Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DIDNapper

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstorm Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck of the evil characters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its richest allies.

to:

** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstorm Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck chunk of the evil characters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its richest allies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstorm Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck of the evil characters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its richest allies.

to:

** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstorm Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck of the evil characters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its richest allies.allies.
* While the kidnapping and bondage are part of the AuthorAppeal, it's never fully stated how slavery works in this setting as Slavery appears to be outlawed in both the Kingdom and the Empire yet everybody talks as if slavery is just having a woman BoundAndGagged around ''trying'' to do the ordered chores. The kidnapped women appear to be bought by Kingdom locals and no mention is made of other countries where slavery is legal and have a high demand for women.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstrom Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck of the evil characters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its richest allies.

to:

** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstrom Sandstorm Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck of the evil characters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its richest allies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''WARNING! SPOILER AHEAD AS PLOT POINTS WILL BE TALKED ABOUT AND DEBATED, IF YOU DON'T WANT TO BE SPOILED LEAVE THIS SECTION'''


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstrom Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck of the evil charcaters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its most powerful allies.

to:

** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstrom Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck of the evil charcaters characters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its most powerful richest allies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals.

to:

** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. The [[BigBadEnsemble two major villains]] (Krystina and Elda) have been stopped and locked up, as well as [[{{Sadist}} Rolina]] and it's implied that the Sandstrom Guild is going to be wiped out by Haab's guards, so a good chunck of the evil charcaters have been punished. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals. For instance, we can safely assume that with Rielle out of the picture, someone else (perhaps Marcia) was sent to Ghiaccio to put an end to Claude's illegal activities, depriving the Kidnapping Guild of one of its most powerful allies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did Suki simply told the guild to move rather than bringing an entire army to shut them down and kill/jail them? And Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. In the epilogue, all the evil characters are either safe or unpunished, and the kidnapper guild relocates peacefully, a particularly dark detail suggests that the new port is where pirates sell girls into slavery, to the western kingdom nobles who have no qualms about maids who don't need to be paid. Right now, it may feel to one's mileage like a hollow victory at best. If anything, the world just got DarkerAndEdgier.

to:

* Why did Suki simply told the guild to move rather than bringing an entire army to shut them down and kill/jail them? And Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. In the epilogue, all the evil characters are either safe or unpunished, and the kidnapper guild relocates peacefully, a particularly dark detail suggests that the new port is where pirates sell girls into slavery, to the western kingdom nobles who have no qualms about maids who don't need to be paid. Right now, it may feel to one's mileage like a hollow victory at best. If anything, the world just got DarkerAndEdgier.DarkerAndEdgier.
** For why Suki didn't seek an army on them, I'd say that she may have been worried that the guildmaster would [[ShootTheHostage kill the prisoners if a fight broke out]] and tried take another option. Or perhaps she's too nice for her own good, which would be consistent with her characterization so far. As for the victory being hollow and the world being DarkerAndEdgier, let's not forget that a war has been prevented with the Empire and the [[ArtifactOfDoom Maunak Eye]] is destroyed. That's two major threats resolved. Now, Cherisa reigns alone and will be able to focus on fighting the rampant criminality, since her efforts won't be hindered by her mother's actions. Her army has also been purged from its more corrupt elements (notably Rielle) and will be more efficient in stopping the criminals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Re-formulating the epilogue's results.


* Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. Yet somehow, Cilia, a very pleasant character who grew to enjoy her company in captivity, is sold back to the amazons as a slave, being tortured and chained. It simply put, logically makes no sense why Suki would release the worst slavers, but sell a very mild settler leader back to slavery, considering she hates slavery and kidnappers in the first place. Especially knowing Suki wanted the girls free.

to:

* Why did Suki simply told the guild to move rather than bringing an entire army to shut them down and kill/jail them? And Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. Yet somehow, Cilia, a very pleasant character who grew to enjoy her company in captivity, is sold back to In the amazons as a slave, being tortured epilogue, all the evil characters are either safe or unpunished, and chained. It simply put, logically makes no sense why Suki would release the worst slavers, but kidnapper guild relocates peacefully, a particularly dark detail suggests that the new port is where pirates sell a very mild settler leader back to girls into slavery, considering she hates slavery and kidnappers in to the first place. Especially knowing Suki wanted western kingdom nobles who have no qualms about maids who don't need to be paid. Right now, it may feel to one's mileage like a hollow victory at best. If anything, the girls free.world just got DarkerAndEdgier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. Yet somehow, Cilia, a very pleasant character who grew to enjoy her company in captivity, is sold back to the amazons as a slave. It simply put, logically makes no sense why Suki would release the worst slavers, but sell a very mild settler leader back to slavery, considering she hates slavery and kidnappers in the first place.

to:

* Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. Yet somehow, Cilia, a very pleasant character who grew to enjoy her company in captivity, is sold back to the amazons as a slave.slave, being tortured and chained. It simply put, logically makes no sense why Suki would release the worst slavers, but sell a very mild settler leader back to slavery, considering she hates slavery and kidnappers in the first place. Especially knowing Suki wanted the girls free.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Explanation.


* Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. Yet somehow, Cilia, a very pleasant character who grew to enjoy her company in captivity, is sold back to the amazons as a slave. It simply put, logically makes no sense why Suki would release the worst slavers, but sell a very mild settler leader back to slavery.

to:

* Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. Yet somehow, Cilia, a very pleasant character who grew to enjoy her company in captivity, is sold back to the amazons as a slave. It simply put, logically makes no sense why Suki would release the worst slavers, but sell a very mild settler leader back to slavery.slavery, considering she hates slavery and kidnappers in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Suki releases all captives, even an evil slaver girl who busts her own slaver pirate boss from jail. Yet somehow, Cilia, a very pleasant character who grew to enjoy her company in captivity, is sold back to the amazons as a slave. It simply put, logically makes no sense why Suki would release the worst slavers, but sell a very mild settler leader back to slavery.

Top