or simply defeated? The Broodals just flat-out [[DefeatEqualsExplosion explode]] when you defeat them yet they come back for later fights just fine.

to:

* When Mario wins against a boss, are they destroyed or simply defeated? The Broodals just flat-out [[DefeatEqualsExplosion explode]] when you defeat them yet they come back for later fights just fine.fine.
** You answered your own question. Enemies "Poofing" in Mario games does not translate to an actual death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Mario wins against a boss, are they destroyed or simply defeated? The Broodals just flat-out [DefeatEqualsExplosion explode]] when you defeat them yet they come back for later fights just fine.

to:

* When Mario wins against a boss, are they destroyed or simply defeated? The Broodals just flat-out [DefeatEqualsExplosion [[DefeatEqualsExplosion explode]] when you defeat them yet they come back for later fights just fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bowser may have hired these guys just to delay Mario. He IS distractible with helping people and fighting bad guys you know.

to:

** Bowser may have hired these guys just to delay Mario. He IS distractible with helping people and fighting bad guys you know.know.
* When Mario wins against a boss, are they destroyed or simply defeated? The Broodals just flat-out [DefeatEqualsExplosion explode]] when you defeat them yet they come back for later fights just fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe they can only capture if they form a partnership with someone. Both Cappy AND Mario are capturing creatures and objects.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On replaying, it is mentioned that Torkdrift was working for Bowser, so that's something.

to:

** On replaying, it is mentioned that Torkdrift was working for Bowser, so that's something.something.
** Bowser may have hired these guys just to delay Mario. He IS distractible with helping people and fighting bad guys you know.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why is Bowser's kingdom suddenly Japanese ruins in the sky? It's never looked like that in other games. Also, why is Bowsers kingdom across the globe from the Mushroom Kingdom? With a long-running dispute and rivalry among the two lands, I always thought they were much closer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The most Doylist-est of explanations is that making capture/pulling-pegs-out-of-the-ground/etc. animations for every possible cap in the game would take too much time, so they developers opted for the time-saving route.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another possibility is that every attempt to keep Bowser and Peach together have failed, so they just kind of figure it's yet another lost cause the moment Mario gets involved (and they'd be right).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How are the non-Broodal bosses associated with Bowser? Torkdrift, for example, is stealing flowers, but it's not stated to be for the wedding, and if so, it would be the only theft you actually prevent in the game. Cookatiel might be associated with Bowser since he obviously didn't have any trouble from her in taking the stew, so maybe she and Mollosque-Lanceur were deployed to continue messing with the kingdom's resources after Bowser got what he needed? What's going on?

to:

* How are the non-Broodal bosses associated with Bowser? Torkdrift, for example, is stealing flowers, but it's not stated to be for the wedding, and if so, it would be the only theft you actually prevent in the game. Cookatiel might be associated with Bowser since he obviously didn't have any trouble from her in taking the stew, so maybe she and Mollosque-Lanceur were deployed to continue messing with the kingdom's resources after Bowser got what he needed? What's going on?on?
** On replaying, it is mentioned that Torkdrift was working for Bowser, so that's something.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why weren't Bowser Jr. and the koopalings at Bowser's wedding? Shouldn't they be celebrating their dad getting married and Peach being their new mom?

to:

* Why weren't Bowser Jr. and the koopalings at Bowser's wedding? Shouldn't they be celebrating their dad getting married and Peach being their new mom?mom?
** Only Bowser Jr. is canonically Bowser's son, but it still doesn't explain why the Koopalings aren't there besides the fact that they simply haven't been in any of the 3D games so far.
* How are the non-Broodal bosses associated with Bowser? Torkdrift, for example, is stealing flowers, but it's not stated to be for the wedding, and if so, it would be the only theft you actually prevent in the game. Cookatiel might be associated with Bowser since he obviously didn't have any trouble from her in taking the stew, so maybe she and Mollosque-Lanceur were deployed to continue messing with the kingdom's resources after Bowser got what he needed? What's going on?

Top