Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / BatmanAndRobin

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Why? Because he's nuts, obviously. Seriously, that's the reason, both in the film, the comics, and the animated series. He isn't quite as cracked up as guys like the Joker or Two-Face but he's not exactly sane either. Even before the accident that turned him into Mr. Freeze he was heavily obsessed with curing his wife's condition. After the accident his obsession kicked into overdrive and he stopped caring about ''anything'' except curing his wife. The thing you have to understand about pathological obsessions is the sufferers focus on what, in their minds, seems like the most direct route to their goal. Anything that deviates from that route or adds extra steps along the way is an unacceptable distraction, even if it would produce the same result with a fraction of the effort. Based on this, I'd say that at some point in movie!Freeze's (or The Freezinator as I like to call him) history he was in a position where turning to crime seemed like his only option. For instance, after his accident Freeze may have become unemployable. Rumors of rank incompetence and lax safety standards would swirl around him, damaging his scientific reputation. Universities and private companies would be understandably reluctant to fund a project that already turned one person into a mutant freak, and no doubt they would balk at the expense of maintaining a constant sub-zero environment for Freeze and fueling his diamond-powered suit. After getting rejected enough times and becoming increasingly desperate Freeze could easily have concluded that the only way to get the research money he needed was by stealing it or blackmailing the city for it. And once he goes that far, well, there's no turning back. If he developed the early-stage cure after turning to crime it makes sense that he wouldn't sell it to fund his research. In his (now slightly unhinged) mind, crime is the most direct route to curing his wife. Anything else, including using the early-stage cure to get legitimate funding, is an unacceptable distraction.

to:

*** Why? Because he's nuts, obviously. Seriously, that's the reason, both in the film, the comics, and the animated series. He isn't quite as cracked up as guys like the Joker ComicBook/TheJoker or Two-Face ComicBook/TwoFace but he's not exactly sane either. Even before the accident that turned him into Mr. Freeze he was heavily obsessed with curing his wife's condition. After the accident his obsession kicked into overdrive and he stopped caring about ''anything'' except curing his wife. The thing you have to understand about pathological obsessions is the sufferers focus on what, in their minds, seems like the most direct route to their goal. Anything that deviates from that route or adds extra steps along the way is an unacceptable distraction, even if it would produce the same result with a fraction of the effort. Based on this, I'd say that at some point in movie!Freeze's (or The Freezinator as I like to call him) history he was in a position where turning to crime seemed like his only option. For instance, after his accident Freeze may have become unemployable. Rumors of rank incompetence and lax safety standards would swirl around him, damaging his scientific reputation. Universities and private companies would be understandably reluctant to fund a project that already turned one person into a mutant freak, and no doubt they would balk at the expense of maintaining a constant sub-zero environment for Freeze and fueling his diamond-powered suit. After getting rejected enough times and becoming increasingly desperate Freeze could easily have concluded that the only way to get the research money he needed was by stealing it or blackmailing the city for it. And once he goes that far, well, there's no turning back. If he developed the early-stage cure after turning to crime it makes sense that he wouldn't sell it to fund his research. In his (now slightly unhinged) mind, crime is the most direct route to curing his wife. Anything else, including using the early-stage cure to get legitimate funding, is an unacceptable distraction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Actually Ivy states that she "pulled Nora's plug" and we see her do just that. It seems she did intend on killing her and simply thought that while unplugged Nora would die or drown (clearly she had to be fumbling around with the body as she swiped her pendant). Ivy meant to kill her, but Batman managed to save her in time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Because he could logically have overpowered her before she could. In that moment, the best thing to do was to dispose of him quickly without much of a physical battle, which she tries to do by pushing him into the pool and letting her plants handle him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What is Two-Face's suit doing in the property locker at Arkham? He died in that outfit in the last movie.

to:

* What is Two-Face's suit doing in the property locker at Arkham? He died in that outfit in the last movie.movie.
** A deleted scene from ''Film/BatmanForever'' deals with Harvey escaping Arkham. The outfit could be from the previous time he was caught.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It wasn't Freeze's plan at all. The rocket was for a quick escape (though he didn't really seem to need it; that tank it came out of ''picks him up'' from his landing sight.) Freeze simply recklessly disregarded the rocket in favor of the glider and like stated above, Batman exaggerated the theoretical damage.

to:

** It wasn't Freeze's plan at all. The rocket was for a quick escape (though he didn't really seem to need it; that tank it came out of ''picks him up'' from his landing sight.) Freeze simply recklessly disregarded the rocket in favor of the glider and like stated above, Batman exaggerated the theoretical damage.damage.
* What is Two-Face's suit doing in the property locker at Arkham? He died in that outfit in the last movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As stated above, they most definitely don't care, or maybe Freeze bribed them to place him there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Batman was talking out of his ass. Of course such a small rocket with no warhead wouldn't destroy Gotham. It would've just been a chunk of metal falling down. Sure, there'd some damage, but definitely not city-wide.

to:

** Batman was talking out of his ass. Of course such a small rocket with no warhead wouldn't destroy Gotham. It would've just been a chunk of metal falling down. Sure, there'd some damage, but definitely not city-wide.city-wide.
** It wasn't Freeze's plan at all. The rocket was for a quick escape (though he didn't really seem to need it; that tank it came out of ''picks him up'' from his landing sight.) Freeze simply recklessly disregarded the rocket in favor of the glider and like stated above, Batman exaggerated the theoretical damage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They only went there after they had captured Freeze and a dozen of his men at the charity ball. Likely one of the goons, or maybe Freeze himself for some reason, squealed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And how did Freeze himself plan on surviving the explosion? When he leaves the rocket, he uses a glider to slowly descend back to Gotham, the city that he was trying to blow up.

to:

** And how did Freeze himself plan on surviving the explosion? When he leaves the rocket, he uses a glider to slowly descend back to Gotham, the city that he was trying to blow up.up.
** Batman was talking out of his ass. Of course such a small rocket with no warhead wouldn't destroy Gotham. It would've just been a chunk of metal falling down. Sure, there'd some damage, but definitely not city-wide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He volunteered for the job. Why should he had left then?



* Mr. Freeze's plan was for the rocket to plummet down to Gotham and reduce it to a crater, slaughtering thousands of people according to Batman. Wouldn't that include Mr. Freeze's wife in his hideout, thus destroying his entire motivation and decided livelihood?

to:

* Mr. Freeze's plan was for the rocket to plummet down to Gotham and reduce it to a crater, slaughtering thousands of people according to Batman. Wouldn't that include Mr. Freeze's wife in his hideout, thus destroying his entire motivation and decided livelihood?livelihood?
** And how did Freeze himself plan on surviving the explosion? When he leaves the rocket, he uses a glider to slowly descend back to Gotham, the city that he was trying to blow up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mr. Freeze's plan was for the rocket to plummet down to Gotham and reduce it to a crater, slaughtering thousands of people according to Batman. Wouldn't that include Mr. Freeze's wife in his hideout, thus destroying his entire motivations for this thirst for vengeance in the first place?

to:

* Mr. Freeze's plan was for the rocket to plummet down to Gotham and reduce it to a crater, slaughtering thousands of people according to Batman. Wouldn't that include Mr. Freeze's wife in his hideout, thus destroying his entire motivations for this thirst for vengeance in the first place?motivation and decided livelihood?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Does Arkham usually put men and women in the same cell together? On top of that, the man has a grudge against this woman for trying to kill his wife. Is this a revenge thing for the guards? What guarantee Freeze won't kill her, or do they care?

to:

* Does Arkham usually put men and women in the same cell together? On top of that, the man has a grudge against this woman for trying to kill his wife. Is this a revenge thing for the guards? What guarantee Freeze won't kill her, or do they care?care?
* How did Batman and the police discover that the ice cream factory was Mr. Freeze's hideout?
* Mr. Freeze's plan was for the rocket to plummet down to Gotham and reduce it to a crater, slaughtering thousands of people according to Batman. Wouldn't that include Mr. Freeze's wife in his hideout, thus destroying his entire motivations for this thirst for vengeance in the first place?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** What was to stop her from ''grabbing'' Robin's head and forcibly kissing him? He was close enough, and he wasn't really paying attention to her.

to:

*** What was to stop her from ''grabbing'' Robin's head and forcibly kissing him? him just after the lips are off? He was close enough, and he wasn't really paying attention to her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** What was to stop her from ''grabbing'' Robin's head and forcibly kissing him? He was close enough, and he wasn't really paying attention to her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** My guess is, they couldn't think of another quick way to get her into the Batcave.

to:

** My guess is, they couldn't think of another quick way to get her into the Batcave.Batcave.
* Does Arkham usually put men and women in the same cell together? On top of that, the man has a grudge against this woman for trying to kill his wife. Is this a revenge thing for the guards? What guarantee Freeze won't kill her, or do they care?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Mr. Freeze, of all people, would be aware of the RuleOfCool.

to:

*** Mr. Freeze, of all people, Freeze would be aware of an expert on the RuleOfCool.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** RuleOfCool (pun intended)

to:

*** RuleOfCool (pun intended)Mr. Freeze, of all people, would be aware of the RuleOfCool.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** RuleOfCool (pun intended)



** My guess is, they couldn't think of another quick way to get her into the Batcave.

to:

** My guess is, they couldn't think of another quick way to get her into the Batcave.

Added: 85

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Babara Afred's niece in this universe?

to:

* Why is Babara Afred's Barbara Alfred's niece in this universe?universe?
** My guess is, they couldn't think of another quick way to get her into the Batcave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well, we already know he decks his clothes out in special gear to cool him down, so maybe he has Doctor Schoel's-like pads built into the slippers, except they keep the slippers cold. As for the cigar, a tiny bit of heat like on the tip probably isn't going to hurt him.

to:

** Well, we already know he decks his clothes out in special gear to cool him down, so maybe he has Doctor Schoel's-like pads built into the slippers, except they keep the slippers cold. As for the cigar, a tiny bit of heat like on the tip probably isn't going to hurt him.him.
* Why is Babara Afred's niece in this universe?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Complaining. The reason is that Gordon just wasn\'t as prominent a character in the movies.


