Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / GuildWars

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wiki/ namespace clean up.


* The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the [[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nundu_Bay Nundu Bay mission]]), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "[[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nightfall_%28event%29 Nightfall (event)]]" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on Wiki/TVTropes.)

to:

* The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the [[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nundu_Bay Nundu Bay mission]]), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "[[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nightfall_%28event%29 Nightfall (event)]]" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on Wiki/TVTropes.Website/TVTropes.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


[[spoiler:Markis]] is the White Mantle's [[TheMole mole]], while [[spoiler:Dinas]] is the Shining Blade's [[ReverseMole reverse mole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis]]'s betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?

to:

[[spoiler:Markis]] is the White Mantle's [[TheMole mole]], while [[spoiler:Dinas]] is the Shining Blade's [[ReverseMole reverse [[TheMole mole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis]]'s betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the [[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nundu_Bay Nundu Bay mission]]), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "[[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nightfall_%28event%29 Nightfall (event)]]" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on TVTropes.)

to:

* The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the [[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nundu_Bay Nundu Bay mission]]), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "[[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nightfall_%28event%29 Nightfall (event)]]" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on TVTropes.Wiki/TVTropes.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Has nothing to do with familiarity with in-universe fiction.


* Maybe they were GenreSavvy enough to not tell everyone they had TheMole, so thus Dinas couldn't know ''who'' it was, even if he found out there ''was'' a mole in their midst? For all he knew, it could ahve been you.

to:

* Maybe they were GenreSavvy enough to not didn't tell everyone they had TheMole, so thus Dinas couldn't know ''who'' it was, even if he found out there ''was'' a mole in their midst? For all he knew, it could ahve been you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**It's a dream. Abaddon can bring forth Nightfall through the tormented nightmares of the people whose minds he has touched. It was too late for the Nightfallen Garden, but helping Melonni defeat her nightmares and preventing the Harbingers of Twilight from gaining traction is why Marga Coast was saved from permanent Nightfall before it began.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[spoiler:Markis]] is the White Mantle's [[TheMole mole]], while [[spoiler:Dinas]] is the Shining Blade's [[ReverseMole reverse mole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis]]'s betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?

to:

[[spoiler:Markis]] is the White Mantle's [[TheMole mole]], while [[spoiler:Dinas]] is the Shining Blade's [[ReverseMole reverse mole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis]]'s betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?Huh?
* Maybe they were GenreSavvy enough to not tell everyone they had TheMole, so thus Dinas couldn't know ''who'' it was, even if he found out there ''was'' a mole in their midst? For all he knew, it could ahve been you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Sorry for all the edits, I always miss something in the preview. >_<


[[spoiler:Markis]] is the White Mantle's [[TheMole mole]], while [[spoiler:Dinas]] is the Shining Blade's [[ReverseMole reverse mole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis's]] betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?

to:

[[spoiler:Markis]] is the White Mantle's [[TheMole mole]], while [[spoiler:Dinas]] is the Shining Blade's [[ReverseMole reverse mole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis's]] [[spoiler:Markis]]'s betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[spoiler:Markis is the White Mantle's [[TheMole mole]], while Dinas is the Shining Blade's [[ReverseMole reverse mole]]]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis's]] betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?

to:

[[spoiler:Markis [[spoiler:Markis]] is the White Mantle's [[TheMole mole]], while Dinas [[spoiler:Dinas]] is the Shining Blade's [[ReverseMole reverse mole]]]].mole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis's]] betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[spoiler:Markis is the White Mantle's {{Mole}}, while Dinas is the Shining Blade's ReverseMole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis's]] betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?

to:

[[spoiler:Markis is the White Mantle's {{Mole}}, [[TheMole mole]], while Dinas is the Shining Blade's ReverseMole]].[[ReverseMole reverse mole]]]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? [[spoiler:Markis's]] betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spoilering.


[[WMG:Dinas and Markis]]
Dinas is the Shining Blade spy who was trusted by the White Mantle, and Markis is the White Mantle spy who was trusted by the Shining Blade. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? Markis's betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while Dinas was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?

to:

[[WMG:Dinas and Markis]]
[[WMG:These Guys Suck at Espionage]]
[[spoiler:Markis is the White Mantle's {{Mole}}, while
Dinas is the Shining Blade spy who was trusted by the White Mantle, and Markis is the White Mantle spy who was trusted by the Shining Blade. Blade's ReverseMole]]. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? Markis's [[spoiler:Markis's]] betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while Dinas [[spoiler:Dinas]] was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* (original poster here) I know about the information on the wiki (And am the person who started the Nightfall (event) article), the issue is that bits of the game point in both directions. Some in mission dialogue says that the event actually happened, but it is not shown in the first mission cutscene, and people do talk about "Melonni confronting her nightmares", as a description.

to:

* (original poster here) I know about the information on the wiki (And am the person who started the Nightfall (event) article), the issue is that bits of the game point in both directions. Some in mission dialogue says that the event actually happened, but it is not shown in the first mission cutscene, and people do talk about "Melonni confronting her nightmares", as a description.description.

