Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MonsterHunter

Go To

OR

Added: 738

Changed: 324

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Axes would have originally been tools, not weapons, used for cutting down trees and the like. At some point, people would have went "I bet you can kill monsters with these things," which is hardly a leap of logic--the same would have happened with knives evolving into various swords. But since we never got a regular axe as a weapon class, what probably happened was that axes by themselves were not considered a good enough weapon for hunting monsters by the Guild. It wasn't until the development of the Switch Axe and Charge Blade that an axe-style weapon was officially sanctioned.



* How come rolling into water/swimming doesn't cause waterblight while being spit by a ludroth (or basically water monster in general) does?
** because you're not covered in Leviathan spit.

to:

*** Maybe something about the fat content or chemical make-up of the meat makes the reverse true? It is monster meat, after all.
* How come rolling into water/swimming doesn't cause waterblight while being spit by a ludroth Ludroth (or basically water monster in general) does?
** because Because you're not covered in Leviathan spit.



** Because it can survive the Frenzy Virus better than the regular Najarala.



* How do I get ''bones'' from a Daimyo Hermitaur? It's a giant ''crustacean''!

to:

* How do I get ''bones'' from a Daimyo Hermitaur? It's a giant ''crustacean''!''crustacean''!
** ... from it's stomach?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How do I get ''bones'' from a Daimyo Hermitaur? It's a giant ''crustacean''!
* How did Moofahs get onto Moga Island / Deserted Island in ''Generations''? They weren't there in the third-generation games and it's highly unlikely they just somehow managed to swim their way onto the island.

to:

* How do I get ''bones'' from a Daimyo Hermitaur? It's a giant ''crustacean''!
* How did Moofahs get onto Moga Island / Deserted Island in ''Generations''? They weren't there in the third-generation games and it's highly unlikely they just somehow managed to swim their way onto the island.
''crustacean''!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How did Moofahs get onto Moga Island / Deserted Island? They weren't there in the third-generation games and it's highly unlikely they just somehow managed to swim their way onto the island.

to:

* How did Moofahs get onto Moga Island / Deserted Island? Island in ''Generations''? They weren't there in the third-generation games and it's highly unlikely they just somehow managed to swim their way onto the island.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How do I get ''bones'' from a Daimyo Hermitaur? It's a giant ''crustacean''!

to:

* How do I get ''bones'' from a Daimyo Hermitaur? It's a giant ''crustacean''!''crustacean''!
* How did Moofahs get onto Moga Island / Deserted Island? They weren't there in the third-generation games and it's highly unlikely they just somehow managed to swim their way onto the island.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Same way Jay Leno does.

to:

** Same way Jay Leno does.does.
* How do I get ''bones'' from a Daimyo Hermitaur? It's a giant ''crustacean''!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ukanlos, how do they eat with such a small mouth and a massive chin like that?

to:

* Ukanlos, how do they eat with such a small mouth and a massive chin like that?that?
** Same way Jay Leno does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[FridgeLogic But rare steaks hold more flavor than well-done steaks...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's also possible that what actually makes the hunters cringe isn't the sound of the roars, but the sheer ''magnitude'' of them. We do know a few monsters can scream so loud that they can actually destroy ''ships'' (Akantor) so it's pretty reasonable to assume that they aren't blocking the sound so much as the concussive force of it. So blocking a roar is more like bracing against a concussive explosion with the alternative being to clap their hands over their ears and bunker down to avoid being knocked away and deafened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why does Tidal Najarala of all monsters have an Apex form?

to:

* Why does Tidal Najarala of all monsters have an Apex form?form?
* Ukanlos, how do they eat with such a small mouth and a massive chin like that?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For the same reason the hunter doesn't die when jumping from those same heights, but the small monsters still manage to hurt them with hits that have no real force behind them.

to:

** For the same reason the hunter doesn't die when jumping from those same heights, but the small monsters still manage to hurt them with hits that have no real force behind them.them.
* Why does Tidal Najarala of all monsters have an Apex form?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[CaptainObvious Or it could just be that in the Monster Hunter world, they discovered gunpowder before us, technology wise, therefore, they'd have guns at more "primitive" stages of technology]]

to:

** [[CaptainObvious Or it could just be that in the Monster Hunter world, they discovered gunpowder before us, technology wise, therefore, they'd have guns at more "primitive" stages of technology]]technology.]] Besides, given what you're fighting, it WOULD make a lot of sense to develop more powerful weapons sooner than it would to say, invent things that DON'T help against monsters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[CaptainObvious Or it could just be that in the Monster Hunter world, they discovered gunpowder before us, technology wise, therefore, they'd have guns at more "primitive" stages of technology]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Perhaps you don't get the whole part, just the best chunk of a given part. Getting two heads may actually mean getting two useful parts of the head.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The flavor text for the paintball mentions that it is scented, and that that is how you track the monster.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* How the hell can throwing a paintball at something mark its position on a map likely made of paper, papyrus, or something similar?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just scratching some itches. Nothing fancy.

