Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / Prisoners

Go To

OR

Changed: 1117

Removed: 843

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So if Bob Taylor didn't kill the girls or any other children, why did both girls' parents identify their clothes as those he had? Was it just the same kind which they thought were these?
** He stole the clothes from their houses. That's why Keller found the other sock below the window.
* Does Bob Taylor have any other role than a red herring? I mean, he is not the perpetrator, so why bother going the extra mile, stealing clothes, drenching them in blood and everything? At first, I thought he was to become a scapegoat for the real kidnapper, but said kidnapper stated that Bob had been forgotten.
** The theory that Loki and the police came up with is that Bob Taylor is deeply traumatized from his own abduction and re-enacting the methods of his kidnappers. He is aware of where the girls live from the vigil, not because he took them.
* It's entirely possible that if Keller hadn't acted as he did, [[spoiler: the girls wouldn't have survived]]. Keller only (unknowingly) goes to the location of the girls to apologize for his behavior and later [[spoiler: Joy identifies Keller having been there]], which tells Keller where they were. He attempts to rescue his daughter himself but fails. The only reason Loki enters the scene is to [[spoiler: inform Holly that Alex, her nephew]] has been found. The culprit is already administering lethal injection at this point, so it would have been too late if Loki hadn't come at that very moment.

to:

* So if Bob Taylor didn't kill the girls or any other children, why did both girls' parents identify their clothes as those he had? Was it just the same kind which they thought were these?
** He stole the clothes from their houses. That's why Keller found the other sock below the window.
* Does Bob Taylor have any other role than a red herring? I mean, he is not the perpetrator, so why bother going the extra mile, stealing clothes, drenching them in blood and everything? At first, I thought he was to become a scapegoat for the real kidnapper, but said kidnapper stated that Bob had been forgotten.
** The theory that Loki and the police came up with is that Bob Taylor is deeply traumatized from his own abduction and re-enacting the methods of his kidnappers. He is aware of where the girls live from the vigil, not because he took them.
[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]
* It's entirely possible that if Keller hadn't acted as he did, [[spoiler: the girls wouldn't have survived]]. Keller only (unknowingly) goes to the location of the girls to apologize for his behavior and later [[spoiler: Joy identifies Keller having been there]], which tells Keller where they were. He attempts to rescue his daughter himself but fails. The only reason Loki enters the scene is to [[spoiler: inform Holly that Alex, her nephew]] has been found. The culprit is already administering lethal injection at this point, so it would have been too late if Loki hadn't come at that very moment.moment.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Grammatical redundancy


* It's entirely possible that if Keller hadn't acted as he did, [[spoiler: the girls wouldn't have survived]]. Keller only (unknowingly) goes to the location of the girls to apologize for his behavior and later [[spoiler: Joy identifies Keller having been there]], which tells Keller where they were. He attempts to rescue his daughter himself but fails. The only reason Loki enters the scene is to inform the [[spoiler: inform Holly that Alex, her nephew]] has been found. The culprit is already administering lethal injection at this point, so it would have been too late if Loki hadn't come at that very moment.

to:

* It's entirely possible that if Keller hadn't acted as he did, [[spoiler: the girls wouldn't have survived]]. Keller only (unknowingly) goes to the location of the girls to apologize for his behavior and later [[spoiler: Joy identifies Keller having been there]], which tells Keller where they were. He attempts to rescue his daughter himself but fails. The only reason Loki enters the scene is to inform the [[spoiler: inform Holly that Alex, her nephew]] has been found. The culprit is already administering lethal injection at this point, so it would have been too late if Loki hadn't come at that very moment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's entirely possible that without Keller assaulting and then abducting Alex, the girls may not have lived. Keller only visits the Jones' home to apologize to Holly for his behavior, and then later Joy says that Keller was at the place they were being held. While he does go back to the Jones' house, Holly ends up throwing him in the pit before he can save Anna. The only reason Loki gets sent to the Jones' house is to inform Holly that her nephew had been found-- Holly was already giving Anna a lethal injection. It would have been too late when or if Joy remembered where she was. What Keller did was brutal, but ultimately saved the girls.

to:

* It's entirely possible that without if Keller assaulting and then abducting Alex, hadn't acted as he did, [[spoiler: the girls may not wouldn't have lived. survived]]. Keller only visits (unknowingly) goes to the Jones' home location of the girls to apologize to Holly for his behavior, behavior and then later [[spoiler: Joy says that identifies Keller was at the place having been there]], which tells Keller where they were being held. While he does go back were. He attempts to the Jones' house, Holly ends up throwing him in the pit before he can save Anna. rescue his daughter himself but fails. The only reason Loki gets sent to enters the Jones' house scene is to inform the [[spoiler: inform Holly that Alex, her nephew had nephew]] has been found-- Holly was found. The culprit is already giving Anna a administering lethal injection. It injection at this point, so it would have been too late when or if Joy remembered where she was. What Keller did was brutal, but ultimately saved the girls.Loki hadn't come at that very moment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The theory that Loki and the police came up with is that Bob Taylor is deeply traumatized from his own abduction and re-enacting the methods of his kidnappers. He is aware of where the girls live from the vigil, not because he took them.