[[WMG:Dinas and Markis]]
Dinas is the Shining Blade spy who was trusted by the White Mantle, and Markis is the White Mantle spy who was trusted by the Shining Blade. So, if both groups have spies embedded deeply within the enemy organisation, why aren't both groups aware that there are spies in their midst? Markis's betrayal was played as a huge shock to the Shining Blade, while Dinas was trusted by the Mantle right up until the Battle for Lion's Arch. Huh?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the [[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nundu_Bay Nundu Bay mission]]), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "[[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nightfall_%28event%29 Nightfall (event)]]" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on TVTropes.)

to:

* The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the [[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nundu_Bay Nundu Bay mission]]), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "[[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nightfall_%28event%29 Nightfall (event)]]" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on TVTropes.))
* (original poster here) I know about the information on the wiki (And am the person who started the Nightfall (event) article), the issue is that bits of the game point in both directions. Some in mission dialogue says that the event actually happened, but it is not shown in the first mission cutscene, and people do talk about "Melonni confronting her nightmares", as a description.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added links


* The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the Nundu Bay mission), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "Nightfall (event)" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on TVTropes.)

to:

* The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the [[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nundu_Bay Nundu Bay mission), mission]]), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "Nightfall (event)" "[[http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Nightfall_%28event%29 Nightfall (event)]]" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on TVTropes.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Explanation for \"Just Bugs Me\" re: Nundu Bay


Are we just fighting inside a dream of Melonni's, or did the Marga Coast actually go Nightfall while we were inside the sunspear Sanctuary? A mission inside a dream seems very strange, but the mission briefings do seem to lean towards this, and the cutscene before the mission briefing shows no torment lands. The mission dialogue seems to suggest that Nightfall came very suddenly, but that does seem something that could happen in a dream.

to:

Are we just fighting inside a dream of Melonni's, or did the Marga Coast actually go Nightfall while we were inside the sunspear Sanctuary? A mission inside a dream seems very strange, but the mission briefings do seem to lean towards this, and the cutscene before the mission briefing shows no torment lands. The mission dialogue seems to suggest that Nightfall came very suddenly, but that does seem something that could happen in a dream.dream.
*The mission takes place in the Nightfallen Marga Coast (only accessible through the Nundu Bay mission), just like how the Jennur's Horde mission takes place in the Nightfallen Garden of Seborhin. This might not be spelled out in the primary quests, but is AllThereInTheManual. (Check the "Nightfall (event)" page on the official wiki; questions about the game are better answered there than on TVTropes.)

Added: 161

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


::: No time, the lab's entrance is on the other side of Kryta, With the amount of Mantle She'd be in too much danger if they tried to move her.

to:

::: * No time, the lab's entrance is on the other side of Kryta, With the amount of Mantle She'd be in too much danger if they tried to move her.her.
** Also, they'd have lost due to sheer numbers and the fact that the Jade armors and bows apply spectral agony as part of every attack, rather than as a skill...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Normally I'd agree with you, however given that they were being taken into a nigh-inescapable location to help fight a force seemingly intent on killing EVERYONE there, I assume a genius like Zinn would be willing to take the golem along, even if it is just as a means of escape should things go horribly wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the Elona Reach mission, why does Turai Ossa start the vision crystal ritual before having all the pieces together? I suppose he wouldn't want to wait and allow more time for a forgotten attack, but starting the ritual earlier does still seem risky (Mission wise, either crystal option could be interesting). On a gameplay note for the mission, it's too bad that the priests do not join the player's party, rather than wandering on their own and getting killed.

to:

In the Elona Reach mission, why does Turai Ossa start the vision crystal ritual before having all the pieces together? I suppose he wouldn't want to wait and allow more time for a forgotten attack, but starting the ritual earlier does still seem risky (Mission wise, either crystal option could be interesting). On a gameplay note for the mission, it's too bad that the priests do not join the player's party, rather than wandering on their own and getting killed.killed.

