Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / AngelBeats

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I always assumed it's because of something Angel did.

to:

* I always assumed it's because of something Angel did.did.
* In Yuri's flashback, before her death, she's seen as a child, so why is it she appears as a teenager in the afterlife?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


During the third episode, why did, when the teachers stop the concert, they actively try to [[spoiler:throw Iwasawa's guitar away? I don't claim to be an expert on how NPC's work, but it seems that they would more realistically just confiscate it, instead of just "Hurp Durp, we'll throw it out." The whole reason that confiscation rules exist is so teachers don't just destroy and throw away items that students may have worked hard to get, or may be sentimentally valuable to them.]]

to:

During the third episode, why did, when the teachers stop the concert, they actively try to [[spoiler:throw Iwasawa's guitar away? I don't claim to be an expert on how NPC's work, but it seems that they would more realistically just confiscate it, instead of just "Hurp Durp, we'll throw it out." The whole reason that confiscation rules exist is so teachers don't just destroy and throw away items that students may have worked hard to get, or may be sentimentally valuable to them.]]]]
*I always assumed it's because of something Angel did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Most of these people may not have even known what the weapons looked like before dying, so long as one person could make the machine there is no reason someone else couldn't work it.

to:

* Most of these people may not have even known what the weapons looked like before dying, so long as one person could make the machine there is no reason someone else couldn't work it.it.

During the third episode, why did, when the teachers stop the concert, they actively try to [[spoiler:throw Iwasawa's guitar away? I don't claim to be an expert on how NPC's work, but it seems that they would more realistically just confiscate it, instead of just "Hurp Durp, we'll throw it out." The whole reason that confiscation rules exist is so teachers don't just destroy and throw away items that students may have worked hard to get, or may be sentimentally valuable to them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Guild: why exactly are there so many ''children'' with weapons-making prowess in the afterlife in this day and age? Adults would be improbable enough, but teenagers? And this is only from Japan, remember; nowhere else, where the situation is that much less stable. Even allowing for the fact that these ''are'' people who have led explicitly unhappy (and probably often rough) lives, it seems rather unlikely.

to:

The Guild: why exactly are there so many ''children'' with weapons-making prowess in the afterlife in this day and age? Adults would be improbable enough, but teenagers? And this is only from Japan, remember; nowhere else, where the situation is that much less stable. Even allowing for the fact that these ''are'' people who have led explicitly unhappy (and probably often rough) lives, it seems rather unlikely.unlikely.
* Most of these people may not have even known what the weapons looked like before dying, so long as one person could make the machine there is no reason someone else couldn't work it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Different monitors, and different camera angles catch either one or both? (hasn't checked the scene)

to:

* Different monitors, and different camera angles catch either one or both? (hasn't checked the scene)scene)

The Guild: why exactly are there so many ''children'' with weapons-making prowess in the afterlife in this day and age? Adults would be improbable enough, but teenagers? And this is only from Japan, remember; nowhere else, where the situation is that much less stable. Even allowing for the fact that these ''are'' people who have led explicitly unhappy (and probably often rough) lives, it seems rather unlikely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** I sure hope so. Unfortunately though, the series is not that famous..yet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** We don't know the circumstances of the crash. If it had happened as a result of an earthquake (not unheard of in Japan) there would have been major issues concerning structural integrity while digging; it does no good to dig a passage to them if it's going to collapse the rest of the tunnel. In such a case, with all other possible damage to the surrounding area, it could easily be a week until any disaster relief could get close to the crash to dig them out. As for the latter, stress makes people do irrational things.

Added: 102

Changed: 68

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* They can't really die, but starving just isn't a pleasant feeling.



A minor thing, but in the second computer room, the monitor behind his head displays two hearts on either side of his head sometimes, and a single heart directly behind his head other times.

to:

A minor thing, but in the second computer room, the monitor behind his head displays two hearts on either side of his head sometimes, and a single heart directly behind his head other times.times.
* Different monitors, and different camera angles catch either one or both? (hasn't checked the scene)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The light novel describes the terrain as slowly fading out into thick mist and fog outside the bounds of the school, which probably acts as a type of EnclosedSpace.

to:

** The light novel describes the terrain as slowly fading out into thick mist and fog outside the bounds of the school, which probably acts as a type of EnclosedSpace.
EnclosedSpace / ClosedCircle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The light novel describes the terrain as slowly fading out into thick mist and fog outside the bounds of the school, which probably acts as a type of EnclosedSpace.




to:

* I always assumed that the SSS collected as many tickets as they could afterwards and then gave them out amongst the members until another Operation Tornado was required.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That would remove the whole point of the purgatory, which was to [[spoiler:give children/teenagers the happy youth they never had in order to help them pass on.]] [[spoiler:Keeping the person paralyzed while in the afterlife wouldn't help this much.]] It's also been shown that the SSS doesn't know nearly as much about the afterlife school as they believe they do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n** [[spoiler: According to the other epilogue, yeah, "Purgatory" is still the same.]]





to:

