Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / GreenLantern

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Here's one of the problems with super heroes sharing the same universe...of all the kind-hearted, do-gooders on earth, why did the ring pick Hal Jordan. I'm pretty sure there were a LOT of "Chosen Ones" on earth. I'm surprised it didn't go for Superman.

to:

* Here's one of the problems with super heroes sharing the same universe...of all the kind-hearted, do-gooders on earth, why did the ring pick Hal Jordan. I'm pretty sure there were a LOT of "Chosen Ones" on earth. I'm surprised it didn't go for Superman.earth worthy of the ring. I can see the ring not picking Superman because he wasn't born on earth, and Batman since he strikes fear in his enemies, but what about Aquaman and the others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Based on the reaction to the aforementioned ''Man of Steel'', the answer would apparently be "Yes." Remember, it's better to let innocents die than have blood directly on your hands.

to:

*** Based on the reaction to the aforementioned ''Man of Steel'', the answer would apparently be "Yes." Remember, it's better to let innocents die than have blood directly on your hands.hands.
* Here's one of the problems with super heroes sharing the same universe...of all the kind-hearted, do-gooders on earth, why did the ring pick Hal Jordan. I'm pretty sure there were a LOT of "Chosen Ones" on earth. I'm surprised it didn't go for Superman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Presumably once the body's been destroyed there's nowhere to put the soul; what else was he going to do? Let Parallax consume more people just to protect the (hopeless) souls he's already eaten?

to:

** Presumably once the body's been destroyed there's nowhere to put the soul; what else was he going to do? Let Parallax consume more people just to protect the (hopeless) souls he's already eaten?eaten?
*** Based on the reaction to the aforementioned ''Man of Steel'', the answer would apparently be "Yes." Remember, it's better to let innocents die than have blood directly on your hands.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the film... what the fuck happened to the souls Parallax devoured when it got destroyed by the sun? Did they get to move on to the afterlife? Or were they set ablaze and vaporized, too? ... OH, GOD, THAT MEANS HAL JORDAN DESTROYED MORE LIVES THAN THE KRYPTONIANS (Superman included) IN "MAN OF STEEL"! THAT WOULD BE THE WORST SUPERHERO ACT EVER!

to:

* In the film... what the fuck happened to the souls Parallax devoured when it got destroyed by the sun? Did they get to move on to the afterlife? Or were they set ablaze and vaporized, too? ... OH, GOD, THAT MEANS HAL JORDAN DESTROYED MORE LIVES THAN THE KRYPTONIANS (Superman included) IN "MAN OF STEEL"! THAT WOULD BE THE WORST SUPERHERO ACT EVER!EVER!
** Presumably once the body's been destroyed there's nowhere to put the soul; what else was he going to do? Let Parallax consume more people just to protect the (hopeless) souls he's already eaten?

Added: 350

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the film, the government agents discover that Hector Hammond has been "infected" by Parralax's energy. Why would they risk being around him without protective clothing? Were they not worried about a completely unknown, possibly parasitic life form, having the ability to spread from one host to another?

to:

* In the film, the government agents discover that Hector Hammond has been "infected" by Parralax's Parallax's energy. Why would they risk being around him without protective clothing? Were they not worried about a completely unknown, possibly parasitic life form, having the ability to spread from one host to another?another?
* In the film... what the fuck happened to the souls Parallax devoured when it got destroyed by the sun? Did they get to move on to the afterlife? Or were they set ablaze and vaporized, too? ... OH, GOD, THAT MEANS HAL JORDAN DESTROYED MORE LIVES THAN THE KRYPTONIANS (Superman included) IN "MAN OF STEEL"! THAT WOULD BE THE WORST SUPERHERO ACT EVER!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There might be no direct translation for what they were saying. Like in InfiniteCrisis when the always lovely {{Supergirl}} told {{Firestorm}} that there was no word for "escape" in Kryptonese. (Which, as good ol' AnimalMan immediately noted, explains quite a bit)

to:

** There might be no direct translation for what they were saying. Like in InfiniteCrisis when the always lovely {{Supergirl}} told {{Firestorm}} that there was no word for "escape" in Kryptonese. (Which, as good ol' AnimalMan ComicBook/AnimalMan immediately noted, explains quite a bit)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** No. Being a Green Lantern is often a thankless job and occupations among their number have included paupers all the way up to royalty. They are not paid by the Guardians, and if they require money then they must get in ways other than using the ring (which would be considered using it for personal gain). However, they are provided with room and board on Oa, so there is that, and in some continuities the ring can help with basic needs like food and places to sleep so they will not starve or be homeless while being a Green Lantern.