[[WMG:Nundu Bay: Dream or Real]]
Are we just fighting inside a dream of Melonni's, or did the Marga Coast actually go Nightfall while we were inside the sunspear Sanctuary? A mission inside a dream seems very strange, but the mission briefings do seem to lean towards this, and the cutscene before the mission briefing shows no torment lands. The mission dialogue seems to suggest that Nightfall came very suddenly, but that does seem something that could happen in a dream.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It really makes no sense, but it's an excuse to charge up the urn when someone is in possession of it. Having it stop in a crucial moment could've been a fatal mistake, so i guess they had the collapse effect happen at any moment.

to:

** It really makes no sense, but it's an excuse to charge up the urn when someone is in possession of it. Having it stop in a crucial moment could've been a fatal mistake, so i guess they had the collapse effect happen at any moment.moment.

[[WMG:Vision Crystal]]
In the Elona Reach mission, why does Turai Ossa start the vision crystal ritual before having all the pieces together? I suppose he wouldn't want to wait and allow more time for a forgotten attack, but starting the ritual earlier does still seem risky (Mission wise, either crystal option could be interesting). On a gameplay note for the mission, it's too bad that the priests do not join the player's party, rather than wandering on their own and getting killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 233

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rocks sliding off sideways? (I never actually though of tghis before, though, thanks for pointing it out.). In addition, when does the catnedral stop collapsing, and how do the Kurzicks do it (If the process doesn't stop automatically at some point.)?

to:

* Rocks sliding off sideways? (I never actually though thought of tghis this before, though, thanks for pointing it out.). In addition, when does the catnedral cathedral stop collapsing, and how do the Kurzicks do it (If the process doesn't stop automatically at some point.)?)?
** It really makes no sense, but it's an excuse to charge up the urn when someone is in possession of it. Having it stop in a crucial moment could've been a fatal mistake, so i guess they had the collapse effect happen at any moment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In "The Arborstone", after you collect the Sacred Urn, the cathedral starts collapsing on top of you, causing the "Cathedral Collapse" effect, which rains rocks down on you every few seconds. However, you can still get hit by Cathedral Collapse in areas where ''there are no roofs above you''. How?

to:

In "The Arborstone", after you collect the Sacred Urn, the cathedral starts collapsing on top of you, causing the "Cathedral Collapse" effect, which rains rocks down on you every few seconds. However, you can still get hit by Cathedral Collapse in areas where ''there are no roofs above you''. How?How?
*Rocks sliding off sideways? (I never actually though of tghis before, though, thanks for pointing it out.). In addition, when does the catnedral stop collapsing, and how do the Kurzicks do it (If the process doesn't stop automatically at some point.)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Can you really imagine a pair of asuras -- Zinn and Blimm no less -- agreeing to move their work for a bunch of stupid bookahs? Surely you understand that their research is far more important than Surma or Salami or whatever.

to:

** Can you really imagine a pair of asuras -- Zinn and Blimm no less -- agreeing to move their work for a bunch of stupid bookahs? Surely you understand that their research is far more important than Surma or Salami or whatever.whatever.

[[WMG:Cathedral Collapse]]
In "The Arborstone", after you collect the Sacred Urn, the cathedral starts collapsing on top of you, causing the "Cathedral Collapse" effect, which rains rocks down on you every few seconds. However, you can still get hit by Cathedral Collapse in areas where ''there are no roofs above you''. How?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I understand that they were in a hurry, but why didn't Zinn and Blimm bring their 30' engine of destruction to the battle?

to:

* I understand that they were in a hurry, but why didn't Zinn and Blimm bring their 30' engine of destruction to the battle?battle?
** Can you really imagine a pair of asuras -- Zinn and Blimm no less -- agreeing to move their work for a bunch of stupid bookahs? Surely you understand that their research is far more important than Surma or Salami or whatever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


::: No time, the lab's entrance is on the other side of Kryta, With the amount of Mantle She'd be in too much danger if they tried to move her.

to:

::: No time, the lab's entrance is on the other side of Kryta, With the amount of Mantle She'd be in too much danger if they tried to move her.her.
* I understand that they were in a hurry, but why didn't Zinn and Blimm bring their 30' engine of destruction to the battle?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


So at the end of [[StoryArc War in Kryta]], players have to stop the White Mantle from killing Salma. But why did she have to stay in the capitol during the fight? The Shining Blade have access to a secret laboratory with an aura that makes ''every skill fail''. She would've been untouchable there!

to:

So at the end of [[StoryArc War in Kryta]], players have to stop the White Mantle from killing Salma. But why did she have to stay in the capitol during the fight? The Shining Blade have access to a secret laboratory with an aura that makes ''every skill fail''. She would've been untouchable there!there!
::: No time, the lab's entrance is on the other side of Kryta, With the amount of Mantle She'd be in too much danger if they tried to move her.

Top