Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / AllStarBatmanAndRobinTheBoyWonder

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misplaced, moving to the correct tab


[[AC:FridgeLogic]]
* So, why ''did'' the Joker kill Dick's parents? Granted the series was CutShort so Miller never got a chance to answer that question, but with everything else going on in the series, there is '''nothing''' to suggest the Joker has anything to gain from randomly shooting two trapeze artists. Then again, this is the Joker; him shooting random innocents ForTheEvulz would be valid characterization.
** If the other remarks are foreshadowing, it might mean something completely unexpected and even worse than previously thought: Batman had him do it.
* Batman's strategy for dealing with Green Lantern in issue 9 was to make sure everything in the room was yellow (even the lemonade). What would he have done if Hal had, oh say, gone outside, grabbed a car, and chucked it at Batman? I doubt Batman would've been able to make sure ''all'' the cars outside were painted yellow as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The whole story could be viewed as Creator/FrankMiller sitting down and going "would actually happen if a rich 8 year old boy mentally never grew up after his parents died in front of him and became obsessed with his 8 year old ideals of justice and law?" Going so far as to become a vigilante, believing the cops are either too inept or corrupt. Notice how he acts towards Grayson when he wants to impress him, like a kid showing another kid his favorite toys. Notice how impulsive and child-like he is? Because he's still Bruce Wayne, Age Eight, crying for his mom and dad, but they won't come.

to:

* The whole story could be viewed as Creator/FrankMiller sitting down and going "would "what would actually happen if a rich 8 year old boy mentally never grew up after his parents died in front of him and became obsessed with his 8 year old ideals of justice and law?" Going so far as to become a vigilante, believing the cops are either too inept or corrupt. Notice how he acts towards Grayson when he wants to impress him, like a kid showing another kid his favorite toys. Notice how impulsive and child-like he is? Because he's still Bruce Wayne, Age Eight, crying for his mom and dad, but they won't come.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As pointed out in [[WebVideo/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Batman mentions "having [his] eye on [Dick] for some time" and mentions "other candidates for the job", which would seem to indicate he had been planning to bring Dick in on his crime-fighting well before his parents were murdered. Linkara further interprets Bruce's snarls that "he'd have waited years" to imply he would have abducted Dick and possibly killed his parents himself to get him to join him.
* Linkara also pointed out that we never see Batman giving Hal Jordan his ring back. The Goddamn Batman with a Green Lantern ring...oh dear...
** If you look at how Bruce reacts to becoming Green Lantern in the {{Elseworld}}s [[http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/marvel_dc/images/8/80/Green_Lantern_Darkest_Knight_009.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20100529173519 In Darkest Knight]]... It's pretty close.
*** A horrifying thought occurs when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance and the FridgeHorror about the Green Lantern ring. Batman is mentally eight years old, afraid of nothing, fanatically dedicated to his job, unable to work with others, and has no qualms about killing people. ''ComicBook/DarkNightsMetal'' shows exactly what happens when a sociopathic, damaged, murderous Batman acquires any sort of power.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''The Dark Knight Returns'', Bruce laments the death of Jason Todd, and decides to take Carrie Kelley under his wing (no pun intended). Dick Grayson, Age Twelve, may be the reason why Bruce actually develops some humanity to his other Robins.
* The whole story could be viewed as Frank Miller sitting down and going "would actually happen if a rich 8 year old boy mentally never grew up after his parents died in front of him and became obsessed with his 8 year old ideals of justice and law?" Going so far as to become a vigilante, believing the cops are either too inept or corrupt. Notice how he acts towards Grayson when he wants to impress him, like a kid showing another kid his favorite toys. Notice how impulsive and child like he is? Because he's still Bruce Wayne, Age Eight, crying for his mom and dad, but they won't come.

to:

* In ''The Dark Knight Returns'', ''ComicBook/TheDarkKnightReturns'', Bruce laments the death of Jason Todd, and decides to take Carrie Kelley under his wing (no pun intended). Dick Grayson, Age Twelve, may be the reason why Bruce actually develops some humanity to his other Robins.
* The whole story could be viewed as Frank Miller Creator/FrankMiller sitting down and going "would actually happen if a rich 8 year old boy mentally never grew up after his parents died in front of him and became obsessed with his 8 year old ideals of justice and law?" Going so far as to become a vigilante, believing the cops are either too inept or corrupt. Notice how he acts towards Grayson when he wants to impress him, like a kid showing another kid his favorite toys. Notice how impulsive and child like child-like he is? Because he's still Bruce Wayne, Age Eight, crying for his mom and dad, but they won't come.