to:

** No. Being a Green Lantern is often a thankless job and occupations among their number have included paupers all the way up to royalty. They are not paid by the Guardians, and if they require money then they must get in ways other than using the ring (which would be considered using it for personal gain). However, they are provided with room and board on Oa, so there is that, and in some continuities the ring can help with basic needs like food and places to sleep so they will not starve or be homeless while being a Green Lantern.Lantern.
* From the film: At one point, during an attempted attack on Parralax, all the Lanterns that are ganging up on him use their collective will to construct a net of sorts to keep Parralax immobilized. How does it work when multiple Lanterns create one object with their energy? Wouldn't they all have to be thinking the exact same thing? And are Lanterns limited in the size of the things they can create with the ring?
* In the film, the government agents discover that Hector Hammond has been "infected" by Parralax's energy. Why would they risk being around him without protective clothing? Were they not worried about a completely unknown, possibly parasitic life form, having the ability to spread from one host to another?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Honestly the better question than why does the ring go to a planet already inhabited with so many heroes which is simple. Obviously this depends on the writers but there are planets where everybody has super powers, despite how good our geniuses tend to be nearly everywhere seems to have technology running around that makes our stuff look stone aged. We might always win but that's because we're also the protagonist. I want to know why the ring doesn't seek out any of the extant heroes. Batman's will power greater than any of the Lanterns I've seen sans possibly Jon Stewart. If he's too close to evil or crazy Superman, Flash, Wonder Woman. There are lots of better choices.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Are the Green Lanterns paid? All the Earth Green Lanterns have day jobs, but it looks like for all the other Green Lanterns it's a full time gig, so what do they live off of?

to:

* Are the Green Lanterns paid? All the Earth Green Lanterns have day jobs, but it looks like for all the other Green Lanterns it's a full time gig, so what do they live off of?of?
** No. Being a Green Lantern is often a thankless job and occupations among their number have included paupers all the way up to royalty. They are not paid by the Guardians, and if they require money then they must get in ways other than using the ring (which would be considered using it for personal gain). However, they are provided with room and board on Oa, so there is that, and in some continuities the ring can help with basic needs like food and places to sleep so they will not starve or be homeless while being a Green Lantern.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There might be no direct translation for what they were saying. Like in InfiniteCrisis when the always lovely {{Supergirl}} told {{Firestorm}} that there was no word for "escape" in Kryptonese. (Which, as good ol' AnimalMan immediately noted, explains quite a bit)

to:

** There might be no direct translation for what they were saying. Like in InfiniteCrisis when the always lovely {{Supergirl}} told {{Firestorm}} that there was no word for "escape" in Kryptonese. (Which, as good ol' AnimalMan immediately noted, explains quite a bit)bit)
* Are the Green Lanterns paid? All the Earth Green Lanterns have day jobs, but it looks like for all the other Green Lanterns it's a full time gig, so what do they live off of?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There might be no direct translation for what they were saying. Like in InfiniteCrisis when the always lovely {{Supergirl}} noted that there was no word for "escape" in Kryptonese. (Which, as good ol' AnimalMan immediately noted, explains quite a bit)

to:

** There might be no direct translation for what they were saying. Like in InfiniteCrisis when the always lovely {{Supergirl}} noted told {{Firestorm}} that there was no word for "escape" in Kryptonese. (Which, as good ol' AnimalMan immediately noted, explains quite a bit)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A slight nitpick: When Tomar-Re introduced him to the other lanterns, why didn't the rings translate whatever they are saying?

to:

* A slight nitpick: When Tomar-Re introduced him to the other lanterns, why didn't the rings translate whatever they are saying?saying?
** There might be no direct translation for what they were saying. Like in InfiniteCrisis when the always lovely {{Supergirl}} noted that there was no word for "escape" in Kryptonese. (Which, as good ol' AnimalMan immediately noted, explains quite a bit)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Oops.


* A slight nitpick: When Tomar-Re

to:

* A slight nitpick: When Tomar-ReTomar-Re introduced him to the other lanterns, why didn't the rings translate whatever they are saying?

Added: 32

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why are there only two Green Lanterns for a single space sector if said Space Sectors are 0.028% of the whole freaking universe!There are at least 100 billion galaxies in the universe,each containing billions to trillions of stars. Even if only one planet in a billion has an interstellar civilization, there would be trillions of interstellar races. And the Guardians intend 7200 people to look after all that?!

to:

* Why are there only two Green Lanterns for a single space sector if said Space Sectors are 0.028% of the whole freaking universe!There universe! There are at least 100 billion galaxies in the universe,each containing billions to trillions of stars. Even if only one planet in a billion has an interstellar civilization, there would be trillions of interstellar races. And the Guardians intend 7200 people to look after all that?!



