Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / PiratesOfTheCaribbean

Go To

OR

Added: 894

Changed: 331

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The first time I wondered why Davy Jones was so hell bent on getting Jack's soul... to the point where he wants 100 souls in exchange for it. It's not like he has any trouble find desperate sailors willing to crew his ship. Then I realize there are two very good reasons why he might want Jack in particular trapped in the Locker
** Jack is a Pirate Lord and holds one of the 9 Pieces of Eight. If Jack is trapped in the Locker along with the piece then there is no way to release Calpyso. Jones still loves Calypso but he also hates her for betraying him. This way Jones can keep Calypso trapped forever if he wants to and if at some point he chooses to release her it would be simple enough for him to take the piece from the Locker. Noone (least of all Jones) expected Barbossa & Co would go to save Jack... or that they would succeed
** It's implied several times in Dead Mans Chest and At Worlds End that Jack and Tia had a sexual relationship in the past and it didn't end very well. In At World's End its revealed Tia is the goddess Calypso, true love of Davy Jones and the reason he tore out his heart. If Davy knew about Jack's affair with Tia then he would no doubt want revenge on Jack for sleeping with his woman!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The one with the wooden eye mentions that they "didn't find out they needed his blood to lift the curse until after" they had thrown him overboard, and they threw him overboard because he thought they deserved the curse. So obviously, after they realized they were cursed, and started trying to find a way to break it. Before they found one, Bootstrab is thrown overboard for some slight involving it. Then they somehow ( the Voodoo Queen who turned out to be Calypso, perhaps?) find out how to break the curse, and then go looking for the only source of Turner blood left: Will.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Angelica also provides FridgeBrilliance for Will Turner, and Jack's insistence that "pirate is in your blood." In [[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanTheCurseOfTheBlackPearl Curse of the Black Pearl]] why is Jack so certain that Will will turn out to be a "pirate" (metaphorically or literally) like his father? He probably witnessed Angelica go through a similar identity crisis. Angelica clearly tried to fight the pirate in her by becoming a nun, but after being seduced by Jack, accepted that she had too much of her father in her for that life. Granted, Jack had no idea her father was Blackbeard until [[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanOnStrangerTides On Stranger Tides]], but he still may have known her father was a pirate.

to:

* Angelica also provides FridgeBrilliance for Will Turner, and Jack's insistence that "pirate is in your blood." In [[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanTheCurseOfTheBlackPearl ''[[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanTheCurseOfTheBlackPearl Curse of the Black Pearl]] Pearl]]'' why is Jack so certain that Will will turn out to be a "pirate" (metaphorically or literally) like his father? He probably witnessed Angelica go through a similar identity crisis. Angelica clearly tried to fight the pirate in her by becoming a nun, but after being seduced by Jack, accepted that she had too much of her father in her for that life. Granted, Jack had no idea her father was Blackbeard until [[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanOnStrangerTides ''[[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanOnStrangerTides On Stranger Tides]], Tides]]'', but he still may have known her father was a pirate.



* Take a good look at the ''PiratesOfTheCaribbean'' skull logo. Red scarf, plaits, the coins, the beads - yep, that's Captain Jack Sparrow. Or what remains of him. Just to drive the point home, attached to the plaits is a Captain Jack Sparrow voodoo doll.

to:

* Take a good look at the ''PiratesOfTheCaribbean'' ''Pirates of the Caribbean'' skull logo. Red scarf, plaits, the coins, the beads - yep, that's Captain Jack Sparrow. Or what remains of him. Just to drive the point home, attached to the plaits is a Captain Jack Sparrow voodoo doll.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Angelica also provides FridgeBrilliance for Will Turner, and Jack's insistence that "pirate is in your blood." In [[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanTheCurseOfTheBlackPearl Curse of the Black Pearl]] why is Jack so certain that Will will turn out to be a "pirate" (metaphorically or literally) like his father? He probably witnessed Angelica go through a similar identity crisis. Angelica clearly tried to fight the pirate in her by becoming a nun, but after being seduced by Jack, accepted that she had too much of her father in her for that life. Granted, Jack had no idea her father was Blackbeard until [[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanOnStrangerTides On Stranger Tides]], but he still may have known her father was a pirate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** For the love of Mother and Child, let's just handle this question the way the series itself would. When Barbossa's crew is eventually freed from the bottle (as they will be, given the fact that some of their actors are returning for movie #5), if anyone asks what they ate in the bottle all that time, someone will answer, "Sea turtles."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Back when Phillip was talking about the mermaid, he mentions there were monsters that were not let in the Ark. Now considering the existence of the monsters like the Kraken and the dark magicla arts like voodoo and even questionable forces like the Fountain, what ''were'' some of the monsters he spoke of that were forbidden of the Ark?
** Especially when you factor in everything the novels build upon when tlaking about Jack's youth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After you've seen "Dead Man's Chest", now you know the basical tactic of Kraken (grab the hull, kill with tentacles the crew, drag the ship underwater). You realize (just as Will probably did, and later Jack too) that when Will stepped on what he believed was the Dutchman, the Kraken was just feet under him, still holding the hull and... playing with the corpses, momentarily calm and waiting. Just. Some. Feet.

