Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / StarWarsBattlefront

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why is Palpatine personally taking to the battlefield? Yes, he's an awesome fighter and it shows, but he's old and not invincible and, orders of magnitude more importantly THE EMPEROR! If he were to die here, The Galactic Empire would suffer a massive blow to its command structure. Is there an in universe reason or just RuleOfFun?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Actually, he retired. He's listed in the Credits as "Retired Clone Trooper".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because "ammo" that creates red beams is cheaper in-universe, and since vehicles presumably go through a lot more of it than your infantry, you might as well save a few credits on arming them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Linking directly instead of through redirect.


** [[WildMassGuessing It's not the lightsaber that deflects it, but the Jedi using the Force]]. After all, in Star Wars Episode V, Darth Vader deflects Han Solo's blaster without a lightsaber. The LaserSword likely just serves as a somatic placebo to help the Jedi time the reaction right (the same reason for all the over-the-top flamboyant motions with any other violent use of the force).

to:

** [[WildMassGuessing It's not the lightsaber that deflects it, but the Jedi using the Force]]. After all, in Star Wars Episode V, Darth Vader deflects Han Solo's blaster without a lightsaber. The LaserSword LaserBlade likely just serves as a somatic placebo to help the Jedi time the reaction right (the same reason for all the over-the-top flamboyant motions with any other violent use of the force).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Bail Organa used the ''Tantive IV'' in ''RevengeOfTheSith'', so it did exist at the time.

to:

*** Bail Organa used the ''Tantive IV'' in ''RevengeOfTheSith'', ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'', so it did exist at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When I played through the campaign and beat it I thought you caused an AlternateUniverse where the rebels [[TheBadGuyWins WERE completely crushed on Hoth]], but I'm not sure that is correct. If this isn't true, the narrator dying sounds like the likely explanation.

to:

** When I played through the campaign and beat it it, I thought you caused an AlternateUniverse where the rebels [[TheBadGuyWins WERE completely crushed on Hoth]], but I'm not sure that is correct. If this isn't true, the narrator dying sounds like the likely explanation.



** [[WildMassGuessing It's not the lightsaber that deflects it, but the Jedi using the Force]]. After all, in Star Wars Episode V, Darth Vader deflects Han Solo's blaster without a lightsaber. The LaserSword likely just serves as a somatic placebo to help the Jedi time the reaction right (The same reason for all the over-the-top flamboyant motions with any other violent use of the force)
*** Vader's didn't use the force to block Han's shot expect maybe to move his hand in the way. Vader's hand is made of Mandalorian Iron so it can absorb blaster fire.

to:

** [[WildMassGuessing It's not the lightsaber that deflects it, but the Jedi using the Force]]. After all, in Star Wars Episode V, Darth Vader deflects Han Solo's blaster without a lightsaber. The LaserSword likely just serves as a somatic placebo to help the Jedi time the reaction right (The (the same reason for all the over-the-top flamboyant motions with any other violent use of the force)
force).
*** Vader's Vader didn't use the force Force to block Han's shot expect except maybe to move his hand in the way. Vader's hand is made of Mandalorian Iron Iron, so it can absorb blaster fire.



*** Also, remember that blocking takes up stamina, I.E. force power, meaning that by blocking they prepare for everything by having both lightsaber and force ready to defend them.

to:

*** Also, remember that blocking takes up stamina, I.E. force power, meaning that by blocking blocking, they prepare for everything by having both lightsaber and force ready to defend them.



** It's even worse when playing on the Death Star in the same era. With Obi-Wan and the Emperor as the Hero characters no less.

to:

** It's even worse when playing on the Death Star in the same era. With Obi-Wan and the Emperor as the Hero characters characters, no less.



** Out-of-universe answer: its much easier and cheaper to use the same models as much as possible. In-universe is technically the same thing. If you can use the same shell/case for multiple weapons, why wouldn't you? The internal parts are different, obviously, but making only one casing for three weapons makes getting replacement parts easier. Not sure about Fett's blaster, but physically it does look similar to the E-11 BlasTech blaster rifle the stormtroopers use. As for the grenade launcher, there are only so many ways you can make one. I've got nothing for the Tri-Fighter, except that it makes the Tri-Fighter worth flying in the game. It, in my experience, is the weakest fighter, so having the highest rate of fire helps it out.

to:

