Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / BrooklynNineNine

Go To

OR

Added: 152

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I'm not a cop myself, but from what I've read, real life police don't necessarily tend to strictly partner up in the sense that TV often depicts them as doing -- i.e., in the sense that you only ever have one partner ever. Cops tend to work in squads and kind of interchange "partners" from other members of the squad depending on the situation. While obviously some officers might find they work particularly well with other officers and might tend to work with them more frequently, in other cases it might just be as simple as grabbing the nearest person from your squad who happens to be there and doesn't look like they're doing anything at that particular moment when you catch a case and need someone to work with. The B99 squad is apparently just flexible in that way; note we've also seen Boyle work with Diaz (especially in the earlier seasons), Peralta work with Santiage (before they hooked up / Santiago got promoted), Peralta work with Terry, and Santiago work with Boyle on occasion.

to:

** I'm not a cop myself, but from what I've read, real life police don't necessarily tend to strictly partner up in the sense that TV often depicts them as doing -- i.e., in the sense that you only ever have one partner ever. Cops tend to work in squads and kind of interchange "partners" from other members of the squad depending on the situation. While obviously some officers might find they work particularly well with other officers and might tend to work with them more frequently, in other cases it might just be as simple as grabbing the nearest person from your squad who happens to be there and doesn't look like they're doing anything at that particular moment when you catch a case and need someone to work with. The B99 squad is apparently just flexible in that way; note we've also seen Boyle work with Diaz (especially in the earlier seasons), Peralta work with Santiage Santiago (before they hooked up / Santiago got promoted), Peralta work with Terry, and Santiago work with Boyle on occasion.


Added DiffLines:

*** I mean, the series outright states on numerous occasions that Wuntch is a pretty horrible person. So this shouldn't come as too much of a surprise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** So Wuntch kissed Holt ''knowing'' he's gay? '''Horrible'''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Holt has pride flags in the present day. He told Wuntch about his sexuality back in the 70s (something that required a lot of dutch courage). In The Tagger, he says he's been out since 1987. He wouldn't have had a pair of pride flags anywhere in his working environment before coming out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Part of the issue is one of {{Flanderization}}. Initially, she skirts around the edges of acceptable workplace decorum, but does her job well enough that her eccentricities are tolerated. It's implied that she is actually an excellent assistant despite her foibles. A prime example is her behaviour when choosing a new IT person. However, as the series goes on, she becomes more obnoxious and insubordinate without a corresponding increase in utility, while the script continues to have everyone react as though she's the same flighty but effective scamp from the earlier seasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's also possible that they ''do'' get to work with other cops. However, thanks to the things that you pointed out and because the show doesn't focus on the other cops in the precinct (the gang does acknowledge the other cops in the precinct and treats them as friends), we never get to see their side of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The only logical InUniverse explanation is that it ''didn't''. Reminder that Captain Holt as a tendency to lie about and mask his injuries.

to:

** The only logical InUniverse explanation is that it ''didn't''. Reminder that Captain Holt as has a tendency to lie mask/lie about and mask his injuries.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The only logical InUniverse explanation is that it ''didn't''. Reminder that Captain Holt as a tendency to lie about and mask his injuries.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Something just hit me: You'd think that Holt's gay pride flag's (at least I think he has about two of them) would immediately make Wuntch realize that Holt is gay, right?

to:

* Something just hit me: You'd think that Holt's gay pride flag's (at least I think he has about two of them) would immediately make Wuntch realize that Holt is gay, right?right? Is she really as blind as Hitchcock and Skully, in denial or what?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Something just hit me: You'd think that Holt's gay pride flag's (at least I think he has about two of them) would immediately make Wuntch realize that Holt is gay, right?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Yes


** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire, as per TruthInTelevision. His [[VagueAge ambiguous age is probably left unanswered to avoid this kinda thing happening in a realistic way]]. It could also just be RuleOfFunny: Captain Holt is [[MathematiciansAnswer old]] years old. That's all you need to know. That, or it's set in an alternate universe where things work differently. There's some stuff in this show that may suggest this to be the actual case.

to:

** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire, as per TruthInTelevision. His [[VagueAge ambiguous age is probably left unanswered to avoid this kinda thing happening in a realistic way]]. It could also just be RuleOfFunny: Captain Holt is [[MathematiciansAnswer old]] years old. That's all you need to know. That, or it's this show is set in an alternate universe where things work differently. There's some stuff in this show that may suggest this to be the actual case.