* I just assumed it was how their world works. Maybe the structure of food is too complicated to recreate perfectly, or they just didn't want to take any chances. And yeah, that was weird, but maybe he only managed to grab one because, I dunno, he was running from Angel or something.




to:

*Maybe Otonashi's a special case? Since [[spoiler: Kanade had to have some way of knowing who donated her heart to her?]]




to:

* Yeah, probably. Of course, DeusExMachina can always work too, since it can be justified due to the overall situation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** According to the third drama CD, physical terrain blocks them from moving further... But what if you could fly over it?




to:

* If the third drama CD is to be believed, with [[spoiler: sufficient time and coding prowess, one can indeed change reality.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


So apparently, your memories [[YouFailAnatomyForever are]] [[spoiler: stored in your heart?]]

to:

So apparently, your memories [[YouFailAnatomyForever [[YouFailBiologyForever are]] [[spoiler: stored in your heart?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


So apparently, your memories [[YouFailBiologyForever are]] [[spoiler: stored in your heart?]]

to:

So apparently, your memories [[YouFailBiologyForever [[YouFailAnatomyForever are]] [[spoiler: stored in your heart?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

So apparently, your memories [[YouFailBiologyForever are]] [[spoiler: stored in your heart?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


What happens if someone dies in an enclosed space, with not enough room for another body? Or if their body is split, what if the parts can't come back together? If someone is stuck in an enclosed room or a deathtrap, wouldn't they not be able to go anywhere?

to:

What happens if someone dies in an enclosed space, with not enough room for another body? Or if their body is split, what if the parts can't come back together? If someone is stuck in an enclosed room or a deathtrap, wouldn't they not be able to go anywhere?anywhere?

Why doesn't anyone use [[spoiler:Angel Player to alter reality, or give themselves powers]]? Is there some reason why they can't?

A minor thing, but in the second computer room, the monitor behind his head displays two hearts on either side of his head sometimes, and a single heart directly behind his head other times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Actually, I gathered she died in hospital. The trip was shown since it was important to Otonashi, being the last time he could be with his sister.

to:

** Actually, I gathered she died in hospital. The trip was shown since it was important to Otonashi, being the last time he could be with his sister.sister.

Why on Earth did it take ''an entire week'' for help to arrive at the train crash? And why did that guy think it was a good idea to try to run off with some stolen water... in an enclosed space?

If they can make whatever they can remember from using only dirt, why can't they make food? And why does Otonashi end up with just one meal ticket, when they literally get a couple thousand from Operation Tornado?

Why do they need to eat? Presumably, since [[spoiler:one can survive without a heart]], they wouldn't need a stomach or anything either.

What happens if someone dies in an enclosed space, with not enough room for another body? Or if their body is split, what if the parts can't come back together? If someone is stuck in an enclosed room or a deathtrap, wouldn't they not be able to go anywhere?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* From what I understand, the SSS have taken over the school's principal's office for use as their headquarters/meeting room. I'm just curious as to why the faculty never try to do anything about this. I know NPCs generally brush everything off, but they have shown some exasperation with their antics and will makes moves if propped enough, like during the concert in episode 3. Or are they just tired of getting launched out of the building by that giant hammer trap?
** I don't recall which episode it was exactly, but it was revealed in an episode that, pretty much, no matter what the SSS did, it would be considered "normal" by all the other NPCs. That's why in the sixth episode they're able to get away with eating chips in class, playing a board game, shirtless pushups, going to the bathroom every minute (literally) and sleeping in class (over three student's tables, while they're taking notes no less!)

to:

* From what I understand, the SSS have taken over the school's principal's office for use as their headquarters/meeting room. I'm just curious as to why the faculty never try to do anything about this. I know NPCs [=NPCs=] generally brush everything off, but they have shown some exasperation with their antics and will makes moves if propped enough, like during the concert in episode 3. Or are they just tired of getting launched out of the building by that giant hammer trap?
** I don't recall which episode it was exactly, but it was revealed in an episode that, pretty much, no matter what the SSS did, it would be considered "normal" by all the other NPCs.[=NPCs=]. That's why in the sixth episode they're able to get away with eating chips in class, playing a board game, shirtless pushups, going to the bathroom every minute (literally) and sleeping in class (over three student's tables, while they're taking notes no less!)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Otonashi's DeadLittleSister is heavily implied to have died while he had her out of the hospital without permission. How did he not get in serious trouble for that?

to:

Otonashi's DeadLittleSister is heavily implied to have died while he had her out of the hospital without permission. How did he not get in serious trouble for that?that?
** Actually, I gathered she died in hospital. The trip was shown since it was important to Otonashi, being the last time he could be with his sister.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Otonashi's DeadLittleSister is heavily implied to have died while he had her out of the hospital without permission. How did he not get in serious trouble for that?

to:

* Otonashi's DeadLittleSister is heavily implied to have died while he had her out of the hospital without permission. How did he not get in serious trouble for that?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Otonashi's DeadLittleSister is heavily implied to have died while he had her out of the hospital without permission. How did he not get in serious trouble for that?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Why hasn't anyone tried to move beyond the high school premises? What's beyond those hills? Is it prohibited to move away? There's no mention of it anywhere in the series.

to:

Why hasn't anyone tried to move beyond the high school premises? those hills? What's beyond those hills? Is it prohibited to move away? them? There's no mention of it anywhere in the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Why hasn't anyone tried to move beyond the high school premises? Is it prohibited in a way? There's no mention of it anywhere in the series.

to:

Why hasn't anyone tried to move beyond the high school premises? What's beyond those hills? Is it prohibited in a way? to move away? There's no mention of it anywhere in the series.