*** A horrifying thought occurs when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance and the FridgeHorror about the Green Lantern ring. Batman is mentally eight years old, afraid of nothing, fanatically dedicated to his job, unable to work with others, and has no qualms about killing people. ComicBook/DarkNightsMetal shows exactly what happens when a sociopathic, damaged, murderous Batman acquires any sort of power.

to:

*** A horrifying thought occurs when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance and the FridgeHorror about the Green Lantern ring. Batman is mentally eight years old, afraid of nothing, fanatically dedicated to his job, unable to work with others, and has no qualms about killing people. ComicBook/DarkNightsMetal ''ComicBook/DarkNightsMetal'' shows exactly what happens when a sociopathic, damaged, murderous Batman acquires any sort of power.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Pure speculation


* Not quite in-universe, but consider that if you're not already a fan of Batman or know him only through adaptations, this is as likely as anything to be your ''introduction'' to the franchise and character; the "all-star" miniseries by the [[Creator/FrankMiller nearly-worshipped writer]] would sound like a good jumping-on point. How many people who would ''love'' the ''real'' Batman will forever miss out on something wonderful because they think this is what he's really like, not being in a position to know that this is Batman InNameOnly to the point that calling him "Batman in name only" doesn't go far enough and the main reason for Miller's DarthWiki/FallenCreator status?

to:

* Not quite in-universe, but consider that if you're not already a fan of Batman or know him only through adaptations, this is as likely as anything to be your ''introduction'' to the franchise and character; the "all-star" miniseries by the [[Creator/FrankMiller nearly-worshipped writer]] would sound like a good jumping-on point. How many people who would ''love'' the ''real'' Batman will forever miss out on something wonderful because they think this is what he's really like, not being in a position to know that this is Batman InNameOnly to the point that calling him "Batman in name only" doesn't go far enough and the main reason for Miller's DarthWiki/FallenCreator status?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Not quite in-universe, but consider that if you're not already a fan of Batman or know him only through adaptations, this is as likely as anything to be your ''introduction'' to the franchise and character; the "all-star" miniseries by the [[Creator/FrankMiller nearly-worshipped writer]] would sound like a good jumping-on point. How many people who would ''love'' the ''real'' Batman will forever miss out on something wonderful because they think this is what he's really like, not being in a position to know that this is BatmanInNameOnly to the point that calling him "Batman in name only" doesn't go far enough and the main reason for Miller's FallenCreator status?

to:

* Not *Not quite in-universe, but consider that if you're not already a fan of Batman or know him only through adaptations, this is as likely as anything to be your ''introduction'' to the franchise and character; the "all-star" miniseries by the [[Creator/FrankMiller nearly-worshipped writer]] would sound like a good jumping-on point. How many people who would ''love'' the ''real'' Batman will forever miss out on something wonderful because they think this is what he's really like, not being in a position to know that this is BatmanInNameOnly Batman InNameOnly to the point that calling him "Batman in name only" doesn't go far enough and the main reason for Miller's FallenCreator DarthWiki/FallenCreator status?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*Not quite in-universe, but consider that if you're not already a fan of Batman or know him only through adaptations, this is as likely as anything to be your ''introduction'' to the franchise and character; the "all-star" miniseries by the [[Creator/FrankMiller nearly-worshipped writer]] would sound like a good jumping-on point. How many people who would ''love'' the ''real'' Batman will forever miss out on something wonderful because they think this is what he's really like, not being in a position to know that this is BatmanInNameOnly to the point that calling him "Batman in name only" doesn't go far enough and the main reason for Miller's FallenCreator status?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This isn't a Linkara wiki.


* In ''The Dark Knight Returns'', Bruce laments the death of Jason Todd, and decides to take Carrie Kelly under his wing (no pun intended). Dick Grayson, Age Twelve, may be the reason why Bruce actually develops some humanity to his other Robins.

to:

* In ''The Dark Knight Returns'', Bruce laments the death of Jason Todd, and decides to take Carrie Kelly Kelley under his wing (no pun intended). Dick Grayson, Age Twelve, may be the reason why Bruce actually develops some humanity to his other Robins.



* As pointed out in [[WebVideo/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Crazy Steve mentions "having [his] eye on [Dick] for some time" and mentions "other candidates for the job", which would seem to indicate he had been planning to bring Dick in on his crime-fighting well before his parents were murdered. Linkara further interprets Steve's snarls that "he'd have waited years" to imply he would have abducted Dick and possibly killed his parents himself to get him to join him.
* Linkara also pointed out that we never see Crazy Steve giving Hal Jordan his ring back. Crazy Steve with a Green Lantern ring...oh dear...
** If you look at how Bruce reacts to becoming Green Lantern in the elsewords [[http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/marvel_dc/images/8/80/Green_Lantern_Darkest_Knight_009.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20100529173519 In Darkest Knight]]... It's pretty close.
*** A horrifying thought occurs when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance and the FridgeHorror about the Green Lantern ring. Crazy Steve is mentally eight years old, afraid of nothing, fanatically dedicated to his job, unable to work with others, and has no qualms about killing people. DarkNightsMetal shows exactly what happens when a sociopathic, damaged, murderous Batman acquires any sort of power.