to:

* After you've seen "Dead Man's Chest", now you know the basical tactic of Kraken (grab the hull, kill with tentacles the crew, drag the ship underwater). You realize (just as Will probably did, and later Jack too) that when Will stepped on what he believed was the Dutchman, the Kraken was just feet under him, still holding the hull and... playing with the corpses, momentarily calm and waiting. Just. Some. Feet.Feet.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** IIRC, before "fainting" Elizabeth dramatically cries out "Oh! The heat!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the opening of ''At World's End'', the hanging scene, where they're hanging everyone remotely associated with piracy, the fact that all Beckett has to do is say someone is a pirate and to hang them, no matter if they were. The real big bit of fridge horror was the kid who began the song; Hanging is potentially immediately fatal, as the sudden stop can(and usually does) snap necks. The kid, however, was on the small side, and probably didn't gain enough momentum in the drop to snap his neck. He strangled until he died.
** Actually, they all did. The "long drop" method of hanging(the one which breaks your neck) wasn't invented until the late 1800's... [[FridgeHorror which means that about 90 percent of all historical hangings were strangulations.]]
* Take a good look at the ''PiratesOfTheCaribbean'' skull logo. Red scarf, plaits, the coins, the beads - yep, that's Captain Jack Sparrow. Or what remains of him.

to:

* In the opening of ''At World's End'', the hanging scene, where they're hanging everyone remotely associated with piracy, the fact that all Beckett has to do is say someone is a pirate and to hang them, no matter if they were. The real big bit of fridge horror was the kid who began the song; Hanging is potentially immediately fatal, as the sudden stop can(and can (and usually does) snap necks. The kid, however, was on the small side, and probably didn't gain enough momentum in the drop to snap his neck. He strangled until he died.
** Actually, they all did. The "long drop" method of hanging(the hanging (the one which breaks your neck) wasn't invented until the late 1800's... [[FridgeHorror which means that about 90 percent of all historical hangings were strangulations.]]
strangulation.]] And yes, the kid still suffered longer due to his lesser weight.
* Take a good look at the ''PiratesOfTheCaribbean'' skull logo. Red scarf, plaits, the coins, the beads - yep, that's Captain Jack Sparrow. Or what remains of him. Just to drive the point home, attached to the plaits is a Captain Jack Sparrow voodoo doll.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''On Stranger Tides'', Jack leaves Angelica in the exact same situation he was in before ''The Curse Of The Black Pearl''. On an island, her ship stolen by Barbarossa and with a pistol that has one shot.

to:

* In ''On Stranger Tides'', Jack leaves Angelica in the exact same situation he was in before ''The Curse Of The Black Pearl''. On an island, her ship stolen by Barbarossa Barbossa and with a pistol that has one shot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's a joke, the same pirates have been trying to get the dog to give them the keys in the ride the movie is based on for fifty years



* After you've seen "Dead Man's Chest", now you know the basical tactic of Kraken (grab the hull, kill with tentacles the crew, drag the ship underwater). You realize (just as Will probably did, and later Jack too) that when Will stepped on what he believed was the Dutchman, the Kraken was just feet under him, still holding the hull and... playing with the corpses, momentarily calm and waiting. Just. Some. Feet.

to:

* After you've seen "Dead Man's Chest", now you know the basical tactic of Kraken (grab the hull, kill with tentacles the crew, drag the ship underwater). You realize (just as Will probably did, and later Jack too) that when Will stepped on what he believed was the Dutchman, the Kraken was just feet under him, still holding the hull and... playing with the corpses, momentarily calm and waiting. Just. Some. Feet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** "You took advantage of our hospitality last time, it holds fair now you return the favour!" (''cue shoving her towards his crew who start pawing at her and pulling her clothes'')He most certainly would let them.

to:

*** "You took advantage of our hospitality last time, it holds fair now you return the favour!" (''cue shoving her towards his crew who start pawing at her and pulling her clothes'')He clothes despite her cries'') He most certainly would let them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** "You took advantage of our hospitality last time, it holds fair now you return the favour!" He most certainly would let them.

to:

*** "You took advantage of our hospitality last time, it holds fair now you return the favour!" He (''cue shoving her towards his crew who start pawing at her and pulling her clothes'')He most certainly would let them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternately, they each knew her well enough personally now that they simply didn't buy it. Will's engaged to her, Jack's been hanging out with her on a pirate ship (as well as an equally hot and brutal island the movie before), and Norrington's seen her faint once for real (in the first movie due to a suffocating corset) and he's seen that trick before (when Jack was about to be hanged).

to:

** Alternately, they each knew her well enough personally now that they simply didn't buy it. Will's a friend from childhood who was at point engaged to her, Jack's been hanging out with her on a pirate ship (as well as an equally hot and brutal island the movie before), and Norrington's seen her faint once for real (in the first movie due to a suffocating corset) and he's seen that trick before (when Jack was about to be hanged).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternately, they each knew her well enough personally now that they simply didn't buy it. Will's engaged to her, Jack's been hanging out with her on a pirate ship (as well as an equally hot and brutal island the movie before), and Norrington's ''already seen that trick once.''

to:

** Alternately, they each knew her well enough personally now that they simply didn't buy it. Will's engaged to her, Jack's been hanging out with her on a pirate ship (as well as an equally hot and brutal island the movie before), and Norrington's ''already seen her faint once for real (in the first movie due to a suffocating corset) and he's seen that trick once.''before (when Jack was about to be hanged).

Added: 960

Changed: 123

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** The Spanish did have two encounters with magic. The Spanish fishermen pulled a man out of the water in the ocean who had been there for too long not to drown. Second, the Spaniard and his men would've had to use the magic portal of gravity-defying water to reach the Fountain in the first place.



** While that's a romantic notion, the other end of the idea is that "How do merpeople reproduce?" See Futurama's Atlanta episode for a "logical" answer. BUT: What if a mermaid's kiss makes a human man immune to drowning and either they do it on land as humans or if they do it as fish, he can survive underwater to do the dirty deed? The film never answers the question directly because of squick and sometimes imagination is better. Notice how there were NO mer men. If they do hatch from eggs like fish, maybe the majority are born female (like aligators and crocs needing a certain temperature range to make males) and logically, they capture human males to provide what they need. Mermaids be pirates of a kind, slavers too.

to:

** While that's a romantic notion, the other end of the idea is that "How do merpeople reproduce?" See Futurama's Atlanta episode for a "logical" answer. BUT: What if a mermaid's kiss makes a human man immune to drowning and either they do it on land as humans or if they do it as fish, he can survive underwater to do the dirty deed? The film never answers the question directly because of squick and sometimes imagination is better. Notice how there were NO mer men. If they do hatch from eggs like fish, maybe the majority are born female (like aligators alligators and crocs needing a certain temperature range to make males) and logically, they capture human males to provide what they need. Mermaids be pirates of a kind, slavers too.



**** There was a zombie who was stabbed in the chest, pulled it out and did not die. He was seen in other scenes; he's the one who threw the voodoo doll of Jack off the cliff and he's one of the two remaining zombie officers when [[spoiler: the Spanish arrive at the Fountain]].



* Angelica might remind one of Elizabeth Swan or Anamaria, both physically and in her personality. She is dark, with an accent and a temper similar to Anamaria's, and she looks a little bit like Elizabeth. With Angelica being the one woman Jack ever loved, this may be why he found Elizabeth and Anamaria a bit attractive later in his adventures; they both reminded him of Angelica.

to:

* Angelica might remind one of Elizabeth Swan or Anamaria, both physically and in her personality. She is dark, with an accent and a temper similar to Anamaria's, and she looks a little bit like Elizabeth. With Angelica being the one woman Jack ever loved, this may be why he found Elizabeth and Anamaria a bit attractive later in his adventures; they both reminded him of Angelica. It's also possible that those three women have the traits that Jack likes in women.



*** Unlikely, as there were at least two people who could attest that mermaids can speak at that point ; Scrum and the dark-skinned zombie officer. They were both on the longboat where they were used as live bait for the mermaids and both heard the blonde mermaid speak (in fact Scrum was the one who had a conversation with her and was smitten afterwards ["I'm in love!"]).



* Philip states that Syrena's beauty indicates she is "...one of God's creature and not one of those dark things that found no refuge on the Ark." Did he forget that the Bible states more than once that beauty does NOT equal goodness (something he would likely know, being a preacher and carrying a Bible with him at the time)? Or that Syrena's fellow mermaids were also beautiful, but bloodthirsty and vicious? Or that the Flood which made the Ark's construction necessary wouldn't have harmed mermaids since they're aquatic beings?

to:

* Philip states that Syrena's beauty indicates she is "...one of God's creature and not one of those dark things that found no refuge on the Ark." Did he forget that the Bible states more than once that beauty does NOT equal goodness (something he would likely know, being a preacher and carrying a Bible with him at the time)? Or that Syrena's fellow mermaids were also beautiful, but bloodthirsty and vicious? Or that the Flood which made the Ark's construction necessary wouldn't have harmed mermaids (nor was it intended to target them) since they're aquatic beings?