** Tomar-Re, the Lantern of Krypton's sector noted that by the time he noticed it's intending doom, it was too late. He considered it his greatest failure until the day he died.

to:

** Tomar-Re, the Lantern of Krypton's sector noted that by the time he noticed it's intending impending doom, it was too late. He considered it his greatest failure until the day he died.



** Maybe it's sort of like EaglelandOsmosis only for a planet instead of a country.

to:

** Maybe it's sort of like EaglelandOsmosis only for a planet instead of a country.country.
*A slight nitpick: When Tomar-Re
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Maybe when you are [[TimeAbyss billions of years old]], what happened in a few years is infinitely less than a blink of the eye.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Ophidion wanted the Garden of Eden to himself. [[WhatAnIdiot He didn't expect God to punish him as well.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ever notice how a lot of characters who are aliens make suspiciously Earth-based constructs?

to:

* Ever notice how a lot of characters who are aliens make suspiciously Earth-based constructs?constructs?
** Maybe it's sort of like EaglelandOsmosis only for a planet instead of a country.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** We don't know how old Relic's universe was when it perished. It's possible that Relic lived in a universe monumentally younger than our own. That, and maybe a huge contributor to the drain was that the DC Universe had god-like entities of emotional spectrum.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** I thought it was due to Parallax being basically dead for eons. It probably wasn't strong enough to completely possess him, and goals of nobility were a sign Hal was shining through.


Added DiffLines:

** Light's Out gives a possible answer: using power rings drain energy from the universe. Thus the Guardians couldn't use as much as they wanted without the universe collapsing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Star Sapphire was a crystal the Zamarons gave to someone they felt expressed love the best, being basically like Larfleeze's battery. The problem is that they realized that no one person could handle all the power and made their own corps. as an answer. They still use the title Star Sapphire since their ultimate gem is the seed that created their corps.

to:

** The Star Sapphire was a crystal the Zamarons gave to someone they felt expressed love the best, being basically like Larfleeze's battery. The problem is that they realized that no one person could handle all the power and made their own corps. as an answer. They still use the title Star Sapphire since their ultimate gem is the seed that created their corps.corps.
* Ever notice how a lot of characters who are aliens make suspiciously Earth-based constructs?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** You're going too far in both ways though. No weakness is boring, but this weakness it far too limiting. Yes I know Superman, and even one of the most broken super heroes ever like him is at least weak to a rare type of rock that people would need to specifically seek out to use. ANYONE can get something that's yellow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Guardians have been hit ''hard'' with {{Flanderization}}. Which really just turns Sinestro into JerkassHasAPoint.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Star Sapphire was a concept previous to the Emotional Spectrum thingie, when trying to fill out the seven types of corps jonhs just used the previous concept and expanded it.

to:

** Star Sapphire was a concept previous to the Emotional Spectrum thingie, when trying to fill out the seven types of corps jonhs just used the previous concept and expanded it.it.
** The Star Sapphire was a crystal the Zamarons gave to someone they felt expressed love the best, being basically like Larfleeze's battery. The problem is that they realized that no one person could handle all the power and made their own corps. as an answer. They still use the title Star Sapphire since their ultimate gem is the seed that created their corps.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
answering questions : D


** it happened, sometimes the rings combine y one wierd two colored ring, sometimes it replaces the original ring.



* Why are the wielders of violet power rings called Star Sapphire? Sapphires are blue, aren't they?

to:

* Why are the wielders of violet power rings called Star Sapphire? Sapphires are blue, aren't they?they?
** Star Sapphire was a concept previous to the Emotional Spectrum thingie, when trying to fill out the seven types of corps jonhs just used the previous concept and expanded it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Okay, I'm sorta loving the LightsOut arc and all but one thing that confused the hell out of he is, how are they using up the emotional spectrum faster than those of Relic's universe? I mean their justification for this is that now their are more corps than in Relic's universe, but the other six corps were fairly recent additions. Not to mention Relic's universe also had seven versions of 'lightsmiths', who in addition to being much larger than beings of this universe were also maintaining CITIES of light with the emotional spectrum 24/7 in addition to other constructs as well as usage in mundane lifestyles (Example:Becoming a Red Lightsmith apparently being offered as a form of immortality).

to:

* Okay, I'm sorta loving the LightsOut arc and all but one thing that confused the hell out of he is, how are they using up the emotional spectrum faster than those of Relic's universe? I mean their justification for this is that now their are more corps than in Relic's universe, but the other six corps were fairly recent additions. Not to mention Relic's universe also had seven versions of 'lightsmiths', who in addition to being much larger than beings of this universe were also maintaining CITIES of light with the emotional spectrum 24/7 in addition to other constructs as well as usage in mundane lifestyles (Example:Becoming a Red Lightsmith apparently being offered as a form of immortality).immortality).
* Why are the wielders of violet power rings called Star Sapphire? Sapphires are blue, aren't they?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Okay, I'm sorta loving the LightsOut arc and all but one thing that confused the hell out of he is, how are they using up the emotional spectrum faster than those of Relic's universe? I mean their justification for this is that now their are more corps than in Relic's universe, but the other six corps were fairly recent additions. Not to mention Relic's universe also had seven versions of 'lightsmiths', who in addition to being much larger than beings of this universe were also maintaining CITIES of light with the emotional spectrum 24/7 in addition to other constructs.

to:

* Okay, I'm sorta loving the LightsOut arc and all but one thing that confused the hell out of he is, how are they using up the emotional spectrum faster than those of Relic's universe? I mean their justification for this is that now their are more corps than in Relic's universe, but the other six corps were fairly recent additions. Not to mention Relic's universe also had seven versions of 'lightsmiths', who in addition to being much larger than beings of this universe were also maintaining CITIES of light with the emotional spectrum 24/7 in addition to other constructs.constructs as well as usage in mundane lifestyles (Example:Becoming a Red Lightsmith apparently being offered as a form of immortality).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Antenna, tentacles, tail, etc. Then theres the fact that the ring can be made to fit on a limb and such. Just read a comic which featues non-humaniod Lanterns.

to:

** Antenna, tentacles, tail, etc. Then theres the fact that the ring can be made to fit on a limb and such. Just read a comic which featues non-humaniod Lanterns.Lanterns.
* Okay, I'm sorta loving the LightsOut arc and all but one thing that confused the hell out of he is, how are they using up the emotional spectrum faster than those of Relic's universe? I mean their justification for this is that now their are more corps than in Relic's universe, but the other six corps were fairly recent additions. Not to mention Relic's universe also had seven versions of 'lightsmiths', who in addition to being much larger than beings of this universe were also maintaining CITIES of light with the emotional spectrum 24/7 in addition to other constructs.

Added: 349

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** One of the (non cannonical) novels actually notices this. Gathned states that a Green Lantern's lungs are modified to be able to use CO[[subscript:2]] as well as oxygen to breathe. One of the villains is not so lucky, and is nearly killed when Kyle leave him trapped in a force field to be picked up.

to:

*** One of the (non cannonical) novels actually notices this. Gathned Gathnet states that a Green Lantern's lungs are modified to be able to use CO[[subscript:2]] as well as oxygen to breathe. One of the villains is not so lucky, and is nearly killed when Kyle leave him trapped in a force field to be picked up.


Added DiffLines:

*** Ignoring the fact that lanterns routinely fly around space, billions of miles away from stars, I distinctly remember an arc where a Green Lantern was exploring a region of space that had ''no'' light whatsoever and was getting along just fine. Similarly, Rot Lop Fan. The correct answer is SufficientlyAdvancedTechnology [[AWizardDidIt Did It]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* What happens when somebody wears more than one type of power ring? Does their hand explode? This assumes that whoever is doing the wearing has a countermeasure to the identity check the rings have such as what the Manhunters did with tissue samples.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Aliens? I think you're reading too much into Gaiman's remark that Cain and Abel just happened along. No, in ''TheBooksOfMagic'', the Phantom Stranger notes that in prehistory Earth was both a globe that cooled from star-stuff and developed life over eons ''and'' a disk that was created by the gods and overrun by demons. TheDCU has a MultipleChoicePast. Both Vandal Savage and Cain of Dreaming are the Biblical Cain, and doubtless others besides, depending on the story being told. Why? I dunno, Hypertime or whatever.

to:

**** Aliens? I think you're reading too much into Gaiman's remark that Cain and Abel just happened along. No, in ''TheBooksOfMagic'', ''ComicBook/TheBooksOfMagic'', the Phantom Stranger notes that in prehistory Earth was both a globe that cooled from star-stuff and developed life over eons ''and'' a disk that was created by the gods and overrun by demons. TheDCU has a MultipleChoicePast. Both Vandal Savage and Cain of Dreaming are the Biblical Cain, and doubtless others besides, depending on the story being told. Why? I dunno, Hypertime or whatever.

Top