Added: 754

Changed: 193

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding questions


** But why is CJ still there at all? The precinct didn’t previously have a “day captain” and “night captain.” Why didn’t Holt just get his full command back after he and Jake returned?
* In the first episode after Florida, Jake uses a cane because he’d been shot in the leg. But Holt had been impaled on rebar earlier that day and he seems fine. His injury was most likely worse than Jake’s - why did he recover so quickly?




to:

* Why did Figgis only threaten Jake and Holt? The whole squad worked to take him down, not just those two. If anything, wouldn’t Figgis want to target Rosa, who wasPimento’s fiancé at the time?
* Why couldn’t Holt testify at Jake and Rosa’s trial? He’d mentioned that the investigation into Hawkins was off the books and wasn’t official, but that shouldn’t mean that he couldn’t testify about it. And Jake also texted Holt for help when he realized that they were about to hit up the bank. Why wasn’t that considered evidence?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Why are Captains the only candidates for Commissioner? The series has shown several Deputy Commissioners. Are they ineligible for the top job?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** IIRC when Holt gets back CJ has been put in charge of the day shift, while Holt is moved to the night shift. In any case, while C.J is an idiot and the characters had good reasons, they nevertheless genuinely did disobey a direct order from a superior officer, and as Holt is the person they disobeyed the orders for there's a clear conflict of interest there. Holt is often shown to be rather LawfulGood in inclination, and a key theme of the series is often how a real police department often doesn't work like it does in the movies -- namely, that the characters don't always have HeroInsurance when they break the rules in service of the plot. While Holt obviously doesn't like being on the night shift and is happy to ensure that the punishment doesn't last any longer than it needs to, they still rightfully had some punishment of some kind coming and it would be inappropriate for him to intervene on their behalf to get them out of it entirely.

to:

** IIRC when Holt gets back CJ has been put in charge of the day shift, while Holt is moved to the night shift.shift, so he's not really in charge of the day shift any more. In any case, while C.J is an idiot and the characters had good reasons, they nevertheless genuinely did disobey a direct order from a superior officer, and as Holt is the person they disobeyed the orders for there's a clear conflict of interest there. Holt is often shown to be rather LawfulGood in inclination, and a key theme of the series is often how a real police department often doesn't work like it does in the movies -- namely, that the characters don't always have HeroInsurance when they break the rules in service of the plot. While Holt obviously doesn't like being on the night shift and is happy to ensure that the punishment doesn't last any longer than it needs to, they still rightfully had some punishment of some kind coming and it would be inappropriate for him to intervene on their behalf to get them out of it entirely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** IIRC when Holt gets back CJ has been put in charge of the day shift, while Holt is moved to the night shift. In any case, while C.J is an idiot and the characters had good reasons, they nevertheless genuinely did disobey a direct order from a superior officer, and as Holt is the person they disobeyed the orders for there's a clear conflict of interest there. Holt is often shown to be rather LawfulGood in inclination, and a key theme of the series is often how a real police department often doesn't work like it does in the movies -- namely, that the characters don't always have HeroInsurance when they break the rules in service of the plot. While Holt obviously doesn't like being on the night shift and is happy to ensure that the punishment doesn't last any longer than it needs to, they still rightfully had some punishment of some kind coming and it would be inappropriate for him to intervene on their behalf to get them out of it entirely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When C.J puts the squad on night shift for going to Florida against his direct orders, why didn't Captain Holt just take them off the night shift and back on the day shift?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire, as per TruthInTelevision. His [[VagueAge ambiguous age is probably left unanswered to avoid this kinda thing happening in a realistic way]]. It could also just be RuleOfFunny: Captain Holt is [[MathematiciansAnswer old]] years old. That's all you need to know.