** Out-of-universe answer: its it's much easier and cheaper to use the same models as much as possible. In-universe is technically the same thing. If you can use the same shell/case for multiple weapons, why wouldn't you? The internal parts are different, obviously, but making only one casing for three weapons makes getting replacement parts easier. Not sure about Fett's blaster, but physically physically, it does look similar to the E-11 BlasTech blaster rifle the stormtroopers use. As for the grenade launcher, there are only so many ways you can make one. I've got nothing for the Tri-Fighter, except that it makes the Tri-Fighter worth flying in the game. It, in my experience, is the weakest fighter, so having the highest rate of fire helps it out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Actually, if you delve into the expanded universe, you learn that after Hoth, the 501st was given a paid leave, and didn't come back into service until after the Rebels won on Endor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Also AI soldiers fire at waist-height, meaning they ''never'' hit Ewoks, so your AI teammates will hemorrhage all your reinforcement points without helping the fight at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why is just about EVERY vehicle laser red?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Just because the clones all use Jango's template doesn't mean they all sound exactly like him. Take ''[[VideoGame/StarWarsRepublicCommando Republic Commando]]'', for example. Delta Squad consists entirely of Jango clones, but all of them have unique quirks and specialties, and only Boss is voiced by Morrison. (And amusingly, the Republic announcer is ''Sev's'' voice.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wait, so... in the campaign, it says that it's Jedi who stole the plans for the Death Star. I thought [[DarkForcesSaga Kyle Katarn]] did that?

to:

* Wait, so... in the campaign, it says that it's Jedi who stole the plans for the Death Star. I thought [[DarkForcesSaga [[VideoGame/DarkForcesSaga Kyle Katarn]] did that?



** It's likely half-deliberately overpowering Jedi characters (at least in the first game) and half-not really putting any effort into how the lightsaber reacts to non-lightsaber things in-game - note that in games where the lightsaber is more common, like the DarkForcesSaga, explosives and [[KineticWeaponsAreJustBetter slugs]] (unless enveloped in energy, like with the Imperial Repeater) won't be deflected.

to:

** It's likely half-deliberately overpowering Jedi characters (at least in the first game) and half-not really putting any effort into how the lightsaber reacts to non-lightsaber things in-game - note that in games where the lightsaber is more common, like the DarkForcesSaga, VideoGame/DarkForcesSaga, explosives and [[KineticWeaponsAreJustBetter slugs]] (unless enveloped in energy, like with the Imperial Repeater) won't be deflected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[RuleOfFun Because it's fun.]]
Willbyr MOD

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hottip cleanup; see thread for details.


** [[RuleOfFun Rule of Fair Play]], dude. The droids already have a lot going their way: [[hottip:*: Ability to survive on the outside of Polis Massa, faster fighters, Droidekas, plus their troop carriers carry more troops.]]

to:

** [[RuleOfFun Rule of Fair Play]], dude. The droids already have a lot going their way: [[hottip:*: Ability way:[[note]]Ability to survive on the outside of Polis Massa, faster fighters, Droidekas, plus their troop carriers carry more troops.]][[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Out-of-universe answer: its much easier and cheaper to use the same models as much as possible. In-universe is technically the same thing. If you can use the same shell/case for multiple weapons, why wouldn't you? The internal parts are different, obviously, but making only one casing for three weapons makes getting replacement parts easier. Not sure about Fett's blaster, but physically it does look similar to the E-11 BlasTech blaster rifle the stormtroopers use. As for the grenade launcher, there are only so many ways you can make one. I've got nothing for the Tri-Fighter, except that it makes the Tri-Fighter worth flying in the game. It, in my experience it is the weakest fighter, so having the highest rate of fire helps it out.

to:

** Out-of-universe answer: its much easier and cheaper to use the same models as much as possible. In-universe is technically the same thing. If you can use the same shell/case for multiple weapons, why wouldn't you? The internal parts are different, obviously, but making only one casing for three weapons makes getting replacement parts easier. Not sure about Fett's blaster, but physically it does look similar to the E-11 BlasTech blaster rifle the stormtroopers use. As for the grenade launcher, there are only so many ways you can make one. I've got nothing for the Tri-Fighter, except that it makes the Tri-Fighter worth flying in the game. It, in my experience it experience, is the weakest fighter, so having the highest rate of fire helps it out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spelling errors


* Something about the CIS faction bugs me...Specifically, the vehicles. Most of them are some form of droid (Vulture droid, Tri-fighters, Hailfire droids, etc.)...and yet the Clones can use them if they cut into one or find an empty one. For the droid-[=PCs=], I can accept that they swap AIs or something, but how, exactly, does an organic drive a droid?
** [[RuleOfFun Rule of Fair Play]], dude. The droids already have alot going their way: [[hottip:*: Ability to survive on the outside of Polis Massa, faster fighters, Droidekas, plus their troop carriers carry more troops.]]

to:

* Something about the CIS faction bugs me...Specifically, the vehicles. Most of them are some form of droid (Vulture droid, Tri-fighters, Tri-Fighters, Hailfire droids, etc.)...and yet the Clones can use them if they cut into one or find an empty one. For the droid-[=PCs=], I can accept that they swap AIs or something, but how, exactly, does an organic drive a droid?
** [[RuleOfFun Rule of Fair Play]], dude. The droids already have alot a lot going their way: [[hottip:*: Ability to survive on the outside of Polis Massa, faster fighters, Droidekas, plus their troop carriers carry more troops.]]