Added: 432

Removed: 432

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



The world of Angel Beats resembles the real world quite a bit, to the point that there's is even a sky filled with stars. Now, what would happen if people would look at that sky with a telescope? Would they see the planets normally, or discern galaxies? If so, that world must be rather vast in and of itself. Actually, the same question applies to all series with an alternate or virtual reality, such as the one in ''TheMatrix''.


Added DiffLines:


The world of Angel Beats resembles the real world quite a bit, to the point that there's is even a sky filled with stars. Now, what would happen if people would look at that sky with a telescope? Would they see the planets normally, or discern galaxies? If so, that world must be rather vast in and of itself. Actually, the same question applies to all series with an alternate or virtual reality, such as the one in ''TheMatrix''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** On a related note: where do the vapor trails in the picture as shown on the main page come from? Does that world have planes? If so, where do they come from?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The world of Angel Beats resembles the real world quite a bit, to the point that there's is even a sky filled with stars. Now, what would happen if people would look at that sky with a telescope? Would they see the planets normally, or discern galaxies? If so, that world must be rather vast in and of itself. Actually, the same kind of questions applies to all series with an alternate or virtual reality, such as the one in ''TheMatrix''.

to:

The world of Angel Beats resembles the real world quite a bit, to the point that there's is even a sky filled with stars. Now, what would happen if people would look at that sky with a telescope? Would they see the planets normally, or discern galaxies? If so, that world must be rather vast in and of itself. Actually, the same kind of questions question applies to all series with an alternate or virtual reality, such as the one in ''TheMatrix''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The world of Angel Beats resembles the real world quite a bit, to the point that there's is even a sky filled with stars. Now, what would happen if people would look at that sky with a telescope? Would they see the planets normally, or discern galacies? If so, that world must be rather vast in and of itself. Actually, the same kind of questions applies to all series with an alternate or virtual reality, such as the one in ''TheMatrix''.

to:

The world of Angel Beats resembles the real world quite a bit, to the point that there's is even a sky filled with stars. Now, what would happen if people would look at that sky with a telescope? Would they see the planets normally, or discern galacies? galaxies? If so, that world must be rather vast in and of itself. Actually, the same kind of questions applies to all series with an alternate or virtual reality, such as the one in ''TheMatrix''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I don't recall which episode it was exactly, but it was revealed in an episode that, pretty much, no matter what the SSS did, it would be considered "normal" by all the other NPCs. That's why in the sixth episode they're able to get away with eating chips in class, playing a board game, shirtless pushups, going to the bathroom every minute (literally) and sleeping in class (over three student's tables, while they're taking notes no less!)

to:

** I don't recall which episode it was exactly, but it was revealed in an episode that, pretty much, no matter what the SSS did, it would be considered "normal" by all the other NPCs. That's why in the sixth episode they're able to get away with eating chips in class, playing a board game, shirtless pushups, going to the bathroom every minute (literally) and sleeping in class (over three student's tables, while they're taking notes no less!)less!)

Why hasn't anyone tried to move beyond the high school premises? Is it prohibited in a way? There's no mention of it anywhere in the series.

The world of Angel Beats resembles the real world quite a bit, to the point that there's is even a sky filled with stars. Now, what would happen if people would look at that sky with a telescope? Would they see the planets normally, or discern galacies? If so, that world must be rather vast in and of itself. Actually, the same kind of questions applies to all series with an alternate or virtual reality, such as the one in ''TheMatrix''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* From what I understand, the SSS have taken over the school's principal's office for use as their headquarters/meeting room. I'm just curious as to why the faculty never try to do anything about this. I know NPCs generally brush everything off, but they have shown some exasperation with their antics and will makes moves if propped enough, like during the concert in episode 3. Or are they just tired of getting launched out of the building by that giant hammer trap?

to:

* From what I understand, the SSS have taken over the school's principal's office for use as their headquarters/meeting room. I'm just curious as to why the faculty never try to do anything about this. I know NPCs generally brush everything off, but they have shown some exasperation with their antics and will makes moves if propped enough, like during the concert in episode 3. Or are they just tired of getting launched out of the building by that giant hammer trap?trap?
** I don't recall which episode it was exactly, but it was revealed in an episode that, pretty much, no matter what the SSS did, it would be considered "normal" by all the other NPCs. That's why in the sixth episode they're able to get away with eating chips in class, playing a board game, shirtless pushups, going to the bathroom every minute (literally) and sleeping in class (over three student's tables, while they're taking notes no less!)

Top