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Moreover, if the bottled ships ''weren't'' time-looped, they'd likely be rendered useless after only a few days of battering by the constant storms inside the bottles. Blackbeard wants trophies he can be proud of, not gale-demolished piles of flotsam.

to:

*** Moreover, if the bottled ships ''weren't'' time-looped, they'd likely be rendered useless after only a few days weeks of battering by the constant storms inside the bottles. Blackbeard wants trophies he can be proud of, not gale-demolished piles of flotsam.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Moreover, if the bottled ships ''weren't'' time-looped, they'd likely be rendered useless after only a few days of battering by the constant storms inside the bottles. Blackbeard wants trophies he can be proud of, not gale-demolished piles of flotsam.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Philip has an obvious crush on Syrena. He says those things about her because he's trying to reconcile his feelings with his faith, not because he's trying to be logically-consistent about either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alternately, despite her own efforts to appear tough-as-nails before Blackbeard and his crew, Angelica isn't ''completely'' heartless. She probably avoided having anything to do with Syrena because she didn't want to risk feeling sorry for the mermaid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They only know that the chalices are ''a'' way of reaching the Fountain. They don't know whether or not there might be others, so destroying the Fountain itself is the only sure way they can guarantee no one can use it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Why is the ride in [[Ride/DisneyThemeParks New Orleans Square?]] Because notorious pirate Jean Lafitte fought in The Battle of New Orleans during the War of 1812. It was a [[Main/HistoricalInJoke Historical In Joke]].



* Why is the ride in [[Ride/DisneyThemeParks New Orleans Square?]] Because notorious pirate Jean Lafitte fought in The Battle of New Orleans during the War of 1812. It was a [[Main/HistoricalInJoke Historical In Joke]].

to:

* Why is the ride in [[Ride/DisneyThemeParks New Orleans Square?]] Because notorious pirate Jean Lafitte fought in The Battle of New Orleans during the War of 1812. It was a [[Main/HistoricalInJoke Historical In Joke]].\n
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Why is the ride in [[Ride/DisneyThemeParks New Orleans Square?]] Because notorious pirate Jean Lafitte fought in The Battle of New Orleans during the War of 1812. It was a [[Main/HistoricalInJoke Historical In Joke]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***they probably all knew it wouldn't work, they were just too pissed at eachother to realise until they pulled the trigger
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Philip states that Syrena's beauty indicates she is "...one of God's creature and not one of those dark things that found no refuge on the Ark." Did he forget that the Bible states more than once that beauty does NOT equal goodness (something he would likely know, being a preacher and carrying a Bible with him at the time)? Or that Syrena's fellow mermaids were also beautiful, but bloodthirsty and vicious? Or that the Flood which made the Ark's construction necessary wouldn't have harmed mermaids since they're aquatic beings?

Added: 327

Removed: 323

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In At World's End when the pirates first see the massive armada, Cotton's parrot says "abandon ship!" And flies away. He returns when the battle is won and says "Wind in the sails!" as the pirates celebrating. Way back in Curse of the Black Pearl, Gibbs said that phrase is assumed to mean "Yes". The parrot was cheering!


Added DiffLines:

* In At World's End when the pirates first see the massive armada, Cotton's parrot says "abandon ship!" And flies away. He returns when the battle is won and says "Wind in the sails!" as the pirates are celebrating. Way back in Curse of the Black Pearl, Gibbs said that phrase is assumed to mean "Yes". The parrot was cheering!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*In At World's End when the pirates first see the massive armada, Cotton's parrot says "abandon ship!" And flies away. He returns when the battle is won and says "Wind in the sails!" as the pirates celebrating. Way back in Curse of the Black Pearl, Gibbs said that phrase is assumed to mean "Yes". The parrot was cheering!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That\'s an explicit plot point, not Fridge anything.


* When Jack meets Will for the first time, he immediately asks why Will looks familiar. It turns out this is because he's the son of Bootstrap Bill.

to:

* When Jack meets Will for the first time, he immediately asks why Will looks familiar. It turns out this is because he's the son of Bootstrap Bill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When Jack meets Will for the first time, he immediately asks why Will looks familiar. It turns out this is because he's the son of Bootstrap Bill.

Top