to:

** The theory that Loki and the police came up with is that Bob Taylor is deeply traumatized from his own abduction and re-enacting the methods of his kidnappers. He is aware of where the girls live from the vigil, not because he took them.them.
* It's entirely possible that without Keller assaulting and then abducting Alex, the girls may not have lived. Keller only visits the Jones' home to apologize to Holly for his behavior, and then later Joy says that Keller was at the place they were being held. While he does go back to the Jones' house, Holly ends up throwing him in the pit before he can save Anna. The only reason Loki gets sent to the Jones' house is to inform Holly that her nephew had been found-- Holly was already giving Anna a lethal injection. It would have been too late when or if Joy remembered where she was. What Keller did was brutal, but ultimately saved the girls.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Does Bob Taylor have any other role than a red herring? I mean, he is not the perpetrator, so why bother going the extra mile, stealing clothes, drenching them in blood and everything? At first, I thought he was to become a scapegoat for the real kidnapper, but said kidnapper stated that Bob had been forgotten.

to:

* Does Bob Taylor have any other role than a red herring? I mean, he is not the perpetrator, so why bother going the extra mile, stealing clothes, drenching them in blood and everything? At first, I thought he was to become a scapegoat for the real kidnapper, but said kidnapper stated that Bob had been forgotten.forgotten.
** The theory that Loki and the police came up with is that Bob Taylor is deeply traumatized from his own abduction and re-enacting the methods of his kidnappers. He is aware of where the girls live from the vigil, not because he took them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Does Bob Taylor have any other role than a red herring? I mean, he is not the perpetrator, so why bother going the extra mile, stealing clothes, drenching them in blood and everything? At firsf, I thought he was to become a scapegoat for the real kidnapper, but said kidnapper stated that Bob had been forgotten.

to:

* Does Bob Taylor have any other role than a red herring? I mean, he is not the perpetrator, so why bother going the extra mile, stealing clothes, drenching them in blood and everything? At firsf, first, I thought he was to become a scapegoat for the real kidnapper, but said kidnapper stated that Bob had been forgotten.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He stole the clothes from their houses. That's why Keller found the other sock below the window.

to:

** He stole the clothes from their houses. That's why Keller found the other sock below the window.window.
* Does Bob Taylor have any other role than a red herring? I mean, he is not the perpetrator, so why bother going the extra mile, stealing clothes, drenching them in blood and everything? At firsf, I thought he was to become a scapegoat for the real kidnapper, but said kidnapper stated that Bob had been forgotten.

Changed: 99

Removed: 98

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* He stole the clothes from their houses. That's why Keller found the other sock below the window.

to:

\n* ** He stole the clothes from their houses. That's why Keller found the other sock below the window.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So if Bob Taylor didn't kill the girls or any other children, why did both girls' parents identify their clothes as those he had? Was it just the same kind which they thought were these?

to:

* So if Bob Taylor didn't kill the girls or any other children, why did both girls' parents identify their clothes as those he had? Was it just the same kind which they thought were these?these?

* He stole the clothes from their houses. That's why Keller found the other sock below the window.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* So if Bob Taylor didn't kill the girls or any other children, why did both girls' parents identify their clothes as those he had? Was it just the same kind which they thought were these?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
most of these aren\'t examples. Moving Keller/Killer to Meaningful Name


[[AC:FridgeHorror]]
* After the horrific ordeal that Alex Jones is put through not only is he [[spoiler: not really responsible for the girls being abducted]] but he is also [[spoiler:a victim of the same abductor.]]
** I don't know about that, he [[spoiler: did kidnap the girls and bring them to Holly, even if he didn't intend to hurt them.]]
*** Technically, he [[spoiler:only took them for a joyride in the van. It was his mother who "decided they should stay", in her own words; at the time Alex actually took them it apparently wasn't even a kidnapping. ''Holly'' turned it into a kidnapping by not letting them leave the van after the ride was over.]]
* It seems odd that Mr. Jones, [[spoiler:a supposed Satanist proudly waging a war against God, would confess his sins to a priest. Perhaps this confession was a sign that he was beginning to reform and that, by murdering Mr. Jones, the priest inadvertently carried out a HeelFaceDoorSlam]].
** The priest claimed that Jones [[spoiler: ''boasted'' about the murders, and said he'd kill again. His motivations for "confessing" are never really made clear, but is seemed to me that he was basically taunting the priest ForTheEvulz.]]
*** [[spoiler:When you think about it, it can be seen as Mr. Jones swan song: his whole motivation for carrying out the murders was "taking souls away from God" as revenge for God "killing" his son with cancer. Mr. Jones ends up making ''the priest kill him'' by confessing his murders and boasting he would kill again (basically daring the priest to stop him). He didn't just manage to take a soul away from the path of God, he took one of His shepherds'. And it worked: the priest's alcoholism may even be caused by his guilty conscience.]]
* Keller sounds like 'killer'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
grammar