Added DiffLines:

*** This troper, on the other hand, assume all the games happen all at the same timeline, and that the games aren't a generation per game.


Added DiffLines:

** Hold a moment there. Just what do we consider as "dragons"? We do not have a standard for these creatures at all, because we do not have these creatures at all in this world. Maybe, in the Monster Hunter world, they do have that standard. Or, they could just be categorizing the Kirin and the Yama Tsukami as "Elder Dragons" because, maybe, in their language, Elder Dragon means anything older or as old as the world. Or there could just be a gigantic shortage of information and knowledge that the authorities just categorize them as such. Whatever is the case, it all points out to the fact that the world of Monster Hunter is so vast, it reaches out to them and teaches them things about the world itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** You accidentally inhaled the attack, and now your lungs are full of liquid, forcing you to take longer to catch your breath.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is it that an egg can withstand you jumping down several stories while holding it, but is otherwise so fragile it will break if you so much as breathe on it?

to:

* Why is it that an egg can withstand you jumping down several stories while holding it, but is otherwise so fragile it will break if you so much as breathe on it?it?
** For the same reason the hunter doesn't die when jumping from those same heights, but the small monsters still manage to hurt them with hits that have no real force behind them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is it that an egg can withstand you jumping down several stories while holding it, but will otherwise break if you so much breathe on it?

to:

* Why is it that an egg can withstand you jumping down several stories while holding it, but will is otherwise so fragile it will break if you so much as breathe on it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is it that an egg can withstand you jumping down several stories while holding it, but will otherwise break if you so much look at it?

to:

* Why is it that an egg can withstand you jumping down several stories while holding it, but will otherwise break if you so much look at breathe on it?

Added: 140

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Well-Done Steak gives you a higher stamina boost than Rare Steak, but why? In RealLife, cooking food to well-doneness causes the nutrients to burn or evaporate away.

to:

* Well-Done Steak gives you a higher stamina boost than Rare Steak, but why? In RealLife, cooking food to well-doneness well-done causes the nutrients to burn or evaporate away.



** because you're not covered in Leviathan spit.

to:

** because you're not covered in Leviathan spit.spit.
* Why is it that an egg can withstand you jumping down several stories while holding it, but will otherwise break if you so much look at it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I think the official explanation is that the design of the weapon is ancient, your new weapon is a replica.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs, and the terminology may simply have stuck with the weapon InUniverse regarding the more modern designs, like the Amatsumagatsuchi HBG.

to:

*** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs, and InUniverse the terminology may simply have stuck with the weapon InUniverse regarding the more modern designs, like the Amatsumagatsuchi HBG.despite technology advancing to greater levels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs, and the terminology may simply have stuck with the weapon InUniverse.

to:

*** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs, and the terminology may simply have stuck with the weapon InUniverse.InUniverse regarding the more modern designs, like the Amatsumagatsuchi HBG.

Added: 675

Removed: 674

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs, and the terminology may simply have stuck with the weapon InUniverse.



** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs, and the terminology may simply have stuck with the weapon InUniverse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs.

to:

** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs.designs, and the terminology may simply have stuck with the weapon InUniverse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The [[SchizoTech]] might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs.

to:

** This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The [[SchizoTech]] SchizoTech might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**This troper always thought that the crossbow parts were simply the analogue to the spring and firing pin in a modern firearm's bolt assembly, seeing as the player character even draws the bowstring lever back when loading a Bowgun. The [[SchizoTech]] might have been such that the helical spring may not have been developed fully yet, with simpler, more familiar leaf springs and toughened bowstrings in place of the coils modern firearms use (note that in real life the helical spring wasn't developed until the 15th Century CE). Otherwise, ArtisticLicense simply comes into play for many of the designs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How come rolling into water/swimming doesn't cause waterblight while being spit by a ludroth (or basically water monster in general) does?

to:

* How come rolling into water/swimming doesn't cause waterblight while being spit by a ludroth (or basically water monster in general) does?does?
** because you're not covered in Leviathan spit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The extra taste gives the hunter all the motivation to keep going.

to:

** The extra taste gives the hunter all the motivation to keep going.going.
* How come rolling into water/swimming doesn't cause waterblight while being spit by a ludroth (or basically water monster in general) does?

Top