to:

** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire, as per TruthInTelevision. His [[VagueAge ambiguous age is probably left unanswered to avoid this kinda thing happening in a realistic way]]. It could also just be RuleOfFunny: Captain Holt is [[MathematiciansAnswer old]] years old. That's all you need to know. That, or it's set in an alternate universe where things work differently. There's some stuff in this show that may suggest this to be the actual case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a (rather cynical) Watsonian explanation, Gina has frequently been accused of being a CreatorsPet (or at least CreatorsFavorite). It's possible that she gets away with all her horrible actions simply because the writers like her too much to inflict any meaningful punishments on her.

to:

** In a (rather cynical) Watsonian Doylist explanation, Gina has frequently been accused of being a CreatorsPet (or at least CreatorsFavorite). It's possible that she gets away with all her horrible actions simply because the writers like her too much to inflict any meaningful punishments on her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Also, whatever her other flaws, Wuntch at least seems to be a pretty good police officer. Careerist tendencies, disproportionate grudge-holding and tendencies towards being a BadBoss aren't in and of themselves fireable offenses as long as Wuntch is sufficiently good at her actual job of, well, being a police officer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** In a (rather cynical) Watsonian explanation, Gina has frequently been accused of being a CreatorsPet (or at least CreatorsFavorite). It's possible that she gets away with all her horrible actions simply because the writers like her too much to inflict any meaningful punishments on her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The fact that even someone "obsessively careful with money" might want a personal vehicle doesn't really seem like a headscratcher. In fact, it makes even more sense, since if there's one person who almost certainly carefully budgeted and planned ahead in order to ensure that she could afford to buy a car with a minimum of financial hardship, it is Amy Santiago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rosa probably thought the Papa John that Gina met wasn't the real Papa John.

to:

** Rosa probably thought the Papa John that Gina met wasn't the real Papa John.
John, and Gina got lied to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Rosa probably thought the Papa John that Gina met wasn't the real Papa John.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In episode 21 of season 1, why does Rosa think someone is lying to Gina when she claims to know Papa John (as in, the guy the pizza chain is named for)? It's not like they just randomly chose that name, there really ''is'' a Papa John: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Schnatter John Schnatter]], who founded the chain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire, as per TruthInTelevision. His [[VagueAge ambiguous age is probably left unanswered to avoid this kinda thing happening in a realistic way]].

to:

** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire, as per TruthInTelevision. His [[VagueAge ambiguous age is probably left unanswered to avoid this kinda thing happening in a realistic way]].
way]]. It could also just be RuleOfFunny: Captain Holt is [[MathematiciansAnswer old]] years old. That's all you need to know.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire, as per TruthInTelevision.

to:

** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire, as per TruthInTelevision.
TruthInTelevision. His [[VagueAge ambiguous age is probably left unanswered to avoid this kinda thing happening in a realistic way]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire.

to:

** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire.
retire, as per TruthInTelevision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Captain Holt probably isn't the type to ''want'' to retire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* How old is Captain Holt supposed to be? It's been established in various flashbacs that he was already working as a detective in the 1970s. For that to make sense, he must have been born in the mid-1950s or earlier... But that would mean he should be very close to retirement age if he hasn't already reached it. Yet he never talks about retirement and is still very much trying to reach the position of the Police Commissioner. Doesn't the NYPD have some kind of mandatory retirement age?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It's quite obviously just a joke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I gotta ask... In "The Therapist", Jake mentions that while he was living in New York, he's lived in a place where the toilet was literally in the refrigerator... Does such a thing happen in RealLife (specifically New York), or is that [[RuleOfFunny a thing that only happens in the Brooklyn 99 universe?]]

to:

* This isn't important, but I just gotta ask... In "The Therapist", Jake mentions that while he was living in New York, he's lived in a place where the toilet was literally in the refrigerator... Does such a thing happen in RealLife (specifically New York), or is that [[RuleOfFunny a thing that only happens in the Brooklyn 99 universe?]]

Top