*** [[spoiler:When you think about it, it can be seen as Mr. Jones Swan Song: his whole motivation for carrying out the murders is "taking souls away from God" as revenge for God "killing" his son with cancer. Mr. Jones ends up making the ''priest kill him''. He didn't just manage to take a soul away from the path of God, he took one of his shepherds. And it worked: the priest's alcoholism may even be caused by his guilty conscience.]]

to:

*** [[spoiler:When you think about it, it can be seen as Mr. Jones Swan Song: swan song: his whole motivation for carrying out the murders is was "taking souls away from God" as revenge for God "killing" his son with cancer. Mr. Jones ends up making the ''priest ''the priest kill him''. him'' by confessing his murders and boasting he would kill again (basically daring the priest to stop him). He didn't just manage to take a soul away from the path of God, he took one of his shepherds.His shepherds'. And it worked: the priest's alcoholism may even be caused by his guilty conscience.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added possible explanation to why Mr Jones went to confess

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler:When you think about it, it can be seen as Mr. Jones Swan Song: his whole motivation for carrying out the murders is "taking souls away from God" as revenge for God "killing" his son with cancer. Mr. Jones ends up making the ''priest kill him''. He didn't just manage to take a soul away from the path of God, he took one of his shepherds. And it worked: the priest's alcoholism may even be caused by his guilty conscience.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The priest claimed that Jones [[spoiler: ''boasted'' about the murders, and said he'd kill again. His motivations for this are never really made clear, but my interpretation is that he was basically taunting the priest ForTheEvulz.]]

to:

** The priest claimed that Jones [[spoiler: ''boasted'' about the murders, and said he'd kill again. His motivations for this "confessing" are never really made clear, but my interpretation is seemed to me that he was basically taunting the priest ForTheEvulz.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The priest claimed that Jones [[spoiler: ''boasted'' about the murders, and said he'd kill again. His motivations for this are never really made clear, but my interpretation is that he was basically taunting the priest ForTheEvulz.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It seems odd that Mr. Jones, [[spoiler:a supposed Satanist proudly waging a war against God, would confess his sins to a priest. Perhaps this confession was a sign that he was beginning to reform and that, by murdering Mr. Jones, the priest inadvertently carried out a HeelFaceDoorSlam]].

to:

* It seems odd that Mr. Jones, [[spoiler:a supposed Satanist proudly waging a war against God, would confess his sins to a priest. Perhaps this confession was a sign that he was beginning to reform and that, by murdering Mr. Jones, the priest inadvertently carried out a HeelFaceDoorSlam]].HeelFaceDoorSlam]].
*Keller sounds like 'killer'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Technically, he [[spoiler:only took them for a joyride in the van. It was his mother who "decided they should stay", in her own words; at the time Alex actually took them it apparently wasn't even a kidnapping. ''Holly'' turned it into a kidnapping by not letting them leave the van after the ride was over.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:FridgeHorror]]



** I don't know about that, he [[spoiler: did kidnap the girls and bring them to Holly, even if he didn't intend to hurt them.]]

to:

** I don't know about that, he [[spoiler: did kidnap the girls and bring them to Holly, even if he didn't intend to hurt them.]]]]
* It seems odd that Mr. Jones, [[spoiler:a supposed Satanist proudly waging a war against God, would confess his sins to a priest. Perhaps this confession was a sign that he was beginning to reform and that, by murdering Mr. Jones, the priest inadvertently carried out a HeelFaceDoorSlam]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After the horrific ordeal that Alex Jones is put through not only is he [[spoiler: not really responsible for the girls being abducted]] but he is also [[spoiler:a victim of the same abductor.]]

to:

* After the horrific ordeal that Alex Jones is put through not only is he [[spoiler: not really responsible for the girls being abducted]] but he is also [[spoiler:a victim of the same abductor.]]
** I don't know about that, he [[spoiler: did kidnap the girls and bring them to Holly, even if he didn't intend to hurt them.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* After the horrific ordeal that Alex Jones is put through not only is he [[spoiler: not really responsible for the girls being abducted]] but he is also [[spoiler:a victim of the same abductor.]]

Top