to:

* As pointed out in [[WebVideo/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Crazy Steve Batman mentions "having [his] eye on [Dick] for some time" and mentions "other candidates for the job", which would seem to indicate he had been planning to bring Dick in on his crime-fighting well before his parents were murdered. Linkara further interprets Steve's Bruce's snarls that "he'd have waited years" to imply he would have abducted Dick and possibly killed his parents himself to get him to join him.
* Linkara also pointed out that we never see Crazy Steve Batman giving Hal Jordan his ring back. Crazy Steve The Goddamn Batman with a Green Lantern ring...oh dear...
** If you look at how Bruce reacts to becoming Green Lantern in the elsewords {{Elseworld}}s [[http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/marvel_dc/images/8/80/Green_Lantern_Darkest_Knight_009.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20100529173519 In Darkest Knight]]... It's pretty close.
*** A horrifying thought occurs when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance and the FridgeHorror about the Green Lantern ring. Crazy Steve Batman is mentally eight years old, afraid of nothing, fanatically dedicated to his job, unable to work with others, and has no qualms about killing people. DarkNightsMetal ComicBook/DarkNightsMetal shows exactly what happens when a sociopathic, damaged, murderous Batman acquires any sort of power.



** If the other remarks are foreshadowing, it might mean something completely unexpected and even worse than previously thought: Steve had him do it.

to:

** If the other remarks are foreshadowing, it might mean something completely unexpected and even worse than previously thought: Steve Batman had him do it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Batman's strategy for dealing with Green Lantern in issue 9 was to make sure everything in the room was yellow (even the lemonade). What would he have done if Hal had, oh say, gone outside, grabbed a car, and chucked it at Batman? I doubt Batman would've been able to make sure ''all'' the cars outside were painted yellow as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If the other remarks are foreshadowing, it might mean something completely unexpected and even worse than previously thought: Steve had him do it.

Added: 416

Changed: 371

Removed: 218

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As pointed out in [[WebVideo/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Crazy Steve sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson (Age Twelve) regardless of his parents being alive.
** Not just that - Linkara also points out that Crazy Steve sounds like he was so desperate to get Dick to become his ward, that he would have ''killed the boy's parents himself if the assassin hadn't beat him to it''.

to:

* As pointed out in [[WebVideo/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Crazy Steve sounded like mentions "having [his] eye on [Dick] for some time" and mentions "other candidates for the job", which would seem to indicate he was going had been planning to kidnap bring Dick Grayson (Age Twelve) regardless of in on his crime-fighting well before his parents being alive.
** Not just that -
were murdered. Linkara also points out further interprets Steve's snarls that Crazy Steve sounds like he was so desperate "he'd have waited years" to get Dick to become his ward, that imply he would have ''killed the boy's abducted Dick and possibly killed his parents himself if the assassin hadn't beat to get him to it''. join him.


Added DiffLines:


[[AC:FridgeLogic]]
* So, why ''did'' the Joker kill Dick's parents? Granted the series was CutShort so Miller never got a chance to answer that question, but with everything else going on in the series, there is '''nothing''' to suggest the Joker has anything to gain from randomly shooting two trapeze artists. Then again, this is the Joker; him shooting random innocents ForTheEvulz would be valid characterization.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Horror made real when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce is mentally age 8, have no fear, too dedicated, inability to work with others, and no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. Give him Atlatean gene and you have The Drowned. Give him the helmet of Ares and you have Merciless. Inject him with Doomsday Virus created a swearing Devastator. Actually killed Joker transform him to Batman who Laughs All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.

to:

*** Horror made real A horrifying thought occurs when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce and the FridgeHorror about the Green Lantern ring. Crazy Steve is mentally age 8, have no fear, too dedicated, inability eight years old, afraid of nothing, fanatically dedicated to his job, unable to work with others, and has no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. Give him Atlatean gene and you have The Drowned. Give him the helmet of Ares and you have Merciless. Inject him with Doomsday Virus created qualms about killing people. DarkNightsMetal shows exactly what happens when a swearing Devastator. Actually killed Joker transform him to sociopathic, damaged, murderous Batman who Laughs All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.acquires any sort of power.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Horror made real when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce is mentally age 8, have no fear, too dedicated, inability to work with others, and no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. Give him Atlatean gene and you have The Drowned. Give him the helmet of Ares and you have Merciless. Inject him (or Earth -1 Batman) give a swearing Devastator. All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.

to:

