Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / RedRidingHood

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!Per wiki policy, Administrivia/SpoilersOff applies here and all spoilers are unmarked. Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As far as Suzette (Valerie's mother) knows, everyone she loves except Valerie -- Henry's father, Lucy, and Valerie's father (though whether or not she ''truly'' loved him was debatable)-- is dead, and Valerie has moved into the woods, and very well may vanish herself in the near future. Poor thing.

to:

* As far as Suzette (Valerie's mother) knows, everyone she loves except Valerie -- Henry's father, Lucy, father Adrien, Lucie, and Valerie's father (though whether or not she ''truly'' loved him was debatable)-- is dead, and Valerie has moved into the woods, and very well may vanish herself in the near future. Poor thing.



* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that she had a crush on her half-brother. Which is stated outright from Suzette as to why she put Valerie together with him instead.

to:

* Plus, remember Lucy Lucie being in love with Henry? Well, this means that she had a crush on her half-brother. Which is stated outright from Suzette as to why she put Valerie together with him instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wick cleaning


** IncestIsRelative, but she probably doesn't even know Henry is related to her.

to:

** IncestIsRelative, but she She probably doesn't even know Henry is related to her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the book, Valerie's mom noted how unimaginative her husband was, unable to dream of a life beyond being poor farmers. [[spoiler: This becomes ironic when in the movie, it's revealed that the werewolf and Valerie's father are one-and-the-same, given the werewolf ''does'' dream of a better life, where they can move to the city, rob rich folk and feast on them (two birds with one stone).]]

to:

* In the book, Valerie's mom noted how unimaginative her husband was, unable to dream of a life beyond being poor farmers. [[spoiler: This becomes ironic when in the movie, it's revealed that the werewolf and Valerie's father are one-and-the-same, given the werewolf ''does'' dream of a better life, where they can move to the city, rob rich folk and feast on them (two birds with one stone).]]stone).



* [[spoiler:As far as Suzette (Valerie's mother) knows, everyone she loves except Valerie -- Henry's father, Lucy, and Valerie's father (though whether or not she ''truly'' loved him was debatable)-- is dead, and Valerie has moved into the woods, and very well may vanish herself in the near future. Poor thing.]]
* A different sort of FridgeHorror comes up when you realize the film implies [[spoiler:Cesaire very well may have turned his own mother into stew, which Valerie eats a bite of before stopping herself]]. Something very similar to this happens in older versions of Red Riding Hood.
* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother]]. Which is stated outright from Suzette as to why she put Valerie together with him instead.

to:

* [[spoiler:As As far as Suzette (Valerie's mother) knows, everyone she loves except Valerie -- Henry's father, Lucy, and Valerie's father (though whether or not she ''truly'' loved him was debatable)-- is dead, and Valerie has moved into the woods, and very well may vanish herself in the near future. Poor thing.]]

* A different sort of FridgeHorror comes up when you realize the film implies [[spoiler:Cesaire Cesaire very well may have turned his own mother into stew, which Valerie eats a bite of before stopping herself]].herself. Something very similar to this happens in older versions of Red Riding Hood.
* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she she had a crush on her half-brother]].half-brother. Which is stated outright from Suzette as to why she put Valerie together with him instead.



[[Headscratchers/RedRidingHood Go here]]

to:

[[Headscratchers/RedRidingHood Go here]]here]]

----

Added: 393

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Father Solomon's children may seem strange, given he is a priest and apparently pretty high-ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an Orthodox village, hence,it makes sense for Father Solomon to have children as Orthodox priests aren't banned from being married.

to:

* Father Solomon's children may seem strange, given he is a priest and apparently pretty high-ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an Orthodox village, hence,it hence it makes sense for Father Solomon to have children as Orthodox priests aren't banned from being married.


Added DiffLines:

** Another possibility is he's an Eastern Rite Catholic, who often don't practice (mandatory) clerical celibacy. Western Ukrainian clergy of the Greek Catholic Church even make up a hereditary caste. However, they must marry before being ordained. Bishops also must have been celibate clerics (thus are usually former monks) in Eastern Catholic and Orthodox churches, just like the Latin Rite.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's also worth noting that "no marriage" was something that evolved over time with more isolated areas having priesthoods be passed down through families similar to various trades.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Even if you remembered that in the original fairytale a woodcutter saves Red from the wolf, the film has two woodcutters who'd have a personal reason to save Valerie, so knowing the original story provides you with no useful hint as to who the wolf could not be.
* Father Solomon's children may seem strange,given he is a priest and apparently pretty high ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an Orthodox village, hence, it makes sense for Father Solomon to have children as Orthodox priests aren't banned from being married.

to:

* Even if you remembered that in the original fairytale fairy tale a woodcutter saves Red from the wolf, the film has two woodcutters who'd have a personal reason to save Valerie, so knowing the original story provides you with no useful hint as to who the wolf could not be.
* Father Solomon's children may seem strange,given strange, given he is a priest and apparently pretty high ranked. high-ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an Orthodox village, hence, it hence,it makes sense for Father Solomon to have children as Orthodox priests aren't banned from being married.



* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomon's story of his wife draws its roots from an early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf hunter who shot a silver bullet at a werewolf and as it ran, he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. He didn't find the body, (A little fuzzy if he fould the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.

to:

* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomon's story of his wife draws its roots from an early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf professional werewolf hunter who shot a silver bullet at a werewolf and as it ran, he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. He didn't find the body, (A (a little fuzzy if he fould found the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans woman's stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.




to:

** I think that story originated simply with the werewolf's paw being severed through a knife (very similar to the film) and was then updated in later versions (like most folklore) after silver was added as harming them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the book, Valerie's mom noted how unimaginative her husband was, unable to imagine a life beyond being poor farmers. [[spoiler: This becomes ironic when in the movie, it's revealed that the werewolf and Valerie's father are one-and-the-same, given the werewolf ''does'' dream of a better life, where they can move to the city, rob rich folk and feast on them (two birds with one stone).]]

to:

* In the book, Valerie's mom noted how unimaginative her husband was, unable to imagine dream of a life beyond being poor farmers. [[spoiler: This becomes ironic when in the movie, it's revealed that the werewolf and Valerie's father are one-and-the-same, given the werewolf ''does'' dream of a better life, where they can move to the city, rob rich folk and feast on them (two birds with one stone).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the book, Valerie's mom noted how unimaginative her husband was, unable to imagine a life beyond being poor farmers. [[spoiler: This becomes ironic when in the movie, it's revealed that the werewolf and Valerie's father are one-and-the-same, given the werewolf ''does'' dream of a better life, where they can move to the city, rob rich folk and feast on them (two birds with one stone).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually the idea of the werewolf's supposed vulnerability to silver dates back to the legend of the Beast of Gévaudan, in which a gigantic wolf is killed by a hunter with the name of "Argent" which is Latin for silver, wielding a gun loaded with silver bullets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** This troper heard of a tale similar to the one described above but the bullet wasn't silver, it was "blessed" and the woman claimed her hand was maimed from a occupational hazard, I can't remember what though.

Added: 378

Changed: 1182

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Father Solomon's children may seem strange,given he is a priest and apparently pretty high ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an Orthodox village, hence, it makes sense for Father Solomon to have children as Orthodox priets aren't banned from being married.
* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomons story of his wife draws its roots from an early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf hunter who shot a silver bullet at a werewolf and as it ran, he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. He didn't find the body, (A little fuzzy if he fould the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.

to:

* Father Solomon's children may seem strange,given he is a priest and apparently pretty high ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an Orthodox village, hence, it makes sense for Father Solomon to have children as Orthodox priets priests aren't banned from being married.
** There's a problem with that, however: Father Auguste refers to Father Solomon's silver sword as having been "blessed by the Holy See," a clear reference to the papacy, and thence to the western church. It's possible that Solomon entered the priesthood after his wife died.
* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomons Solomon's story of his wife draws its roots from an early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf hunter who shot a silver bullet at a werewolf and as it ran, he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. He didn't find the body, (A little fuzzy if he fould the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.
** That can't be that old a werewolf story, since the idea that werewolves were vulnerable to silver was invented by Hollywood in the twentieth century. Also, barbed wire fences were only invented in the nineteenth century. Werewolf legends are much older than that; the story of Lykaon comes from ancient Greece, so werewolf myths existed in some form at least that far back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No need to say it twice.


* Anyone thinking of using the original fairy tale (where Red is saved by a woodcutter) to eliminate who isn't the werewolf would be disappointed as two of the main suspects, Peter and Cesaire, are ''both'' woodcutters, so either could be the rescuer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]

to:

[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]!!FridgeBrilliance



[[AC:FridgeHorror]]

to:

[[AC:FridgeHorror]]!!FridgeHorror



* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]] Which is stated outright from Suzette as to why she put Valerie together with him instead.
** IncestIsRelative

!FridgeLogic

to:

* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]] half-brother]]. Which is stated outright from Suzette as to why she put Valerie together with him instead.
instead.
** IncestIsRelative

!FridgeLogic
IncestIsRelative, but she probably doesn't even know Henry is related to her.

!!FridgeLogic
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]] Which is stated outright from Suzette as why she put Valerie together with him instead.

to:

* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]] Which is stated outright from Suzette as to why she put Valerie together with him instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Father Solomon's children may seem strange,given he is a priest and apparently pretty high ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an orthodox village, hence, it makes sense for father solomon to have children as orthodox priets aren't banned from being married.

to:

* Father Solomon's children may seem strange,given he is a priest and apparently pretty high ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an orthodox Orthodox village, hence, it makes sense for father solomon Father Solomon to have children as orthodox Orthodox priets aren't banned from being married.



* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomons story of his wife draws its roots from an early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf hunter shot a silver bullet at a werewolf as it ran, he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. Not finding the body, (A little fuzzy if he fould the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.

to:

* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomons story of his wife draws its roots from an early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf hunter who shot a silver bullet at a werewolf and as it ran, he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. Not finding He didn't find the body, (A little fuzzy if he fould the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.



* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]]

to:

* Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]] Which is stated outright from Suzette as why she put Valerie together with him instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!FridgeBrilliance

to:

!FridgeBrilliance[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]



!FridgeHorror

to:

!FridgeHorror[[AC:FridgeHorror]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A different sort of FridgeHorror comes up when you realize the film implies [[spoiler:Cesaire very well may have turned his own mother into stew, which Valerie eats a bite of before stopping herself]]. Something very similar to this happens in older versions of Red Riding Hood.
** Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]]
*** IncestIsRelative

to:

** * A different sort of FridgeHorror comes up when you realize the film implies [[spoiler:Cesaire very well may have turned his own mother into stew, which Valerie eats a bite of before stopping herself]]. Something very similar to this happens in older versions of Red Riding Hood.
** * Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]]
*** ** IncestIsRelative
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomons story of his wife draws its roots from n early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf hunter shot a silver bullet at a werewolf as it ran,he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. Not finding the body, (A little fuzzy if he fould the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.

to:

* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomons story of his wife draws its roots from n an early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf hunter shot a silver bullet at a werewolf as it ran,he ran, he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. Not finding the body, (A little fuzzy if he fould the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wobble3



to:

* This is more of a supernatural geek FridgeBrilliance. Father Solomons story of his wife draws its roots from n early werewolf tale of a professonal Werewolf hunter shot a silver bullet at a werewolf as it ran,he saw he had severed the paw from the wrist. Not finding the body, (A little fuzzy if he fould the paw or not), but the wolf never attacked again. Years later, a doctor heard the story and confessed to bandaging a womans stump of a hand when she claimed she lost it to a barbed fence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Anyone thinking of using the original fairy tale (where Red is saved by a woodcutter) to eliminate who isn't the werewolf would be disappointed as two of the main suspects, Peter and Cesaire, are ''both'' woodcutters, so either could be the rescuer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: As far as Suzette (Valerie's mother) knows, everyone she loves except Valerie -- Henry's father, Lucy, and Valerie's father (though whether or not she ''truly'' loved him was debatable)-- is dead, and Valerie has moved into the woods, and very well may vanish herself in the near future. Poor thing.]]
** A different sort of FridgeHorror comes up when you realize the film implies [[spoiler: Cesaire very well may have turned his own mother into stew, which Valerie eats a bite of before stopping herself]]. Something very similar to this happens in older versions of Red Riding Hood.
** Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler: she had a crush on her half-brother.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: As [[spoiler:As far as Suzette (Valerie's mother) knows, everyone she loves except Valerie -- Henry's father, Lucy, and Valerie's father (though whether or not she ''truly'' loved him was debatable)-- is dead, and Valerie has moved into the woods, and very well may vanish herself in the near future. Poor thing.]]
** A different sort of FridgeHorror comes up when you realize the film implies [[spoiler: Cesaire [[spoiler:Cesaire very well may have turned his own mother into stew, which Valerie eats a bite of before stopping herself]]. Something very similar to this happens in older versions of Red Riding Hood.
** Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler: she [[spoiler:she had a crush on her half-brother.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Father Solomon's children may seem strange,given he is a priest and apparently pretty high ranked. But if you look at the cross on the roof of the church, it is clear we are dealing with an orthodox village, hence, it makes sense for father solomon to have children as orthodox priets aren't banned from being married.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[JustBugsMe/RedRidingHood Go here]]

to:

[[JustBugsMe/RedRidingHood [[Headscratchers/RedRidingHood Go here]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler: she had a crush on her half-brother.]] Um.... EWWWWW!

to:

** Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler: she had a crush on her half-brother.]] Um.... EWWWWW!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** {{Incest is Relative}}

to:

*** {{Incest is Relative}}
IncestIsRelative
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** {{Incest is Relative}}
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Plus, remember Lucy being in love with Henry? Well, this means that [[spoiler: she had a crush on her half-brother.]] Um.... EWWWWW!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!FridgeBrilliance
* Even if you remembered that in the original fairytale a woodcutter saves Red from the wolf, the film has two woodcutters who'd have a personal reason to save Valerie, so knowing the original story provides you with no useful hint as to who the wolf could not be.






Top