** Well, we already know he decks his clothes out in special gear to cool him down, so maybe he has Doctor Schoel's-like pads built into the slippers, except they keep the slippers cold. As for the cigar, a tiny bit of heat like on the tip probably isn't going to hurt him.
* Why is Barbera Afred's niece, and not Commissioner Gordon's daughter/niece? What? A bumbling old guy like Gordon can't have a hot daughter/niece that looks like Alicia Silverstone?

to:

** Well, we already know he decks his clothes out in special gear to cool him down, so maybe he has Doctor Schoel's-like pads built into the slippers, except they keep the slippers cold. As for the cigar, a tiny bit of heat like on the tip probably isn't going to hurt him.
* Why is Barbera Afred's niece, and not Commissioner Gordon's daughter/niece? What? A bumbling old guy like Gordon can't have a hot daughter/niece that looks like Alicia Silverstone?
him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well, we already know he decks his clothes out in special gear to cool him down, so maybe he has Doctor Schoel's-like pads built into the slippers, except they keep the slippers cold. As for the cigar, a tiny bit of heat like on the tip probably isn't going to hurt him.

to:

** Well, we already know he decks his clothes out in special gear to cool him down, so maybe he has Doctor Schoel's-like pads built into the slippers, except they keep the slippers cold. As for the cigar, a tiny bit of heat like on the tip probably isn't going to hurt him.him.
* Why is Barbera Afred's niece, and not Commissioner Gordon's daughter/niece? What? A bumbling old guy like Gordon can't have a hot daughter/niece that looks like Alicia Silverstone?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If memory serves, the plan wasn't just to keep it frozen, just use the freeze as a way to kill everyone so Ivy could populate the world with her dumb plant monsters. So, had Batman not shown up in the eleven minutes it takes for the freezing victims to die, it wouldn't have mattered if sunlight thawed anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Freeze is deathly allergic to warmth, why does he smoke a cigar and wear polar bear slippers that ''aren't'' frozen like his robe?

to:

* If Freeze is deathly allergic to warmth, why does he smoke a cigar and wear polar bear slippers that ''aren't'' frozen like his robe?robe?
** Well, we already know he decks his clothes out in special gear to cool him down, so maybe he has Doctor Schoel's-like pads built into the slippers, except they keep the slippers cold. As for the cigar, a tiny bit of heat like on the tip probably isn't going to hurt him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If the venom goes in Bane's bloodstream, why is there never any blood going through those tubes on his head? Shouldn't Antonio have bled to death after the tubes were pulled off, or even before he is transformed?

to:

* If the venom goes in Bane's bloodstream, why is there never any blood going through those tubes on his head? Shouldn't Antonio have bled to death after the tubes were pulled off, or even before he is transformed?transformed?
* If Freeze is deathly allergic to warmth, why does he smoke a cigar and wear polar bear slippers that ''aren't'' frozen like his robe?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Bane is brain damaged and can barely walk straight. So how is he able to operate a moving vehicle and obey traffic laws like a normal person?

to:

* Bane is brain damaged and can barely walk straight. So how is he able to operate a moving vehicle and obey traffic laws like a normal person?person?
* If the venom goes in Bane's bloodstream, why is there never any blood going through those tubes on his head? Shouldn't Antonio have bled to death after the tubes were pulled off, or even before he is transformed?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If he can loudly murder somebody in their own lab, he probably considered the entire facility "somewhere safe."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After getting strapped down, why is Antonio just obediently lying still on the operating table instead of trying to escape, knowing full well he is about to experience extreme pain and brain damage? He even does this while being injected with venom!

to:

* After getting strapped down, why is Antonio just obediently lying still on the operating table instead of of, you know, trying to escape, knowing full well escape and avoid the excruciating pain he is about going to experience extreme pain and brain damage? He even does this while being injected with venom!be subjected to? Those shackles look big enough for his hands to squeeze through.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How was Freeze planning to freeze the entire world if sunlight can thaw the ice?

to:

* How was Freeze planning to freeze the entire world if sunlight can thaw the ice?ice?
* Is Bane's mask ever taken off? If not, then how does he keep himself fed? Surely, smashing walls and strangling people would use up a lot of energy.
* How long was Bane just standing in the lab, roaring and flexing, before Poison Ivy picked him up? Didn't Woodrue think about moving him somewhere safe?
* Bane is brain damaged and can barely walk straight. So how is he able to operate a moving vehicle and obey traffic laws like a normal person?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After getting strapped down, why is Antonio just obediently lying still on the operating table instead of trying to escape, knowing full well he is about to experience extreme pain and brain damage? He even does this while being injected with venom!

to:

* After getting strapped down, why is Antonio just obediently lying still on the operating table instead of trying to escape, knowing full well he is about to experience extreme pain and brain damage? He even does this while being injected with venom!venom!
* How was Freeze planning to freeze the entire world if sunlight can thaw the ice?

Top