History Funny / PiratesSMP

** Later, Kyle tries experimenting with lasso mechanics by dragging Water behind him in a boat to see if the Great Thrasher would get to her. He somehow gets struck by lightning while attempting this.

* Day 24: Kyle lending Cruppy a ''gun'' in exchange for a lasso.

* Day 24: Kyle giving Cruppy a ''gun'' in exchange for a lasso.

** Kyle giving Cruppy a ''gun'' in exchange for a lasso.

** The fact that Owen's VOD is titled "The terrible awful horrible run-in with a bug".
** While charting the borders of the accessible seas, Owen finds an old journal on "The Shipwreck" questline island where a former crew member wrote about fishing there for almost 70 years after the crash, with added responses from Kyle and Apo mocking him for spending those 70 years stranded instead of trying to get off the island. Owen's addition to the journal calls them out for being rude and says they'd learn something if they sat down and listened for once, then lists one time he "spoke to him about a lost treasure, and he said"... Cut to the next page, and the ''[[BaitAndSwitch rest]]'' of Owen's entry is him spamming "L"s about how the reader is gullible enough to think there was actually treasure there.

* Day 25: Eloise's livestream is sponsored by [=WhatsApp=], whose services she analogizes as a MessageInABottle, except it only lands on one beach, and the person opening it can only read the message if they input an certain PIN code. She also explains its encryption service in that no seagulls will be able to steal the message like it does food.

*** Star then denies any involvement when ''four different people'', including stars brother (who's questionably involved with Sausage himself), climb up to see what's going on. This is in spite of [[ImplausibleDeniability the very clear and public in-game chat message]] announcing that "[[gold:Kestrel [=MythicalSausage=]]] was doomed to fall by [[blue:Nightingale acho]]".

* There's an old diary in a run-down house on the island for "The Shipwreck" treasure questline, explaining how the man who lived there moved there after the ship went down and spent 70 years fishing on the island. The ''rest'' of the diary is quickly filled with various server-members (Kyle, Apo, and Owen) mocking the old man for wasting his years fishing away, an entry from Graecie yelling at everyone else for mocking the old man and being all-around insensitive, a couple more entries (Martyn and Will) saying they didn't bother reading all that, and finally Sniff commenting that they're "a bit lost lol".

* There's an old diary in a run-down house on the island for "The Shipwreck" treasure questline, explaining how the man who lived there was stranded, lost everything, and spent 70 years fishing on the island. The ''rest'' of the diary is filled with various server-members (Kyle, Apo, and Owen) mocking the old man for wasting his years fishing away, an entry from Graecie yelling at everyone else for mocking the old man and being all-around insensitive, a couple more entries (Martyn and Will) saying they didn't bother reading all that, and finally Sniff commenting that they're "a bit lost lol".

** At every single mention of Owen's name in Gabriel's journals, Cleo and Eloise [[LemonyNarrator makes a comment about]] how this questionably romantic relationship has gone to the point of obsession.

** At the end of his stream for the day, Sausage manages to get a date with Alison and spends a good chunk of it... ''dancing''. His chat, forced to play ThirdWheel to the entire ordeal, is split between cheering him on for actually having the charisma to pull this off or crying for BrainBleach.
--->'''[=Wassup_im_E=]:''' youre paying for all our therapy.

** Finn seems to be under the impression that Bek is a large creature with scales and wings... then Sausage somehow makes the situation ''worse''. It's exacerbated by the fact that Bek is still awake enough to hear Sausage's half of the NewhartPhonecall ''and aro/ace''.
--->'''[=MythicalSausage=]:''' what do you think would happen if bekyamon were to breed with another sea creature?\\

** After more discussion, Kyle, Sausage, and Water try to convince Bek to "transform into her true form"... only for her to relog wearing a WesternAnimation/PeppaPig skin and have her IGN changed to 'Peppayamon'.
** Cleo then tries to set the record straight, telling Finn that Bek is just a regular human with one eye... [[BaitAndSwitch then]] adds that "[[{{Cyclops}} the eye is in the middle of their forehead]]" and that they have "seven pointed teeth".

* Every time a time a creator-character makes an innuendo, sometimes even when ''not flirting with anyone'' (while the viewers collectively take psychic damage).

** Cleo then tries to set the record straight, telling Finn that Bek is just a regular human with one eye... [[BaitAndSwitch then]] adds that "[[{{Cyclops}} the eye is in the middle of their forehead]]".

:::: After more discussion, Kyle, Sausage, and Water try to convince Bek to "transform into her true form"... only for her to relog wearing a WesternAnimation/PeppaPig skin and have her IGN changed to 'Peppayamon'.