*** Horror made real when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce is mentally age 8, have no fear, too dedicated, inability to work with others, and no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. Give him Atlatean gene and you have The Drowned. Give him the helmet of Ares and you have Merciless. Inject him (or Earth -1 Batman) give with Doomsday Virus created a swearing Devastator. Actually killed Joker transform him to Batman who Laughs All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Horror made real when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce is mentally age 8, have no fear, too dedicated, inability to work with others, and no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. Give him Atlatean gene and you have The Drowned. Give him the helmet of Area and you have Merciless. All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.

to:

*** Horror made real when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce is mentally age 8, have no fear, too dedicated, inability to work with others, and no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. Give him Atlatean gene and you have The Drowned. Give him the helmet of Area Ares and you have Merciless.Merciless. Inject him (or Earth -1 Batman) give a swearing Devastator. All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Horror made real when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce is mentally age 8, have no fear, and no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.

to:

*** Horror made real when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce is mentally age 8, have no fear, too dedicated, inability to work with others, and no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. Give him Atlatean gene and you have The Drowned. Give him the helmet of Area and you have Merciless. All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Horror made real when combined with the above FridgeBrilliance that Bruce is mentally age 8, have no fear, and no qualm to kill people: give this boy the Green lantern ring and you have Dawnbreaker. Give Crazy Steve speedforce and you have Red Death. All can be seen in horrifying action in DarkNightsMetal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''The Dark Knight Returns'', Bruce laments the death of Jason Todd, and decides to take Carrie Kelly under his wing (no pun intended). Dick Grayson may be the reason why Bruce actually develops some humanity to his other Robins.

to:

* In ''The Dark Knight Returns'', Bruce laments the death of Jason Todd, and decides to take Carrie Kelly under his wing (no pun intended). Dick Grayson Grayson, Age Twelve, may be the reason why Bruce actually develops some humanity to his other Robins.



* As pointed out in [[WebVideo/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Crazy Steve sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson regardless of his parents being alive.

to:

* As pointed out in [[WebVideo/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Crazy Steve sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson (Age Twelve) regardless of his parents being alive.

Added: 251

Changed: 593

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The whole story could be viewed as Frank Miller sitting down and going "would actually happen if a rich 8 year old boy mentally never grew up after his parents died in front of him and became obsessed with his 8 year old ideals of justice and law?" Going so far as to become a vigilante, believing the cops are either too inept or corrupt. Notice how he acts towards Grayson when he wants to impress him, like a kid showing another kid his favorite toys. Notice how impulsive and child like he is? Because he's still Bruce Wayne, Age Eight, crying for his mom and dad, but they won't come.


Added DiffLines:

** If you look at how Bruce reacts to becoming Green Lantern in the elsewords [[http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/marvel_dc/images/8/80/Green_Lantern_Darkest_Knight_009.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20100529173519 In Darkest Knight]]... It's pretty close.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Batman smashes the Batmobile through cop cars, delivers a flying kick hard enough to break glass to an officer's jaw, and sets criminals on fire with thermite. There is simply no way these people are living through the night, and if they do they are certainly going to be disabled for life at least.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Linkara also pointed out that we never see Crazy Steve giving Hal Jordan his ring back. Crazy Steve with a Green Lantern ring...oh dear...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:FridgeBrillance]]

to:

[[AC:FridgeBrillance]][[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:FridgeBrillance]]
* In ''The Dark Knight Returns'', Bruce laments the death of Jason Todd, and decides to take Carrie Kelly under his wing (no pun intended). Dick Grayson may be the reason why Bruce actually develops some humanity to his other Robins.

Added: 4

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As pointed out in [[WebOriginal/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Crazy Steve sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson regardless of his parents being alive.

to:

* As pointed out in [[WebOriginal/AtopTheFourthWall [[WebVideo/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that Crazy Steve sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson regardless of his parents being alive.


Added DiffLines:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* As pointed out in [[WebOriginal/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that [[DetractorNickname Crazy Steve]] sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson regardless of his parents being alive.
** Not just that - Linkara also points out that [[DetractorNickname Crazy Steve]] sounds like he was so desperate to get Dick to become his ward, that he would have ''killed the boy's parents himself if the assassin hadn't beat him to it''.

to:

* As pointed out in [[WebOriginal/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that [[DetractorNickname Crazy Steve]] Steve sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson regardless of his parents being alive.
** Not just that - Linkara also points out that [[DetractorNickname Crazy Steve]] Steve sounds like he was so desperate to get Dick to become his ward, that he would have ''killed the boy's parents himself if the assassin hadn't beat him to it''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As pointed out in [[AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that [[DetractorNickname Crazy Steve]] sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson regardless of his parents being alive.

to:

* As pointed out in [[AtopTheFourthWall [[WebOriginal/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara's]] review, he points out that [[DetractorNickname Crazy Steve]] sounded like he was going to kidnap Dick Grayson regardless of his parents being alive.

Top