*** This can be fixed if you take up modding. I'm a modder, and it isn't hard to make vehicles inacessible to the other side.

to:

*** This can be fixed if you take up modding. I'm a modder, and it isn't hard to make vehicles inacessible inaccessible to the other side.



* Why does the campaign end before Endor? I know the Empire ultimately loses, but an Unwinnable Battle could still be an effective end, not to mention that the Emperor specifically refers to the forces on Endor as "a legion of the Empire's best troops" or something to that effect.

to:

* Why does the campaign end before Endor? I know the Empire ultimately loses, but an Unwinnable Battle a battle that is not winnable could still be an effective end, not to mention that the Emperor specifically refers to the forces on Endor as "a legion of the Empire's best troops" or something to that effect.



** I imagine that having the player lose to a bunch of teddy bears would undercut the claim that the 501st were the best of the best. Granted, plenty of of people have already complained that the Emporer's claims about his so called best legion are already undercut by the movie, but I guess the game developers were making sure they didn't make the same mistake.

to:

** I imagine that having the player lose to a bunch of teddy bears would undercut the claim that the 501st were the best of the best. Granted, plenty of of people have already complained that the Emporer's Emperor's claims about his so called best legion are already undercut by the movie, but I guess the game developers were making sure they didn't make the same mistake.



* How is it you can play on Tantive IV in the Clone Wars era if that ship wasn't built until after the clone wars ended? They could've easily just left the Clone Wars unavaible to choose on that location instead of defying time and space.

to:

* How is it you can play on Tantive IV in the Clone Wars era if that ship wasn't built until after the clone wars ended? They could've easily just left the Clone Wars unavaible unavailable to choose on that location instead of defying time and space.



*** I guess the only limit was that the creators couldn't get some of the maps balanced if they went with noncanon factions (Hoth, Endor, Geonosis). Impossibility of something physically happening does not stop the resulting battles from being awesome, though.

to:

*** I guess the only limit was that the creators couldn't get some of the maps balanced if they went with noncanon non-canon factions (Hoth, Endor, Geonosis). Impossibility of something physically happening does not stop the resulting battles from being awesome, though.



** Out-of-universe answer: its much easier and cheaper to use the same models as much as possible. In-universe is technically the same thing. If you can use the same shell/case for multiple weapons, why wouldn't you? The internal parts are different, obviously, but making only one casing for three weapons makes getting replacement parts easier. Not sure about Fett's blaster, but physically it does look similar to the E-11 BlasTech blaster rifle the stormtroopers use. As for the grenade launcher, there are only so many ways you can make one. I've got nothing for the trifighter, except that it makes the trifighter worth flying in the game. It, in my experience it is the weakest fighter, so having the highest rate of fire helps itt out.

to:

** Out-of-universe answer: its much easier and cheaper to use the same models as much as possible. In-universe is technically the same thing. If you can use the same shell/case for multiple weapons, why wouldn't you? The internal parts are different, obviously, but making only one casing for three weapons makes getting replacement parts easier. Not sure about Fett's blaster, but physically it does look similar to the E-11 BlasTech blaster rifle the stormtroopers use. As for the grenade launcher, there are only so many ways you can make one. I've got nothing for the trifighter, Tri-Fighter, except that it makes the trifighter Tri-Fighter worth flying in the game. It, in my experience it is the weakest fighter, so having the highest rate of fire helps itt it out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Out-of-universe answer: its much easier and cheaper to use the same models as much as possible. In-universe is technically the same thing. If you can use the same shell/case for multiple weapons, why wouldn't you? The internal parts are different, obviously, but making only one casing for three weapons makes getting replacement parts easier. Not sure about Fett's blaster, but physically it does look similar to the E-11 BlasTech blaster rifle the stormtroopers use. As for the grenade launcher, there are only so many ways you can make one. I've got nothing for the trifighter, except that it makes the trifighter worth flying in the game. It, in my experience it is the weakest fighter, so having the highest rate of fire helps itt out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* So does anyone have an explanation for why the Imperial blaster rifle, Imperial shotgun, Imperial arc-caster, and Boba Fett's EE-3 blaster all use the same exact model? Or why all four factions use the same exact grenade launcher? Or why the Tri-Fighter shoots ''bullets?''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, keep in mind that the campaign story is narrated by a lowly soldier from the 501st legion. It's possible that he just wasn't privy to all the details, and just waited for his commanders to tell him who to shoot.

Top